I Believe there's a HUGE difference between Catholicism and Christianity.

  • Thread starter BlackTigress777
  • Start date
  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Dude653

Senior Member
Mar 19, 2011
12,321
1,039
113
#41
Roman Catholics would have been stoned to death under the Mosaic Covenant.


yeah,,but also under the Mosaic Covenant, you could stone your children to death for disobeying,,,,just sayin......:rolleyes:
 
C

Closemyeyes2cU

Guest
#42
If you "pray to the saints" you are consulting the dead. Just short of witchcraft.
Oh I know. I'm defending praying to the saints. Thats a big no no.
 
J

jimmydiggs

Guest
#43
yeah,,but also under the Mosaic Covenant, you could stone your children to death for disobeying,,,,just sayin......:rolleyes:
Was it wrong for God to institute that?
 
J

jimmydiggs

Guest
#44
Oh I know. I'm defending praying to the saints. Thats a big no no.
Praying to the dead is a big no no.

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZ0olOHhtuc[/video]
 
M

mule

Guest
#46
Oh no Jesus spoke to the dead -- He spoke face to face with moses and elijah --
witch craft I say !!! divining the dead -- He must have come from satan --oh wait didn't Jesus point out a house divided or something like that -- I suppose you have to take the word of a winebibbler and gluttonous man.
OH man what does the Lord require, but you seek JUSTICE love MERCY and walk HUMBLY with your God.

guess where I learned that scripture. yep ha ha

you are killing me here ha ha *_*
 

Katy-follower

Senior Member
Jun 25, 2011
2,719
155
63
#47
From what I have seen, mediate believes in exalting the Father above all
He believes in works for salvation.

He stated in another forum that he's not been born again.

God should come first then neighbor second.

"You must be born again!"

(Mediate - please don't take offense to this, I'm just trying to stress that it's important to be born again)


when does one become born again? is it the moment they hand a starving man a meal? Is it when they read the stories of Jesus and feel his pain for humanity not just his tales of judgement? Is it when they look at another human being and want to help that person at no cost to themselves?

If God is love, and we came from love. Then what is hate? And where did that come from? That is my eternal question.
I am not in Christ by some magic moment in my life whereby the spirit suddenly comes upon me and I am saved....To love God, what must I do? I must do what is pleasing in his eyes. I must give without thinking of myself, and thank Him. that really is all. Give wholly without thought for myself
Holy Spirit, terms, language, is it, is it not, what about this, maybe this, denominational ism, born again, not born again, it's all irrelevant
 
M

megaman125

Guest
#48
yeah,,but also under the Mosaic Covenant, you could stone your children to death for disobeying,,,,just sayin......:rolleyes:
No you couldn't. If you went out and stoned your children, you'd actually be breaking the Biblical laws about capital punishment.
 

Katy-follower

Senior Member
Jun 25, 2011
2,719
155
63
#49
mark 2: 21-22

no man also seweth a piece of new cloth on an old garment: else the new piece that filled it up taketh away from the old, and the rent is made worse.
and no man putteth new wine into old bottles: else the new wine doth burst the bottles, and the wine is spilled, and the bottles will be marred: but new wine must be put into new bottles.
This is talking about the establishing of a New Covenant, a New Testament church. The Jews were unable to receive Jesus' corrections required so they were about to be made null and void. God hasn't turned His back on Israel (Romans 11 says their rejection not total or final). They are still His chosen people, they've just been temporarily hardened until fullness of the Gentiles comes in.

Not all Christians are part of the new Testament church, because not all are born again.

**By grace through faith (not by works) for salvation**
 
Last edited:
M

mule

Guest
#50
it applies to men as well,
how can you be born again if you are old cloth? how can you be mended?
how can the Holy Spirit dwell in you if you are an old flask? you will burst and the wine will spill.

amazing
 
U

Ugly

Guest
#51
There is no difference between Catholicism and Christianity. Want to know why? Because Catholicism is a denomination of Christianity. Catholicism is not a separate religion. Catholics have different beliefs than Protestants and East Orthodox. Catholics believe that Mary was crowned 'Queen of Heaven' by Jesus. They believe that Mary was sinless like Jesus. Protestants oppose these beliefs. But Catholics are Christians. Whether you like it or not.

I have posted in a few topics in this forum regarding Catholicism. I have friends who are Catholic. I received a book with information about the Catholic Saints from one of them. I find it quite interesting. I even went to a Roman Catholic primary (elementary) school. If anyone is wondering which of the three denominations I follow, I follow Protestantism. I am not a Catholic or Eastern Christian (East Orthodox).

Catholics are Christians. End of discussion.

With love. GBU

OK everyone, 16 year old Tom has declared that he's right, and the discussion is now over because he has spoken. Lets all now bow in obedience and reverence and thank him for being right and setting us straight and declaring the end of the discussion.

Takes a huge prideful ego to assume just because you've spoken, there are no other options and everyone needs to stop discussing it because you're right.
 
Mar 1, 2012
117
2
0
28
#52
OK everyone, 16 year old Tom has declared that he's right, and the discussion is now over because he has spoken. Lets all now bow in obedience and reverence and thank him for being right and setting us straight and declaring the end of the discussion.

Takes a huge prideful ego to assume just because you've spoken, there are no other options and everyone needs to stop discussing it because you're right.
I don't think I am right. I am expressing my opinion on the subject. And when I said "end of discussion" I meant that it was my end to the discussion. I can see where you are coming from though. It might make you think that I am proud. But I'm not proud. I don't have a prideful ego.

Ugly, look at the post from different perspectives first before you claim that someone has a 'huge prideful ego' straight away.
 
N

nw2u

Guest
#53
the Catholic church is what grew up from the seed of Christ -- until about 1500 ad when a priest named Luther posted a these on the church door ( this was their form of debate like this message boards is ours)
Actually, it was earlier than Luther.

From: The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, Nelson 1292

1054 AD: A cardinal, sent by the Pope, slapped a document on the altar of the Church of Holy Wisdom in Constantinople during the Sunday worship, excommunicating the Patriarch of Constantinople from the Church.

This was the start of the Orthodox Church.


Quite a bit of a mess was underway well before this. Many things were being taught which were not true. Paul speaks of it in his letters.

The first Ecumenical Council met in 325 AD in Nicea to address many serious concerns with the church.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Jan 23, 2011
115
1
18
#54
Actually, it was earlier than Luther.

From: The Orthodox Study Bible, New Testament and Psalms, Nelson 1292

1054 AD: A cardinal, sent by the Pope, slapped a document on the altar of the Church of Holy Wisdom in Constantinople during the Sunday worship, excommunicating the Patriarch of Constantinople from the Church.

This was the start of the Orthodox Church.


Quite a bit of a mess was underway well before this. Many things were being taught which were not true. Paul speaks of it in his letters.

The first Ecumenical Council met in 325 AD in Nicea to address many serious concerns with the church.
Luther wasn't even the first to pose these kind of questions to the church after the Orthodox split either. Jan Hus, a Czech Priest, started a proto-Reformation in Bohemia in the late 14th-early 15th century (the Reformation was in 1517). It lead to series of wars and Hus's eventually execution for heresy. Luther was saved for several reasons, namely because he had protection from an elector of the Holy Roman Empire

Even then, Luther liked the Catholic church, at least at the start. he just saw some theological issues with it and wanted to try and fix them, but when he found the Pope himself at the time was corrupt, he advocated a split. The rest is history
 
Jul 12, 2012
933
2
0
#55
Denominational-ism, terminology instead of understanding, stumbling blocks: these are on the earth and the islands. But we are supposed to stand on the sand, or go in ships, and fish men from the sea.
 
Dec 14, 2009
1,400
2
0
#56
Those born again are seen as righteous before God, because they've been covered by the blood of Jesus. They are sheep. Their sins have been forgiven and they are no longer condemned. Those of us saved are referred to as sheep that used to be goats.




The sheep (the saved) have been forgiven completely so there is no condemnation for those in Christ Jesus. The sheep will receive rewards, they will not face the White throne judgment. The white throne is for the goats, those who die not having been born again. Harsh judgment will be on those who heard the Gospel truth while they were alive, but they chose to ignore it and go their own way..these are the ones that are not saved.



No, it's a glimpse into the future judgment.

This world consists of two groups... the sheep and the goats.

The sheep represent God's children (those who have accepted Christ, have been born again and as a result are seen as righteous before God through Jesus).

The goats are those that were never saved.

The sheep will be placed to the right and the goats to the left.

The sheep are going to Heaven but the goats to the other place.




Why don't you want to be a sheep?




It doesn't work like that.

Jesus Christ died to save us from eternal punishment and eternal separation from Him. Only through Jesus can a person be saved.
Why do you pass judgment on your brother? Or you, why do you despise your brother? For we will all stand before the judgment seat of God;

Jesus had the spirit of sacrifice, why can't I?
 
M

Mich223

Guest
#57
I think on the last day Catholics and Protestants alike will be in God's Kingdom. Yes, we see the bible differently, but we are all Christians. Catholics rely on tradition more so than Protestants. But don't forget there are over 30,000 different Protestant groups that claim they are the way to Christ.
 
M

metanoia

Guest
#58
If Catholicism is not Christianity, there was a very long time from Pentecost to the Reformation where Christianity did not exist. Do we make Jesus a liar? He said the Spirit of truth would guide the apostles "into all truth." Either the Spirit guided the Church into all truth, or He left the world in darkness for 1500 years.
 
M

mdankoski

Guest
#59
The point about Catholics being christian - they do not have a salvation prayer. They say form pre - written prayers to God and Jesus as well as a couple hundred other, the saints, or those they consider to be saints. The only hint actually saying that they give up their old ways of life and ask the Lord to come in is at their baptism, which is said in Latin, by the priest, and repeated by the parents in behalf of the child when the child is 2 weeks old.

That is not to say that ALL Catholics are not Christian. There are quite a few who have actually thought about the words of prayers that others have written, gotten on their knees, and made a commitment to follow Him so are Christian, yet there are many more who believe that since they repeat something, memorize it, and are able to say it at will makes them Godly. Parrots can do that.

See my post earlier in this section about Constantine trying to unite the Roman empire.

I do know what I am talking about, as I was raised Catholic, went to both Catholic grade school and Catholic high school, but I did not become a Christian until after I had graduated Catholic high school. It was about a year later, as a matter of fact. I no longer claim to be Catholic, although my name is still on their books. The only way to REALLY leave is to have the old poop, I mean pope, ex-communicate me, and I haven't yet felt the need to go to Rome and ask him to.
 
M

mdankoski

Guest
#60
To Metanoia and any other new members who happen to be Catholic. I meant no offense to you or your beliefs. I was very dissatisfied with what I found, and since I have decided to follow our Lord I have found quite a lot of those beliefs to be false. The basis of the Catholic church was indeed born again Christians, but through Constantine and man relying on his own understanding, it has degenerated through the years to the point that it is hardly recognizable from original Christianity. My blessings on you if you really have made a commitment to follow the Lord and are truly seeking the Truth. I'm sure you will find it, and welcome to the forum. Mike