Response to Critique of Calvinism

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,621
281
83
If God knows all truth, then there is not any "chance".

Let me explain.

Suppose I am going to make a choice, either "A" or "B".

Suppose you say I chose "A". Is that a true statement? It is if I chose "A". If I chose "B", then it is not a true statement.

Let's say I chose "A". Then the statement that I chose "A" is a true statement.

But God knows ALL TRUTH! And so, God knows which choice I made, even though it is a free choice.

Abraham chose to sacrifice his son. That it a truth and God knew it because it is His nature to know ALL TRUTH.

It has nothing to do with seeing into the future or taking chances. Do you understand now?

This may sound a little contrived to you, and yet, it is no more contrived than saying that God chose certain people to be saved and others to be condemned, but yet He holds them accountable because they still "choose" whether to believe or not.
Your take was unusual and had its advantages. However, the issue still boils down to what the ground of Abraham's election is. Did God's "foreknowledge" of Abraham's actions have any "part" in His choosing of Him - or not? Is foreseeing of the "right choices" an integral part of God's election or is right choices made as a result of God working in those He has chosen, without any foreseeing of "right choices"?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
Ya zone came:p in a said i killed the thread
and its been like this since
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,709
3,650
113
lol yeah. It is obvous Abrham knew who God was when he called him. and probably already had a relationship with him.. Thats why abraham did not question God. he went.. knowing God could fulfill his promise.
Couldn't the same be said of Ambimelech" God called him in a dream.Told him to lay off Sarah, Ambimelech immediately obeyed without question, but all this doesn't imply Ambimelech had a previous 'knowing' of God did it"
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Couldn't the same be said of Ambimelech" God called him in a dream.Told him to lay off Sarah, Ambimelech immediately obeyed without question, but all this doesn't imply Ambimelech had a previous 'knowing' of God did it"
That would be an assumption. I would not want to even go there..

If you just had a dream from someone you did not know. would you immediately obay? Human nature says we only obey those we already trust, or those put in charge over us.. And then,, if their is really no trust, we will only obey what we want, we did this as kids.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,709
3,650
113
That would be an assumption. I would not want to even go there..

If you just had a dream from someone you did not know. would you immediately obay? Human nature says we only obey those we already trust, or those put in charge over us.. And then,, if their is really no trust, we will only obey what we want, we did this as kids.
So when God appears in a dream, Ambimelech already knew God? Trusted Him?
 

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,621
281
83
Yes you have many times said you absolutely refuse to believe in any kind prevenient grace.
What do you mean here i go again? Tribesman dont ever say again i bear false witness.
Its hard enuf right now to even talk with you.
I say what is right. That I don't accept that doctrine is not the same thing as not accepting anything than what I think. And, fine with me. You don't need to talk to me at all. Just drop it. I am not interested in your agreement. I can also say enough as I have already seen through your despising and scorning (which you have tried to hide) is just showing what you are up to. Serious stuff. Hopefully you'll repent and come out of the cave.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
God uses everyone sinner and saint.
Mixing that with salvation i dont think is good.
Its never been a question of what God can do
but whether we can glean from scripture what
He does do and why.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
I say what is right. That I don't accept that doctrine is not the same thing as not accepting anything than what I think. And, fine with me. You don't need to talk to me at all. Just drop it. I am not interested in your agreement. I can also say enough as I have already seen through your despising and scorning (which you have tried to hide) is just showing what you are up to. Serious stuff. Hopefully you'll repent and come out of the cave.
Yes youve noticed me the last couple days after you went off on everyone.
Dont call it scorn, nor make it into some creepy despising dealy. Or say im hiding it
after ive made it very clear publically. Your acting above your paygrade and not
Ill say it again NOT obeying scripture in your actions. OK? you clear now?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
Prolly be a good time for a turkey snack
 

superdave5221

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2009
1,409
31
48
Your take was unusual and had its advantages. However, the issue still boils down to what the ground of Abraham's election is. Did God's "foreknowledge" of Abraham's actions have any "part" in His choosing of Him - or not? Is foreseeing of the "right choices" an integral part of God's election or is right choices made as a result of God working in those He has chosen, without any foreseeing of "right choices"?
You are still not getting it. Your use of the term "foreseeing" and "foreknowledge" indicate that you do not understand my argument.

God knows all truth as part of His nature. Knowing Truth is as much a part of His nature as omniscience and omnipotence. In fact, it fits in that word "omniscience".

God does not view time as we do. He sees Truth. It is part of His nature to know all events in time. It is not something that He views or foresees. It is our nature to sin. We don't have to learn to sin. It comes naturally. It is God's nature to know all Truth. He doesn't have to learn it, or foresee it.

God chose Abraham because of the truth He knew to be that Abraham would respond to grace the way that he did.

This is a difficult concept. But it is more difficult for me to believe that God created certain people with the express purpose of sending them to Hell.

That may be true. And God can do as He wishes and He doesn't have to explain Himself to me, but it goes against what I believe to be God's nature of love and justice.
 

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,621
281
83
Yes youve noticed me the last couple days after you went off on everyone.
Dont call it scorn, nor make it into some creepy despising dealy. Or say im hiding it
after ive made it very clear publically. Your acting above your paygrade and not
Ill say it again NOT obeying scripture in your actions. OK? you clear now?
It wasn't "everyone" and it wasn't without a reason. You looked for a reason to go against me and thought you find an excuse to do so. Then your despise, scorn and envy (that was only subtly seen or hinted at in earlier posts) came out in the open. Your colors showed off as no "friend" at all, though you wanted to masquerade as such. The purpose of your activity here at cc is clear to me now and I see it as meaningless to further discuss with you. You speaking of "obeying scripture" I can not take seriously seeing this. Sad as that is. But let's drop this then.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
And that has no conflict with scripture. In fact it harmonizes:cool:
 

tribesman

Senior Member
Oct 13, 2011
4,621
281
83
You are still not getting it. Your use of the term "foreseeing" and "foreknowledge" indicate that you do not understand my argument.

God knows all truth as part of His nature. Knowing Truth is as much a part of His nature as omniscience and omnipotence. In fact, it fits in that word "omniscience".

God does not view time as we do. He sees Truth. It is part of His nature to know all events in time. It is not something that He views or foresees. It is our nature to sin. We don't have to learn to sin. It comes naturally. It is God's nature to know all Truth. He doesn't have to learn it, or foresee it.

God chose Abraham because of the truth He knew to be that Abraham would respond to grace the way that he did.

This is a difficult concept. But it is more difficult for me to believe that God created certain people with the express purpose of sending them to Hell.

That may be true. And God can do as He wishes and He doesn't have to explain Himself to me, but it goes against what I believe to be God's nature of love and justice.
Let's drop the terms foreseeing and foreknowledge then. We simply do not agree on what ground God chose Abraham.

Would God be "unjust" and "unloving" if He only predestinated certain individuals to glory and actively or passively passing by the rest?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
It wasn't "everyone" and it wasn't without a reason. You looked for a reason to go against me and thought you find an excuse to do so. Then your despise, scorn and envy (that was only subtly seen or hinted at in earlier posts) came out in the open. Your colors showed off as no "friend" at all, though you wanted to masquerade as such. The purpose of your activity here at cc is clear to me now and I see it as meaningless to further discuss with you. You speaking of "obeying scripture" I can not take seriously seeing this. Sad as that is. But let's drop this then.
Tribesman theres not a thing i can do about your imagination. Ill admit i dont like your doctrine ok?
But you know ive been kind to you.

No im not gunning for you. Im not even in total disagreement with some here who have
some error in their teaching to be admonished, even slight rebuke. But you did go way
too far...then started on the ladies, then some elders....think what you want.
Im not doing whatever spooky thing your describing.

You see my purpose huh? ok then.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
I did predict we would get into philosophy
then impose it upon scripture.
Then force answers.
 

superdave5221

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2009
1,409
31
48
Let's drop the terms foreseeing and foreknowledge then. We simply do not agree on what ground God chose Abraham.

Would God be "unjust" and "unloving" if He only predestinated certain individuals to glory and actively or passively passing by the rest?
God is fully justified in sending anyone to Hell as everyone has broken His Law. But when you combine His love in sending His Son to die on the cross to justify our sins, it seems that if everyone is guilty, and God is no respecter of persons, why would He choose to limit the atonement to only a few?

I am not claiming to know the answers. I do know that God is Holy and just in all that He does, whether or not I understand it. I am just trying to find something that makes sense to me and does not contradict the Word of God. If my idea is unbiblical, then show me. I will accept it and move on.
 
T

tdrew777

Guest
WOW!!! I'm fairly new here, these kind of conversations have their difficulties...and their pleasures.

I am on the other side of the world from most of you, so I go to bed and when I wake up - over a hundred posts to respond to. I wish I could take the time to respond to each one that deserves a response but....that would be an impossible task. So I lose control of 'my' thread....Which also has its advantages, I suppose.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
WOW!!! I'm fairly new here, these kind of conversations have their difficulties...and their pleasures.

I am on the other side of the world from most of you, so I go to bed and when I wake up - over a hundred posts to respond to. I wish I could take the time to respond to each one that deserves a response but....that would be an impossible task. So I lose control of 'my' thread....Which also has its advantages, I suppose.
Ya weve been waiting for you to give us some direction tdrew welcome back:p
 

superdave5221

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2009
1,409
31
48
Ok, I gotta go to bed. I will answer tomorrow. Good night!