all or nothing

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Liamson

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2010
3,078
69
48
#42
Appearances can be deceiving and no two relationships are the same.

I've mostly agreed with everything that AllforFun has said.

Not that I'm an unnaturally forward person but, sometimes a person's fears and expectations can control and strangle a relationship before it ever sees daylight. What may perhaps appear to be me flaking out on them is my sincere understanding of the fundamental differences that exist between people culminating into a point where it exceeds my patience. Then when I stop seeing her, she begs me to stay, which then makes me seem like the crazy person who drops ultimatums and wants to go all in or nothing.

Date 1: I find out She is a Christian and we start going to church together +
Date 2: I find out She has a great voice and loves to sing in the car. +
Date 3: She wants me to see her but, not the other way around -
Date 4: She wants me to make horsey noises when I drive fast -
Date 5: She wants me to wear a cowboy hat and learn to line dance -
Date 6: She wants to name her Children Trace and Rascal - - -

...and then I quit.

But she can't figure out why it happened so suddenly. It must be because I'm a controlling flake.
 
L

lonelymom

Guest
#43
i believe u should be willing to give all to god and everything else will fall into place. but other than that i think it does sound kinda demanding
 
A

allforfun

Guest
#44
Liasom- we are starting to agree on something. Pick a fight so it can stop :) I liked your sequence and many times it happens that way. And neither party is to blame really. Except the person who wants to name her kid Rascal. That is punishable by never finding a good shoe sale.

I think this could come down to different personality types as well. Forgive me, I'm knee deep in starting a thesis for psychology.

All or nothing types~Type A personality for a better terminology. They (me) are seen as a high maintenance type of personality because they live with gusto, work with gusto and yes can be exhausting. It is not that we have more energy than other people, we just pour more of our attention into what we are doing at the time. Apply this to a relationship and it can be a good thing because the other person will feel the full extent of the emotions involved and generally never have to question what the Type A is feeling.

However, if the person is a more laid back person (which I wish I was many time) this can be overwhelming, exhausting, draining, demanding and can seem controlling.


Or I might need to go back to studying and lay off this a bit.

Liasom
 

Liamson

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2010
3,078
69
48
#45
Liasom- we are starting to agree on something. Pick a fight so it can stop :) I liked your sequence and many times it happens that way. And neither party is to blame really. Except the person who wants to name her kid Rascal. That is punishable by never finding a good shoe sale.

I think this could come down to different personality types as well. Forgive me, I'm knee deep in starting a thesis for psychology.

All or nothing types~Type A personality for a better terminology. They (me) are seen as a high maintenance type of personality because they live with gusto, work with gusto and yes can be exhausting. It is not that we have more energy than other people, we just pour more of our attention into what we are doing at the time. Apply this to a relationship and it can be a good thing because the other person will feel the full extent of the emotions involved and generally never have to question what the Type A is feeling.

However, if the person is a more laid back person (which I wish I was many time) this can be overwhelming, exhausting, draining, demanding and can seem controlling.


Or I might need to go back to studying and lay off this a bit.

Liasom
I'm usually one for beating the compatibility drum but, this is definitely something that is a compatibility issue. For some people the ability to express creatively and intensely the spectrum of all that they feel for someone is essential. Some people find this annoying or even smothering.
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,580
4,268
113
#46
I think that when a guy says "all or nothing" he means for a woman to move across the country (or world) to be with him and leave her old life behind.
 
J

Jullianna

Guest
#47
Pretty close, Zero. In this case, it meant his way or no way while I was still wondering if I was even interested. Sometimes you instinctively know that while the good times with someone would be REALLY GOOD, the bad times with them would be unbearable and far more frequent.
 

Liamson

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2010
3,078
69
48
#48
Pretty close, Zero. In this case, it meant his way or no way while I was still wondering if I was even interested. Sometimes you instinctively know that while the good times with someone would be REALLY GOOD, the bad times with them would be unbearable and far more frequent.
Oh.......

I will say this much though, ^that^ is thoroughly unromantic if his name isn't William Darcy.

Most guys can't get away with drawing a line in the sand, declaring how they feel, without some kind of an escape clause or an exit strategy.

"If this fails, and I tell her I love her, only to have her reject my affections and intentions, will leave me no choice but to leave. That is a chance I'm going to have to take because I cannot live under the spell of such a beautiful woman, without letting her know just how much she means to me."
-Guy's thoughts
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,580
4,268
113
#49
Pretty close, Zero. In this case, it meant his way or no way while I was still wondering if I was even interested. Sometimes you instinctively know that while the good times with someone would be REALLY GOOD, the bad times with them would be unbearable and far more frequent.
Very true and insightful. You're a smart lady, Julianna. ;)
 
J

Jullianna

Guest
#50
Oh.......

I will say this much though, ^that^ is thoroughly unromantic if his name isn't William Darcy.

Most guys can't get away with drawing a line in the sand, declaring how they feel, without some kind of an escape clause or an exit strategy.

"If this fails, and I tell her I love her, only to have her reject my affections and intentions, will leave me no choice but to leave. That is a chance I'm going to have to take because I cannot live under the spell of such a beautiful woman, without letting her know just how much she means to me."
-Guy's thoughts
Not even close to my precious Mr. Darcy *insert heart palpitation here* :) And that's beautiful btw :) Why can't a guy just say THAT? haha
 
Last edited by a moderator:
J

Jullianna

Guest
#51
Very true and insightful. You're a smart lady, Julianna. ;)
Thank you, my dear. I think that once you've been in a relationship that was RIGHT, you know what it's supposed to feel like. And when you've seen the wrong ones on a daily basis year after year after year in your work, you have a sack full of red flags to draw from. :)
 
Aug 2, 2009
24,580
4,268
113
#52
I prefer Jane Eyre to Pride & Prejudice. :p

Can never have too many red flags. :)
 

Liamson

Senior Member
Feb 3, 2010
3,078
69
48
#53
G

GreenNnice

Guest
#54
Pretty close, Zero. In this case, it meant his way or no way while I was still wondering if I was even interested. Sometimes you instinctively know that while the good times with someone would be REALLY GOOD, the bad times with them would be unbearable and far more frequent.
~~~
Girl (pondering the possibilities): Really good! Really GOOD! REALLY GOOD! UNBEARABLE! UNBEARABLY GOOD! UNBEARABLE! REALLY, REALLY, GO-UNBEARABLE! SOOOO GOOD, BUT SOOOO UNBEARABLE!
__
I , but of course, was being tongue and cheek but I think the moment a guy says, 'You want to really be in this all the way or not?', that is the time to...JUST, JUST, just, slooow down and..


.....That is the time to not ask yourself if it's (relationship) really good or, even, and, this might upset some ladies, but that is also the time to not ask yourself if 'it' is unbearable. In fact, in a moment like this (My Moment as Zere would say thru his hero , Rebeca Black :D ) of being asked by the guy to either be 100% committed to the relationship, it is time to ask yourself nothing but, to God, everything....

Girl: Is this really you, God, what do you want me to do?

___
TRUST me, and, much more importantly ;) , TRUST God, He, in our telling moments of life, talking of BIG life decisions and things said that have the potency to change our lives dramatically, will be there for you, always. And, then, after asking, and, He telling what you are to do next, follow Him, even if it SEEMS like you're throwing yourself overboard of a ship. The whale will gulp you up and you will be safe from the fatally harmful effects of the sea. And, think, too: WHAT a good story God's given you from your decision to follow Him.

The Lord leads.

____
I think, Liamman, that you say wise things about relationship, but, ultimátely, the girl is leaving you because not of any of the things you do on the date, it's what you don't do: Put God in the centre of your date.

Your way to know her is great as is your 1st date, going to church, but what about date of bible study? Going to church for date 2,3,4,5,6. ?

----Girls will most often, I think, not tell you the REAL REASON they are leaving you. And, christian girls want to date (I say, 'be with') real christian guys, ones that incorporate their belief in God-salvation into every thing they do in life.

And, it's not my opinion but the truth: MOST christian girls want a guy who is going to control them into improving their life, and, true , you can do some yourself (thru God's leading) but, ultimately, it is God who helps us all succeed in life per his personal relationship He so desires with each and every one of us.
:)
I could be wrong too but I think julieannie, allfunfor, will agree: If all or nothing means committing BOTH your vives, as best you can, then they will STAY (after as I said above, she, by herself, gets down on her knees and asks, 'Is this really you, God, what you want me to do?'

Everyone is different, as allfunfor said, some girls like guys telling all about themselves while some get annoyed after while, but I guarantee, they (christian girls) agree on one thing: they all want and pray for a christian guy to meet who is from God given.

God bless!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
1

1still_waters

Guest
#55
Ladies, if a guy gives you a stupid, jealousy based ultimatum, give him a nice farewell card. Signed in your lipstick and stomped on by your best pair of heels.
 
J

Jullianna

Guest
#56
Thank you, Stilly. When a guy/lady gives you a list of people you can't talk to/things he doesn't think you should do, and basically says it's his way or no way, NO WAY is the correct answer.
 
1

1still_waters

Guest
#57
Thank you, Stilly. When a guy/lady gives you a list of people you can't talk to/things he doesn't think you should do, and basically says it's his way or no way, NO WAY is the correct answer.
I reckon Texan women, especially, don't like to be told what to do.
 
J

Jullianna

Guest
#58
Well, because in my experience women never actually gives us the chance.


quote]

That’s unfortunate. :( When the Lord calls to our hearts, He doesn’t throw a rope around our necks and play tug-o-war with us until we’re choking. He calls to our hearts, softens them and woos us until we trust Him enough to willingly put our hand in His in full faith and submission. I’m thinking there’s a lesson to be learned here all the way around…

There’s a reason women cry over movies, love songs, sappy poems and like men who make them laugh. And if a woman’s heart is so hardened that it can’t be touched by such things, I have to wonder if it’s healthy enough for a relationship.
 
J

Jullianna

Guest
#59
I reckon Texan women, especially, don't like to be told what to do.
It's really not even that.. The things I listed spring from jealousy and insecurity in a man, not from the kind of love that lasts a lifetime. And if they rear their head early in a relationship, you can pretty well count on that becoming far worse and more frequent. I've seen women behave in the same controlling way toward men.

When a woman knows she can TRUST you with her heart, she doesn't mind being ASKED to do something/not to do something if it troubles a man. But, like I said in the above post, you can't learn to trust when the rope around your neck is choking the life out of you. :)
 
Jul 25, 2005
2,417
34
0
#60
I've never been in a serious relationship, but anytime I'm handed something that resembles political games or some sort of treaty, I bolt.

Life is complicated and problem-filled enough.