CONDEMNATION IS THE ROOT CAUSE

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
Maybe gb9's church preaches about being born-again before one can even see the kingdom of God. Maybe they teach you must believe in Christ too. Maybe they believe that it's by grace through faith in Christ's finished work that they are saved and have now eternal life - just like Jesus said.

It might not be a good place for some people to go for sure with it's heretical beliefs in Christ...:rolleyes:
Sounds more like the honor-among-thieves gentleman's agreement that has infected much of the church: don't talk about my sin and I won't talk about yours. And then they consider that to be love.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
Sounds more like the honor-among-thieves gentleman's agreement that has infected much of the church: don't talk about my sin and I won't talk about yours. And then they consider that to be love.

Or....this may be a novel thought...maybe they are called "believers" because they actually do believe in Christ and all that He did....just sayin'....:)


Jesus did say " When I come back will I find faith on the earth?"
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
well, the both of you think it is o.k. to stand over other people in judgement, and see nothing wrong with that. self-examine much???
This is a miss-characterisation. We are neither judging people, or saying they are sinners or sinning.
We are clarifying two different models of faith. Being born again has always been a question christians have argued about, because it is about what begins ones walk with Christ.

The key focus of people is simply the word fruit and responsibility. It matters that people take responsibility for sin, and are held to account, in a real judicial view. Murder is murder, by a conscious choosing human being who could also not to murder. It is a theme that has been foundational to our legal system, to social responsibility, to prisons, to punishment.

There are obviously sins which do not have such a large an effect but are equally destructive of relationships and ultimately walking with Jesus.

A theology that moves away from this into mystical experiences and dwelling in Christ etc without a desire to resolve sin, causes a lot of the people of God to pay attention, and say, this is not the gospel of Christ.

And the root is the mystical new heart from heaven, perfect, acceptable which is our eternal inheritence, which once given cannot be lost, leads inevitably to this world view.

Now people have had no problem describing themselves as sinners, continually sinning, every day. I am not here to say they are lying and wrong, I am just repeating this very position. And it is stated to prove the purity and holiness is impossible, because if it was possible they as christians would be walking it. But this is a circular argument. They hold their theology because of personal failure, not the personal failure proves the theology. It just shows compromise.

Our position is to understand our differences and declare them plainly. We believe in free choice, and people choosing what they follow. We know where and why we stand, that is all the Lord calls us to do. If people say this is judgemental, it is not us being judgemental, we are merely preaching the word. I do not know the sins people are being convicted of, real or unreal, I am just called to show what Jesus said.

I hope this helps. I would do not more or less for Buhhists, Muslims, Jews etc. Knowing why we are different is the beginning of seeing our choices and empowering us to make choices. We will stand before the Lord about these very choices, so I suggest everyone knows what they are standing on and why. My sharing is the deep heritage of the people of God, who have not been mystics in this sense, but practical followers of Christ, learning to love, care and forgive as commanded by Christ through His power and love as expressed in the cross. It is that simple and that different.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
Or....this may be a novel thought...maybe they are called "believers" because they actually do believe in Christ and all that He did....just sayin'....:)
Jesus did say " When I come back will I find faith on the earth?"
If you have faith in what someone says, you follow their instructions. So having faith in Jesus is obeying Him, ie following the sermon on the mount.

It sounds like your position is the sermon on the mount is impossible. If this is so, you do not believe in Jesus or have faith in His words. So oddly though you create this mental image of you are truly representing Him, that is actually a lie.
You are representing part of Pauls teaching, in isolation and excluding most of Christian understanding of Christ and the cross. Of course you claim this is the "true" understanding and what went before was wrong "religious" but it is you who are actually "religious" or "mystic" in your influence and ignore actually practically finding ways to "live" it out in obedience.

You label the obedience as "legalism" and call it evil, a denial of Christs power, but in reality you are saying any human following is "self-righteousness" as if that is evil, and just being "mystically" with Christ is the real spirituality. But your being is in religious meetings, and fellowships, listening to your "special" teachers who have the "knowledge" sounds a lot like a cult following rather than being taught by the "Holy Spirit"

One thread where a person who was sharing being taught by the "Holy Spirit" was immediately deemed evil and wrong, before much had been said. At the time I found that odd, but with this theological track record now I know it is just your groups double standard. But thankyou for educating us about how you deal with your ideas and theology and make it appear something else than it actually is. That takes great skill, but ultimately is pointless.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
If you have faith in what someone says, you follow their instructions. So having faith in Jesus is obeying Him, ie following the sermon on the mount.

It sounds like your position is the sermon on the mount is impossible. If this is so, you do not believe in Jesus or have faith in His words. So oddly though you create this mental image of you are truly representing Him, that is actually a lie.
You are representing part of Pauls teaching, in isolation and excluding most of Christian understanding of Christ and the cross. Of course you claim this is the "true" understanding and what went before was wrong "religious" but it is you who are actually "religious" or "mystic" in your influence and ignore actually practically finding ways to "live" it out in obedience.

You label the obedience as "legalism" and call it evil, a denial of Christs power, but in reality you are saying any human following is "self-righteousness" as if that is evil, and just being "mystically" with Christ is the real spirituality. But your being is in religious meetings, and fellowships, listening to your "special" teachers who have the "knowledge" sounds a lot like a cult following rather than being taught by the "Holy Spirit"

One thread where a person who was sharing being taught by the "Holy Spirit" was immediately deemed evil and wrong, before much had been said. At the time I found that odd, but with this theological track record now I know it is just your groups double standard. But thankyou for educating us about how you deal with your ideas and theology and make it appear something else than it actually is. That takes great skill, but ultimately is pointless.

No....Peter unfortunately all that is a construct you have made in your own head and thus have erected a straw-man again.
 

gb9

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2011
11,896
6,400
113

No....Peter unfortunately all that is a construct you have made in your own head and thus have erected a straw-man again.
they certainly keep the hay farmers in business with all these strawman!!!
 

gb9

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2011
11,896
6,400
113
Sounds more like the honor-among-thieves gentleman's agreement that has infected much of the church: don't talk about my sin and I won't talk about yours. And then they consider that to be love.
my church's motto is " leading people into a growing relasionship with Jesus". but you will have a problem with that. the secondary motto is " no perfect people allowed". but you will have a problem with that too.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
they certainly keep the hay farmers in business with all these strawman!!!

Yes..that is true...lol

And I'm sure your church has "believers" in it that actually do believe in Christ and in what He has done for us - despite what some people try to say.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
my church's motto is " leading people into a growing relasionship with Jesus". but you will have a problem with that. the secondary motto is " no perfect people allowed". but you will have a problem with that too.

What?..really? ...your church believes in a growing relationship with Christ? That you guys actually believe in Christ and trust in Him as you grow in the grace and knowledge of Him?

My goodness...there must be dozens of heretic-hunter websites about you that actually believe in Christ.
 
Jul 23, 2015
1,950
7
0
:smoke: and its really hard
to fought against those evil cults este what we mean is
evil high priest
:read:
Acts 5:17
Then the high priest rose up, and all that were with him, (being of the sect of the sadducees,) and were filled with rage:
18*and laid their hands on the apostles, and put them in the public prison.
19*But an angel of the Lord opened the doors of the prison by night, and having brought them out said,
20*"Go stand and speak in the temple to the people all the words of this life."

:ty:

godbless us all always
 

gb9

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2011
11,896
6,400
113

What?..really? ...your church believes in a growing relationship with Christ? That you guys actually believe in Christ and trust in Him as you grow in the grace and knowledge of Him?

My goodness...there must be dozens of heretic-hunter websites about you that actually believe in Christ.
we also teach and believe that obeying and living as Jesus taught is the best way to live life. wow, man, pray for us, we are in deep trouble!! lol!!
 

gb9

Senior Member
Jan 18, 2011
11,896
6,400
113
also, being in a college town ( uga ) it is so great to hear young people tell about being heavy in alcohol, drug, sexual abuse, and a roommate or friend invites them to church, they began to come regularly, eventually accepting Christ. but they will have a problem with this too.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
we also teach and believe that obeying and living as Jesus taught is the best way to live life. wow, man, pray for us, we are in deep trouble!! lol!!
Really?..That's just Apostasy gone wild! Have you guys never read 1 Tim 4:1?

Next thing is they will make a video about you guys as they erect their self-proclaimed heretic hunter websites about you. They will put horns on your pastor and clothe him in a sheep's coat with a wolf's face underneath it.

Repent!....:rolleyes:
 
F

FreeNChrist

Guest
From the The IVP New Testament Commentary Series on Identity....

"The Galatian believers began their Christian life by receiving the Spirit (3:2-3), but they soon turned to the law to direct their lives. They probably felt that observance of the law was the way of life that would establish their identity and guide their behavior as the people of God. By turning to observance of law as their way of life, however, they were denying the Spirit's sufficiency to identify them as the people of God and to direct their conduct. Paul's references to the Spirit in chapters 3 and 4 assure his readers that their experience of the Spirit has clearly established their identity as the true children of Abraham and as the children of God. In this section (5:13—6:10) his references to the Spirit express his confidence that the Spirit is more than adequate to direct their moral behavior. The Spirit is the best guarantee of Christian identity and the only sure guide for Christian behavior. The Spirit is the only source of power to love in a way that fulfills the whole law."
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0

No....Peter unfortunately all that is a construct you have made in your own head and thus have erected a straw-man again.
Grace7 - please do not think constructs have no value. They are what theology or faith creates. Without these constructs we could not have conversations.

Your approach is to just say constructs are evil, especially if they show my group to be wrong or flawed. That is just anti-analysis and anti-truth. It is why Jesus used parables, because parables show relationships and problems in peoples decision making process.

I think someone called me a white washed tomb. The reason this does not work is because I believe in sorting out the heart of people, being as truthful on the inside as on the outside. It was your group who actively denied the need to sort out your heart and emotions, that to leave the chaos within in Gods hands and leave well alone. When pushed on love, the language of the heart, total denial that the human heart had experience of love at all. This was then followed by love is in people but not the right type. It is this Jesus was critising about all aspects of life, you need to sort out your heart by letting Christ in and love out through obedience. But here you say I am lying. Obedience is not key, it is just the mystical new heart.

It makes me wonder if you believe in discipleship at all? I suppose that is too human and not looking to Christ, except you look to your teachers to show the way.

I call your language camoflage, because I do not know which is real or just a diversion. Little is consistent or hangs together, so most is just aimed at creating a nice reinforcing image of being lovely. What is below the clothing?
A mystic new heart, but looks like that is all. Maybe ceremonies and being together in praise awaiting the next mystical outpouring from the prophet or seance with the dead prophet who wants to tell you how well you are doing...
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0
we also teach and believe that obeying and living as Jesus taught is the best way to live life. wow, man, pray for us, we are in deep trouble!! lol!!
gb9 - I think wherever you stand you are not standing with Grace7, but actually were we are.

"obeying and living as Jesus taught is the best way to live life" - this is what we have been saying

But grace7 is saying this is impossible. Coming to Christ is not repentance, confession and turning from a life of sin to righteousness and believing on Christ for the forgiveness of sins. He preaches a different gospel or have you not noticed.

If he had shared as you have, I would never have had any problems. Be careful, you might come under his condemnation soon.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
gb9 - I think wherever you stand you are not standing with Grace7, but actually were we are.

"obeying and living as Jesus taught is the best way to live life" - this is what we have been saying

But grace7 is saying this is impossible. Coming to Christ is not repentance, confession and turning from a life of sin to righteousness and believing on Christ for the forgiveness of sins. He preaches a different gospel or have you not noticed.

If he had shared as you have, I would never have had any problems. Be careful, you might come under his condemnation soon.

What we are saying Peter for about the 50th time now - is that we live the Christian life by the Life of Christ bearing fruit in us by grace through faith - not by human self-effort. This is the stumbling block for those with a works-based mindset.

And as usual this statement of yours is a "construct in your mind"..here is what you said " But grace7 is saying this is impossible. Coming to Christ is not repentance, confession and turning from a life of sin to righteousness and believing on Christ for the forgiveness of sins"

This above in blue is the construct of your own mind.

It's getting to be useless to keep telling you the same things over and over again and to be constantly dealing with your endless fabrications about what is being said. But we still keep saying the truth of what we believe and trust the Holy Spirit to reveal to the viewers the things of Christ.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
168
0

It's getting to be useless to keep telling you the same things over and over again
I could say 100% the same thing to you. The difference is I understand exactly what you are saying.
I can believe there are faries at the bottom of the garden but it does not mean it is real or relevant.

You have constructed an idea of the human mind cannot conceive of total forgiveness. Funnily that is what I believe, but it is forgiveness for a purpose. The small difference is future sin is forgiven, so as you sin it no longer is relevant, which I do not accept. And the reason is, walking in righteousness is possible, it is based on a communion with God and the healing of hurt and pain in your heart. But this whole process is irrelevant to you, it is just a new birth, a supernatural event.

As I have stated before the problem in your model is this supernatural event should show itself in changed lives, but most fall away. So all this supernatural activity, but to no avail except they are all actually saved now.

For me the reality of repenting of sin is walking in righteousness. It is staying in righteousness and avoiding sin, or if you stumble, repenting and sorting it out, distinguishes you as a believer. Salvation is being found in faith when you meet the Lord, not some fancy you may have had sometime in your life.

I always hope you might see this truth, but somehow your desire to believe everyone stays saved no matter what, seems to blind you to the poison of sin, and what being a member of the Kingdom means.

But hey, I know you are a dyed in the wool believer and know my position, so you have already made you choice.
I call you teaching heresy, because its emphasis is mystical and not practical and real, about real sin and walking like Christ.
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
okie dokie....:rolleyes:...fell free to call me a heretic if you desire when you don't agree with some areas of scripture.....I still love you and forgive you. You are the Lord's favorite. He has great plans for you and your family. I bless you in the name of the Lord!..All is well!...The Lord will be faithful to all of us!
 
Sep 4, 2012
14,424
689
113
It is Christ that is transforming us, and renewing our minds. It is not us being "self aware." "The renewing of the mind" is the means by which transformation takes place. "Mind"is the translation of νοός that Paul uses especially to connote a person's "practical reasoning" or "moral consciousness." Christians are to adjust their way of thinking about everything in accordance with the "newness" of the Spirit (Romans 7:6). This reprogramming of the mind does not happen overnight, but is a life long process by which our way of thinking is to resemble more and more the way God wants us to think.
The renewing of our minds is the restoring of our mind to what it was before Adam's sin. This means growing from an imperfect, flawed state into perfection.

The gnostic and hyper grace concept of renewing the mind is realizing that we are already perfect and rejecting and abandoning any ideas that conflict with this identity.