Charles Taze Russell and the Bible Students

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#61
So, I WILL promote them all. I heard them all. I've read their books and they are RIGHT ON.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#62
Zone:"Articles on C. Peter Wagner's "New Apostolic Reformation" as well as false spiritual warfare teachings. This page includes the "successul apostles, prophets, evangelists, pastors and teachers" named on the Wagner Leadership Institute's site as those with "proven effectiveness in ministry, communications skills and a recognized anointing for the impartation of ministry skills". Beware of these "Latter Rain" advocates who would lay another foundation than the one already laid in Jesus Christ and the Apostles and Prophets of Scripture!
Do you believe everything you read? The "ARTICLES" are written by cessationists!! You should read Wagner's book "Apostles and Prophets" or Bill Hamon's book on Apostles. Get the thoughts from the people who walk in the anointing rather than nay-sayers who lack both understanding and knowledge on the subject. Wagner addresses the Apostolic reformation, latter rain, the ministries of the apostle and prophet in NT times (included today). If you have not read anything by these people, SO AS TO BE ABLE TO COMPARE IT TO GOD'S WORK AND SEE FOR YOURSELF, you do NOT have the right to discredit them.
Maggie
hi maggie.
i'm quite familiar with it all.
this is one of the most dangerous groups around, they have an agenda, they are not who you think they are.
if you must go that way, so be it but please stop openly promoting them. i have to come against it.
thank you.
zone.
 
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#63
And yes, they do make mistakes. I'm NOT cool with Bentley or Crowder and Haggard fell. BUT Let the one who has no sin throw the first stone. Otherwise look at the FRUIT.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#64
So, I WILL promote them all. I heard them all. I've read their books and they are RIGHT ON.
hi maggie.
do you agree with Roman Catholicism? (not the ordinary person: the institution and the dogma?)
thank you.
zone.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#65
And yes, they do make mistakes. I'm NOT cool with Bentley or Crowder and Haggard fell. BUT Let the one who has no sin throw the first stone. Otherwise look at the FRUIT.
this isn't about any individuals sins of the flesh maggie: that's not my business.
its about who are these people really and what is their end game.
there's a couple of things they all have in common.

thanks
zone.
 
S

silverwind

Guest
#66
oh.
i'm sorry.
i got the cul.....i mean the other church (belief) wrong.

here's something i had previously posted (before i had an angelic visit and was told i have been totally wrong) on another thread about unitarianim which is NOW ORTHODOX CHRISTIANITY. my traditional orhtodox beliefs turned out ot be a trick of satan designed to keep me from the real truth.

i'm excited to start posting on my NEW BELIEF SYSTEM, which i will post a new thread on.

it's a combination of all the beliefs until YESTERDAY (WHICH I AM SO THANKFUL FOR HAVING HAD MY PREVIOUS FOUNDATION SHAKEN), at which time i looked over the posts covering doctrines i had previously rejected....NOW I GET IT!

easy to get mixed up since i had apparently electro-shock therapy while spending 2 months on a psychiatric ward12 years ago (an agonizing and very painful and difficult time) before i got saved.

I DIDN'T KNOW THEY HAD CONDUCTED SECRET EXPERIMENTS ON ME UNTIL A MEMBER HERE POINTED IT OUT! can you believe it? thank you WESTAND/GLOWING! i am so indebted to you and Arnold Murray whom i have actually been suspicious of, but i'll post on my new thread about why i now embrace his teachings. thanks again GLOWING/WE STAND!

so johnny, anything i say can't be trusted. but i'll just babble on...that's okay here; LOTS OF PEOPLE DO IT. and since i won't use my intellect (since apparently i'm braindead) NO ONE CAN CRITICIZE ME SINCE I MUST APPROACH MY NEW BELIEFS WITH THE MIND OF A CHILD.

i'm actually glad though because it means i don't have to study anymore (since its all been striving through the works of a braindead intellect) that was apparently erased (possibly reprogrammed to become satan incarnate?) AND I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW IT! LOLOLOLOL!

~

anyways, the "STUDENTS" (Russell) have come up here before.

someone (can't remember who and who cares, really?) had gotten upset by looking at their site as a result of the good brothers here FINALLY repeating so many times that JESUS ISN'T GOD...(i am so grateful to them for thier persistence on the matter since i was becoming a Pharisee! BY BELIEVING JESUS WAS GOD! wow MAN AM I GLAD I GOT THAT RESOLVED).

here's the site the guy looked at that made him doubt the deity of Christ. unfortunately he is stilll convinced that Jesus was divine (CAN YOU IMAGINE?)....but i am hoping the unitarians and arians can can help the young man see the light. i might be able to convince people to accept the good doctrines i now embrace when i post my new thread....if i can rememeber what my beliefs are since i am braindead.

but that doesn't matter: WHATEVER I WANT TO BELIEVE IS COOL - DON'T CRITICIZE ME!

and as long as i continually remind people that i am not using my mind but am just believing what i post, I AM OFF LIMITS. no accountability because i WANT TO BE CALLED A CHRISTIAN TOO, and anyone who questions my beliefs is a BULLY, ARROGANT, RUSE, UNCHRISTIAN, A PHARISEE, A SCHOLAR, ONE OF THOSE TYPES AND JUST PLAIN DECEIVED.

what's really cool about my new Christian religion is that the bible doesn't matter so you can't use it against me: I'VE GRADUATED PAST THAT NOW because i am now a prophet also. so, PREPARE YE TO HEAR OH HARLOT CHURCH FOR I HAVE IT THAT I AM TO SPEAK TO YOU. but i'll do that later.


now where was i?......




















oh yes!
here's the unitarian aspect of my new religion (there are some links there that flesh out the rest of my religion in this regard....feel free to click around: i'll be happy to answer questions). i know quite a bit about my new religion since i was once an enemy of it all, but THANKFULLY MY EYES WERE OPENED AND NOW I CAN FELLOWSHIP WITH THOSE WHO BELIEFS WAS PREVIOUS DISMAYED OVER....beacuse i can believe whatever i want to, and i am still a CHRISTIAN - don't CRITICIZE ME! :





more to come!

YAY! this is so good.

i thought i was saved by a saviour who was actually God and that i had been a blind dead inner who He called and washed by Grace BUT COME ON!

HOW OLD FASHIONED AND COMPLICATED IS THAT?

no, my new religion is so much better.....hopefully i can convince some of you die-hard orthodox christians WITH MY PROPHECIES AND GOLD DUST AND SECRETS FROM THE HOLY PLACE, and the stuff i learned from Arnold Murray at Shepherd's Chapel and the Unitarian/Arians....plus the Chrisadelphians have some neat stuff i've added in.

there's also the fact that i now believe i have the gift of prophecy (which i have 'a word' for someone here....you know who you are), AND, i can raise people from the dead, drink poison, walk on water (i'm actually like jesus...i'm not him, buti'm like him).

i'm also now an Apostle, and so i have instruction for all you loathsome lazy workers of iniquity who are pretending to be Christians while you sit there reading your Bibles and going to chrch: HYPOCRITES!

~

ECUSE me for a moment while i go talk to God...He's here right now and want to have a face to face about someone here.....

what's that?

oh! God told me you university types and trinitarians don't know him at all.

i asked God what he meant and he said zone, see all those phonies out there who profess to know me? they draw near to me with their lips but they've never really known me?

i said, yes Lord, i think i see them. what's wrong with them Loord.

God said, they believe they know me from the scriptures. they gather in groups and think i'll hear them. but you dear zone: you are chosen because you have drawn near to me in humilty and i have made you a prophet to the nations, and apostle and have given you extraordinary powers.

i said thank you God!

God said...no problem. see you later in the holy secret place.

so anyways......going to make a thread on my new beliefs....after i go into the secret place and have my deadbrain restarted by Lectio Divina and contemplative prayer.

i have a call to make to Mike Bickle and Mr Wagner who i now believe are actually meant to rule the church: i gotta find out what MY PURPOSE IS.

back later!
Jesus is God!
Period.
End of Story. No need to add or take away from that, It is what it is...
Everyone needs to.......... GET OVER IT! :)
 
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#67
I was raised Catholic. Not very strict Catholic, but Catholic. I left the Catholic church after high school and never went back.

So....no.
Maggie

WHY do you ask?
 
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#68
Their "end Game"?

Not sure what you mean by that, but their focus is Jesus. Their GOAL, is to bring lost souls into the kingdom and to enable and empower Believers to do the will of God. Period.
 
F

Forgiven66

Guest
#69
Way to stay on topic Zone and others. Please stop using this as a place to troll and argue. Thanks to the few others who tried answering my question.

Although let me say that these bible students claim to not have similar beliefs as JW's, and claim Russell is not truly the founder of the JW's. They have told me that the JW's were formed after Russell's death.

On another note, they justify using a study book called "Studies in the Scriptures" to help them read the bible by saying it's similar to using a teacher or preacher help you study the bible but just recorded in book form.


I have heard a little bit about this group, I believe they are called "the Millienium Dawn Bible Study Group," they split from the JW, shortly after Russell's death, as the JW, made, Judge Rutherford their new president and he did make some changes to what Russell's taught, so MDBSG remain loyal to the original teachings of Russell, while the JW follow the changes that Judge Rutherford and the following Presidents after the Judge, made after Russell's death.


We are told by their fruit ye shall know them (Matthew 7:15-23). Both the Russellites, and Jehovah Witnesses have not produce the Genuine fruit of the Spirit.
 
J

johnnyyy

Guest
#70
Thank you Forgiven66 for your response that is actually on topic. I'm wondering how the Russell Bible Students do not produce fruit of the Spirit?
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
#71
hi maggie.
i'm quite familiar with it all.
this is one of the most dangerous groups around, they have an agenda, they are not who you think they are.
if you must go that way, so be it but please stop openly promoting them. I have to come against it zone.
As you in reality come against the words of Christ, it has to follow that whoever you come against does not count for much

As you cannot accept the most fundamental requirement of the Christian faith, but feel you have the spiritual authority to add to it, thereby setting aside Jesus condition of how a person must see him to have eternal life, and introducing your own conditions, adding to what Jesus clearly and continuously stated.

Thefrefore to reiterate once again, as you have in the last few hours

The Holy Spirit would NEVER contradict the plain and continuous words of Christ as to the neccessary requirement of belief in him for a person to have eternal life, such a thing is impossible. Therefore anyone who will not accept the plain and continuous words of Christ is not being led of the Holy Spirit but themselves, and Christ was clear as to what that meant

HE WHO SPEAKS ON HIS OWN DOES SO TO GAIN HONOUR FOR HIMSELF, BUT HE WHO SEEKS THE HONOUR OF THE ONE WHO SENT HIM IS A TRUE PERSON AND THERE IS NOTHNIG FALSE ABOUT HIM
John 7:18&19

It is the heart that matters to God, and any true Christian knows in their heart that the above in bold is the truth. And the results of people speaking for themselves and seeking in their hearts honour for themselves have been made abundantly apparent-this is especially true in the last few hours
 
Last edited:
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#72
Russell Student cannot produce Fruit of the HOly Spirit because they do not HAVE the Holy Spirit for IF THEY HAD the Holy Spirit they would havd discernment as to know the truth from the false. And they don't.
 
R

ResLight

Guest
#73
oh.
here's the site the guy looked at that made him doubt the deity of Christ. unfortunately he is stilll convinced that Jesus was divine (CAN YOU IMAGINE?)....but i am hoping the unitarians and arians can can help the young man see the light. i might be able to convince people to accept the good doctrines i now embrace when i post my new thread....if i can rememeber what my beliefs are since i am braindead.
Many may be surprised to know that Charles Taze Russell did believe in the deity of Christ and that Jesus is divine.

Charles Taze Russell and Deity of Christ
Russell and the Deity of Christ

Searches of Russell's Works
Trinity (Searches)

See also:
Did Arius Deny the Deity of Christ?
Trinity in the Bible?: Arius

As far as I know most Bible Students also do believe in the deity of Christ, and that Jesus is divine. They do not, however, interpret his being deity/divine to mean that Jesus is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#74
Many may be surprised to know that Charles Taze Russell did believe in the deity of Christ and that Jesus is divine.

Charles Taze Russell and Deity of Christ
Russell and the Deity of Christ

Searches of Russell's Works
Trinity (Searches)

See also:
Did Arius Deny the Deity of Christ?
Trinity in the Bible?: Arius

As far as I know most Bible Students also do believe in the deity of Christ, and that Jesus is divine. They do not, however, interpret his being deity/divine to mean that Jesus is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
yes of course.
so they are polythesists on some level. it doesn't matter, since the entire purpose is the denial that Jesus Christ is Emannuel.

they have to be polytheists because every one of those cults says man is becoming god. russell was a highranking mason, he had an agenda, and mission accomplished unfortunately for those who listen to him. the Word of Faith movement and Hinn and Co. are the SAME GROUP.

HINT:
Babylonian Talmudism (The Pharisees) teaches the same thing >> the jews received a divine spark and as a whole the jewish people ARE the messiah (secular jews, jews who hold to moses and prophets do not believe this, nor are even aware of it)...THEY CAN NOT HAVE JESUS CHRIST BEING THE GOD OF ABRAHAM ISAAC AND JACOB can they?
 
R

ResLight

Guest
#75
Charles Taze Russell is one of the FOUNDERS of the Jehovah's Witnesses.


Charles Taze Russell was never associated with the Jehovah's Witnesses organization. Russell did not believe in such an organization, and he preached against such authoritarianism.

Furthermore, Russell did not believe in the kind of message that is preached by the Jehovah's Witnesses. Russell's main message, the ransom for all, is almost the very opposite of that which the Jehovah's Witnesses preach.

I believe it is therefore incorrect to think of Charles Taze Russell as the founder of that which he did not believe in, and that which he preached against.

Russell founded no religion, no denomination, etc. He was a non-sectarian who did not believe in sectarianism or denominationalism. The only religion he believed in was that of Jesus and the apostles.

The real founder of the Jehovah's Witnesses organization was Joseph Rutherford.

See:
Russell Was Not the Founder of Jehovah's Witnesses







 
R

ResLight

Guest
#76
quote=MaggieMye;456748]Russell is a false prophet.
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/513182/Charles-Taze-Russell

[/quote]

Charles Taze Russell never claimed to be a prophet.

Charles Taze Russell plainly stated that he was not a prophet.

Charles Taze Russell plainly stated that his writings were studies in the scriptures and should not be considered as prophecy.

Charles Taze Russell plainly stated that his writings were not infallible, and he admitted the possibility of human error in his conclusions.

See:
Did Russell Claim to be a Prophet?
 
M

MaggieMye

Guest
#77
I concede. However, Russell was NOT a Biblical Christian
 
R

ResLight

Guest
#78
Russell Not a Mason



Charles Taze Russell was most definitely not a Mason. All the video presents as proof is what has to imagined and assumed, and then what is imagined and assumed has to be imagined and assumed to be fact.

We have overwhelming proof that Russell was not a member of, or in support of the goals of, the Masons' organization, in the tens of the thousands of pages that have been produced from Russell's works.

See also:http://ctr.reslight.net/?feed=rss2&cat=3
If the above link does not display correctly in your browser, use the link below:
Freemasons


 
R

ResLight

Guest
#79
Bible Students Refused to Join Rutherford's New Organization

I have heard a little bit about this group, I believe they are called "the Millienium Dawn Bible Study Group," they split from the JW, shortly after Russell's death
More correctly, the Bible Students movement (as a whole, represented by the majority), rejected Rutherford's new organization and his new gospel. The JWs to this day put forth the perception that the JW organization existed in Russell's day, and that Rutherford simply continued such an organization, while those they consider "opposers" are said to have "left" the organization. In reality, within a few months, Rutherford, in effect, had destroyed the legal entity that Russell had left, and had replaced it with a new entity that simply bore the same name.

What happened is that (over the next decade after Russell died) the majority of the Bbile Students refused to accept Rutherford's new "organization" dogma, as well as his new gospel. From the perspective of most of these Bible Students, they were not "leaving" that new organization, they simply refused to join that new organization. Most them would say that they simply remained "Bible Students".

In Russell's day, each congregation was an individual and independent group of Bible Students; there was no central authority that claimed rulership over the congregations. Many tried to make Russell into such, but he refused to take on such a role, even over those congregations that ordained him as "pastor" (shepherd). He viewed himself as under-shepherd, always pointing to the Most High shepherd -- Jehovah (Psalm 23:1) -- and the one whom Jehovah appointed over his sheep as shepherd (Ezekiel 34:23; John 10:29) -- and the apostles to whom all truth was made known through the holy spirit (John 14:26; 16:4-13; Galatians 1:12; Ephesians 3:5; 2 Timothy 2:2; Jude 1:3) -- as the only true authority in the church.

Russell stated:

Indeed, so far as the true Church is concerned, the only authority in it is the Lord, the Head of the Church, and his Word, and the words of those whom he specially chose to be his mouth-pieces, the apostles.


By 1930, the majority of the Bible Students movement was carrying on their affairs without Rutherford. Rutherford, in 1931, named his new organization "Jehovah's Witnesses" in order that his new organization would be distinguished from the general Bible Students movement.
 
R

ResLight

Guest
#80
Fruit of the Spirit

We are told by their fruit ye shall know them (Matthew 7:15-23). Both the Russellites, and Jehovah Witnesses have not produce the Genuine fruit of the Spirit.
Jesus was not speaking of any group, organization or movement as whole when he said by their fruits you shall know them. He was speaking of any Christian as an individual, whether he might associated with any denomination, any sect, any movement. It is the individual Christian that must produce the fruit of the spirit; the individual cannot leave that to being dependent on association with a sectarian denomination, organization, etc. Indeed, such a sectarian spirit hinders the development of the fruit of the spirit.

Also, each individual Christian is at various levels of developing the fruit of the spirit, and every Christian is also hindered by the remains of body -- the sinful flesh -- in which the holy spirit resides; one does not convert and all of sudden display all the fruit of the holy spirit within the flesh. Having, however, been begotten (or, born again) as new creatures, the new creation itself, apart from the flesh is totally without sin. It is the new creation that needs to develop the fruit of the spirit, which, in turn, brings the sinful flesh into subjection.

All of this, however, has little to do with being members of either of Jehovah's Witnesses, the Bible Students movement, Baptists, Methodists, Catholic, etc. Indeed, to whatever extent the Christian has any kind of sectarian spirit, even if that sectarian spirit be associated with the Bible Students, to that extent he is being carnal in his thinking, and even though he made be a "born again" Christian, God's holy spirit is hindered; such may remain as a child even though he may still be a new creature in Christ; the apostle Paul says that such thoughts are carnal, and every Christian that gets carried away with such sectarianism will need to be disciplined (as a son) for such.

See what I have written on sectarianism:
Sectarianism Bible Students Info Site

Russell on Sectarianism:
Sectarianism