The heresies of the few

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
T

Tankman131

Guest
The issue of "what is truth" and "what is heresy" actually do go hand in hand.
If we are going to make judgements over what is and isn't heresy, we need a standard.
And the question was answered. Now back to the topic at hand
 
Mar 20, 2015
768
13
0
You are off the topic of this one
I don't think so but let's have a look at the word heresies/heresy : opinion or doctrine at variance with the orthodox or accepted doctrine, especially of a church or religious system.
 

SolidGround

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2014
904
17
18
And the question was answered. Now back to the topic at hand
I was never really sure what the topic at hand was. There were too many side convos, so I just picked up on the ones that I was acquainted with, and thinking about.
 
Jan 19, 2013
11,909
141
0
this is of the many issues the Bible speaks about even the very elect will be deceived in the last days.
Where does the Bible say the elect will be deceived in the last days?
 
Mar 21, 2015
643
4
0
There's no fellowship with false prophets.

It's like this concept some try to promote here, that Christianity is all divided.
Well, the church is not really a message board, where any cult whackjob can create a pulpit and spew......

I have no use for fake religion, whatsoever.
Well regretfully, it seems to me that Christianity is "all divided".
And that 'false prophets', whackjobs and fake religion abound.

The problem being that anyone who disagrees with "my" interpretation and conclusions has to be one of the above.
Regardless of whether it's the usual cultish targets like the JWs, Mormons, SDAs etc etc or a monolith like Catholicism.
 

SolidGround

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2014
904
17
18
It's dialogue over what is the true meaning of the Biblical text?
Then the answer is "through the mind of Christ given us".

Does the Spirit reveal all truths to us instantly? No. There is progressive revelation, as documented in Scripture, and as proven by a Beleiver's growth in Christ and progress toward maturity.

As we are still in bodies of flesh, much is not revealed to us...
and yet many form opinions about topics that are not revealed to mankind.
When people call "heresy" on these topics, I call them out on it.
But the basis of Truth, is what is revealed in Scripture, and unveiled by the Holy Spirit dwelling within the Believer.

The Spirit does not contradict itself, so in debates over theologies,
We must discern what is of Spirit, and what is of flesh,
What is useful, and what is philosophical,
What is concrete, and what is conjecture.

Sometimes, we have to just admit that God has not yet revealed certain things.
Other times, we have to refute those who twist the Word.
And yet more often, we have to edifying those who are misinformed of the Word, or who have misplaced zeal.
 
Last edited:
A

atwhatcost

Guest
Asking questions just give them a soapbox, Sirk. It's what they want. Satan wants his agenda heard, questions raised in the hearts of new or unstudied believers. It might enable him to drive a wedge between them and Christ.

And how fruitful has it been to put truth out there in front of these divisive heretics? The only think I've noticed it produced is high blood pressure, anger, and frustration. I can't find those among the fruit of the Spirit.

As Jesus said, "Any place that does not receive you or listen to you, as you go out from there, shake the dust off the soles of your feet for a testimony against them" (Mark 6:11). I've seen Jehovah's Witnesses do this when they leave someone's house who debates them, but their use of Jesus' statement is no reason for us not to use it here in the face of those who "will not receive ... or listen."

They won't hear it anyway.

After repeatedly banging your head against a stone wall, the wall not budging and your head sustaining concussive damage, at what point do you finally decide the effort is pointless?
My husband (way before he was my husband) loaded for bear. He'd study the scripture enough to pull out all the places that looked like they contradicted themselves and used those as his bullets to attack Christians. It worked. It really did work on the young in Christ and the ethnically-Christian, but not spiritually-Christian. (Those born into a church but thinking they were saved simply because their parents were.) He drove many of them away from the Lord.

And then he met a woman who knew her Bible and knew God. Every night he went fully armed with his "contradictions." Every night she deflected them one by one. This went on for three weeks.

Would you invite him back to your house after the first night? How about after the second? I certainly would have kicked him out early that first night for "wasting my time." Thank God, Carol (that woman) isn't me. Three weeks later he went home so angry with her he was just about ready to kill her. And the next morning he woke up a believer.

Of course they don't listen! That doesn't negate God using the saint who can put up with that attitude over the long haul from saying what God would have them say so the deaf hear and believe.

I can't be that saint, because I still have the patience of Jonah. I can see why you can't be that person. You were gifted in three specific ways -- to listen well and to point out a pile of hooey when you hear it. And once there, you're the guy who knows what to do instead of relying on that pile of hooey. Isn't that pretty much the description of what you do in life?

But Sirk ain't us. I may be a toe. You may be an arm. Sirk may well be the finger that pulls out whatever is in their ears that they're listening too. That's why we're the body of Christ, each gifted differently. The whole thing needs doing, and together God uses all our gifts to get it done. (And a lot more done without us, but... you know. A different part of the story. lol)

I think Sirk is nuts, but in a good way. I don't have that talent he has, but we can still do something for him as he hangs in those front-lines -- pray. My prayer is going to be "God do this quickly, because that's got to hurt." (Toe. Gets stubbed a lot. What were you expecting me to think? lol) You pray what you think is necessary for Sirk too, and that's how the body works together.
 
Mar 20, 2015
768
13
0
Then the answer is "through the mind of Christ given us".

Does the Spirit reveal all truths to us instantly? No. There is progressive revelation, as documented in Scripture, and as proven by a Beleiver's growth in Christ and progress toward maturity.

As we are still in bodies of flesh, much is not revealed to us...
and yet many form opinions about topics that are not revealed to mankind.
When people call "heresy" on these topics, I call them out on it.
Yes but round and round we go, but interesting you mention that truth is not yet revealed to us instantly, progressive revelation i like the sound of that, i suppose people like me will have to wait and see what truth gets revealed, if ever?, it's almost like make your own truth or listen to your own truth?


But the basis of Truth, is what is revealed in Scripture, and unveiled by the Holy Spirit dwelling within the Believer.
Is this not what all Christians say though?

I'm off for a cup of tea, lol.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
So which is it? Ignore or invisible?......I'm a Blond so things need to be real clear before I get it as to which I am......
Neither -- friend. I just generally think "Yup" when I read what you write, but don't acknowledge it because of the coding. (I'd say "Yup" a lot if I was allowed a mere 3 letters instead of ten. Yup. Probably people like me causing that coding. lol)
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
I don't believe that all the divisions come from twisting the Word selfishly or maliciously.
Ignorance and misplace zeal are just as often the cause.
Which is the difference between "heresies of a few" and smack-gob huge arguments and disagreements of the many.
 
T

Tankman131

Guest
Neither -- friend. I just generally think "Yup" when I read what you write, but don't acknowledge it because of the coding. (I'd say "Yup" a lot if I was allowed a mere 3 letters instead of ten. Yup. Probably people like me causing that coding. lol)
Yup

________:p
 
May 30, 2015
1,179
7
0
Where does the Bible say the elect will be deceived in the last days?
Here's a hint:

2 Thessalonians 2:3
Let no one in any way deceive you, for it will not come unless the apostasy comes first, and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the son of destruction,



One doesn't become an apostate in any unified area of belief without having first believed something in that area of belief.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
The issue is that only one's denomination accepts one's version of orthodoxy.
Orthodoxy is man being confident in his own understanding of the Word.
Not really. It's the overall orthodoxy that took centuries of educated Christian scholars to define, not create.
 

SolidGround

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2014
904
17
18
Which is the difference between "heresies of a few" and smack-gob huge arguments and disagreements of the many.
I can see that.
But sometimes they all get wrapped up in the same box.

Sometimes, misplaced zeal is the very thing that drives us to call "heresy".
 

SolidGround

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2014
904
17
18
Not really. It's the overall orthodoxy that took centuries of educated Christian scholars to define, not create.
The issue is "educated".
Be wary of the scribes.

Their definitions are exactly what cause the divisions.
If you ask a Lutheran about orthodoxy, you get a different set than from a Baptist, and a different set from the Pentacostal, and a different set from the Reformed theologian from the dispensationalist and from the traditionalist and from the Roots movement... etc
 
Last edited:

SolidGround

Senior Member
Jan 15, 2014
904
17
18
Yes but round and round we go, but interesting you mention that truth is not yet revealed to us instantly, progressive revelation i like the sound of that, i suppose people like me will have to wait and see what truth gets revealed, if ever?, it's almost like make your own truth or listen to your own truth?


Is this not what all Christians say though?

I'm off for a cup of tea, lol.
It's not at all like "make your own truth" or "listen to your own truth".
It's the exact opposite.
That mentality is what we need to break apart from.
We need to stop making dividing lines about issues that are nonessential and unrevealed.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
JesusLives, Mormons aren't Christians. No matter how you slice it.

I hope we're not all in individual rooms. I'd prefer a big mansion with no walls and massive feasts for all to attend!
I'm still thinking it had better be an opened-air place that makes the Outback/Sahara/Serengeti/Texas/Alaska/Gobi look like a closet so we can all fit as we worship together and in person.
 
A

atwhatcost

Guest
How can anyone talk about God's truth if there are divisions in Christianity of what God's truth is in the Bible?. The divisions are or what appears to be the interpretations of the Bible, can't all be the truth but if the subject is a stumbling block for you then i'll leave it at that but some might see it as a bit of a copout.
If you got to my post, you read JIA's post. There are NO divisions among Christians. Ack, he put it better, so look at what he said.

Still the Strawman argument. I was born in the day time, but not today.
 
May 30, 2015
1,179
7
0
I'm still thinking it had better be an opened-air place that makes the Outback/Sahara/Serengeti/Texas/Alaska/Gobi look like a closet so we can all fit as we worship together and in person.
You'd be welcome at my house!

[video=youtube_share;TRq96MRbRds]http://youtu.be/TRq96MRbRds[/video]