81% of Christians think Christianity is following rules in the bible

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
Personally I have never heard of the term "mystery doctrine" before today but I knew what Gr8grace was talking about when he mentioned it. Immediately in my spirit came "Christ in you."
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
Just a wee bit of research reveals that the term mystery doctrine is code language for the dispensational view of grace. We have seen elements of that here in those who reject the whole counsel of GOD and claim that what Jesus spoke to the apostles was for the Jews (the gospel of the kingdom), but what Paul wrote was a mystery not revealed to the other apostles and is only for the church (the gospel of grace). In other words, two gospels.
I believe that gr8grace who used this term has a dispensational view of grace. I think. Is that correct, gr8grace?
 
Feb 11, 2016
2,501
40
0
That's right. The mystery of GOD has been openly and plainly revealed for the whole world to see. Except , of course, to those who gnosis better.

Well there is that which are called mysteries, even things which are already spoken of which God gives us insight into. I never heard of this mystery doctrine, but we know they were stewards of the mysteries of God. Even as Paul speaks of that which was written of the two becoming one (back in Genesis) he is speaking along the lines of Christ and the church, so he hints what is shown plainly (on the one hand) contains more then what meets the eye and speaking in this mystery of Christ in you just the same.

Even in carnal things there are mysteries to me, I mean, a lot of what my own dogs did or do can be a mystery to me, or even what my husband is taken in by, and the scripture speaks of mysteries, I just never heard of a mysetry doctrine. I understand what you mean in that. I recall once someone calling what is "called" (meaning some denomination) "The church of Christ" heretical (in some sense) and I stood there hearing this for the first time (not understanding that the true words for church of Christ is adopted in name to another organization (which is shortsighted somehow) and I just find peoples wording difficult to follow, and so I need to guess half the time, "Are they speaking of a specific church or doctrine they deem heretical or will they just snag you on a word to condemn you" (which seems very common from the earliest of days even till now).

So sometimes you dont know what someone is talking about. I was going to ask what is meant by this doctrine, but then I keep reminding myself not to ask questions in this climate (which is hard for me to remember not to do) but thats a bad habit I am dealing with (Im working on it).
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Well there is that which are called mysteries, even things which are already spoken of which God gives us insight into. I never heard of this mystery doctrine, but we know they were stewards of the mysteries of God. Even as Paul speaks of that which was written of the two becoming one (back in Genesis) he is speaking along the lines of Christ and the church, so he hints what is shown plainly (on the one hand) contains more then what meets the eye and speaking in this mystery of Christ in you just the same.

Even in carnal things there are mysteries to me, I mean, a lot of what my own dogs did or do can be a mystery to me, or even what my husband is taken in by, and the scripture speaks of mysteries, I just never heard of a mysetry doctrine. I understand what you mean in that. I recall once someone calling what is "called" (meaning some denomination) "The church of Christ" heretical (in some sense) and I stood there hearing this for the first time (not understanding that the true words for church of Christ is adopted in name to another organization (which is shortsighted somehow) and I just find peoples wording difficult to follow, and so I need to guess half the time, "Are they speaking of a specific church or doctrine they deem heretical or will they just snag you on a word to condemn you" (which seems very common from the earliest of days even till now).

So sometimes you dont know what someone is talking about. I was going to ask what is meant by this doctrine, but then I keep reminding myself not to ask questions in this climate (which is hard for me to remember not to do) but thats a bad habit I am dealing with (Im working on it).
there is nothing wrong with asking a question sis. In fact, I would rather you ask than now, as most of us would.

Certain people will not ask or even attempt to figure out what the person is saying, and just place people in a grouping, even if that person is not saying what he says he is.

That is the problem here. If you have a question, please ask..
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I believe that gr8grace who used this term has a dispensational view of grace. I think. Is that correct, gr8grace?
and that means he believes in two gospels? and is gnostic, and whatever terms you like to throw around?

See how you group people??

I have a dispensational view of grace!.. The grace which was a mystery to the OT, and is revealed to us today. But is still grace..


Not two gospels but one
 

ArtsieSteph

Senior Member
Apr 1, 2014
6,194
1,319
113
33
Arizona
Man that section about Bible reading now adays being demoted to "soundbite journalism" hit me right in the gut. I do the same thing: flip open the bible, read a verse, think about it, onto the next thing. I haven't done a real devotional.....like ever. Well I guess that isn't true. I would write down my findings, think about them, read like a psalm or something, and then move one.

Sadly with my OCD I get nervous about doing extensive research, because delving into the Bible was what I would do when I was like obsessing and I would like spend hours and hours. There is nothing wrong with that, but it was like a, "I have to do this to be ok, to be Christian" sorta legalistic freakout.

I gotta have a better attitude. The opposite of hardly reading isn't ok either.
 
Feb 11, 2016
2,501
40
0
there is nothing wrong with asking a question sis. In fact, I would rather you ask than now, as most of us would.

Certain people will not ask or even attempt to figure out what the person is saying, and just place people in a grouping, even if that person is not saying what he says he is.

That is the problem here. If you have a question, please ask..
Thats just it, in much of this I really feel I shouldnt have to try to figure someone else out if we are posting his words (where in doing so between thats where the handling of the same becomes more visible) to better see where someone is coming from. Especially where someone breaks off and picks up the majority of the time and where they are doing their comparing. Which should tell me enough, and also if they refuse to use the scripture and chose rather to speak from themselves all the time. I would think time better spent would be taken up to hear and understand the Lords words not others (in his name) who seem to be against taking up the word and yet at the same time seek to entangle others over words.

I will still ask a question EG, what I am looking to cut off (if it can be done at all) is the practice of doing so where I find myself playing into the sport (so to speak).

Like, all of these ???..???...??? when you just post a couple of verses in their context is of the sport, and me asking something back to the same is me stupidly engaging in the sport.

I am trying to resist that where I might find it to be true and disengage from it, which can be hard sometimes, and because you dont always see it coming, but that just shows me where my lack of watchfulness is (so to self correct) But this is perfect place to test it out but I am actually finding such a great blessing in doing so.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Thats just it, in much of this I really feel I shouldnt have to try to figure someone else out if we are posting his words (where in doing so between thats where the handling of the same becomes more visible) to better see where someone is coming from. Especially where someone breaks off and picks up the majority of the time and where they are doing their comparing. Which should tell me enough, and also if they refuse to use the scripture and chose rather to speak from themselves all the time. I would think time better spent would be taken up to hear and understand the Lords words not others (in his name) who seem to be against taking up the word and yet at the same time seek to entangle others over words.

I will still ask a question EG, what I am looking to cut off (if it can be done at all) is the practice of doing so where I find myself playing into the sport (so to speak).

Like, all of these ???..???...??? when you just post a couple of verses in their context is of the sport, and me asking something back to the same is me stupidly engaging in the sport.

I am trying to resist that where I might find it to be true and disengage from it, which can be hard sometimes, and because you dont always see it coming, but that just shows me where my lack of watchfulness is (so to self correct) But this is perfect place to test it out but I am actually finding such a great blessing in doing so.
I understand your pain,

The problem many of us have is we have been churched, I myself used to listen to key words, When I heard them I said ye[, I know what the person believes (whether I actually did or not did not matter, I trusted the men who told me what they believed)

It was not until I actually humbled myselfg to listen to others, and ask where I may have a question, Like, "do you really believe this?" or have I just assumed all these years. When I found freedom, and actually realised there was much more I was taught in error the just what other people believed.
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
I believe that gr8grace who used this term has a dispensational view of grace. I think. Is that correct, gr8grace?

Nevermind. The answer was staring me right in the face.

If I had to narrow it down? It comes down to 3 doctrines that are not taught much. And it keeps the believer ignorant and carnal.

1. eternal security.
2 dispensations.....the church age is unique and it was a MYSTERY............
3.Mystery doctrine.
 
Feb 11, 2016
2,501
40
0
I understand your pain,

The problem many of us have is we have been churched, I myself used to listen to key words, When I heard them I said ye[, I know what the person believes (whether I actually did or not did not matter, I trusted the men who told me what they believed)

It was not until I actually humbled myselfg to listen to others, and ask where I may have a question, Like, "do you really believe this?" or have I just assumed all these years. When I found freedom, and actually realised there was much more I was taught in error the just what other people believed.
I will say I have never felt obligated to humble myself in ways that would require me to sift through the many doctrines of men that come after the apostles. I dont put my trust in any of the men that come after, but I dont believe I have been given a reason why I should either.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I will say I have never felt obligated to humble myself in ways that would require me to sift through the many doctrines of men that come after the apostles.
Then may I ask politely how you plan on discussing the word of God with them? How can you understand what a person believes so you can properly discuss what you believe to that person, if you do not understand what they believe?

I am not asking you to listen to them and change your belief system (although in doing so you may find out you may change that belief system, It happened to me and many others)




I dont put my trust in any of the men that come after, but I dont believe I have been given a reason why I should either.
And no one is telling you to trust in any man, We are just asking the common courtesy, if your going to discuss our belief, give us the courtesy to find out what that belief is, And not do as some people. and assume you know what it is.

Is it not better when we do this? And I assume ( I know I know, thats bad) You would like the same courtesy instead of having someone just judging you and placing you under some group. which you do not belong to, nor hav really any comminality with..
 

wolfwint

Senior Member
Feb 15, 2014
3,652
899
113
61
If a person has been born again,then their spirit was sealed and Incorruptible.

So If there were tares with the wheat,wouldn't this be talking about progressive sanctification?
This no answer to my question. What means christianity? All who are called christians ore born again christians?
 
Feb 11, 2016
2,501
40
0
Then may I ask politely how you plan on discussing the word of God with them? How can you understand what a person believes so you can properly discuss what you believe to that person, if you do not understand what they believe?

I am not asking you to listen to them and change your belief system (although in doing so you may find out you may change that belief system, It happened to me and many others)






And no one is telling you to trust in any man, We are just asking the common courtesy, if your going to discuss our belief, give us the courtesy to find out what that belief is, And not do as some people. and assume you know what it is.

Is it not better when we do this? And I assume ( I know I know, thats bad) You would like the same courtesy instead of having someone just judging you and placing you under some group. which you do not belong to, nor hav really any comminality with..
I dont believe you need to handle all the others which come after (counterfeits or not) to discuss the scriptures, that has never interfered with the word of God or staying with the word of God

I wasnt under the impression I was discussing what your teacher has written but the scriptures

I would think it would be a common courtesy to God to remain in the doctrine we have already received

And this is my last response on this.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I dont believe you need to handle all the others which come after (counterfeits or not) to discuss the scriptures, that has never interfered with the word of God or staying with the word of God

I wasnt under the impression I was discussing what your teacher has written but the scriptures

I would think it would be a common courtesy to God to remain in the doctrine we have already received

And this is my last response on this.
Then sadly your not understanding a thing I have said

This is what I mean about trying to listen and understand what the other person is saying,

I already explained that I did not want you to change your belief, Just to understand others are saying before you try to discuss with them. unlike other people in this chat room.

Why you continue to think I want to change your belief system in this line of discussion, I can not fathom.
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
Personally I have never heard of the term "mystery doctrine" before today but I knew what Gr8grace was talking about when he mentioned it. Immediately in my spirit came "Christ in you."
Christ in you and all that it entails..........Is a major part of the mystery doctrine.

You know mystery doctrine Bro.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
Christ in you and all that it entails..........Is a major part of the mystery doctrine.

You know mystery doctrine Bro.
There is no greater revelation one can get in this life nor in the one to come then to know Christ and that He is in us and what all that means.

The knowledge of Him will never be exhausted throughout all the ages to come in eternity. He is that magnificent! The mystery is on-going.....

Ephesians 2:7 (NASB)
[SUP]7 [/SUP] so that in the ages to come He might show the surpassing riches of His grace in kindness toward us in Christ Jesus.

1 Peter 1:13
[SUP]13 [/SUP] Therefore, prepare your minds for action, keep sober in spirit, fix your hope completely on the grace being brought
to you at the revelation of Jesus Christ.


 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
Christ in you and all that it entails..........Is a major part of the mystery doctrine.

You know mystery doctrine Bro.
Mystery Doctrine is not just Christ in you, but Christ in the gentiles. Not so much a mystery anymore. Going on what? 2000 years now? What's new - and the big "mystery" - is the teaching that the gospel of grace that Paul taught is different from the gospel that Christ taught his disciples. What's the saying? If it's not new it's true; if it's new it's not true.
 
Last edited:
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Mystery Doctrine is not just Christ in you, but Christ in the gentiles. Not so much a mystery anymore. Going on what? 2000 years now? What's new - and the big "mystery" - is the teaching that the gospel of grace that Paul taught is different from the gospel that Christ taught his disciples. What's the saying? If it's not new it's true; if it's new it's not true.
Colossians 1:27
To them God willed to make known what are the riches of the glory of this mystery among the Gentiles: which is Christ in you, the hope of glory.

Paul said God wanted to make this mystery known to the gentiles. Not that the mystery was Christ int he gentiles.

The mystery is, CHRIST IN YOU.. It was a mystery to the jews as well. Thats why they could not see Christ dieing unti after his death when he opened their eyes, He made the mystery known to them first