Psychology/Psychiatry/Counseling

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
T

Tintin

Guest
#41

Poison being the key word. Doctors are paid to push drugs on people. There's no better way to natural, whole healing than through the word of Christ, a health diet, exercise and supplements for healing. Medication may temporarily solve one problem for an intermediate time period alone and gives several others long term, it also affects longevity of life too. The practice of psychology is totally independent and doesn't encapsulate the words of God and as such cannot provide the same healing our creator can.
But God can make use of Christian psychologists for our good and for His glory.
 
R

RobbyEarl

Guest
#42
Where is the church? Why would a pastor send a man to a man? Jesus is the only answer. I remember when ambulances would stop by the church on the way to the hospital. Why the church has no power today I do not understand, but yet I do. The church has leaned on the knowledge of man and not the power of God. My associates have cleaned out mental institutions under the power of God. The church needs to recognize the power of God. A pastor that refers you to a psychologist is a blind man leading the blind.
 
Dec 16, 2012
1,483
114
63
#43
Personally I believe that any Psychology/Psychiatry/counselling that is not based on the finished work of Christ is just trying to manipulate the flesh and will have just very limited results.
Absolutely. It's very different when you've come from a formal background of study in psychology and you've got a really close relationship with the Lord to see where things align with God's word, in the bible and in your spirit. The word of the Lord is the answer.
 
R

RobbyEarl

Guest
#44
Absolutely. It's very different when you've come from a formal background of study in psychology and you've got a really close relationship with the Lord to see where things align with God's word, in the bible and in your spirit. The word of the Lord is the answer.
Psychology is mans answer, a psychologist can't even prescribe medicine.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,780
2,943
113
#45
[O


If you do not mind my asking. Do you lead these in your group in prayer? I understand that you would like to lead these to Christ and if they know you are a Christisn would they be against you leading them (or even praying for them ) in prayer?
Sadly, I can not pray with them, although I do promise to pray for them when they are struggling. A while back I had 3 atheists in the group that lit into me and caused a big scene, saying I was pushing Christianity on them. (I never so much as quoted a Buble verse!) After much verbal abuse, they left the group, which hurt terribly at the time, but ended up being the best thing that could have happened. We opened the group up to new members, but that included in die hard atheist so it is still a no-go with prayer. Although the hostile atmosphere created by just the presence of those three atheists is gone, and people are not afraid to speak any more! (Is that demonic, or what?)

I continue to pray for all the members, and the ones in the group respect my leadership, but it remains a secular group. Still, it is something God has called me to, and I know certain individuals are very close to believing, so I will continue to walk a fine line.
 

Angela53510

Senior Member
Jan 24, 2011
11,780
2,943
113
#46
There is no empirical evidence that the brain of someone diagnosed with bipolar, paranoid, ect has a brain any different than any other brain. There is no way to measure if someone is lacking any specific chemical.

My personal experiece with pyschotropic drugs was very negative as was that of everyone I know.

Noone treated with these poisons gets better......
The RA meds I take are very toxic. They are mostly chemo drugs; they damage the liver, kidneys, and lungs. My liver and lungs have been damaged by them. Plus, I am not cured! I have to remain on them till I die, unless someone figures out a way to turn off the genes that trigger RA.

So why would I take such poisons? Because I can get out of bed and dress myself, groom and feed myself. I can contribute in my church and play with my grandchildren. We won't even get into the pain and deformities the disease causes. And incidently, my RA was a type that showed nothing on blood tests, although I was eventually diagnosed by symptoms.

Someone with serious mental illness is no different than me. Their brain is very sick! And although there is no test for Axis 1 disorders, symptoms can definitely be indicative of bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder and depression with psychosis. (This is not major depression) There has been a lot of work done with brain imaging, and there are marked differences in the brains of people who suffer from these disorders. This is not personality disorders, which are not truly treatable with medications, or even major depression!

So these people take the meds, and somewhat like RA meds, they try different drugs until they find the drugs that work the best, with the least side effects. (I've gone off 4 RA drugs because of the side effects!) these drugs do a variety of things, including keep them from getting irrationally paranoid, from experiencing audio or visual hallucinations, minimizing the mood swings, helping with suicidal ideation, and finally, minimizing or eliminating psychosis. Things which, like my RA, don't seem to respond to Biblical counselling!

In fact, one of the Christian women experiences terrible paranoia in response to certain end times scenarios. I've been teaching her that much of what she believes is "pop" theology, and not Biblical. When she thinks about it rationally, she thinks I am right, but when her brain is not working properly, she gets paranoid anyway! And if not over that, then something else irrational! This is one person I do take aside and pray for her, and it does give her peace and calms her down. But she, like every other person in the group, accept that they need to be med compliant or end up "in-patient" after a psychotic break.

I'm sorry if you, or someone you know did not respond well to meds. But probably the severity of mental illness was not there. I am also a big believer in natural methods to work in combo with the meds. That includes good sleep hygiene, exercise, keeping a schedule, counselling and certainly prayer and reading the Bible daily. But for my group, at least, the meds are essential, regardless of how toxic they are!
 
Last edited:

mcubed

Senior Member
Dec 20, 2013
1,449
218
63
#47
Sadly, I can not pray with them, although I do promise to pray for them when they are struggling. A while back I had 3 atheists in the group that lit into me and caused a big scene, saying I was pushing Christianity on them. (I never so much as quoted a Buble verse!) After much verbal abuse, they left the group, which hurt terribly at the time, but ended up being the best thing that could have happened. We opened the group up to new members, but that included in die hard atheist so it is still a no-go with prayer. Although the hostile atmosphere created by just the presence of those three atheists is gone, and people are not afraid to speak any more! (Is that demonic, or what?)

I continue to pray for all the members, and the ones in the group respect my leadership, but it remains a secular group. Still, it is something God has called me to, and I know certain individuals are very close to believing, so I will continue to walk a fine line.
This makes me sadder than you will ever know. If you know Him you are in the Light, no atheist is ever in the light. Samuel said I will not sin against G-d and not pray for you. Always step out in faith not a fine line. G-d is bold where you lack He picks up the rest!!
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,231
6,529
113
#48
While attending the University of Illinois..Champaign-Urbana, the majority of the Psych department grad students were relatively close friends. In conversation it was easy to ascertain and obtain admissions that each of the post-doctorate students were in this field in order to learn more about his own problems, and each were complex personalities, even to a non-psych major as I.

Also while living briefly in Paris, I made friends with a psychiatrist at a neighborhood cafe in Fontenay-sous-Bois, a neighborhood of Paris near the Chateau Vincennes. After a time my friend confided that he had become a psychiatrist in order to confront and overcome his own problems, and they were dark problems. It seems at one point in his life previous, his greatest desire was to murder his mother, his girlfriend, a priest, and a prostitue. Obviously he had overcome this desire, but oh the darkness in his life.

Because I know these people, knew them, I believed that they all needed to know Jesus more than anything else, however I was not yet in the Lord, so this thinking is in retrospect.

God is the answer to all problems when it gets right down to the bottom line. Perhaps there is some, maybe much, self--help availed by psychology and/or psychiatry, but even so, I believe if it is successful, it is only because God is doing the healing.
 
T

Tintin

Guest
#49
Absolutely. It's very different when you've come from a formal background of study in psychology and you've got a really close relationship with the Lord to see where things align with God's word, in the bible and in your spirit. The word of the Lord is the answer.
Ah, I see what you're saying. Very good. God bless you. :)
 
T

Tintin

Guest
#50
This makes me sadder than you will ever know. If you know Him you are in the Light, no atheist is ever in the light. Samuel said I will not sin against G-d and not pray for you. Always step out in faith not a fine line. G-d is bold where you lack He picks up the rest!!
I don't feel you're really in a position to question Angela's walk with God. She absolutely stands for God's truth. But she also knows when it's more important and worthwhile to wait for the right moment. To have bold faith requires someone to know when to speak up and when to shut up. And Angela knows this full well.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,231
6,529
113
#51
We are taught to pray for our enemies but not to pray for any activity that is sinful. We pray for all souls. If when we pray this is our prayer and not for the wrong-doing of the sinner, we are doing the works given by God.

If we pray for the sin of another, we are participating in their sing, but by all means pray for the sinner, always, amen.
 
Mar 2, 2016
8,896
112
0
#52
I've never seen GOD make things worse for people and yet people in need do not consider prayed and prayer is neglected
Sometimes pastors are above their pay grade in regards to ministering to emotional health. There isn't always only a spiritual solution to peoples problems. Sometimes a religious person does more harm than good.
 
Dec 1, 2014
9,701
251
0
#53
I have a real hard time with Psychology/Psychiatry. I guess I feel God/Word of God can deal with these issues. Anyone else feel this way or am I a minority? :)
I agree, and of course we can always talk with God, but there are times it feels good to talk with someone in person and share a bond with them based on compassion and understanding.
 

miknik5

Senior Member
Jun 2, 2016
7,833
588
113
#55
We are taught to pray for our enemies but not to pray for any activity that is sinful. We pray for all souls. If when we pray this is our prayer and not for the wrong-doing of the sinner, we are doing the works given by God.

If we pray for the sin of another, we are participating in their sing, but by all means pray for the sinner, always, amen.
I'm not sure I am understanding your post
 

miknik5

Senior Member
Jun 2, 2016
7,833
588
113
#56
Sometimes pastors are above their pay grade in regards to ministering to emotional health. There isn't always only a spiritual solution to peoples problems. Sometimes a religious person does more harm than good.
Prayer and praying to GOD is always THE most important "solution". It does not necessarily ensure one will be healed but prayer in all things is very important and necessary
 
Feb 26, 2015
737
7
0
#57
Telling a person with mental issues to just Pray to God is very dangerous, if not criminal at best!

Many people have very real problems that need intensive counseling and medications.

If a person is depressed and very suicidal and all you want them to do is pray to God??? No!
 

tanakh

Senior Member
Dec 1, 2015
4,635
1,040
113
76
#58
I wonder why people feel that way about psychology.
I feel it's like saying "oh, your broken leg will mend itself in time, no need for a cast"
If every illness Physical or Mental could be healed by prayer every Hospital would be closed and Psychiatrists would be looking for new jobs. Also every Christian would belong to the Christian Scientist Church and be an avid devotee of Mary Baker Eddy.
 
Mar 2, 2016
8,896
112
0
#59
Prayer and praying to GOD is always THE most important "solution". It does not necessarily ensure one will be healed but prayer in all things is very important and necessary
A man doesn't always get what he prays for but he always reaps what he justly earns.