Yep, I take issue with this. It doesn't matter if we're good people, it doesn't matter how many we help, doesn't matter who we are at all, we're condemned simply for not believing. I could never bring myself to believe that god would impose such a cruel fate upon anyone simply for not believing in him. He created hell, he created the rules that condemn us all there.
He gave us everything but he couldn't have his actions make any sense to us? We are unconvinced by the stories of Jesus, we do not believe they are true, that is all we are guilty of. In fact you said it yourself, we question your beliefs, we don't just accept them, and that's our crime. I fail to understand what about that "crime" is so horrible that it causes anyone to deserve this fate.
Think about what you believe for a moment, think of all the good people in agony worse than anything you've ever experienced in your life, for billions of years all the way into eternity. Think about their suffering for just a second, can you imagine? How can you call this fair, how can you call this just, how can you call this anything but pure evil? I couldn't do what you have done, I couldn't possibly bring myself to think that anyone deserves hell, nor will I ever try to make myself (and I tried to hard to force myself) believe something so detestable ever again. By the way, when I was 15, I still believed in hell, things have changed.
The bottom line for me : torture is sick and is never justified, especially when it's ETERNAL.