And the same is true with how the non-Sabbatarians view those who do keep the Sabbath. Somehow, if we observe the Sabbath and the Law, we are not saved because we're negating gracious salvation. Not all, but some. And I would say it's the same percentage on both sides that incorrectly label the other.
All Christians, both Law-keepers and non should be worshipping every day and getting into church or fellowship as often as they can. But God set apart the Sabbath as different than the rest of the week. The Levites were always ministering, there was always worshipping no matter the day. But God still set the Sabbath apart as unique.
I agree, and the Sabbath-keepers in this forum will agree with you. And I would venture to say the majority of Sabbath keepers everywhere would agree as well.
Those attitudes might not have been unique, but they aren't the majority by any means. And as I mentioned before, I've seen just as many non-Sabbath keepers consider themselves more righteous because they don't need to follow the commandments because they're saved by grace. Again, it's a 2-way street
And as you can see now, that was erroneous thinking on your part. And those that get caught up in that mindset are erroneous in their thinking. What needs to be remembered though, is that attitude is not the mindset of God, nor was it when he gave the Law. The Law was never given to overshadow God's mercy and gracious salvation. It is man who got their priorities out of whack.
Just because we mess up what God gave us, doesn't mean we get rid of what God gave us.
Yes it does. The New Covenant includes the teachings and instructions of the Old. Obviously the sacrifices and atonements are taken care of with Jesus' death, but the practical instructions and morals of the Old are still applicable. That's is why Jesus told His disciples to follow and teach the Law (Matt 5:19). That is why He told them to do what the Pharisees said, not what they did (Matt 23:3). He knew the Pharisees had their priorities out of whack physically. But He also knew they were teaching God's instructions.
For the most part, yes. But on the flip side, are non-Sabbath keepers being consistent and not passing judgment on those who do keep the feasts?
Be aware that all of the broad generalizations that you are making about Sabbath Keepers and their motives are very identical to the non-Sabbath keepers, but on the opposite end of the spectrum.
Our church does. We physically and intentionally observe all of the Biblical Feast days and the New Moons.
If someone is "worshiping the Feast days, they're out of line. But there is nothing contradictory in observing them while worshiping God. The shadow of the sun obviously not the sun itself, but it does serve a purpose, and we are thankful for it. The "shadows" can remind us of the truth. But if the shadow's are faulty, why do folks celebrate Easter or Christmas? Aren't those "shadows"? Why have a sunrise service? He's already risen. We don't need to celebrate it anymore.
Again, if people are seeking justification/salvation through their works, they are in error. But what was God's intention behind the Law? The Sabbath? Did they have anything to do with justification? They didn't. And again, just because man has messed up the application of the Law, doesn't mean God's instruction for it is faulty.
So in summary:
The Law was never meant to justify. Its always been by grace.
If anyone is seeking salvation through the Law, they are wrong. It is only by grace.
They Law provides practical instruction on how to live a life that worships God. They Holy Spirit helps us with that.
Jesus taught His disciples to follow it and teach others to do so. We should follow His example.
Final re-emphasis: If anyone is seeking salvation through the Law, they are wrong. It is only by grace.
