It's all good. I believe in context (Rom 2) Paul was simply comparing a natural Jew without faith with a natural Jew with faith...the latter being a true Jew. Never is the believing Gentile referred to as a true Jew.
This is where I disagree.
The modern "Jews" are not born into Israel, but Babylon. They are Gentiles by birth, because their parents were cast out of their Tribe upon their unbelief in the Son.
No one born of outcasts is considered born into Judah.
I do believe in the Remnant, but I doubt they consider themselves Jews in any way.
They are the firstborn sons of the firstborn sons of those Hebrews that accepted Christ, with a lineage of Faith AND bloodline.
No one born of "Jewish" lineage is part of the Remnant, as we came out of the paganism of our parents Judaism.
The OT makes "citizenship" clear. And also the rules for casting ones out of the Camp. All those who claim Judaism are outside of the Camp, because they reject the Son, and therefore reject the Father,
and their children are born as outcasts, and are to be considered as Gentiles.
A True Jew is one born of Spirit, and made the Bride of Christ. Christ IS the True Jew, and we are made one with Him.
Don't pretend to understand Zechariah when you don't even understand Israel. He speaks of a different Israel than the media tells you about.
Surely, God has kept 12k from each Tribe,
and kept them
and their entire lineage,
saved by Faith through Grace.
The 144k has been kept pure, by birth, Birth, bloodline, Faith, and Seed.
No one born of Judaism can claim this, as they were born into apostasy.
Why do I return to Israel bi-yearly? Not to find the Remnant! But to preach to the lost who have been lied to about their lineage, and their "God", and their position before the True God, and their need for Christ.
This is why Set-Apart Ministries has such a powerful conversion rate in Israel: because we do not coddle "Jews" by pretending they have "half the message" (as my WoL friends minister[unsuccessfully] while in Israel),
but give them the Word as it stands. They have NONE of the message, and need to hear the True Message.
They inherited the faith of Ishmael from their parents. We show them the Faith of Isaac.