Replacement theology? Yes or No.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
The world hates Israel state because they bombed everyone around in middle east. Murdered millions, and millions became refugees.
Look into the history starting 1946, king David hotel bombing. And all the bombing after that.
I know the history. I also know that the British (which I am) sent many Jewish refugees back to Europe to be murdered by Nazis. The whole point of the state of Israel, which was promised under the Balfour declaration, was to prevent a holocaust. Jews have been murdered continually since the diaspora.

Your claim is grossly overstated. Everyone around the Middle East? How many Jews do you think were in Israel in the 1940's? In 1946, it was about half a million. That was about a third of the population of what was the known as Palestine. Murdered millions? Where do you get that from? Osama Bin Laden? Khamenei?

Do know why so many Arabs became refugees? They were warned that Israel would be invaded when it declared independence. Many left prior to the 5 nation invasion of Israel, which was urged on them by the Arab invaders.

I don't condone violence. But the British army trained Egyptian forces and so-called Palestinian militias while doing their best to keep Israelis defenceless. It's hardly surprising that Israelis took up arms. Perhaps you might remember a tiny little conflict with Britain that started in 1775. It only lasted 8 years. I don't hear too many people demanding that America ceases to exist. I'd be fascinated to compare the number of people Americans have killed with the number that Israel has killed. America's military has 2.75 million service personnel. The IDF 675,000. American forces have killed about 4.5 million since 2001, let alone what was done before. Where is the outrage?

A good number of Arabs did not leave Israel during the 1948 war. They are citizens of Israel with the same rights as anyone else.

Israel exists and survives according to God's grace and His plan and purpose. Most people say that America was right to be independent of Britain, in spite of having to use violence. How about extending the same courtesy to Israel.​
 
I know the history. I also know that the British (which I am) sent many Jewish refugees back to Europe to be murdered by Nazis. The whole point of the state of Israel, which was promised under the Balfour declaration, was to prevent a holocaust. Jews have been murdered continually since the diaspora.

Your claim is grossly overstated. Everyone around the Middle East? How many Jews do you think were in Israel in the 1940's? In 1946, it was about half a million. That was about a third of the population of what was the known as Palestine. Murdered millions? Where do you get that from? Osama Bin Laden? Khamenei?

Do know why so many Arabs became refugees? They were warned that Israel would be invaded when it declared independence. Many left prior to the 5 nation invasion of Israel, which was urged on them by the Arab invaders.

I don't condone violence. But the British army trained Egyptian forces and so-called Palestinian militias while doing their best to keep Israelis defenceless. It's hardly surprising that Israelis took up arms. Perhaps you might remember a tiny little conflict with Britain that started in 1775. It only lasted 8 years. I don't hear too many people demanding that America ceases to exist. I'd be fascinated to compare the number of people Americans have killed with the number that Israel has killed. America's military has 2.75 million service personnel. The IDF 675,000. American forces have killed about 4.5 million since 2001, let alone what was done before. Where is the outrage?

A good number of Arabs did not leave Israel during the 1948 war. They are citizens of Israel with the same rights as anyone else.

Israel exists and survives according to God's grace and His plan and purpose. Most people say that America was right to be independent of Britain, in spite of having to use violence. How about extending the same courtesy to Israel.​
If isreal just stayed as it was in 1948 agreement with UN, then things wouldn't be this bad. Ever since 1948, they keep bombing every one in middle east to expand territory, that is the result of millions murdered by Israel state, and millions refugees flood into Europe and America.

Not just bombing, they also have people like Epstein to work to influence all western politics. Western politicians are guilty too. Check AIPAC, almost 100 percent American politicians are financed by Israel state. In turn they give all our Americans money to Israel state, weapons and all.

The harlot riding on the beast!!!!
 
Satan can definitely influence man, which is why we see so many mothers killing their children now in the name of madness. He drives people over the edge. It's also why we hear stories of people who claim to kill other people because "God told me to do it".

I was referring to when Satan is bound for 1000 yrs.
 
If isreal just stayed as it was in 1948 agreement with UN, then things wouldn't be this bad. Ever since 1948, they keep bombing every one in middle east to expand territory, that is the result of millions murdered by Israel state, and millions refugees flood into Europe and America.

Not just bombing, they also have people like Epstein to work to influence all western politics. Western politicians are guilty too. Check AIPAC, almost 100 percent American politicians are financed by Israel state. In turn they give all our Americans money to Israel state, weapons and all.

The harlot riding on the beast!!!!
Your accusations are false and baseless. Israel stayed in its 1948 borders until 1967. Nasser of Egypt was preparing to attack again. Israel launched a preemptive strike. They took back some land that was theirs according to God. They still occupy only a fraction of what God promised to Abraham.

The Balfour declaration (remember that the British ruled Palestine at the time) set boundaries for Israel much larger than the present area. British double dealing ensured that Israel never obtained that land.

Your assertion that Israel has murdered millions is slander. Your assertion that Israel keeps bombing others in the Middle East to gain territory is absurd. Have you heard of self defence? Israel was attacked in 1948, blockaded in 1956, prevented Egypt's sneak attack in 1967 and was attacked by Egypt in 1973. There have been a number of other attacks since.

Tell me how much territory Israel has gained by its supposed murderous attacks?

You should know better than to promote conspiracy theories. You really think that Israel is behind the Muslim invasion of Europe and America? I don't know you listen to, but it is not God. You do not get your information from God's word either.
 
If isreal just stayed as it was in 1948 agreement with UN, then things wouldn't be this bad. Ever since 1948, they keep bombing every one in middle east to expand territory, that is the result of millions murdered by Israel state, and millions refugees flood into Europe and America.

Not just bombing, they also have people like Epstein to work to influence all western politics. Western politicians are guilty too. Check AIPAC, almost 100 percent American politicians are financed by Israel state. In turn they give all our Americans money to Israel state, weapons and all.

The harlot riding on the beast!!!!

Open up a history book please. A real one. Allow yourself the truth. Not this fabricated b/s that is pushed by the anti semitic sympathizers.
 
Outline for the book of Revelation:

1. Preamble 1
2. Historical Prologue 2-3
3. Ethical Stipulations 4-7
4. Sanctions 8-14
5. Succession Arrangements 15-22

The difference being that Deuteronomy is dealing with the establishment of a covenant, while Revelation deals with the sanctions coming to fruition for failure to keep the terms of the covenant.

Incidentally, the books written by the prophets often have the same outline.
Here lets break this down and debunk your claims point by point.

1. “Preamble”: Deuteronomy 1:1–5 = Revelation 1?​

This is superficial resemblance created simply by calling both opening chapters a “preamble.”

Deuteronomy 1:1–5 establishes the historical setting of Moses addressing Israel in Moab:

“These be the words which Moses spake unto all Israel...”
It identifies the covenant mediator, the covenant people, geographical location, and historical circumstances immediately before Israel enters Canaan.

Revelation 1 does nothing comparable.

It opens:

“The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave unto him, to shew unto his servants things which must shortly come to pass...” (Rev. 1:1)

Then John identifies the recipients:

“John to the seven churches which are in Asia” (1:4).

The chapter proceeds into a vision of the glorified Christ commissioning John to write what he sees.

Where are the alleged features of a Deuteronomic covenant preamble?

There is:

  • no Mosaic covenant being ratified,
  • no vassal nation assembling,
  • no oath,
  • no covenant stipulations being announced,
  • no description of Israel accepting covenant obligations.
Instead we have an apocalyptic-prophetic commission and epistolary greeting.

Calling both sections “preambles” proves essentially nothing. Genesis has an opening. Romans has an opening. Ezekiel has an opening. An introductory chapter does not establish literary dependence upon Deuteronomy.

2. “Historical Prologue”: Deuteronomy 1:6–4:49 = Revelation 2–3?​

Here the alleged parallel becomes much worse.

The genuine historical prologue in Deuteronomy recounts Israel's actual covenant history:

  • Horeb,
  • departure into the wilderness,
  • appointment of judges,
  • Kadesh-barnea,
  • Israel's unbelief,
  • wilderness wandering,
  • Edom,
  • Moab,
  • Ammon,
  • Sihon,
  • Og,
  • the Transjordan conquest,
  • Moses' exclusion from Canaan.
That is exactly what a historical prologue does: it recounts the previous relationship between the suzerain and vassal.

Now examine Revelation 2–3.

What history is recounted?

Virtually none.

Instead Christ sends seven contemporary prophetic messages:

“Unto the angel of the church of Ephesus write...”
“Unto the angel of the church in Smyrna write...”
“Unto the angel of the church in Pergamos...”


and so forth.

These chapters concern the spiritual condition of seven churches:

  • Ephesus lost its first love.
  • Smyrna faces persecution.
  • Pergamum tolerates false teaching.
  • Thyatira tolerates Jezebel.
  • Sardis is spiritually dead.
  • Philadelphia perseveres.
  • Laodicea is lukewarm.
That is not an historical prologue recounting God's covenant dealings with Israel.

Indeed, this creates a devastating internal problem for the theory:

If Revelation supposedly describes God terminating His Mosaic covenant with Israel, why is the alleged “historical prologue” addressed explicitly to seven Christian churches in Asia Minor rather than recounting Israel's covenant history?

The proposed correspondence exists only because someone has pasted the label “historical prologue” over material that plainly isn't one.