-
Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.
If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!
To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Y
Well, since you're asking me, I will answer you directly. More than that, I will answer you with a level of truth that you are unlikely to ever hear from somebody who has gone as far in school as I have.
A PhD is meaningless.
The only thing a PhD says about the recipient is that they were able to do the following:
1. Complete more coursework
2. Conceptualize a research project
3. Pass preliminary exams which test their knowledge of subject material and demonstrate they have the ability to carry out a research project
4. Complete a review of relevant literature of their topic area and write up those results
5. Collect data; analyze that data; interpret the results of the analysis; write up those results
6. Defend, orally, in front of a committee of learned professionals, the entirety of the research project
That's IT. The PhD says NOTHING about the ability of the recipient other than to say that person was able to endure more coursework and could oversee a research project. No expertise is needed whatsoever. Unfortunately, academia likes to portray people with PhDs as some sort of subject matter experts, and most of the time, that is not the case at all.
Now, for the other point you made. If I am knowledgeable about things, it is because I have read about them. My knowledge about most things in this world goes no further than the text books I have read. I have very little first-hand experience with most things in life, so my "knowledge" of a particular topic is mostly purely academic, and all I can do is parrot what other people have said. The only really "sad" part of the whole thing is - I'm generally not interested in getting first hand experience with most things. Reading about them is sufficient for me. Most of my life experiences have been major disappointments or have been rather catastrophic, so I prefer to live vicariously through the descriptions of events by an author.
A PhD is meaningless.
The only thing a PhD says about the recipient is that they were able to do the following:
1. Complete more coursework
2. Conceptualize a research project
3. Pass preliminary exams which test their knowledge of subject material and demonstrate they have the ability to carry out a research project
4. Complete a review of relevant literature of their topic area and write up those results
5. Collect data; analyze that data; interpret the results of the analysis; write up those results
6. Defend, orally, in front of a committee of learned professionals, the entirety of the research project
That's IT. The PhD says NOTHING about the ability of the recipient other than to say that person was able to endure more coursework and could oversee a research project. No expertise is needed whatsoever. Unfortunately, academia likes to portray people with PhDs as some sort of subject matter experts, and most of the time, that is not the case at all.
Now, for the other point you made. If I am knowledgeable about things, it is because I have read about them. My knowledge about most things in this world goes no further than the text books I have read. I have very little first-hand experience with most things in life, so my "knowledge" of a particular topic is mostly purely academic, and all I can do is parrot what other people have said. The only really "sad" part of the whole thing is - I'm generally not interested in getting first hand experience with most things. Reading about them is sufficient for me. Most of my life experiences have been major disappointments or have been rather catastrophic, so I prefer to live vicariously through the descriptions of events by an author.
Not exactly. But only with reference to sundials!
Seriously, the whole emphasis on degrees began with the Scholasticism of the Roman Catholic Church, and their insistence on giving lofty titles to their clergy. Unfortunately, the Protestant Reformers failed to see that this was something not based on Scripture. So now even evangelicals and fundamentalists like to parade their doctorates to impress their audiences. Also, almost all these churches today insist that their pastors should have Master of Divinity degrees. Just check out some of their ads. Which means that if Christ or His apostles walked into an evangelical or fundamentalist church today, they might receive the cold shoulder because after all they were "unlearned men".
Seriously, the whole emphasis on degrees began with the Scholasticism of the Roman Catholic Church, and their insistence on giving lofty titles to their clergy. Unfortunately, the Protestant Reformers failed to see that this was something not based on Scripture. So now even evangelicals and fundamentalists like to parade their doctorates to impress their audiences. Also, almost all these churches today insist that their pastors should have Master of Divinity degrees. Just check out some of their ads. Which means that if Christ or His apostles walked into an evangelical or fundamentalist church today, they might receive the cold shoulder because after all they were "unlearned men".
S
That reminds me of a Tears for Fears song, Everybody wants to rule the world. No doubt I am dating myself here.
People proclaiming to be teachers have the burden of proof to explain how they acquired knowledge that we do not possess.
Choosing who to consider as a good source of information makes all the difference.
A good place to start is asking this question: How do you know that?
Seymour
People proclaiming to be teachers have the burden of proof to explain how they acquired knowledge that we do not possess.
Choosing who to consider as a good source of information makes all the difference.
A good place to start is asking this question: How do you know that?
Seymour