Well options are limited in a small town mainly because there just aren't that many people there. And not many people often translates to not a lot of economic opportunity for the young men in tow so they don't stay there.
As for the church side, there's a book titled why men hate going to church that basically lays out how churches have become very welcoming places for women that cater to women's strengths and desires but ysually leave men feeling like they aren't valued or there's something wrong with them and don't really address men's deep seated needs and fears in the same way. And one of the things they tend to say about the women looking for Godly men is that their standards and expectations are so high that even Jesus wouldn't be acceptable to them. So as you look for this man of God be sure your expectations are in line with the fact that even if he's super devoted to Jesus, he's still just a mere mortal man not some super human saint.
That doesn't mean that there aren't Godly men out there, but they have their own sets of challenges.