I respectfully disagree...
Rev 14:12 Here is the patience of the saints: here are they that keep the commandments of God, and the faith of Jesus.
The saints keep the Commandments and the fourth one is not excluded.
Does your Armstrongite still teach the following?
1. The Trinity was a pagan doctrine, formulated by men, and did not describe the
true nature of God. In Armstrong's theology, God the Father and Jesus Christ
were two separate beings, composed of a "substance" called spirit. The Holy
Spirit was the impersonal force that was used to accomplish God's will. God the
Father and Jesus Christ were in the image of a man.. possessing the anatomy of a
human being only composed of a "substance" called spirit. The nature of God was
viewed as a family, that human beings could be born into at the
resurrection...literally being added to the Godhead just like a new child adds
to a human family.
2. The gospel message, in Armstrong's theology, was
primarily about the soon-coming rule of Jesus Christ at his second coming. The
central focus was not on what Jesus Christ accomplished on the cross. Announcing
this message of the rule of Jesus Christ before the end of man's rule was the
goal of Armstrong's ministry. He believed this message needed to be proclaimed
before Christ would return. He viewed himself as the "Elijah to come" in the Old
Testament...in a role very similar to John the Baptist, who came as a forerunner
of Jesus Christ at his first coming.
3. Worldwide Church of God was
viewed as the one and only true church of God. Other Christian churches were in
error. All other Christians, while sincere, were not really true Christians and
were not saved. Other Christians were not saved primarily because they don't
keep the Saturday Sabbath, and thus were still in their sin. They could not be
repentant, because they were still breaking the Ten Commandments by not
observing the Saturday Sabbath. In effect, churches such as the Seventh Day
Adventists were also excluded because they didn't believe other elements of
Armstrong's teachings such as keeping the annual festivals of Leviticus 23. The
church's teachings as a whole were called "The Truth" and members quite often
spoke of how they came to a knowledge of "The Truth".. meaning Herbert
Armstrong's teachings.
4. Herbert Armstrong, the leader, was viewed as
being the sole representative of God on Earth. He was called God's apostle. He
was the ultimate authority on what the Bible said, and published many books
which were meant to interpret the Scripture for Christians. He claimed to have
restored true Christianity to the world, which had not been taught since the
early apostolic days. While Armstrong taught to believe only your Bible, in
reality he meant the Bible as interpreted by Herbert Armstrong and Worldwide
Church of God. His hermeneutics included connecting unrelated verses in order to
form doctrines, as he viewed the Bible as a "coded book" that required such a
method to come up with the "right doctrine". Incidentally, his wife claimed to
have a vision from an angel which inaugurated Herbert and herself into the
ministry..it's funny how many aberrant beliefs have some element of angelic
appearances whether in vision or in person, inaugurating them to teach the "true
gospel" which hasn't been taught since the apostles..including the Mormons and
JWs (Gal 1:8).
5. Christians were required to observe elements of the Old
Covenant, including the Seventh Day Sabbath (Saturday), observance of the Holy
Days of Leviticus 23, a tithing system that allocated about 23% of their gross
income before tax to the church or festival observance, and observance of the
clean/unclean meat laws. It was a very works oriented view of salvation composed
of a patchwork quilt of Old Covenant and New Covenant concepts.
6.
Catholic and Protestant churches were formed through an amalgam of Christianity
and pagan customs as the result of an apostasy which occurred after the closing
of the New Testament canon. Customs such as Sunday observance, Christmas, and
Easter begun to be observed by the new apostate church. There was a very strong
anti-Catholic element, particularly because the Catholic church claimed to
change the day of worship from Saturday to Sunday. Catholicism was viewed as the
whore of Babylon in Revelation, with Protestant churches being viewed as the
daughters of the whore. There was no understanding of the Protestant Reformation
and the concept of imputed righteousness that was the focus of the Reformer's
message.
7. Christians were literally to become members of the God family
upon the resurrection. Their human life and their overcoming of sins is for the
purpose of qualifying them for salvation, and becoming a god being, to rule over
their own planet (this was inferred if not explicitly taught), very similar to
Mormon theology. The Christian was viewed as being given only conditional
eternal life, and their salvation process was described as being analogous to
the impregnation of the human egg cell by the sperm...and this spiritual
pregnancy could be terminated by God at any point prior to the spiritual birth,
which occurs at the resurrection. They denied that this spiritual birth occurs
at conversion.
8. A very complex eschatology (teaching about end time
events) which taught that the 12 tribes of Israel are the ancestors of those who
comprise the Western European peoples, and that events in prophecy can only be
understood in this context.
9. A virtual universal salvation...the view
was that most of mankind is not being called to salvation now...the Church is
being called to salvation and being judged by God. The rest are spiritually
blinded and won't be given an opportunity for salvation until a future
resurrection after the Millennium, when they will be given an opportunity for
salvation without Satan's influence.
10. A system of 3 resurrections. The
first resurrection is the resurrection of the righteous at Christ's return. The
second resurrection is the resurrection of the unsaved unevangelized, which is
the group in point 6. The third resurrection is the resurrection to eternal
punishment, to be thrown into the lake of fire.
11. Soul sleep; that
those who die are in a state of sleep until they are resurrected. There is no
consciousness between death and the resurrection for anyone.
12. Eternal
punishment involved annihilationism,and not eternal suffering in hell...being
thrown in the lake of fire.
13. Taught a healing doctrine that basically
discouraged seeking medical treatment and condemned it as a lack of faith.
Healing was viewed as part and parcel of Christ's sacrifice. The sad thing about
this is that when it was taught, my understanding is that church leadership
sought medical care but many of the membership did not, because they believed it
was God's will. A friend of my family was attending Ambassador College, the
church's university, at the time and was disillusioned by the hypocrisy of the
church's leadership seeking medical treatment while the membership was
encouraged not to.
14. Viewed the rich as being spiritually superior to
the poor...most of the deacons and elders were individuals who were fairly
successful in their vocational careers. Undoubtedly this condescending view of
the poor was related to Armstrong's mentality regarding material
wealth.
15. Denied the bodily resurrection, instead teaching a spiritual
resurrection much like the Jehovah's Witnesses teach. Jesus Christ does not have
a physical resurrection body, in their theology.
16. Practiced strict
rules regarding church discipline. For example, if a member questioned a point
of doctrine, or a church leader's decision, he could face being
disfellowshipped. Since the church taught that it was the sole representative of
God on earth, and salvation was tied to church attendance, being
disfellowshipped was the same as losing one's salvation. This made it easy for
them to control the membership and to enforce total uniformity within the
church.
17. Taught that the role of the membership was to "pray and pay".
Evangelizing to unbelievers was the primary job of Herbert Armstrong, and was
done through his television program, church literature, and visits to world
leaders, at great expense to the church's membership. The normal church member
didn't evangelize to others, and was not viewed as qualified to do
such.
18. Church services were by ministerial invitation only....and
usually those who were invited to church services were indoctrinated by church
literature prior to attending the church services. Those individuals were called
PMs (potential members). The local pastor met with these individuals privately
before allowing them to come to services. They were questioned to assess their
knowledge of church teachings, and then allowed to attend if the minister
thought God was working with them. By then, it was likely that these individuals
were keeping the Saturday Sabbath already, at home, or they would not have been
allowed to attend.
19. Baptism was not viewed as a first act of
obedience, and identifying one's self publicly with Christ; it was viewed as a
required ceremony which imparted the Holy Spirit to the believer. Salvation did
not begin until the point of baptism. Baptisms were conducted quite often as a
private event with few other individuals observing. For instance, I was baptized
in someone's basement as part of a group with only a few family members present.
I can remember wondering what would happen between the time I was approved for
baptism and the actual event; if I died in an accident or something would I
still be saved?
20. De-emphasized the grace of God. If you had asked a
church member for a definition of grace, I doubt you could have obtained one
from them. Grace was discussed basically only in the context of grace versus
works or keeping the commandments...as if these two concepts are opposites. The
caricature of traditional Christianity was that they don't believe obedience is
part of the Christian life, and that other Christians are using the concept of
grace to cover up sin and disobedience. There was no understanding of the
concept of imputed righteousness, and no understanding that obedience is a fruit
of true faith, rather than being the cause of it. At the very least, it was
"grace plus" and never faith alone, grace alone, in Jesus Christ alone, unto
good works for the glory of God.