Do Dispensationalism and Free-will Salvation question God's providence?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
H

Hoffco

Guest
#21
Sorry, Abiding, What are you sayings, who is presenting "manmade doctrine". We are discussing the Eternal decrees of God's sovereign will. Namely His decree of salvation to His elect sinners vs, the free will teach of many dispensationalists. Who is this "Op"
 
H

Hoffco

Guest
#22
The answer to the question above is, NO. The thing that free will questions is ,the sovereignty of God. God's will is sovereign over man's will. Man can not change the sov. will of God. King Nebuchadnezzer had to become dumb to learn that God rules heaven and earth, the free will baptist and others, have never learned it yet. they reject the God if the Bible for their weak pathetic god of their making. Abiding, Who in here is presenting vain philosophy? who is "Op"?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#23
They go hand in hand. Part of dispensationalism is the belief that the method of salvation changed. It is only logical to at least touch on the corelation between free-will salvation and dispensationalism as I believe it stands... a question of God being omnipotent to the extent of election regardless of the century or the people.

Not all dispensationalists believe the method changed, Lets get this corrected first.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#24
The answer to the question above is, NO. The thing that free will questions is ,the sovereignty of God. God's will is sovereign over man's will. Man can not change the sov. will of God. King Nebuchadnezzer had to become dumb to learn that God rules heaven and earth, the free will baptist and others, have never learned it yet. they reject the God if the Bible for their weak pathetic god of their making. Abiding, Who in here is presenting vain philosophy? who is "Op"?
Nebachadnezzar proved free will. God had to put road blocks in his way to get him to do what he wanted. He could have easily just "forced him" But he did not.

God does not remove free will, he works through it. Hi omniscience (knowledge of future events, or how people will act) helps him to put people in place he KNOWS will chose freely to do his will.



 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#25
God's righteousness has always been imputed in both the OT and the NT. Faith has always been the vehicle through which God imputes His righteousness.
A proper understanding of the fall of mankind in the garden is essential to understanding man's relationship to God as his creator.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#26
uh oh,do I have bad breath or am I taking your breath away? The truth is very rare today, so it can be overwhelming . The fact is ,christians do not study the Bible , grammatically, contextually, and historically. The lie of the devil is, since an epistles is written to a church, every thing in it has to relate to christians, this is a tragic error. much of the epistles are condemning the unholy professing carnal believers. I am not so sure,the church will ever recover from their apostasy.? I pray for a new wave of sal. from God , but I doubt it is going to happen. Millions of believers have no assurance of sal, because they are still in their sins. All this Justification by faith alone is just sealing them in their false decision and taking them to hell. Sanctification of the Spirit is the first work in sal. justification is 2nd, after the new birth,. New birth is a sovereign call of God giving life to a dead soul, then we are able to respond in repentance, faith and holiness. John Pipper is good on the necessity of works in true sal. listen to his message on Rom.2:4-13 very good.
lol You put me to sleep :p Church this morning...
The interpretation of James 2:4 is still not pertaining to works for salvation. Not sure if we are still beating heads about that. :) It is true that many are not confident in their salvation, and I believe it's a failure to understand that salvation is a promise that is not fulfilled by anything that we do as humans. If, with that understanding, a person still doubts their salvation, they are doubting God and needs to deal with that issue... not because they might not be saved, but because they are too self-centered. Not by works of righteousness that we have done, but because of his mercy we are saved.
 
J

jimmydiggs

Guest
#27
Dispensationalism and free will, neither of the two can be found in scripture. Disp teaches there are two Gospels and free will teaches there are two saviors.
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#28
God's righteousness has always been imputed in both the OT and the NT. Faith has always been the vehicle through which God imputes His righteousness.
A proper understanding of the fall of mankind in the garden is essential to understanding man's relationship to God as his creator.
God's righteousness is what creates right and wrong (hang in there before gasping). Without the law there is no consequence for sin... and salvation would be unnecessary (Rom. 5:13) Regardless of what time a person is born they are responsible, because God requires justification, for their actions. We do not have free will of any kind before salvation because we are in bondage to sin. Through the purchase of Christ's redemption we are purchased from that sin and commanded unto good works... to follow the steps that God FOREORDAINTED for us to follow.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#29
AH,sorry, James 2:24. The context is on "faith without works is dead". Pastor are always reading verses out of context, this is why we are so deceived on sal. today. because believers will not receive God's word, God has sent a spirit of deception amon the churches to believe the lie, of "faith alone." We need a new reformation to finish some undone work of the reformation
count me OUT of your "new reformation"
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
#30
Dispensationalism and free will, neither of the two can be found in scripture. Disp teaches there are two Gospels and free will teaches there are two saviors.
wow diggs.
good catch.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
#31
Dispensationalism and free will, neither of the two can be found in scripture. Disp teaches there are two Gospels and free will teaches there are two saviors.
We must have two different bibles.

Dispensationalism does not always teach there are two gospels (although some does) And free will does not teach two saviors.
 
J

jimmydiggs

Guest
#32
We must have two different bibles.
I know it's summer and all but sometimes you have to take the glasses off, then you can see the light.

Dispensationalism does not always teach there are two gospels (although some does) And free will does not teach two saviors.
Dispensationalism at it's root teaches two gospels. It's hard to remain a dispy and not create two gospels whether explicitly or by implication. Free will teaches two saviors, because it takes you and Jesus to save yourself.
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#34
God's righteousness is what creates right and wrong (hang in there before gasping). Without the law there is no consequence for sin... and salvation would be unnecessary (Rom. 5:13) Regardless of what time a person is born they are responsible, because God requires justification, for their actions. We do not have free will of any kind before salvation because we are in bondage to sin. Through the purchase of Christ's redemption we are purchased from that sin and commanded unto good works... to follow the steps that God FOREORDAINTED for us to follow.
The consequence of sin was before the law. God told Adam in the garden that if he ate of the forbidden fruit he would die. Sin is the cause of death. First spiritual death and eventually physical death.
The entrance of the law made sin personal. The law says thou shalt not to every man who hears it. Even Gentiles who were without the law still knew it was wrong to murder, steal and commit other lewd acts.
When we become saved by grace through faith we are Gods workmanship unto good works. Our works are good because of our position in Christ. We are adopted sons so we can now please our Father. When we are the children of hell we can do no good works even if they are the same works a believer does.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#35
Dispensationalism and free will, neither of the two can be found in scripture. Disp teaches there are two Gospels and free will teaches there are two saviors.
This is difficult to respond to this in a kind manner. Dispensationalism teaches only that there is a passage of time. God has prophecied events that are future when given but come to present with the passage of time. The world was promised a Savior. the prophecy came by way of Israel. Israel still looks for her Savior. Is there any honor or virtue in continuing to wait for that which has already come to pass? Dispensations are not the creation of man but are there to be recognized by man. Dispensations are helpful in our understanding of what God has done and what God is doing.
Free will was given to man at his creation. God made man in His likeness and image. Man's will must be submitted to God through love if man is to glorify God. If man was compelled to submit to God without free will God would not receive the glory that is due Him. God created man not a robot.
Being against dispensations is like being against breakfast, lunch and dinner time. Perhaps the anti-dispensationists only eat pulse at every meal.
Those against free will truly do not understand the sovereignty of God.
The bible never says that resistance is futile you will be assimilated. It says whosoever will may come.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#36
We must have two different bibles.

Dispensationalism does not always teach there are two gospels (although some does) And free will does not teach two saviors.
In a manner of speaking they actually do teach two gospels and two saviors. Dispensationalism teaches that in the Old Testament sacrifices were required for salvation and the New testament teaches grace alone without works is required for salvation. Free-will salvation requires that God's death and resurrection may be required to justify, but we actively have to ACCEPT that He was able to save and does... hence two saviors (God and self).
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#37
This is difficult to respond to this in a kind manner. Dispensationalism teaches only that there is a passage of time. God has prophecied events that are future when given but come to present with the passage of time. The world was promised a Savior. the prophecy came by way of Israel. Israel still looks for her Savior. Is there any honor or virtue in continuing to wait for that which has already come to pass? Dispensations are not the creation of man but are there to be recognized by man. Dispensations are helpful in our understanding of what God has done and what God is doing.
Free will was given to man at his creation. God made man in His likeness and image. Man's will must be submitted to God through love if man is to glorify God. If man was compelled to submit to God without free will God would not receive the glory that is due Him. God created man not a robot.
Being against dispensations is like being against breakfast, lunch and dinner time. Perhaps the anti-dispensationists only eat pulse at every meal.
Those against free will truly do not understand the sovereignty of God.
The bible never says that resistance is futile you will be assimilated. It says whosoever will may come.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
The original meaning and the evolved meaning of doctrines are two different things... but one should base their stance on an ideology based on original intent. Examples would be Halloween, Islam, and Dispensationalism. The creation of Dispensationalism in the church was an attempt to explain why we no longer need to sacrifice and follow many Old Testament laws. Today many dispensationalists believe is what is dubbed 4 and 9/10's Calvinism. The original dispensationalists believed as stated as above... that God was not able to complete the salvation of a man without that man's permission.
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#38
Sorry, Abiding, What are you sayings, who is presenting "manmade doctrine". We are discussing the Eternal decrees of God's sovereign will. Namely His decree of salvation to His elect sinners vs, the free will teach of many dispensationalists. Who is this "Op"
Wondering if he means Orthodox Presbyterian
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#39
In a manner of speaking they actually do teach two gospels and two saviors. Dispensationalism teaches that in the Old Testament sacrifices were required for salvation and the New testament teaches grace alone without works is required for salvation. Free-will salvation requires that God's death and resurrection may be required to justify, but we actively have to ACCEPT that He was able to save and does... hence two saviors (God and self).
Simply not true. You have not grasped what God has taught. The Jews to this day have not grasped this either.

I can say without reservation that God does not save any soul against its will. It is wholly false to conclude that a man who bows his head and receives Christ is somehow contributing to Christ's work as Savior. Jesus taught that He submitted His will to His Father's will.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
M

Mammachickadee

Guest
#40
I was refreshing my 5 point Calvinism when it hit me. The fact that believers across the world and throughout history disagreed with each other on salvation but some were still believers is proof that free-will salvation is false and God's sovereignty and election is the glue that holds the church together.