I watched James White on youtube make mistakes and have documented the mistakes.
The scholars I accept can't make mistakes like that...
What should we think about your judgment if you are trusting someone who is unaccredited?
First, I didn't state that I trusted him. Second, I said nothing about his accreditation, other than referring to him as "Dr. White." Third, I directed the readers of this thread to his book, which is extensively footnoted. If you don't like him because of his accreditation or his mistakes, fine, but don't blow off the evidence he has collected for those reasons. If you flatly refuse to read the evidence, and just argue against the man, that is intellectual dishonesty.
As to accreditation, Moses, Samuel, David, Ezra, Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, Daniel, John the Baptist, John the Revelator, Matthew, Luke, Apollos, Timothy and Jesus Himself were all "unaccredited" (Paul may have been, as a Pharisee). Accreditation, by itself, is no guarantee of truth, and lack of it is no guarantee of error.