Some conclusions I've made and want to start a debate

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#22
About point 9: where in scripture we found that God Jesus Christ was created? If the son is created he is not God! John 1,1-16says clear that Jesus Christ is God! Of course we find the word trinty not in the bible. But if you study about God father, God Son and God Holy Spirit you will find that they belongs together, even if it is not fully clear to us.
Just because Jesus was created doesn't take away that he is indeed God, he has been chosen to be the very express image of the Father. As it is said:

For in him dwells all the fullness of the deity bodily. (Colossians 2:9 [ABP])
And even Jesus said,

You heard that I said to you, I go away, and I come to you. If you loved me, you would have rejoiced that I said, I go to the father, for my father [*2*greater than *3*me *1*is]. (John 14:28 [ABP])
The father is greater than Jesus. And even so, although Jesus is the first born of creation, God has also engendered more sons of God. Anyone who has the spirit of God is also a son of God, being one with God, so its not really a trinity, its a family, as it shows:

For as many as [*2*in spirit *3*of God *1*are led], these are sons of God. (Romans 8:14 [ABP])
And in Colossians we read:

who is the image of the unseen God, first-born of all creation; (Colossians 1:15 [ABP])
Referring to Jesus as the firstborn of all creation, indicating he too was created.
 
G

Genesis28-15

Guest
#23
Just because Jesus was created doesn't take away that he is indeed God, he has been chosen to be the very express image of the Father. As it is said:



And even Jesus said,



The father is greater than Jesus. And even so, although Jesus is the first born of creation, God has also engendered more sons of God. Anyone who has the spirit of God is also a son of God, being one with God, so its not really a trinity, its a family, as it shows:



And in Colossians we read:



Referring to Jesus as the firstborn of all creation, indicating he too was created.

Can you share the scripture that teaches us Jesus was created.
 

Ahwatukee

Senior Member
Mar 12, 2015
11,159
2,375
113
#24
Greetings cgaviria,

Just because Jesus was created doesn't take away that he is indeed God, he has been chosen to be the very express image of the Father.
The statement above is false! First of all, to be God means to have no beginning and no end, self existing, that is, eternal. Therefore, Jesus could not be God in that respect and that because He would have had some starting point like the angels. In short, if you are a created being, you cannot be God.

Also, no created being could pay the penalty for sins, but God himself. Jesus is God in the flesh, not the Father, but another person of the Godhead. Before he took on flesh, he existed with the Father, having no beginning and no ending. The Jews recognized what Jesus was saying when he said, "Before Abraham was, I am," which is why they picked up stones to kill him and that because they understood that he was proclaiming to be thee God. The Jews would not have picked up stones to kill Jesus for being a created being.

Regarding the other topics on your list, your lack of belief that Jesus is God Almighty, the Sovereign Lord, makes the rest irrelevant, and that because you are believing in another Jesus, which cancels everything else out. I have much more to say regarding this, which I will address later.
 
G

Genesis28-15

Guest
#25
I haven't met a christian that does not sin because I don't believe that I've ever met anyone YET that truly has the spirit of God.
woooowwww :confused: so you are the only one, huh? What about 1 John 1:8, you just kind of skipped over that one... Here, I'll re-post it for you: " If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us." (1 John 1:8)
 
G

Genesis28-15

Guest
#26
I was waiting for the ball to drop. Well, we can't say he didn't warn us. He told us in the New Christian Chat Members forum that he recently "encountered opposition" from another Bible forum which he then "abandoned" (was banned from??) their forum.

And is it me, or does his user name sound slightly familiar? :rolleyes:


I made this connection myself too, but I haven't been on here long enough to officially draw that conclusion, but I'm glad you did though, VioletReigns.

Given that this information is true, cgaviria, and you did in fact state that you "abandoned" the last Christian Forum you "encountered opposition" in, but you actually were banned...that would be a lie. And a sin. So according to your gospel, you aren't going to make the cut either.

If what you say is true, what a lonely, quiet place Heaven must be with God sitting up there all by Himself... :(
 
G

Genesis28-15

Guest
#27
God and the angels are just sitting up there waiting for a bride that will never exist? Jesus Is preparing a place is His Father's mansion that has many rooms, for nobody? How about this scripture: Confess your trespasses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The effective, fervent prayer of a righteous man avails much. James 5:16
Do you suggest that this book of the Bible as well as the others that mention repentance and the confession of sins are written to UNSAVED people and that they are not meant to be applied to the lives of people that actually have the Spirit of God?
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
#28
Hello guys, my name is Christian and I want to start a discussion on things I have concluded over many years of study since I was a kid. Alot of the things I have concluded do not agree with mainstream Christianity nor the Catholic church as I truly believe most Christians are led astray by false doctrine. I am posting these things in hopes to start a debate, because I think it is healthy to discuss scripture, as that is the only thing I am interested in with being here, to discuss in hopes to find truth, and I also hope to find other believers who might hold the same doctrines. So here I go (and I can back all these things with scripture):


1. First and foremost I believe in Jesus Christ as the only begotten Son of God and was made manifest in the flesh to us, and died, and was resurrected, and in him we have salvation.


2. I believe in predestination, God chooses and God preordains. It is a clear teaching of scripture. We do what we do because he has already determined what we will do from the very beginning.


3. I believe in the literal power of the Holy Spirit. When receiving the Holy Spirit there is clear evidence of having it, such as speaking on different languages, and healings, and miracles.


4. I believe that in receiving the Holy Spirit we are then born of God, and that our mind is literally changed to be able to follow the commandments of God. Upon receiving the Holy Spirit, you sin no more, as it is impossible to do so.


5. I believe the whore of Babylon is the Vatican and its church, and has corrupted the entire world with false teachings, and that most of christianity that exists in the world still has many of the teachings that were created by the roman catholic church. I believe the vatican will be destroyed first at some point in the future, by 10 entities that are yet to reveal themselves to us, before the coming of the Lord.


6. I believe America to be the beast of the earth, the false prophet, spreading its form of government unto the world, as in spreading its democratic form of government unto many other nations, and that this form of government first originated in the Roman empire, which is also the first beast, the beast of the sea, which is now reviving in the european union as its own entity, and shares this same form of government. I believe the "image of the beast" to be other smaller nations taking on this same form of government, as in other smaller democracies. This is clearly evident in the characteristic of the US to spread its form of government unto other nations, and as of late there have been public CIA releases showing the US government's involvement in the coupe of many nations and setting up puppet democracies. I'm not a "conspiracist", as I dont think the leaders in our government are aware that they are fulfilling prophecy, they are just blindly spreading a way of life and a way of government that is evil in the eyes of God, as it concerns the things of man and not the things of God.


7. I believe the rapture is a false teaching. I believe in ONE second coming of the Lord Jesus Christ, where ALL the dead IN HIM, are raised from the dead, and lifted up to meet him in the air as he descends upon the earth. The resurrection of the saints along with the taking away AND the second coming are all ONE single event, there is no secret rapture.


8. I believe in a literal death. When you sleep it is black, you are unconscious, you are unaware, UNTIL the moment of resurrection, where you are brought back to life. I believe the reason God made man in need of sleep was to foreshadow the death that was to come to the world, and then to also foreshadow resurrection, because just as we fall asleep and wake up (how quick it is), i believe that death and resurrection to be similar (it is quick, and we wake up in new bodies).


9. I believe that there are three things, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit, but it is not a "trinity" as originally taught and pushed by the catholic church. The Father is greater than the Son and the Spirit, as the Father has no beginning, and he has made both things for his glory. I believe that the Son and the Spirit were in the beginning, as written by scripture, but were created before all other things were made, and that through the Son were all things created.


10. I believe that all things should be done in the name of Jesus Christ alone as is taught throughout the book of Acts, including baptizing in the name of Jesus Christ alone. I believe the scripture in Matthew about the trinity was altered by the Roman Catholic Church and there is evidence of this and an earlier manuscript that was uncovered showing that the original text said "in my name" only.


11. I believe that the church should be run as in the book of Acts, assembling in homes with breaking of bread and communion, not as it is run today as big mega churches running as major corporate businesses.


12. I believe tithing to be a false teaching, the apostles instructed all new believers to sell everything that they had, and live humbly, and share with each as they had need. I believe this same instruction applies today.


13. I believe that the real promised land is the earth, not the plot of the land in Israel. As it is said, the meek will inherit the earth. I believe that at the second coming of Jesus Christ, as believers, we are to take dominion of the earth. Its at this coming that Jesus Christ will lead a war to destroy nations on the earth, and to throw people in a great fire (hell and gehenna, a literal fire on the earth to destroy people that are alive) that will exist in the future, and that in this fire is where the prophecy of "The wicked will see it and be vexed, He will gnash his teeth and melt away;" in the Psalms will be fulfilled.


14. I believe the judgment of Hell and Gehenna to be a fire that will exist in the future to destroy people that are alive and not in Christ. Their judgment is death by the painful and dreadful death by fire.


15. I don't believe that you go to Heaven or Hell right after death. Like I explained in some of the items before, I believe in actual death, I believe in a resurrection, and as believers we are to remain on the Earth to take dominion of it at the coming of the Lord, and those who are not in Christ will be destroyed in fire. I also believe in a second resurrection where those people will be destroyed in this same fire that will exist (this is the second death).


16. I believe the true Sabbath to be on Saturday, not Sunday. Sunday was instituted by the catholic church and it is a false Sabbath. Although I don't believe we should take a legalistic approach in following the Sabbath, I do believe we are still to honor it and remember it, and there are even indications of the believers in the book of Acts respecting it. It it also one of the ten commandments! Its important!

image.png


HOGWASH
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#30
Hm, for what reasons churches like corinth ore ephesus should assamble on a jewish celebration day. Is the day when their lord rose a reason to assemble at tbis day also to renember it. Fact is, that the bible teaches this and not the Rcc, it was then common that christians met on sunday and Jews at saturday. Important should be that we celebrate this day to the Lord.Where the bible teaches that christians should assamble on Saturday?
Im still on the fence about this. For one thing the Sabbath is indeed on Saturday, there is no denying that. I just want to further investigate what the early church did in following the sabbath, if they even did regard it, and when they actually assembled.
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#31
Can you share the scripture that teaches us Jesus was created.
Sure, here are two scriptures indicating that he is the first of the creation of God, meaning he was created,

who is the image of the unseen God, first-born of all creation; (Colossians 1:15 [ABP])
and,

“And to the angel of the church in Laodicea write: ‘The words of the Amen, the faithful and true witness, the beginning of God’s creation. (Revelation 3:14 ESV)
 

gotime

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
3,537
88
48
#32
EVERYTHING was created THROUGH HIM. He was THERE in the BEGINNING to create all things. Yet in knowing this, we also read:



This verse is indicative that he too was created as the first born of creation. So we can only assume that in the beginning was the Word created, and that THROUGH the WORD, were all things in creation made. Only the Father has no beginning, and all things, including the Son, have been made for his glory, and he has subjected all things to the Son, and he has chosen to make the Son to be in his very own image.
Does Colossians really say that?

Firstborn also has symbolic application in the Old Testament. it represents the one who inherits all things etc. but that aside lets take a look at what is said and see:

Col 1:15 Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of every creature:

What does this mean? well the very next verse tells us:

Col 1:16 For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:
Col 1:17 And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.


Answer: He is the firstborn because he made all things and he is before all things and he maintains all things. But the real clue to the nature of the use of "firstborn" is cleared up in what comes next:

Col 1:18 And he is the head of the body, the church: who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead; that in all things he might have the preeminence.

Notice again Paul uses this term but this time in connection to raising from the dead. Quick question, Was Jesus the first to ever resurrect?

Answer: No He is not thus we see that Paul is using this term in a different sense than literal first born or first one. and ultimately he has first position in all things is the meaning because the firstborn in the old testament had the preeminence in the family so it is in this sense that Paul uses the term firstborn so that people would understand that all things are His.

And thus this lines up with:

Joh 1:3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.
 

gotime

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
3,537
88
48
#33
Ps I agree with a lot of what you said, but your views on Jesus I differ with.
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#34
Greetings cgaviria,

The statement above is false! First of all, to be God means to have no beginning and no end, self existing, that is, eternal. Therefore, Jesus could not be God in that respect and that because He would have had some starting point like the angels. In short, if you are a created being, you cannot be God.

Also, no created being could pay the penalty for sins, but God himself. Jesus is God in the flesh, not the Father, but another person of the Godhead. Before he took on flesh, he existed with the Father, having no beginning and no ending. The Jews recognized what Jesus was saying when he said, "Before Abraham was, I am," which is why they picked up stones to kill him and that because they understood that he was proclaiming to be thee God. The Jews would not have picked up stones to kill Jesus for being a created being.

Regarding the other topics on your list, your lack of belief that Jesus is God Almighty, the Sovereign Lord, makes the rest irrelevant, and that because you are believing in another Jesus, which cancels everything else out. I have much more to say regarding this, which I will address later.
First of all, I am not denying the the Word was present with the Father at the beginning, and that through the Word all things were made. What I am saying is that BEFORE the beginning, it was only the Father. Jesus Christ did have a beginning, as it described in certain verses saying that he is the beginning, the first born, of creation. All things have been subjected to him and have been made through him. Before Abraham, I am, does not affirm that he is at the Father having no beginning, it is affirming that he is is self sufficient, as he even says,

For as the father has life in himself, so he gave also to the son [*2*life *1*to have] in himself; (John 5:26 [ABP])
The Father has granted him this. If he had always been, as you say, then why would he have need for the Father to grant him life in himself? Makes no sense.

And even so, just because Jesus was created does not deny that he is in fact God. He is the express image of the GOD HEAD. He is anointed by the Father and chosen by him. You have to understand something here, Jesus is a SON, and not just a son, but the first born son. What is a son? It is an image, meaning something lesser, reflecting something greater, in this case, the Father. Even Jesus says,

You heard that I said to you, I go away, and I come to you. If you loved me, you would have rejoiced that I said, I go to the father, for my father [*2*greater than *3*me *1*is]. (John 14:28 [ABP])
Jesus said it himself!
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#35
woooowwww :confused: so you are the only one, huh? What about 1 John 1:8, you just kind of skipped over that one... Here, I'll re-post it for you: " If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us." (1 John 1:8)
I am not saying I am the only one and I am not saying I do not have sin. In fact, I have committed many sins that I wish I had not committed. I am also not saying that anyone who receives the holy spirit now has not committed any sins, what I am saying is that once you do receive the holy spirit you STOP sinning. I hold the following scripture to be very true and skipped over and misread by alot of regular Christians because they don't understand what being born of God is and true righteousness being empowered by the holy spirit to be righteous:

Anyone engendered of God, [*3*sin *1*does not *2*commit], for his seed [*2*in *3*him *1*abides]; and he is not able to sin, because [*2*by *3*God *1*he has been engendered]. (I John 3:9 [ABP])
 

gotime

Senior Member
Mar 3, 2011
3,537
88
48
#36
One thing often missed is the reality of Jesus becoming a man:

Php 2:6 Who, being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God:
Php 2:7 But made himself of no reputation, and took upon him the form of a servant, and was made in the likeness of men:

The bolded means he emptied himself and became a servant. Before he was full and not a servant nor a man.

When it says:

Joh 5:26 For as the Father hath life in himself; so hath he given to the Son to have life in himself;

It must be understood in those terms, Jesus the man who is emptied himself and become a servant. The one who was higher than angels but now is a little lower than the angels. Jesus willingly became a lesser but He did not start that way. He started as an equal to the Father.

What really gets things going is when you come to the realization that Jesus is YHWH of the Old Testament.
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#37
I made this connection myself too, but I haven't been on here long enough to officially draw that conclusion, but I'm glad you did though, VioletReigns.

Given that this information is true, cgaviria, and you did in fact state that you "abandoned" the last Christian Forum you "encountered opposition" in, but you actually were banned...that would be a lie. And a sin. So according to your gospel, you aren't going to make the cut either.

If what you say is true, what a lonely, quiet place Heaven must be with God sitting up there all by Himself... :(
Yes, I was banned, but it was because I requested them to delete my account. I posted there for 2 days no different than what I am doing here, and I posted my list of things that I believe in as I did here. They disagreed with what I posted and decided to move my post unto another category that was not widely used, and when i asked them why they did that, they directed me to a private chat with them. In the private chat, I kindly asked for them to show me scripture showing me their views, and they declined to debate me and asked if I would abide by their rules to only discuss things under their views or not. I kindly declined and asked them to delete my account and wished them farewell. I honestly was not aware that their forum was not an open forum before I starting posting. I even have a PDF image of the entire conversation if you wish to see it. I am not some evil spammer coming to forums trying to proselytize people to my views, I honestly wish to debate scripture, and either disprove things I've concluded, or strengthen it, but based on scripture. I also wish, if possible, to find other like minded individuals. I am in a deep search. As I said earlier, I am a student of scripture.
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#38
God and the angels are just sitting up there waiting for a bride that will never exist? Jesus Is preparing a place is His Father's mansion that has many rooms, for nobody? How about this scripture: Confess your trespasses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The effective, fervent prayer of a righteous man avails much. James 5:16
Do you suggest that this book of the Bible as well as the others that mention repentance and the confession of sins are written to UNSAVED people and that they are not meant to be applied to the lives of people that actually have the Spirit of God?

You're writing this as if I'm professing that I have no sins. On the contrary, I have many sins. I guarantee more than you. I was not a good person in the world. I am ashamed of it. And no one is clear of sins either, as it it said,


for all sinned and lack the glory of God; (Romans 3:23 [ABP])

BUT, I do believe that in the receiving of the spirit, you are then CAUSED to SIN NO MORE, as it is written,


Anyone engendered of God, [*3*sin *1*does not *2*commit], for his seed [*2*in *3*him *1*abides]; and he is not able to sin, because [*2*by *3*God *1*he has been engendered]. (I John 3:9 [ABP])
Even Jesus said,

And she said, No one, O Lord. [*3*said *1*And *4*to her *2*Jesus], Nor I condemn you; go and from now [*2*no more *1*sin]! (John 8:11 [ABP])
[26] And I will put in you [*2*heart *1*a new], and [*3*spirit *2*a new *1*I will put] in you, and I will remove the [*2*heart *1*stone] from your flesh, and I will give to you a heart of flesh. [27] And [*2*my spirit *1*I will put] in you, and I shall make it that [*2*by *3*my ordinances *1*you shall go], and [*2*my judgments *1*you shall keep], and you shall observe them.
(Ezekiel 36:26-27 [ABP])

These scriptures indicate the very essence of what having the holy spirit is, TRUE RIGHTEOUSNESS, EMPOWERED BY GOD, NOT BY YOU, BUT BY GOD, BY HIS SPIRIT. Notice how even in this scripture in Ezekiel he even says I will REMOVE your heart of stone, and give you a HEART of flesh. What is the heart??????? it is the MIND. This is NOT a figure of speech. This is LITERAL. You are LITERALLY changed into a different person, able to follow after God and follow his commandments. And it is done By the Spirit of God. Having the Spirit of God is like a possession, but by God. Its so powerful, that even in the other verses we see evidence of what happens when one receives the Spirit:


And he comes from there unto the hill. And behold, a company of dancers of prophets right opposite him; and [*3*leaped *4*upon *5*him *1*spirit *2*of God], and he prophesied in the midst of them. (I Samuel 10:10 [ABP])

This verse was talking about Saul when he was persecuting David. And we know Saul was an unrighteous man, even seeking after the guidance of mediums. And look what the Spirit did even when it sprang on him, he began prophesying!


And Saul sent messengers to take David. And coming they saw the assembly of the prophets prophesying, and Samuel stood ordained over them. And [*3*became *4*upon *5*the *6*messengers *7*of Saul *1*spirit *2*of God], and they prophesied, even they. (I Samuel 19:20 [ABP])

So not just him, but his messengers too! Saul's change was so intense that this next verse follows:


And came to pass all the things being made known to him yesterday and the third day before. And behold, he was in the midst of the prophets prophesying. And [*4*said *1*the *2*people *3*each] to his neighbor, What is this, the thing having happened to the son of Kish? Or is also Saul among the prophets? (I Samuel 10:11 [ABP])

Which is pretty much them saying, what the crap happened here???!!! Is Saul now a prophet??? They were shocked!


And here is another verse, showing the Saul was changed into another person because of the Spirit!


And [*3*shall spring *4*upon *5*you *1*spirit *2*of the LORD], and you shall prophesy with them, and you shall turn into [*2*man *1*another]. (I Samuel 10:6 [ABP])

And also in the book of Acts in the early church we have,


And they were filled all together [*2*spirit *1*of holy], and they began to speak with other languages, as the spirit gave to them to be declared. (Acts 2:4 [ABP])

So yes, I believe the Holy Spirit to be an enabler, the thing that CAUSES a man to follow after the commandments of God, and it comes with evident manifestation that you have indeed received it.
 
Nov 21, 2015
51
0
0
#39
Does Colossians really say that?

Firstborn also has symbolic application in the Old Testament. it represents the one who inherits all things etc. but that aside lets take a look at what is said and see:

Col 1:15 Who is the image of the invisible God, the firstborn of every creature:

What does this mean? well the very next verse tells us:

Col 1:16 For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:
Col 1:17 And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.


Answer: He is the firstborn because he made all things and he is before all things and he maintains all things. But the real clue to the nature of the use of "firstborn" is cleared up in what comes next:

Col 1:18 And he is the head of the body, the church: who is the beginning, the firstborn from the dead; that in all things he might have the preeminence.

Notice again Paul uses this term but this time in connection to raising from the dead. Quick question, Was Jesus the first to ever resurrect?

Answer: No He is not thus we see that Paul is using this term in a different sense than literal first born or first one. and ultimately he has first position in all things is the meaning because the firstborn in the old testament had the preeminence in the family so it is in this sense that Paul uses the term firstborn so that people would understand that all things are His.

And thus this lines up with:

Joh 1:3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.
The firstborn is not just the one that inherits all things, it is also the one that is BORN FIRST, HENCE first born...... first born in the creation. So if anything, first born is DEFINITELY very indicative of Jesus Christ being BORN FIRST as a part of the creation, AND also, an inheritor of everything in creation.

Also, none of what you said has affirmed that Jesus has no beginning as the father. All things HAVE BEEN SUBJECTED TO HIM AND CREATED THROUGH HIM, AND HE IS INDEED THE HEAD OF THE BODY, YESSSSS.

And notice how you even quoted this:

And he is the head of the body of the assembly, who is the beginning, the first-born from the dead, that [*2*should be *4*in *5*all things *1*he *3*preeminent]. (Colossians 1:18 [ABP])
If Jesus had no beginning, what would this scripture say he IS THE BEGINNING.

So I'm telling you, IN THE BEGINNING, the Word was created, and through the Word, were all things made. The Word was present in the very beginning, because it was made before all other things were made, and all other things were made through the Word.