The Trinity Discussion

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
D

Dagallen

Guest
You know dagallen, this comment of yours I think is even below you when you said the following to valiant. "Because Roman Catholic traditions of the Roman Catholic church is greater than scriptures, to the Roman Catholic church, because you live by your traditions, the word God is of no affect. Why don't you try reading the scriptures as written and stop adding your own intertation or the intertation that the Roman Catholis give, think outside the box and be set free."

Were not responsible for what the Roman Catholic church believes or don't believe. And I don't live by any traditions but by what the Bible says. And you have the "huevos" to tell valiant that he needs to read the scriptures? You just quoted John 14:24 and 14:28 where Jesus said He was sent and He said the Father is greater than Him.

First of all of course Jesus Christ was sent by His Father. All you have to do is read John 3:13, John 6:38, John 6:42, John 6:33 or even Ephesians 4:10 where it is written that Jesus Christ came down from heaven. In order for Him to come down from heaven He had to preexist. In fact in the Old Testament at Isaiah 9:6 it says, "For a child will be born to us, A SON WILL BE GIVEN." In other words, He/Jesus was a Son BEFORE He was given and before He was born. Not only that but here is what Luke 2:11 states, "for today in the city of David there has been born for you a Savior, WHO IS CHRIST THE LORD."

Now, to deal with why the Father is greater than all including Jesus Christ. This is clearly and easily explained at Philippians 2:6-8. The Son had voluntarily taken upon himself the form of a servant and the likeness of a man and submitted himself to the Father. In that form thereby foregoing His innate divinity and the powers associated with that divinity. As a man who was submitted to the Father, he had to receive authority for al that he did.

As a man, Jesus did not get special things that weren't already his before his incarnation as a man. he is the God who created the universe, therefore automatically had all the authority over it from the beginning. That this authority was returned to him after his purpsoe in the world was accomplished is also evident. If you notice at Philippians 2:6 it starts out by saying, "who, ALTHOUGH (although means in spite of the fact) He existed in the form of God, did not regard equality with God a thing to be grasped.

So the bottom line is that Jesus Christ was in one form/God and then took another form of that of a servant or human being. This is why vs 8 says, "And being found in the APPEARANCE AS A MAN, humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross."

So when you hear questions like, "If Jesus is God how come He did not know the time of His own return?" Or like you said, "If Jesus is God how come He said the Father is greater than Him?" No matter what excuse one can come up with the answer is always the same, Jesus functioned as a 100% contingent human being. This means He always depended completely on His Father and this is also what we are suppose to be doing. Once you understand this all the excuses evaporate. And btw, Jesus Christ is the only visible manifestation of God, (John 1:18) there is no other because in order to be equal with God you would have to be God yourself. Now, what does not make sense to you dagallen? :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
So he is God, he is the Father of himself and the son of himself, he prayed to himself and went back to himself, he sent himself, he came himself, he bowed to himself, he is subject to himself, he was greater than himself and being you say he is God himself, then God entered into a sinful world and took all the sins of the world upon himself, brought death upon himself and died for all the sins of mankind ? Interesting ! Well if that be the case, then it would not matter if I committed sin or not because the one saved always saved would be true, if that were the case, then there would be no need, to read, to pray or to stop sinning, after all, God came and died for all the sins of mankind, so everyone is saved and I guess there would be no need to talk about hell either, interesting at best.
 
Jul 25, 2017
67
1
0
John 14:23 does not say the Son = God in any shape or form. ."..we will come unto him..." by sheer brute force and no reasoning at all can easily make Son=God. The source is God and Jesus is NOT, that is what you are not considering, you have left that out. Whether conveniently or not. You only know. God alone has the spirit and power, He is the source, not Jesus.

Jesus is using God's power and spirit as we are too, to a smaller degree. By your reasoning then, we as believers by association possessing the spirit of Truth in the flesh today are also a god. Son=God=Believer. Which of course you would also admit is ridiculous and I do as well.

valiant, let us agree to disagree and move on. We all are learning and increasing our knowledge of scripture.

God bless you

AKAP out
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
So he is God, he is the Father of himself and the son of himself, he prayed to himself and went back to himself, he sent himself, he came himself, he bowed to himself, he is subject to himself, he was greater than himself and being you say he is God himself, then God entered into a sinful world and took all the sins of the world upon himself, brought death upon himself and died for all the sins of mankind ? Interesting !
You clearly do not understand the doctrine of the Triune God. God is in Threeness which intercommunicate with each other, and can act separately but always in accord...


Well if that be the case, then it would not matter if I committed sin or not because the one saved always saved would be true, if that were the case, then there would be no need, to read, to pray or to stop sinning, after all, God came and died for all the sins of mankind, so everyone is saved and I guess there would be no need to talk about hell either, interesting at best.
It is sad that you are so blind to the truth,
 
D

Dagallen

Guest
John 14:23 does not say the Son = God in any shape or form. ."..we will come unto him..." by sheer brute force and no reasoning at all can easily make Son=God. The source is God and Jesus is NOT, that is what you are not considering, you have left that out. Whether conveniently or not. You only know. God alone has the spirit and power, He is the source, not Jesus.

Jesus is using God's power and spirit as we are too, to a smaller degree. By your reasoning then, we as believers by association possessing the spirit of Truth in the flesh today are also a god. Son=God=Believer. Which of course you would also admit is ridiculous and I do as well.

valiant, let us agree to disagree and move on. We all are learning and increasing our knowledge of scripture.

God bless you

AKAP out
John 14:23 is a great passage and very revealing ! If a man love me, he will keep my words ( my sayings 14:24 ) and my Father will love him and we ( plural ) will come unto him and make our ( plural ) abode with him. John 14:24 the word which you hear are not mine but the Father's which sent me. ( He did not send himself ) very simple to understand. God bless !
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
John 14:23 does not say the Son = God in any shape or form. .".
As in so many cases in NT it assumes it and expects people to see it. But only the one who is guided by the Spirit will see it.


.we will come unto him..." by sheer brute force and no reasoning at all can easily make Son=God.
The Holy Spirit reveals it to us,

The source is God and Jesus is NOT,
Jesus IS God and is therefore part of the triune source.

that is what you are not considering, you have left that out. Whether conveniently or not. You only know. God alone has the spirit and power, He is the source, not Jesus.
The Father and the Son together with the Spirit are the source. The Name Jesus was given when God became man,

Jesus is using God's power and spirit as we are too, to a smaller degree.
Jesus was and is God. But He subsumed His power while man and worked through the Spirit AS MAN. Otherwise He could not be tempted as we are,

By your reasoning then, we as believers by association possessing the spirit of Truth in the flesh today are also a god. Son=God=Believer. Which of course you would also admit is ridiculous and I do as well.
That is a non sequitur (it does not follow). He was God using the Spirit in all fullness. We are used BY the Spirit.

valiant, let us agree to disagree and move on. We all are learning and increasing our knowledge of scripture.
You may certainly move on. You are blind to the truth, You have much to learn. I pray that God will lead you to the truth about Himself. so that you may know Jesus in all His fullness. Then you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free.,

Knocked out lol
 
J

joefizz

Guest
I am not surprised at your your responses at all, you say things that are not written in scriptures, why is that ? Because Roman Catholic traditions of the Roman Catholic church is greater than scriptures, to the Roman Catholic church, because you live by your traditions, the word God is of no affect. Why don't you try reading the scriptures as written and stop adding your own intertation or the intertation that the Roman Catholis give, think outside the box and be set free.
fascinating that you say this considering that "God head" is in the bible,/scriptures,no matter your split ways on Catholic beliefs,I am not Catholic yet I know this from "reading" the bible.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
The Apostles creed was what the Apostles taught, you can add the trinity concept if you want but the trinity concept itself does not exist in the Apostle Creed.
Creeds are private interpretations they are not equal to scripture they offer no authority by which we could believe God,Seeking the approval of creeds is seeking the approval of men. God is one Spirit.
 

shrume

Senior Member
Jun 26, 2017
2,193
463
83
Ps 133:
1) Behold, how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity!

Don't see much of that in these parts.
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
John 14:23 is a great passage and very revealing ! If a man love me, he will keep my words ( my sayings 14:24 ) and my Father will love him and we ( plural ) will come unto him and make our ( plural ) abode with him.
Only One who was equal with the Father and omnipresent could lay claim to act like the omnipresent Father. Thus He MUST be equal with the Father.



John 14:24 the word which you hear are not mine but the Father's which sent me. ( He did not send himself ) very simple to understand. God bless !
Yes the Father was like the chairman of the Triune God. As such He sent the Son into the world with the agreement of the Holy Spirit. But the Son CHOSE to be sent. It was voluntary in the Godhead,
 
J

joefizz

Guest
John 14:23 is a great passage and very revealing ! If a man love me, he will keep my words ( my sayings 14:24 ) and my Father will love him and we ( plural ) will come unto him and make our ( plural ) abode with him. John 14:24 the word which you hear are not mine but the Father's which sent me. ( He did not send himself ) very simple to understand. God bless !
simple when you read God's word as a "book" and trust your own "knowledge" and "understanding" not God's,
God bless you as well.
 
D

Dagallen

Guest
fascinating that you say this considering that "God head" is in the bible,/scriptures,no matter your split ways on Catholic beliefs,I am not Catholic yet I know this from "reading" the bible.
But you are affected by Roman Catholic beliefs, as people are affected, then most of churches in the world, is in fact affect by the Roman Catholic beliefs system, whether Roman Catholic or not, as Roman Catholic belief system is by far the largest in the world, as one fifth of the world is not affected by the Roman Catholic belief system, as it is the one world belief system.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
John 14:23 is a great passage and very revealing ! If a man love me, he will keep my words ( my sayings 14:24 ) and my Father will love him and we ( plural ) will come unto him and make our ( plural ) abode with him. John 14:24 the word which you hear are not mine but the Father's which sent me. ( He did not send himself ) very simple to understand. God bless !

God is not a man as us. He uses human terms to express the work of His faith in respect to one Spirit .Two atributes working in perfect harmonoy and submision to one another. In that way he does sent His own Spirit not seen . Christ the anointing Holy Spirit of God is one Spirit, as a Father and a Son.
 
J

joefizz

Guest
Ps 133:
1) Behold, how good and how pleasant it is for brethren to dwell together in unity!

Don't see much of that in these parts.
no there is much "unity" here but there are "discussions" that turn into "arguments",but this isn't surprising many here have different "beliefs",some get along with each other some don't.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
no there is much "unity" here but there are "discussions" that turn into "arguments",but this isn't surprising many here have different "beliefs",some get along with each other some don't.
Pro 27:17 Iron sharpeneth iron; so a man sharpeneth the countenance of his friend.
Pro 27:18 Whoso keepeth the fig tree shall eat the fruit thereof: so he that waiteth on his master shall be honoured.
Pro 27:19 As in water face answereth to face, so the heart of man to man.

1Co 3:6 I have planted, Apollos watered; but God gave the increase.
1Co 3:7 So then neither is he that planteth any thing, neither he that watereth; but God that giveth the increase.
 
Jul 25, 2017
67
1
0
valiant: are you making things up again...?

As you stated: "Yes the Father was like the chairman of the Triune God. As such He sent the Son into the world with the agreement of the Holy Spirit. But the Son CHOSE to be sent. It was voluntary in the Godhead,"

What nonsense talk is this? Please use scripture for all this else how can you have any credibility.

"...an agreement with the Holy spirit, what? So you mean to tell me that that God spoke to himself to sent his son into the world. What say is this gibberish about the Holy Spirit, again. I cannot believe you said this. The holy spirit per scripture is God's own power and communication to this world and creation. His spirit performs many tasks, per scripture, including providing his spirit of truth to us. Jesus was given all of the attributes of his spirit.

"..was a kind of chairman of a Triune God." Wow! Where is this in scripture. You must now be making this up, and why?

You have preconceived ideas and answers that rely on forcing scripture to comply with your far-fetched and yes pagan Trinity ideas.

Until you can at least use scripture for scripture's purpose and not for your own devices you are spinning your wheels in useless chat.



 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
valiant: are you making things up again...?

As you stated: "Yes the Father was like the chairman of the Triune God. As such He sent the Son into the world with the agreement of the Holy Spirit. But the Son CHOSE to be sent. It was voluntary in the Godhead,"

What nonsense talk is this? Please use scripture for all this else how can you have any credibility.

"...an agreement with the Holy spirit, what? So you mean to tell me that that God spoke to himself to sent his son into the world. What say is this gibberish about the Holy Spirit, again. I cannot believe you said this. The holy spirit per scripture is God's own power and communication to this world and creation. His spirit performs many tasks, per scripture, including providing his spirit of truth to us. Jesus was given all of the attributes of his spirit.

"..was a kind of chairman of a Triune God." Wow! Where is this in scripture. You must now be making this up, and why?

You have preconceived ideas and answers that rely on forcing scripture to comply with your far-fetched and yes pagan Trinity ideas.

Until you can at least use scripture for scripture's purpose and not for your own devices you are spinning your wheels in useless chat.



I and the father are one. Not that will be or were one.Two attributes explaining the one work of one faith. The father having the greater position not a greater person .The Son in perfect submission and perfect harmony worked with the father together creating the perfect peace of God that surpasses all human understanding.This is as if God was a man as us.

One God, one Spirit who remains without mother or father beginning of Spirit life or end thereof, one faith by which he works his one work of salvation. The demonstration was for his one purpose. They are attributes of God who again is not a man as us, and not two Gods, two Spirits, two separate works of one faith
 

valiant

Senior Member
Mar 22, 2015
8,025
124
63
valiant: are you making things up again...?
No I am interpreting Scripture. It is you who has made up so much. You do not understand the doctrine of the Triune God and you are totally unaware of early church history. There was no worldwide Roman Catholic church in 4th cty.

As you stated: "Yes the Father was like the chairman of the Triune God. As such He sent the Son into the world with the agreement of the Holy Spirit. But the Son CHOSE to be sent. It was voluntary in the Godhead,"

What nonsense talk is this? Please use scripture for all this else how can you have any credibility.


The Father sent the Son. Yet the Son was co equal with the Father. ('I and My Father are one.' 'He who has seen Me has seen the Father. How then do you say show us the Father?' 'Our God and Saviour Jesus Christ'. 'The Son has life in Himself.' ) It is therefore clear that the Father was acting as the equivalent of a chairman in sending one of the members of the Godhead.

"...an agreement with the Holy spirit, what? So you mean to tell me that that God spoke to himself to sent his son into the world.
Yes God spoke to Himself, Father to Son (both terms which are not literal but are to make clear to us that both are the one God and of one nature). In fact we are totally incapable of understanding the Godhead. God has to use human terms to show us something of Himself.

What say is this gibberish about the Holy Spirit, again. I cannot believe you said this.
The Father and the Son sent the Holy Spirit into the world. In John 14-16 He is spoken of as He and clearly differentiated from Father and Son.

The holy spirit per scripture is God's own power and communication to this world and creation.
No that is the Spirit of God. The Holy Spirit is shown to be 'separate' from Father and Son in the NT, while always working in unison,

His spirit performs many tasks, per scripture, including providing his spirit of truth to us. Jesus was given all of the attributes of his spirit.
'He the Spirit of Truth 'shows that He is a separate part of the Godhead. Jesus possessed His own Spirit, although while on earth acting through the Holy Spirit.

.
"..was a kind of chairman of a Triune God." Wow! Where is this in scripture. You must now be making this up, and why?
It is called an illustration. We must use earthly terms to explain God, but He is really beyond explanation.

You have preconceived ideas and answers that rely on forcing scripture to comply with your far-fetched and yes pagan Trinity ideas
.

LOL it is you who has preconceived ideas not based upon facts or scripture. You are blind to the truth because you have not the Spirit within you. You go to the books of your sect which are unreliable.

Until you can at least use scripture for scripture's purpose and not for your own devices you are spinning your wheels in useless chat.
An apt description of YOU :)


 
J

jaybird88

Guest
Perhaps jaybird the following will explain it better than I. https://www.gci.org/God/Deut64 You also might find the following site insightful and the meaning of the Shema as to why Elohim is in the plural. https://jewsforjesus.org/publications/issues/issues-v01-n08/jewishness-and-the-trinity/ It seems no matter what I may say you always have questions so like I said, please read the sites I provided and if you still have questions I will be happy to address them. :eek:

IN GOD THE SON,
bluto
its a simple question, what does the Shema have to do with other gods? there are no other gods mentioned in the Shema, it says nothing of worshiping one G-D as opposed to worshipping many gods, so how do you come up with this concept?
 
J

jaybird88

Guest
The Triune God was not known in the OT. Father, Son and Holy Spirit were spoken of as one, as indeed they are in the NT. The plural Elohim took a singular verb for that reason.
so the teaching with Jesus and the scribe referring to "them" (plural) as "He" (singular) is because neither the scribe or Jesus knew this yet?

The one Creator, Who was Father, Son and Holy Spirit as opposed to His creation.. The Son was the firstBORN before the whole of creation, and was the creator of all things (Jon 1.4)
Father, Son and Holy Spirit would be "they" and not "He".
 

trofimus

Senior Member
Aug 17, 2015
10,684
794
113
so the teaching with Jesus and the scribe referring to "them" (plural) as "He" (singular) is because neither the scribe or Jesus knew this yet?



Father, Son and Holy Spirit would be "they" and not "He".
God is one being, so "He" is fully acceptable.