correct my summary

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
VW, I honestly dont think you have a clue what the trinity is? They follow heresy.. that is REAL! do you also not believe in the trinity VW?

Do you believe that The Father is God, the Son is God and the Holy Spirit is God, three persons yet one/substance in other words God is one, yet three?

IDo you believe that is true?


Phil
Even though it is beside the point, I do believe in God the Father, God the Son, God the Spirit.

You show me where in your scripture it says that one must believe in the trinity to be saved.

It ain't there.
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
To be saved, one must believe in Jesus Christ. Not in the scriptures, not in the trinity, not in the holy catholic church, not in anything but Jesus Christ.

To be saved, to know that one is saved, the only witness that is true, that if of and from God, is the Spirit dwelling in our hearts.

If you wish to start the cult of trinitarians and say that everyone must believe in the trinity of God to be saved, say so now. Then we can go from there.
 
A

AgeofKnowledge

Guest
To be saved, one must believe in Jesus Christ. Not in the scriptures, not in the trinity, not in the holy catholic church, not in anything but Jesus Christ.

To be saved, to know that one is saved, the only witness that is true, that if of and from God, is the Spirit dwelling in our hearts.

If you wish to start the cult of trinitarians and say that everyone must believe in the trinity of God to be saved, say so now. Then we can go from there.
You can't start a trinitarian cult because the teaching of our one God in three persons fulfilling functional roles is the truth. Since it's the truth, it's not a cult teaching by default. The cult teaching is the one that denies this accurate teaching of scripture.

I guess you can call Jesus, the apostles, the early church fathers, their creeds, and all accurate Christians today cultists if you want to for believing what scripture plainly teaches but it's not accurate. You can call a donkey a rooster if you like. It's a free country.

Nobody to my knowledge has said that anyone here is not saved despite using the "H" word in discussions relating to church actions in church history though you seem to have taken it that way. I'm not saying that. Of course, I could have missed that post. It's been a flurry.
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
I think a thing that you havent noticed is that I never said anyone in particular was not saved! but what I am appalled at is professing Christians siding with and agreeing upon what basically is a false view of God.

Lol I like that VW, the cult of Trinitarians, well I would if it wasnt such a serious matter.

Anyhow I have never said you need to believe in the church to be saved, and initially when we are saved, if we are all honest we don't really know God, but we learn and come to see the truth more clearly through the guidance of the Holy Spirit In us and speaking to us through Scripture.

Jesus is after all the second person of the Trinity yet the same substance and attributes as the Father and Holy Spirit, so if you deny this (not you personally VW)... what Jesus are you believing in

As I say the big problem is those who say they have been saved for many years yet still with a full conscience and mind knowing scripture deny the trinity. because the important part is who God is and that of Course is a Triune God. people, who are new Christians etc might not know this i definatly would agree with you there.

The trinity is God, so when we say we believe in God, we should learn who God is and His attributes, it is also the duty of those who are older in Christ to nurture the young into these glorious things of God. But those who do know what the trinity is and still defiantly deny the substance and attributes of God well that is a different story altogether.

I did like that tho the Trinitarian club :D

Anyhow VW, Have a nice evening (or whatever time it is)

Blessings

Phil
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
I think a thing that you havent noticed is that I never said anyone in particular was not saved! but what I am appalled at is professing Christians siding with and agreeing upon what basically is a false view of God.

Lol I like that VW, the cult of Trinitarians, well I would if it wasnt such a serious matter.

Anyhow I have never said you need to believe in the church to be saved, and initially when we are saved, if we are all honest we don't really know God, but we learn and come to see the truth more clearly through the guidance of the Holy Spirit In us and speaking to us through Scripture.

Jesus is after all the second person of the Trinity yet the same substance and attributes as the Father and Holy Spirit, so if you deny this (not you personally VW)... what Jesus are you believing in

As I say the big problem is those who say they have been saved for many years yet still with a full conscience and mind knowing scripture deny the trinity. because the important part is who God is and that of Course is a Triune God. people, who are new Christians etc might not know this i definatly would agree with you there.

The trinity is God, so when we say we believe in God, we should learn who God is and His attributes, it is also the duty of those who are older in Christ to nurture the young into these glorious things of God. But those who do know what the trinity is and still defiantly deny the substance and attributes of God well that is a different story altogether.

I did like that tho the Trinitarian club :D

Anyhow VW, Have a nice evening (or whatever time it is)

Blessings

Phil
Okay, we are getting somewhere. My wife, who believes and loves the Lord, does not understand the trinity, it just does not fit in her mind. When we say God, when we picture God, in reality it is a different picture for each of us, because we are individual and God actually relates to each of us individually. To you the trinity describes and defines God. To another, God is the Father, manifested as three beings. And to another, God is just God, whether it be as Jesus, or the Spirit, or the Father on the throne, it is all the same to them. We must not make our view of God to be the authorized view. If we do that, then we are denying the Spirit, who has the purpose and place given by God to reveal God to each individual as He sees fit. This is what I meant by saying that God is not of the scripture, but rather that the scripture is of God.

In Christ,
vic
 
I

Israel

Guest
The trinity is an image we are expressly told not to do. So if belief in this trinity is the way to salvation, please someone, answer these common sense questions for me.





John 4:19-22

The woman saith unto him, Sir, I perceive that thou art a prophet.

20Our fathers worshipped in this mountain; and ye say, that in Jerusalem is the place where men ought to worship.
21Jesus saith unto her, Woman, believe me, the hour cometh, when ye shall neither in this mountain, nor yet at Jerusalem, worship the Father. 22Ye worship ye know not what: we know what we worship: for salvation is of the Jews.

The Jews never heard of a trinity as they knew exactly what they worshiped. So many people that hold to the trinitarian view seem to all come to an " our mortal minds can't phathom how this works but it is truth" conclusion whenever the dead end approaches on this subject. I choose to take a common sense approach to scripture.

1. The terms, father and son are given in the Bible for a reason and to the best of my ability, I have yet to see any son that did not come after his father; nor have I seen any son who has been in existence for as long as his father. How is this possible given the clear terms that our Bible uses?

2. If God is a Spirit, and the Holy Spirit is a spirit, how are there TWO spirit beings in one triune god?
In my Bible, God has a proper name (YHWH), and the Son has a proper name (Yeshua or Jesus).
Why doesn't the Holy Spirit have a name if he is also God? And in Revelation why is he not getting any
recognition for the work he has done in all of this? I see the Father and the Son, but where is he at?

3. If the God of the old testament said that beside Him there were no other gods, would not three revealed beings in one triune god make the OT God a liar? I mean, no matter how you slice it, three is three.
 
C

Consumed

Guest
Well I'm waiting for Consumed's reply I'll add that I accepted the rebuke to be more loving (even if I disagree with his position that all roads lead to the God of the Bible if he's actually teaching that they do) and thank him for that. Hey, I'm willing to admit I'm not perfect and God isn't finished with me yet :). You'll hear less of the "H" word from me in the future though I still reserve the right to employ it in the historical sense of ancient and modern Judaism and Christianity (but without calling people names).

Honestly, I just want to know now if his statement:

"what part did you miss, the question of your denominatinal doctrination or the overstated view i hold dear to me that all roads lead to calvary at the foot of the cross to where we have access assured to us to the Father??"

means all religions lead to calvary at the foot of the cross to where we have access assured to us to the Father.

I want to know what the word "ROADS" means here from Consumed himself (not someone else trying to speak for him) so I can be sure I understand his position. Thank you and God bless. Consumed, please be good enough to clarify. Thank you brother.

sorry i went out brother, my daughter is more important than this, it started over me asking where did Jesus call anyone a heretic, nothing sinister yet offended some. i have replied to your private mail as you requested a answer with a private message sent by you. feel free to post it on here too brother. i have nothing to hide, i stand out in the light. While i was at the park i asked the Lord if im being wrong with how i seen things, He asked me "what is the most important truth that matters most to me", i replied that He died on the cross for my sins, set me free so i can walk in the full assurance that God the Father calls me his beloved son too, co heir to the promise. Jesus replied to me, "all is good my precious child."

no debating just a kind word, no conviction to my spirit but joy and a fire burned in my heart literally, Holy Fire of God, He is a all consuming fire - hallelujah


and AOK, all religion do not lead to calvary, when have you ever seen a post or even heard in open chat rooms that i enspouse that view brother. Please brother, lighten up bro, you are a intelligent man tha t i do not doubt, wealth of knowledge, share His love bro giving it. In ministry we are taught not to go out of our way to tear people down because they dont get it, just love them thru it in kindness and meekness with a heap of fasting and pray attached.
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
Okay, we are getting somewhere. My wife, who believes and loves the Lord, does not understand the trinity, it just does not fit in her mind. When we say God, when we picture God, in reality it is a different picture for each of us, because we are individual and God actually relates to each of us individually. To you the trinity describes and defines God. To another, God is the Father, manifested as three beings. And to another, God is just God, whether it be as Jesus, or the Spirit, or the Father on the throne, it is all the same to them. We must not make our view of God to be the authorized view. If we do that, then we are denying the Spirit, who has the purpose and place given by God to reveal God to each individual as He sees fit. This is what I meant by saying that God is not of the scripture, but rather that the scripture is of God.

In Christ,
vic

I VW, I can agree with your wife for none us can fully comprehend the vastness of the glories of the Godhead.

Although I will politely disagree with you on views on God.. we have an authorisied view of God, God has given us it in Scripture. For us created beings to start imagining What God is in our own ways and methods is idolatry that is how important this issue is.

We simply are not at liberty to make our on view or image of God in our minds, for that in itself is a dangerous road because it simply is idolatry and not what has been revealed in Scripture by God Himself.

God has revealed His person in scripture By the Holy Spirit and the Spirit shows us this, we are denying the purpose of the Spirit by ignoring His revelation in Scripture By Doing this, God, through the Holy Spirit Inspired Scripture so that we may Know Him.

If we are left to our devices as fallen creatures with no yard stick things will always go pear shaped, That is why we measure everything by the yard stick of Scripture and not emotions or feelings or our imaginations. God has revealed Himself and His purposes in Scripture. we are not free to imagine who He is.


Blessings

Phil
 
A

AgeofKnowledge

Guest
Thank you for your reply Consumed. I understand better where you're coming from. Thank you. Peace and God bless. :)

sorry i went out brother, my daughter is more important than this, it started over me asking where did Jesus call anyone a heretic, nothing sinister yet offended some. i have replied to your private mail as you requested a answer with a private message sent by you. feel free to post it on here too brother. i have nothing to hide, i stand out in the light. While i was at the park i asked the Lord if im being wrong with how i seen things, He asked me "what is the most important truth that matters most to me", i replied that He died on the cross for my sins, set me free so i can walk in the full assurance that God the Father calls me his beloved son too, co heir to the promise. Jesus replied to me, "all is good my precious child."

no debating just a kind word, no conviction to my spirit but joy and a fire burned in my heart literally, Holy Fire of God, He is a all consuming fire - hallelujah


and AOK, all religion do not lead to calvary, when have you ever seen a post or even heard in open chat rooms that i enspouse that view brother. Please brother, lighten up bro, you are a intelligent man tha t i do not doubt, wealth of knowledge, share His love bro giving it. In ministry we are taught not to go out of our way to tear people down because they dont get it, just love them thru it in kindness and meekness with a heap of fasting and pray attached.
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
The trinity is an image we are expressly told not to do. So if belief in this trinity is the way to salvation, please someone, answer these common sense questions for me.

Hi Israel, sorry I must have missed your post, it wasn't intentional. I think your right the Jews saw God as one God, the same as I do. At the same time there is a plurality to God throughout the OT, that is progressive. None in the historic setting really understood it. The same as the Messiahship they never really got that right, but close.


I read an article the other day, how some Jews/rabbis came to the conclusion on passages like Gen 1:26; 11:27 and Isa 6:8 there is no real agreement in early Hebraic litrature on the plurality and in later times 'plural majesty' or 'Talking to angels' where generally regarded as the interpretation in the Babylonian Talmud, Targumim and the midrashim.

Both these attempts are not convincng with the weight of proof. first of we are not made in the image of angels, and secondly in Biblical hebraic times there are no other examples of Monarchs using plural verbs or plural pronouns of himself.

So there where these ideas, but not fully developed, it is only when the fulness of time had arrived do we see this revelation as a whole. the Triune God.

Hope that helps a bit Israel especially concerning hebraic thoughts. Of course we do know that After Christ in later times the rabbis in no way will talk of pluralism, since Christianity.

Anyhow, have a good evening

Phil
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
When you have a chance of changing another person's mind or heart, which by the way is only accomplished by speaking the words of the Spirit in the power of the Spirit, when the Spirit is at work in the one hearing, should you take on the daunting task of trying to change how another thinks? And when it involves religious beliefs, strongly held beliefs, which do not actually have a bearing on salvation; to throw around words like heresy and heretic is beyond irresponsible. It is uncalled for.

It should be agreed that if one believes that Jesus is Lord, crucified for our sins, risen from the dead, the one mediator between God and man, the only way into eternal life and salvation, that they are of the body of Christ. If this be the case, to call such a one a heretic is wrong. This is not loving, not as God is love.

quote]

VW

It is a sign of spiritual immaturity to act as you say. I have seen it countless times. Do not worry for the person who is called the heretic, but rather for the one who continually says those things. He or they woill all be answerable for every idle word they speak.

They do not understand much of the heart of the Giospel

I have always had the opinions I now have. Years ago an internationally renowned minister prayed witrh me after a church service. I had never met them before. They told me much about my life and confirmed I was baptised in the Holy Spirit. If Phil is right that would have to be impossoible

People come on the internet and often make crazy claims, I have seen this much over the last year. We must keep refuting them so that those new to the faith are not damaged by people who by their words show they understand little of what really matters in Christianity or what is most important.
 
I

Israel

Guest
Hi Israel, sorry I must have missed your post, it wasn't intentional. I think your right the Jews saw God as one God, the same as I do. At the same time there is a plurality to God throughout the OT, that is progressive. None in the historic setting really understood it. The same as the Messiahship they never really got that right, but close.


I read an article the other day, how some Jews/rabbis came to the conclusion on passages like Gen 1:26; 11:27 and Isa 6:8 there is no real agreement in early Hebraic litrature on the plurality and in later times 'plural majesty' or 'Talking to angels' where generally regarded as the interpretation in the Babylonian Talmud, Targumim and the midrashim.

Both these attempts are not convincng with the weight of proof. first of we are not made in the image of angels, and secondly in Biblical hebraic times there are no other examples of Monarchs using plural verbs or plural pronouns of himself.

So there where these ideas, but not fully developed, it is only when the fulness of time had arrived do we see this revelation as a whole. the Triune God.

Hope that helps a bit Israel especially concerning hebraic thoughts. Of course we do know that After Christ in later times the rabbis in no way will talk of pluralism, since Christianity.

Anyhow, have a good evening

Phil
Hi Phil,

I understand where you are coming from. That being said, I believe that good old God-given common sense when applied to scripture, keeps us firmly on the ground of truth. When God through Moses brought about the plaugues of Egypt, how was this accomplished?

Psalm 78:40-58

How oft did they provoke him in the wilderness, and grieve him in the desert!

41Yea, they turned back and tempted God, and limited the Holy One of Israel.
42They remembered not his hand, nor the day when he delivered them from the enemy.
43How he had wrought his signs in Egypt, and his wonders in the field of Zoan.
44And had turned their rivers into blood; and their floods, that they could not drink.
45He sent divers sorts of flies among them, which devoured them; and frogs, which destroyed them.
46He gave also their increase unto the caterpiller, and their labour unto the locust.
47He destroyed their vines with hail, and their sycomore trees with frost.
48He gave up their cattle also to the hail, and their flocks to hot thunderbolts.
49He cast upon them the fierceness of his anger, wrath, and indignation, and trouble, by sending evil angels among them.
50He made a way to his anger; he spared not their soul from death, but gave their life over to the pestilence;
51And smote all the firstborn in Egypt; the chief of their strength in the tabernacles of Ham:
52But made his own people to go forth like sheep, and guided them in the wilderness like a flock.
53And he led them on safely, so that they feared not: but the sea overwhelmed their enemies.
54And he brought them to the border of his sanctuary, even to this mountain, which his right hand had purchased.
55He cast out the heathen also before them, and divided them an inheritance by line, and made the tribes of Israel to dwell in their tents.
56Yet they tempted and provoked the most high God, and kept not his testimonies:
57But turned back, and dealt unfaithfully like their fathers: they were turned aside like a deceitful bow. 58For they provoked him to anger with their high places, and moved him to jealousy with their graven images.


We can learn alot from these few verses. God had smote Egypt by sending evil angels. God also led His people, Israel in the wilderness. How?

Exodus 23:20-25

Behold, I send an Angel before thee, to keep thee in the way, and to bring thee into the place which I have prepared.

21Beware of him, and obey his voice, provoke him not; for he will not pardon your transgressions: for my name is in him.
22But if thou shalt indeed obey his voice, and do all that I speak; then I will be an enemy unto thine enemies, and an adversary unto thine adversaries.
23For mine Angel shall go before thee, and bring thee in unto the Amorites, and the Hittites, and the Perizzites, and the Canaanites, the Hivites, and the Jebusites: and I will cut them off.
24Thou shalt not bow down to their gods, nor serve them, nor do after their works: but thou shalt utterly overthrow them, and quite break down their images. 25And ye shall serve the LORD your God, and he shall bless thy bread, and thy water; and I will take sickness away from the midst of thee.

Again, as with the evil angels, we see that it is an angel who acts for God. This particular angel has Gods NAME in Him. And although it is the voice of the angel that Israel heard, the WORDS were God's and therefore holy.

What did Israel do to this angel?

Isaiah 63:9-10

In all their affliction he was afflicted, and the angel of his presence saved them: in his love and in his pity he redeemed them; and he bare them, and carried them all the days of old.
10But they rebelled, and vexed his holy Spirit: therefore he was turned to be their enemy, and he fought against them.

They rebelled against the angel of His presence. This particular angel is in the presence of the LORD. He speaks what he hears. What makes this spirit holy? He has God's name in him. The angel himself is not what makes him holy. It is the WORDS he speaks as it is only what he heard from God that makes him holy. Jesus, being of this very same holy spirit is as the angel was, states that it is not Him that does the works but the Father which dwells in Him. He too spoke God's word. Jesus states that His words are SPIRIT and is life.

God is a Spirit. That Spirit manifested Himself in the image that would be born of a woman by the name of Jesus. The Holy Spirit is as it was before; an angel speaking only what he hears.

Revelation 14:6-7

And I saw another angel fly in the midst of heaven, having the everlasting gospel to preach unto them that dwell on the earth, and to every nation, and kindred, and tongue, and people,
7Saying with a loud voice, Fear God, and give glory to him; for the hour of his judgment is come: and worship him that made heaven, and earth, and the sea, and the fountains of waters.

This angel is only speaking what he heard and glorifying Jesus through the preaching of the gospel.
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
It is evident that there is much division in the body of Christ. What is not acknowledged is why. When the body started, way back then, there were not the methods of instant communication that we have now, everything had to make its way by foot or horse, by messenger. Letters were shared and copied and carried from town to city to village. Because of the nature of God, that He is able to relate to every person in creation alive or dead, as an individual, all at the same time; it was inevitable that divisions would come. "God told me this," or "I see this from Paul's letter to us." Each person is right in what they see and hear, for it is from God by His revelation. And if understood that it is generally for that person, for their growth into Jesus, then there is no problem. And even in sharing what one has heard, again there is no harm, only good, because they are growing in speaking the words of God by His Spirit.

But when we forget that the bond which makes us one is His love in us for each other, and instead try to rely on commonality in all things, that we begin to slay our brothers and sisters, in the spiritual sense. I have known for a long time that hurts to the heart are more painful, more lasting, and eventually more damaging to the person and any relationships that they have. Even in their relationship with God. (I had a router with a 1" 2flute bit cut the back of my hand at 19,000 rpm, and while it hurt, I don't remember the hurt. I was betrayed and lied about by one I loved with the love of Christ, and it still hurts.)

When Jesus prayed for His sheep with His Father, He asked for us to be one in Him with these words:

And the glory which Thou hast given Me I have given to them; that they may be one, just as We are one; I in them, and Thou in Me, that they may be perfected in unity, that they world may know that Thou didst send Me, and didst love them, even as Thou didst love Me.

When Jesus gave us His new commandment, to love one another even as He has loved us, He said that by this, by our love for one another, that the world would know that we are His disciples. So just what is the glory that He has given us that is the same glory that the Father has given Him? It is love, love from the living God. Jesus said of His purpose that He came to lay down His life for the sheep, that no one takes it away from Him, but that He lays it down on His own initiative, that He may take it up again. And then He says the most amazing thing; For this reason the Father loves Me, because I lay down My life that I may take it up again. Jesus laid down His life for us in His love for us. He had commandment from the Father to lay it down and take it up again, but He had to have love for us even as the Father loves us, such that He sent His Son into creation, to become a part of the very creation that is held together by Him, to lay down His life for that creation. For us. This is the glory which God has given Him, that He has given us, and in this glory we are one.

Paul said it best, that he would not ever come to a people with wisdom and enticing words of men. No, he came to people with the knowledge of Jesus Christ, crucified for all, in God's love. Why? So that their faith would rest on the power of God, and not on the wisdom of men. The wisdom of men will pass away. In truth, it is not wisdom at all, not as God has wisdom. God's wisdom is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy and good fruits, unwavering, without hypocrisy.

In conclusion, when we ask what sort of people we should be, the only reasonable answer in the wisdom of the Spirit of God, is those who are full of the glory of God, that is, His love.
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
When you have a chance of changing another person's mind or heart, which by the way is only accomplished by speaking the words of the Spirit in the power of the Spirit, when the Spirit is at work in the one hearing, should you take on the daunting task of trying to change how another thinks? And when it involves religious beliefs, strongly held beliefs, which do not actually have a bearing on salvation; to throw around words like heresy and heretic is beyond irresponsible. It is uncalled for.

It should be agreed that if one believes that Jesus is Lord, crucified for our sins, risen from the dead, the one mediator between God and man, the only way into eternal life and salvation, that they are of the body of Christ. If this be the case, to call such a one a heretic is wrong. This is not loving, not as God is love.

quote]

VW

It is a sign of spiritual immaturity to act as you say. I have seen it countless times. Do not worry for the person who is called the heretic, but rather for the one who continually says those things. He or they woill all be answerable for every idle word they speak. This is correct we are all answerable to God that includes you also LBG.

They do not understand much of the heart of the Giospel MMmmmm

I have always had the opinions I now have. Years ago an internationally renowned minister prayed witrh me after a church service. I had never met them before. They told me much about my life and confirmed I was baptised in the Holy Spirit. If Phil is right that would have to be impossoible. An international renowned Minister!! There are plenty of them around some good some bad. If I am right then what does that make of your internationally renowned Minister, Plus, I dont recall saying anyone wasn't saved..do you?

People come on the internet and often make crazy claims, You are definatly right on there! I have seen this much over the last year. I have witnessed it most just in the last couple of DaysWe must keep refuting them so that those new to the faith are not damaged by people who by their words show they understand little of what really matters in Christianity or what is most important.
You can see my answers in Blue above, Here I will answer your last statement.

If you read my post to VW, you will have recognised that I know full well that new converts and those young in the Faith (not age) will not fully understand the vastness and depths of our Almighty God, in fact no one really can fathom this no matter how long in the walk!

It is the duty of those who are longer in the Faith to nourish those younger and feed them pure food. so I hope that ansers your question, I am fully aware those young in the Faith will take small steps at time leading to long strides.

Unfortunatly, because of bad teaching or just plain biblical illiteracy, some remain in those baby steps and do not progress, which is really sad for they miss out on a lot with their relationship with God. Some may have been christians for 20,30,40 years and never progressed much from the time they were saved.

So you do not have to be the knight in whitye shining armour for new converts, for the debate I was having was with those have have professed Faith for many many many many years.

There are things that are central to True Christian belief, I am sure you know what these are if not you can ask a Pastor or someone who knows.

Maybe unknown to you, you are refuting a foundational truth, I mean the Trinity. For this is what you refute. I am not sure if it is because of how far you have reached in your walk or wether you do know what the Trinity is and reject it.

Blessings

Phil
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
It is evident that there is much division in the body of Christ. What is not acknowledged is why. When the body started, way back then, there were not the methods of instant communication that we have now, everything had to make its way by foot or horse, by messenger. Letters were shared and copied and carried from town to city to village. Because of the nature of God, that He is able to relate to every person in creation alive or dead, as an individual, all at the same time; it was inevitable that divisions would come. "God told me this," or "I see this from Paul's letter to us." Each person is right in what they see and hear, for it is from God by His revelation. And if understood that it is generally for that person, for their growth into Jesus, then there is no problem. And even in sharing what one has heard, again there is no harm, only good, because they are growing in speaking the words of God by His Spirit.

But when we forget that the bond which makes us one is His love in us for each other, and instead try to rely on commonality in all things, that we begin to slay our brothers and sisters, in the spiritual sense. I have known for a long time that hurts to the heart are more painful, more lasting, and eventually more damaging to the person and any relationships that they have. Even in their relationship with God. (I had a router with a 1" 2flute bit cut the back of my hand at 19,000 rpm, and while it hurt, I don't remember the hurt. I was betrayed and lied about by one I loved with the love of Christ, and it still hurts.)

When Jesus prayed for His sheep with His Father, He asked for us to be one in Him with these words:

And the glory which Thou hast given Me I have given to them; that they may be one, just as We are one; I in them, and Thou in Me, that they may be perfected in unity, that they world may know that Thou didst send Me, and didst love them, even as Thou didst love Me.

When Jesus gave us His new commandment, to love one another even as He has loved us, He said that by this, by our love for one another, that the world would know that we are His disciples. So just what is the glory that He has given us that is the same glory that the Father has given Him? It is love, love from the living God. Jesus said of His purpose that He came to lay down His life for the sheep, that no one takes it away from Him, but that He lays it down on His own initiative, that He may take it up again. And then He says the most amazing thing; For this reason the Father loves Me, because I lay down My life that I may take it up again. Jesus laid down His life for us in His love for us. He had commandment from the Father to lay it down and take it up again, but He had to have love for us even as the Father loves us, such that He sent His Son into creation, to become a part of the very creation that is held together by Him, to lay down His life for that creation. For us. This is the glory which God has given Him, that He has given us, and in this glory we are one.

Paul said it best, that he would not ever come to a people with wisdom and enticing words of men. No, he came to people with the knowledge of Jesus Christ, crucified for all, in God's love. Why? So that their faith would rest on the power of God, and not on the wisdom of men. The wisdom of men will pass away. In truth, it is not wisdom at all, not as God has wisdom. God's wisdom is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, reasonable, full of mercy and good fruits, unwavering, without hypocrisy.

In conclusion, when we ask what sort of people we should be, the only reasonable answer in the wisdom of the Spirit of God, is those who are full of the glory of God, that is, His love.

Thanks for the post VW. But I am sorry it certainly not good chrisrian advice, why?

Heres part of your statment:

"Each person is right in what they see and hear, for it is from God by His revelation. And if understood that it is generally for that person, for their growth into Jesus, then there is no problem. And even in sharing what one has heard, again there is no harm, only good, because they are growing in speaking the words of God by His Spirit."

This is a very dangerous statement to make indeed, especially for any young in Faith christians reading it. for you are essentially saying that whatever one belives it is ok, for that person has discerned it is from God. in essence you are saying that any belief aslong as the person says it was given to him by the Spirit it is good wisdom. Any Christian should be very careful about taking this view.

Scripture alone is the standard of truth and not what people hear in their heads or what they think is revelation, if you get a revelation or you think you have, you check it with Scripture.

Why?

2 Timothy 3:16 (English Standard Version)

16 All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,

And then it goes on to say, please take note everyone!

Verse 17:: 17that the man of God may be competent, equipped for every good work.


Self revelation, is foolishness, self edifying.


Blessings

Phil
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
You can see my answers in Blue above, Here I will answer your last statement.

If you read my post to VW, you will have recognised that I know full well that new converts and those young in the Faith (not age) will not fully understand the vastness and depths of our Almighty God, in fact no one really can fathom this no matter how long in the walk!

It is the duty of those who are longer in the Faith to nourish those younger and feed them pure food. so I hope that ansers your question, I am fully aware those young in the Faith will take small steps at time leading to long strides.

Unfortunatly, because of bad teaching or just plain biblical illiteracy, some remain in those baby steps and do not progress, which is really sad for they miss out on a lot with their relationship with God. Some may have been christians for 20,30,40 years and never progressed much from the time they were saved.

So you do not have to be the knight in whitye shining armour for new converts, for the debate I was having was with those have have professed Faith for many many many many years.

There are things that are central to True Christian belief, I am sure you know what these are if not you can ask a Pastor or someone who knows.

Maybe unknown to you, you are refuting a foundational truth, I mean the Trinity. For this is what you refute. I am not sure if it is because of how far you have reached in your walk or wether you do know what the Trinity is and reject it.

Blessings

Phil
Again, you miss the point. LGB no more refutes the trinity than you do. What he refutes is your insistence in calling those who are not believers in the trinity heretics. Which, by the way, you still insist on doing, despite repeated attempts to help you see that this is wrong. While I believe in the trinity, the triune nature of God is not actually stated clearly in scripture, but rather is just like all other truths which relate to our relationship with God, it is revealed by the Holy Spirit. I wonder just how you can believe that your tactics are effective when what several people here have been saying to you has no effect.

Just so we are clear, just where does it state in scripture that believing in the trinity is a foundational belief? That if one does not believe in the trinity that they are lost, or even at best have a deminished relationship with God? I don't often ask this, but please give reference to this belief of yours.
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
Thanks for the post VW. But I am sorry it certainly not good chrisrian advice, why?

Heres part of your statment:

"Each person is right in what they see and hear, for it is from God by His revelation. And if understood that it is generally for that person, for their growth into Jesus, then there is no problem. And even in sharing what one has heard, again there is no harm, only good, because they are growing in speaking the words of God by His Spirit."

This is a very dangerous statement to make indeed, especially for any young in Faith christians reading it. for you are essentially saying that whatever one belives it is ok, for that person has discerned it is from God. in essence you are saying that any belief aslong as the person says it was given to him by the Spirit it is good wisdom. Any Christian should be very careful about taking this view.

Scripture alone is the standard of truth and not what people hear in their heads or what they think is revelation, if you get a revelation or you think you have, you check it with Scripture.

Why?

2 Timothy 3:16 (English Standard Version)

16 All Scripture is breathed out by God and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for training in righteousness,

And then it goes on to say, please take note everyone!

Verse 17:: 17that the man of God may be competent, equipped for every good work.


Self revelation, is foolishness, self edifying.


Blessings

Phil
You make an assumption from a verse of scripture, and this is much more dangerous than what I purpose. No where in the quoted verse does the writer state that the scripture is the standard by which we should judge all truth. Profitable is to mean that it is good to use. You make scripture to say what it does not say. Jesus said that when He, the Spirit of truth is come, that He would guide us into all the truth. So, somehow you have a problem with scripture, in that you make one verse to contradict what Jesus says.
 

phil36

Senior Member
Feb 12, 2009
8,260
2,111
113
51
Again, you miss the point. LGB no more refutes the trinity than you do. What he refutes is your insistence in calling those who are not believers in the trinity heretics. Which, by the way, you still insist on doing, despite repeated attempts to help you see that this is wrong. While I believe in the trinity, the triune nature of God is not actually stated clearly in scripture, but rather is just like all other truths which relate to our relationship with God, it is revealed by the Holy Spirit. I wonder just how you can believe that your tactics are effective when what several people here have been saying to you has no effect.

Just so we are clear, just where does it state in scripture that believing in the trinity is a foundational belief? That if one does not believe in the trinity that they are lost, or even at best have a deminished relationship with God? I don't often ask this, but please give reference to this belief of yours.

HI VW,


Thank you for your reply, but could you be so kind as to read my post above, answering both you and LBG on this very subject, this will help keep you on top of what is being said thank you.


Now VW, you have side stepped my direct answer to your post? would you care to elaborate.

Thank you

Phil
 

VW

Banned
Dec 22, 2009
4,579
9
0
The danger here is that there is no conformity according to man's measure, not without some standard which can be held in the hand and used to make everyone see the truth. But God's truth is not apprehended in this way, rather only division, which is obvious from the last 1700 years of church history. We are not very smart because we keep making the same mistakes, over and over again. The only hope of freedom from our recurring stupidity is reliance on and in the Holy Spirit. But the religious minded must have that comfort blanket to keep them safe, because to rely on the Holy Spirit, to rely on God, is scary. Well, unless we want to continue in our idiocy, that is what we must do.