Will The Actual Calvinists Here Please Stand Up?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

I Am An Actual Calvinist

  • Yes

    Votes: 5 20.8%
  • No

    Votes: 19 79.2%

  • Total voters
    24

Cameron143

Well-known member
Mar 1, 2022
21,460
7,336
113
63
The threat of consequences works with everyone???
That is what you were "saying all along"?

Is this not common knowledge? Even children and animals understand this.
Well tell that to the poster I addressed the question to originally. Evidently it isn't common knowledge.
 
Feb 15, 2025
617
309
63
Your commentary ignited a thought relative to what you've affectionately referred to as 'calvies' have as their strongest argument, because it's too easy to confuse the order. The verse that 'no one can come to Me unless the Father who sent Me draws him (John 6:44)." Later in that chapter, 21 verses later, in John 6:65, Jesus says, "This is why I said that...(my paraphrase of 65a which refers back to v.44)." which is preceded by His claim in v.65, "...there are some of you who do not believe."

"calvies" assert that no one believes unless the Father draw him to Jesus, and refuse to even consider the possibility that the Father draws no one that does not believe.

V.66 illustrates, "From that time on many of His disciples turn back and no longer walked with Him," and
V.67 Jesus asks the Twelve, "Do you want to leave too?" and
v.68-9 illustrates Simon Peter confessing his faith, then
V.70 Jesus effectively says (my paraphrase), "I know, I chose you (because I know you...that is, I know you all...even the one who does not believe."
" "calvies" assert that no one believes unless the Father draw him to Jesus, and refuse to even consider the possibility that the Father draws no one that does not believe."

I think someone who is Christian, Calvanist or otherwise, refuses to believe that because it isn't scripture.
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,528
2,302
113
" "calvies" assert that no one believes unless the Father draw him to Jesus, and refuse to even consider the possibility that the Father draws no one that does not believe."

I think someone who is Christian, Calvanist or otherwise, refuses to believe that because it isn't scripture.
There's a good chance that I'm dealing with a narcissist in this particular case, whose expertise is crazy making.
 
Oct 19, 2024
4,075
904
113
Other people need to discover how much fun we all have on this website. I’m telling you. We all struck gold by finding this place.
Well, I find some threads rather grueling, like bad movie plots that I keep on watching, hoping for a happy ending.
 

Kroogz

Well-known member
Dec 5, 2023
1,478
690
113
"calvies" assert that no one believes unless the Father draw him to Jesus, and refuse to even consider the possibility that the Father draws no one that does not believe.
John 3:16~~“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only Son, so that everyone who believes in Him will not perish, but have eternal life.

Acts 16:31~~They said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.”

2 Cor 6:2~~For He says: “In an acceptable time I have heard you, And in the day of salvation I have helped you.” Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.

Salvation~~Equal privilege, equal opportunity for ALL. Anytime and anywhere.
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,528
2,302
113
John 3:16~~“For God so loved the world, that He gave His only Son, so that everyone who believes in Him will not perish, but have eternal life.

Acts 16:31~~They said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.”

2 Cor 6:2~~For He says: “In an acceptable time I have heard you, And in the day of salvation I have helped you.” Behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.

Salvation~~Equal privilege, equal opportunity for ALL. Anytime and anywhere.
It has occurred to me that a type of deductive reasoning generates a Calvinistic conclusion. That is, it start with the end result and reasons back from there to predict? the means, but it is inductive reasoning that starts with the means to predict the results. And the means are a given, by grace through faith.
 

Kroogz

Well-known member
Dec 5, 2023
1,478
690
113
It has occurred to me that a type of deductive reasoning generates a Calvinistic conclusion. That is, it start with the end result and reasons back from there to predict? the means, but it is inductive reasoning that starts with the means to predict the results. And the means are a given, by grace through faith.
And you will see the armins do the exact same thing with our eternal security and never, no, not ever perishing.
 
Feb 15, 2025
617
309
63
Well, I try, which is more than what some folks around here do.
What is your constructive attempt that is better than mine?
This isn't a competition.

This is about the power within Creation and all Created. And millennia ago that power sent us a message. Proof of The word,The Creator, is in all creation.

The inspired word is the narrative that accompanies those visuals,all of nature,including us,that lets us know not only is Holy Spirit real but "He" has something to tell us.

We are not alone here.

This isn't a game. It isn't fun to mock what Christians believe with their whole heart and live day to day.
Twisting scripture, insisting it says what we need to hear isn't clarity through the Spirit.

No doubt,as every community of Christ has them,there are those who enter and being outright atheist or skeptics,find it a hobby to make claims about the teaching in a chapter and passage just to have fun with the locals.

Shake up our world. See how long we'll spend time trying to set a misguided sister or brother on the righteous path of understanding.

Throwing in a few Ad hominems just to sate their darkness. They even mock God's love.

Most Christians are aware of these agents of the opposition.

Here's the thing.

Jesus told us our natural mind cannot understand the things of God. Because in that natural state we think that stuff is foolish.

Trolls harassing Christs own are proof of that.

No one comes to Jesus unless God leads them to him. Which means leads them to understanding what it means to come to Jesus. And that only happens to that natural man,woman,when the Holy Spirit enters into them first.

And those into whom Holy Spirit enters are known by God as his Elect. Those he elects to call to his salvation. He knew them before the foundation of the world. And he revealed,he wrote their names down in his Lamb's Book of Life.

Omni love? God hated Essau. All those who perished by Gods will in the Old Testament. Even the unborn ripped from their mother's womb. Omni love is our salve,our fiction. Making God not even in our image and likeness. But something we prefer after reading his history in his own words.

If God wanted to save everyone in the world he would have lifted the natural carnal consciousness we are born with. He would have erased our fallen nature because the blood of God,the unblemished lamb that is Jesus,God,The Word, made flesh and who dwelt among us as Emmanuel "God with us".

But he didn't.

Why?

Truly,God only knows. But when Jesus,God The Word,tells his Disciples, and us who read his words,if he lets us to understand because our natural mind is overcome by his spirits will, he taught in parables the way to salvation because it is given to some to understand The Way. While it is not given to others. Because those others are not meant,by God,to understand and repent.

That's Jesus in the actual scripture that I've only paraphrased in part here.

He knows what he's talking about. Because he has mercy upon whom he will have mercy. And hardens whom he will harden.

God sends his words to the world. And humans debate what he actually meant to say to them.

Some do this because they're not believers. Some do this because they are. And are just trying to understand the big picture. But what they miss? They are the big picture.

That's why they understood how to find salvation. Because they first knew they needed it.

Trolls aside, Gods people have always been divided. The wheat and the chaff parable. The casting of the seeds on different ground.

It's all one whole,holy,message. Mockers be damned. As God wills.

This is life! Eternal,irrevocable.

No one can lead a born again Christian to doubt.
God leads us to learn.

The Faithful here know who we are.

So to do the fakes.

Stay the path of righteousness and don't be led down their road.

We know where we're headed at the end of this life.

We know where they're headed too. Some are already there. Read them. You'll see it. That's God too. Showing us the truth.

Discernment and righteous judgement is a blessing. And responsibility.

A long post, yes. Part was my impatience with some here. Most was just me writing what God brought to mind.

Oh,I know, that'll be mocked too.

"Love ya. Muahhhhh.". Sad.

But that's OK. God loves me. And all his Elect.

Thank you for reading me,if you got this far.

God Bless.

 
Oct 19, 2024
4,075
904
113
This isn't a competition.

This is about the power within Creation and all Created. And millennia ago that power sent us a message. Proof of The word,The Creator, is in all creation.

The inspired word is the narrative that accompanies those visuals,all of nature,including us,that lets us know not only is Holy Spirit real but "He" has something to tell us.

We are not alone here.

This isn't a game. It isn't fun to mock what Christians believe with their whole heart and live day to day.
Twisting scripture, insisting it says what we need to hear isn't clarity through the Spirit.

No doubt,as every community of Christ has them,there are those who enter and being outright atheist or skeptics,find it a hobby to make claims about the teaching in a chapter and passage just to have fun with the locals.

Shake up our world. See how long we'll spend time trying to set a misguided sister or brother on the righteous path of understanding.

Throwing in a few Ad hominems just to sate their darkness. They even mock God's love.

Most Christians are aware of these agents of the opposition.

Here's the thing.

Jesus told us our natural mind cannot understand the things of God. Because in that natural state we think that stuff is foolish.

Trolls harassing Christs own are proof of that.

No one comes to Jesus unless God leads them to him. Which means leads them to understanding what it means to come to Jesus. And that only happens to that natural man,woman,when the Holy Spirit enters into them first.

And those into whom Holy Spirit enters are known by God as his Elect. Those he elects to call to his salvation. He knew them before the foundation of the world. And he revealed,he wrote their names down in his Lamb's Book of Life.

Omni love? God hated Essau. All those who perished by Gods will in the Old Testament. Even the unborn ripped from their mother's womb. Omni love is our salve,our fiction. Making God not even in our image and likeness. But something we prefer after reading his history in his own words.

If God wanted to save everyone in the world he would have lifted the natural carnal consciousness we are born with. He would have erased our fallen nature because the blood of God,the unblemished lamb that is Jesus,God,The Word, made flesh and who dwelt among us as Emmanuel "God with us".

But he didn't.

Why?

Truly,God only knows. But when Jesus,God The Word,tells his Disciples, and us who read his words,if he lets us to understand because our natural mind is overcome by his spirits will, he taught in parables the way to salvation because it is given to some to understand The Way. While it is not given to others. Because those others are not meant,by God,to understand and repent.

That's Jesus in the actual scripture that I've only paraphrased in part here.

He knows what he's talking about. Because he has mercy upon whom he will have mercy. And hardens whom he will harden.

God sends his words to the world. And humans debate what he actually meant to say to them.

Some do this because they're not believers. Some do this because they are. And are just trying to understand the big picture. But what they miss? They are the big picture.

That's why they understood how to find salvation. Because they first knew they needed it.

Trolls aside, Gods people have always been divided. The wheat and the chaff parable. The casting of the seeds on different ground.

It's all one whole,holy,message. Mockers be damned. As God wills.

This is life! Eternal,irrevocable.

No one can lead a born again Christian to doubt.
God leads us to learn.

The Faithful here know who we are.

So to do the fakes.

Stay the path of righteousness and don't be led down their road.

We know where we're headed at the end of this life.

We know where they're headed too. Some are already there. Read them. You'll see it. That's God too. Showing us the truth.

Discernment and righteous judgement is a blessing. And responsibility.

A long post, yes. Part was my impatience with some here. Most was just me writing what God brought to mind.

Oh,I know, that'll be mocked too.

"Love ya. Muahhhhh.". Sad.

But that's OK. God loves me. And all his Elect.

Thank you for reading me,if you got this far.

God Bless.

I agree this isn't a competition.

I agree God created the world and the inspired word.

I agree we should not twist Scripture.

Yes, we should be wary of trolls, who think it fun to make twisted claims about the teaching in a chapter.

Yes, no one comes to Jesus unless God leads them to him, and those into whom Holy Spirit enters are His Elect.

"God hated Esau" was a Jewish way of saying God chose Jacob to be the Messiah's forefather.

Omni love is taught by Jesus in MT 5:44&48 and by Paul in 1TM 2:3-4, and by John in JN 3:16.

Why some people who are supposedly Christians deny God's love, God only knows.

Yes, God has mercy upon whom he will have mercy, and He wills to have mercy on those who seek Him (MT 7:7)

I wonder if those who are truly God's are divided (JN 13:35).

Paul taught that born again Christians walk by faith in 2CR 5:7.

LIC
 
Feb 15, 2025
617
309
63
I agree this isn't a competition.

I agree God created the world and the inspired word.

I agree we should not twist Scripture.

Yes, we should be wary of trolls, who think it fun to make twisted claims about the teaching in a chapter.

Yes, no one comes to Jesus unless God leads them to him, and those into whom Holy Spirit enters are His Elect.

"God hated Esau" was a Jewish way of saying God chose Jacob to be the Messiah's forefather.

Omni love is taught by Jesus in MT 5:44&48 and by Paul in 1TM 2:3-4, and by John in JN 3:16.

Why some people who are supposedly Christians deny God's love, God only knows.
The faithful know.

Yes, God has mercy upon whom he will have mercy, and He wills to have mercy on those who seek Him (MT 7:7)
As he tells us, no one can seek him unless God's holy Spirit intervenes upon the natural mind and calls us. Then,we understand. Because the things of God are no longer foolishness to them.

I wonder if those who are truly God's are divided (JN 13:35).
Wonder no more.
https://biblehub.com/topical/u/understanding_division_as_a_sign_of_faithfulness.htm

Paul taught that born again Christians walk by faith in 2CR 5:7.

LIC
"Omni love is taught by Jesus in MT 5:44&48 and by Paul in 1TM 2:3-4, and by John in JN 3:16."
For his Elect. Which precludes the Omni part.

And God ordered the killing of people all through the OT. That's not Omni love.
Because they were damned at death.
You're espousing Christian Universalism. Universal Reconciliation doctrine. That's heresy.
 
Oct 19, 2024
4,075
904
113
The faithful know.

As he tells us, no one can seek him unless God's holy Spirit intervenes upon the natural mind and calls us. Then,we understand. Because the things of God are no longer foolishness to them.

Wonder no more.
https://biblehub.com/topical/u/understanding_division_as_a_sign_of_faithfulness.htm


"Omni love is taught by Jesus in MT 5:44&48 and by Paul in 1TM 2:3-4, and by John in JN 3:16."
For his Elect. Which precludes the Omni part.

And God ordered the killing of people all through the OT. That's not Omni love.
Because they were damned at death.
You're espousing Christian Universalism. Universal Reconciliation doctrine. That's heresy.
No, God's love is unconditional or omni, but salvation is conditional upon seeking and repentance, which not everyone does.
 
Feb 15, 2025
617
309
63
No, God's love is unconditional or omni, but salvation is conditional upon seeking and repentance, which not everyone does.
The God of the Bible isn't like that.

You persist in pushing Christian Universalism,which is not scripture.

And,you are unlearnable in what is correct Godly scripture.

Thank you for proving the words of God are righteous and true.