Hi Cristen,
Thanks for bringing so many laughs and much-needed sanity to the forum.
I don't know if this will help you but the last time I had some major decisions to make (and I'll be facing them for a second time in the next few months), I was terrified of making the wrong decisions. I would get up early all the time to pray because I was so worried about making the wrong choices (about a job, place to live, etc.)
One day I believe God specifically told me, "Don't be afraid, because I will be with you (no matter what decision you make or job you wind up with.)"
This was a huge comfort to me and while of course, nothing went picture-perfect, I know He's been with me in the way things have worked out. While I'm terrified of making another wrong decision as well... I do feel somewhat comforted in knowing He'll be there no matter what (the Bible story that came to mind was of Jacob--Laban changed his wages unfairly many times, but each time, God worked it out to Jacob's prosperity), and I pray it will be the same for you, Cristen, as well as giving you peace of mind.
Hugs and God bless!