I have a question

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
D

Depleted

Guest
#41
God is not in charge here. He gave charge over creation to us, we gave it to satan. satan rules this world, not God. That's the first thing to understand.

Secondly, one is born innocent until one reaches whatever point it is that one thinks they know enough to make a decision. And the Holy Spirit woos all men. Just because human missionaries never reached this or that group, it doesn't mean God's Spirit hasn't.

Going back to no. 1, all men inhabit a world ruled by beings who sole purpose is to make sure we make the wrong decisions.

And who's to say that, despite cultural norms, there weren't individuals within unreached groups that didn't respond to the Holy Spirit's wooing? If one by the Spirit acknowledges the true redeemer it doesn't matter if they don't know our western names for Him, does it?

And lastly, God doesn't send people to hell. He lets them choose to be with Him or not. I believe the lake of fire is created by the decreation of this present earth and heavens, and that people who reject God for this world are simply given it in it's natural state apart from Him.

The vengeful God you seek to understand retired when Christ rose. And anyone any where who accepts the Holy Spirit's witness to that redeemer inherits both a redeemed and new creation.














God's Holy Spirit
God is always in charge!
 
S

sparkman

Guest
#42
Hello everyone, this is my first post so I will introduce myself. I was raised Baptist but around the age of 13 I began to have a resentment towards Christianity, feeling as if I had been brainwashed as a child. As I got older I have become more open minded and realized that I was being ignorant in my resentment for the religion. I no longer say or do things to try to offend Christians as I did in the past. I have friends of many different christian religions now, Catholics, Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, still many childhood friends from the church I went to as a child who are still believers, I also have friends that are atheists. I try to be as open minded with their beliefs as possible. I would consider myself a hopeful agnostic, but definitely I do not believe in the Christian god. I do not write this to offend anyone, but I personally believe that this god is unjust.

One question I have for you all is why did your god create a whole race of people, the native Americans who lived on what is now the United states for thousands of years, just to send them all to hell? Most Christian beliefs that I am familiar with have the belief that if you do not believe in Jesus Christ, you will go straight to hell. There were tribes of natives that were brutal, like the Mayans and Aztecs, but there were also those who learned to live in peace for thousands of years, like the Iroquois. It isn't fair in my morals to create all these natives who had never had the chance of hearing of this religion until the 1400's just to send them all to hell.
Romans 1 says that all have a knowledge of God from creation. Romans 2 says that each individual is aware of God's law because God has embedded this knowledge into the conscience. So, God can rightly judge all of mankind.

Creation itself witnesses to the fact that homosexuality, for instance, is wrong..the male body was not made to have sex with another male body.

By the way, do you think you're in a good situation to judge what is just and fair? Is your system of ethics superior to the One who created all things? And, if you don't think Christianity is correct, what alternative are you proposing?

God isn't on trial, by the way, nor are you the judge. You are the creature, not the creator. You are incapable of wrapping yourself in the robes of the judge and pronouncing a verdict upon God.

It is up to each of us to seek God, and if we are seeking God, He will reveal himself. The problem is that rebellious humans are not seeking God. Romans 3 makes that clear. We rejected God and his guidance in the Garden of Eden, and told him to get lost. God is allowing mankind to experience the fruit of rejecting Him, and that is why we have the horrible results of sin that we see in society...physical suffering and mental suffering of all types. We couldn't learn by revelation that God's way is best; we had to learn it by cruel experience.

Regardless of your rejection of Christianity, you will still face God in the judgment, and I'd suggest facing Him with the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ, and not working out all the intricacies of how God will judge others.

As I mentioned, creation is obvious evidence that God exists. It seems like you acknowledge that. If so, the Creator endowed mankind with verbal ability and reasoning skills. Would such a Creator endow man with such ability, and fail to communicate with him? Assuming he has communicated with him, what communication is the most coherent and claims to be from such an authority? I would propose that the Bible and Christianity is the only such communication which meets those criteria.

The coherent story thread of Scripture involves the creation, man's fall, redemption through Christ, and ultimate full restoration of man's situation as it was in the Garden of Eden in the New Heavens and New Earth (Revelation 21-22). It is very coherent.

Here's a good video on trusting the Bible that might help you:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1XJ7DeR5fc&list=PLKnzCuBYVJm7LQI8en1_ZiDdyNAdVizmW&index=1

By the way this world and the way it operates is meant to inject doubt into mankind. Satan deceives the entire world (Revelation 12:9). It is very much like the Matrix, and the vast majority of mankind is still connected to the Matrix. You are undoubtedly one of them.


I'd encourage you to take the "red pill" and exit the Matrix. The rest of the world is blindly going to destruction (Matthew 7:13-14)...taking the "blue pill". You should watch the movie "Matrix" with Keanu Reeves and think about this them. It is very similar to what is going on in the world.

There are also cults, some of which are represented on this forum, which propose answers to the question you are asking about the "unevangelized unsaved". I would suggest that you avoid them..I was involved with one of them for about ten years. My approach is to leave that question unanswered, and trust what the Bible says when it says "will not the Judge of the earth do what is right?" (Genesis 8:25). It is a question you don't need to answer. It is an issue of faith that God will do what is right, and those who claim to know the answer to this question often are cultists.

I also list some good materials about salvation in my profile if you are interested, and I'd be glad to dialogue with you via CC email.
 
Last edited:
S

sparkman

Guest
#43
Another thing, I do not consider myself without flaws. But I know I will probably never go back to Christianity, I consider myself a decent person. Am I going to hell in your beliefs?
Scripture says you're not a decent person. You may deceive yourself into thinking you're a decent person, but you have an evil nature. In fact, it is so evil that it deceives you into thinking you are good.


Only God can show you the depths of your evil mind, though. If I were you, I'd ask Him to lead you to repentance.

Another thing is that you are comparing yourself with other human beings, and not with God. God is totally holy, and without sin.

Know the moral outrage when you see ISIS terrorists beheading people or burning people alive? That is how God feels about our sins. He sees everything that we do to hurt other people, and feels the same sense of moral outrage. We are so desensitized to our sins that we have no idea of the moral outrage that he feels toward those who are participating in them, especially ourselves.

Ask God to grant you a vision into your own sins, and to let you see yourself as He sees you. That is largely what repentance is about..coming to the point where we see ourselves as God sees us, at some level. I am sure that God is merciful and only shows us a partial view of our true nature.

Here’s a good definition of repentance: Repentance, like faith, is an intellectual understanding that that sin is wrong, an emotional approval of the teachings of scripture regarding sin (a sorrow for sin and hatred of it), and a personal decision to turn from it (a renouncing of sin and a decision of the will to forsake it and lead a life of obedience to Christ instead), empowered by the Holy Spirit, which is received after salvation.

I'd suggest reading this book What is the Gospel? by Greg Gilbert. It is a very clear presentation of the Gospel message:

https://kbcworshipblog.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/whatisthegospel-gilbert.pdf

There's also a good book called The Explicit Gospel by Matt Chandler which would be great to read. Unfortunately many evangelical Christians don't communicate the Gospel message very well, but these two books are excellent in this regard.
 
S

sparkman

Guest
#44
So white men are without sin? You talk about slavery like that is what black people deserved. No one deserves to be treated the way that entire race of people were treated. How do you think the white men won America? Through lies, torture, rape, murder. Most natives welcomed the white men peacefully and with hospitality into their land, what was their reward? Raping their wives, killing their children, giving them small pox and the bubonic plague. Natives used to thrive in this land, but now barely even exist. That tells me, if God is in control, he is bloodthirsty and unjust in my own opinion.
Wrapping yourself in the robes of judge and pronouncing a verdict on God isn't a job description I'd want to take up. There's no future in it. Are you omnipotent and omniscient that you know all of the factors in his decision? Has he revealed all aspects of his dealings with mankind to you?

These sorts of arguments are typical of those who reject God. I would suggest getting out of the business of judging God and seek him in repentance and faith. Leave the business of judging these individuals up to God.

By the way, few Christians thinks that black people should have been enslaved. I smell troll, and probably an atheist troll posing as a seeker.
 
Jan 26, 2016
382
2
0
#45
Romans 9: 14-18. God has mercy on whom He pleases.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#46
I don't believe everyone was born with the knowledge of the Christian god. There are children in Iraq and Palestine and Afghanistan who are born into Islam, we could say this is the same God as the Christian God, there are similarities in the religions, but for most Christians I know, the Muslim God and the Christian God are not the same being, do these children that are born into Islam and are killed as innocent civilians by IED's deserving of going to hell?
Children do not go to hell. The Bible says there is an age of understanding and accountability. A child that dies goes into the arms of the Lord.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#47
So white men are without sin? You talk about slavery like that is what black people deserved. No one deserves to be treated the way that entire race of people were treated. How do you think the white men won America? Through lies, torture, rape, murder. Most natives welcomed the white men peacefully and with hospitality into their land, what was their reward? Raping their wives, killing their children, giving them small pox and the bubonic plague. Natives used to thrive in this land, but now barely even exist. That tells me, if God is in control, he is bloodthirsty and unjust in my own opinion.

Natives warred against each other,murdered and stole land. No one is innocent.Man is evil at heart. God is not unjust.Man does what he wants to do. Just because he says he does it on Gods name doesn't make it right.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#48
Except that man didn't create those people, and God doesn't have a limited number of people he can save... so then because God made us all, and doesn't have a limit on how many of us he can save, why does he still let most of us knowingly go to hell? Does he get some sort of kick out of it?
You have a choice. God doesn't let anyone go to hell,you have a choice. You choose the path.
 
K

kaylagrl

Guest
#49
In my eyes there is a pretty big difference between people that lie, and people that murder and rape bud. You are trying to say someone like Hitler, who believed in Jesus, was worthy of going to heaven, and an innocent civilian in Iraq or Afghanistan that gets blown up deserved to go to hell. As I have said before, an unjust God is no God for me.
Hitler killed over 6 million of Gods chosen people. Trust me,he will not be welcomed into heaven. He is hell today,where he belongs.
 

NayborBear

Banned Serpent Seed Heresy
#50
Hello everyone, this is my first post so I will introduce myself. I was raised Baptist but around the age of 13 I began to have a resentment towards Christianity, feeling as if I had been brainwashed as a child. As I got older I have become more open minded and realized that I was being ignorant in my resentment for the religion. I no longer say or do things to try to offend Christians as I did in the past. I have friends of many different christian religions now, Catholics, Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, still many childhood friends from the church I went to as a child who are still believers, I also have friends that are atheists. I try to be as open minded with their beliefs as possible. I would consider myself a hopeful agnostic, but definitely I do not believe in the Christian god. I do not write this to offend anyone, but I personally believe that this god is unjust.

One question I have for you all is why did your god create a whole race of people, the native Americans who lived on what is now the United states for thousands of years, just to send them all to hell? Most Christian beliefs that I am familiar with have the belief that if you do not believe in Jesus Christ, you will go straight to hell. There were tribes of natives that were brutal, like the Mayans and Aztecs, but there were also those who learned to live in peace for thousands of years, like the Iroquois. It isn't fair in my morals to create all these natives who had never had the chance of hearing of this religion until the 1400's just to send them all to hell.
NEWS FLASH!!
Not gonna answer yer question, 'bout the injuns, but I am going to respond to the a point that brought ya here.
YOU, sir, are someone very special in He who created yer spirit that is within ya. Your leaving the church at such an early age bares witness to that. Whether it be tomorrow, er 30 years down the road......ONCED ya get tired of wondering (and torturing yourself) the why it is ya "reject" the teachings of "the world", and ya don't fit in, and, the "why" it is ya reject the teachings of "churchianity" , and cannot see yourself conforming to them. And onced ya "answer" that little voice betweenst yer ears, asking if yer "ready" yet. You'll be back. Because, Cuz, whether ya know it er not, er even wanna, er not, you only have 2 choices. You can make this harder on yerself, or easier on yerself. But, for NOW?, Resume regular programming schedule. Tis my hope, you get to see this, and one question I won't answer is, "How do you know this?" :cool:
 

RickyZ

Senior Member
Sep 20, 2012
9,635
787
113
#51
God is always in charge!
Satan is “the ruler of this world”; three times the designation is made by Jesus in John’s Gospel (12:31; 14:30; 16:11). Similar descriptions are used in other references: “the god of this age” (II Cor. 4:4; “the god of this world” in the ESV); “the prince of the power of the air” (Eph. 2:2); and “the whole world lies in the power of the evil one” (I Jo. 5:19). In Scripture Satan is uniquely related to this world as the ruler or prince of it; in other words, the world and all that is in it is under his influence and power. (From Ruler of this World)
 

notuptome

Senior Member
May 17, 2013
15,050
2,538
113
#52
Satan is “the ruler of this world”; three times the designation is made by Jesus in John’s Gospel (12:31; 14:30; 16:11). Similar descriptions are used in other references: “the god of this age” (II Cor. 4:4; “the god of this world” in the ESV); “the prince of the power of the air” (Eph. 2:2); and “the whole world lies in the power of the evil one” (I Jo. 5:19). In Scripture Satan is uniquely related to this world as the ruler or prince of it; in other words, the world and all that is in it is under his influence and power. (From Ruler of this World)
Still greater is he who is in you than he who is in the world.

For the cause of Christ
Roger
 
Jan 26, 2016
382
2
0
#53
Satan is “the ruler of this world”; three times the designation is made by Jesus in John’s Gospel (12:31; 14:30; 16:11). Similar descriptions are used in other references: “the god of this age” (II Cor. 4:4; “the god of this world” in the ESV); “the prince of the power of the air” (Eph. 2:2); and “the whole world lies in the power of the evil one” (I Jo. 5:19). In Scripture Satan is uniquely related to this world as the ruler or prince of it; in other words, the world and all that is in it is under his influence and power. (From Ruler of this World)
God is in control. Don't doubt that
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
#54
Hey Ricky,

I tend to go along with your views here but I have a question about ..what happened after the resurrection?..what did Jesus mean when He said " All authority has been given to ME both in heaven and in earth?"...how does this affect the "authority..or rule" of satan in your view?

Also 1 John 5:19 doesn't have the word "power or authority " in the versie..it simply says .."it lies in wickness ( porneia ) " ( which of course the enemy is evil for sure....and I wonder if that could be the result of "sin" being in the world from the fall....either way they are both related in my view)

But the Eph 2:2 actually does say.." according to the ruler of the authority of the air "

How does one jive what the Lord said and the present so-called rule of satan?......

Thanks...


Satan is “the ruler of this world”; three times the designation is made by Jesus in John’s Gospel (12:31; 14:30; 16:11). Similar descriptions are used in other references: “the god of this age” (II Cor. 4:4; “the god of this world” in the ESV); “the prince of the power of the air” (Eph. 2:2); and “the whole world lies in the power of the evil one” (I Jo. 5:19). In Scripture Satan is uniquely related to this world as the ruler or prince of it; in other words, the world and all that is in it is under his influence and power. (From Ruler of this World)
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,760
26,630
113
#55
In my eyes there is a pretty big difference between people that lie, and people that murder and rape bud. You are trying to say someone like Hitler, who believed in Jesus, was worthy of going to heaven, and an innocent civilian in Iraq or Afghanistan that gets blown up deserved to go to hell. As I have said before, an unjust God is no God for me.
Where to start? As you can attest for your very own self, being brought up in a Christian environment does not automatically equate to one being Christian. If you are going to base your beliefs on facts and be logical and rational yadda yadda as agnostics and such like to pretend they are, then you should at least begin by acknowledging that Hitler was not a Christian simply because he was brought up in a Catholic household. The other part of your rationale here is that there is some line at which God should stop being so forgiving of human nature. Guess what? There is no such line beyond there being only one unforgivable sin! Jesus paid the penalty for all other sins on the cross. He has overcome the world, sin, and death, on your behalf. A funny (peculiar) thing about atheists and agnostics etc is that they cry foul at not being given more life when they refuse to acknowledge the Author and Giver of life in the first place. And you need to do some research on hell. It is a translation of four different words, and none of them mean what you probably think they do. Oh, and there are no transitional fossils. Yes, there goes your credibility :)
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,713
3,651
113
#56
And you should really stop quoting scripture, because like I said earlier, I don't believe in it, and if you keep trying to force feed it, I just become less and less responsive to what you are saying.
This forum is all about Scripture. If you are truly interested in what we believe expect Scripture.
What do you want us to quote, the N.Y. Times?
 
T

Txroads

Guest
#57
Hello everyone, this is my first post so I will introduce myself. I was raised Baptist but around the age of 13 I began to have a resentment towards Christianity, feeling as if I had been brainwashed as a child. As I got older I have become more open minded and realized that I was being ignorant in my resentment for the religion. I no longer say or do things to try to offend Christians as I did in the past. I have friends of many different christian religions now, Catholics, Mormons, Jehovah's Witnesses, still many childhood friends from the church I went to as a child who are still believers, I also have friends that are atheists. I try to be as open minded with their beliefs as possible. I would consider myself a hopeful agnostic, but definitely I do not believe in the Christian god. I do not write this to offend anyone, but I personally believe that this god is unjust.

One question I have for you all is why did your god create a whole race of people, the native Americans who lived on what is now the United states for thousands of years, just to send them all to hell? Most Christian beliefs that I am familiar with have the belief that if you do not believe in Jesus Christ, you will go straight to hell. There were tribes of natives that were brutal, like the Mayans and Aztecs, but there were also those who learned to live in peace for thousands of years, like the Iroquois. It isn't fair in my morals to create all these natives who had never had the chance of hearing of this religion until the 1400's just to send them all to hell.
Well, first I think you did a great job kaycie.....

The next thing is I think God reveals himself to people who have never known him or even heard of him. How many stories have you heard from believers in other countries that say I didn't know who this man was that came to me in my dreams and when I asked him he said I am Jesus.
If you look at some of the native American tribes that were here you'll find that several of them worshipped "the Great Spirit". If you listen to a lot of the things they say it may not have been God by his name but they were really really close. And before anyone says close but no cigar just think of the thief in the cross... All it took was LORD do not forget me when you are in your kingdom..