What do you believe and why do you believe it?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Spectrox

Active member
Jul 25, 2019
363
38
28
spectrox must really be lonely to continually come here, inspite of it being entirely contrary to his ideology, and after years of being shown that he is in error on so many levels.
No one has shown me that I'm in error about my basic worldview. But it looks like you've made an error in that you won't be able to respond to this. So I don't know why I'm writing it. Lol.
 

Spectrox

Active member
Jul 25, 2019
363
38
28
No sir, your experiences are not even close to what I said.
I didn't go looking until AFTER I was told.
For example, I desired to know how we are made, because some things written sounded and appeared to be more than one thing.
From there, I just followed what I was told by the voice I was hearing.
Mind you, I said hearing. NOT an impression or feeling, but hearing.
Not with my physical ears though.
My guess is, you are not reading this out loud but silently to yourself, and yet you can hear the very words you are reading right now without saying a word verbally.
I am now therefore speaking to you using your own inner voice.
Listen to yourself for a moment as you read.
Can you hear what you are saying?
Yes, you can.
If you were to purposefully speak your name within your self, couldn't you tell me exactly what you heard yourself say?
You might call it just a thought because it was so fast and yet you can quote the very words you heard.
Sometimes it is fast and sometimes it is the speed of normal speech.
Can you explain to me how you are hearing these so-called thoughts?
That is only one voice you can hear.
Now what about when you hear something you know nothing about?
You know your name and you can say it within yourself consciously and purposely, but what is it when you hear something you know nothing about, unexpectedly?
What if you were not the initiator of that so-called thought, but simply a recipient, listening to a teacher giving you instructions?
If you learn to LISTEN, there are other voices we can hear aside from our own.
I almost fell into a hypnotic spell reading that one!
From what you've described I did have a similar experience leading up to my conversion process and after. But after a while I realised I could not differentiate those inner voices/feelings from myself. After several months, whenever I prayed I realised I was speaking to myself. There was no good evidence that there was an "other". And I became aware of problems with the Bible as an alleged authority.
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
I'm not talking about science or methodological naturalism in that last point. I am asking you to present a formal logic argument. It's easier to look at than endless argument back and forth. Christians have attempted it with the Kalam Cosmological Argument so I am asking you to lay out a brief argument with premises and a conclusion then we won't make avoidable mistakes.

I can present a sound argument for the irrationality of atheism, will that work?
 

Spectrox

Active member
Jul 25, 2019
363
38
28
I can present a sound argument for the irrationality of atheism, will that work?
Go on then. But you would be trying to show that a lack of belief in something (God) is wrong. Will you be defining what the something (God) is and demonstrating that the something (God) warrants belief? This kind of goes back to my point that Christianity seems unable to demonstrate its own claims but instead tries to find something wrong with the unbeliever - a double negative - which is simply shifting the burden of proof. But don't let me hinder you. If you think you've got something then let us hear it.
 

Spectrox

Active member
Jul 25, 2019
363
38
28
What makes you think disbelief is finite, or that the measure of justice is time-dependent?
You tell me? How does heaven and hell work? More importantly how do you know? Have you recently flatlined? Maybe afterlife works in exactly the same way as beforelife?
 

Spectrox

Active member
Jul 25, 2019
363
38
28
Why are you spinning?
Christ is not the creator of the universe and He does not know the day and hour of His return...so how could He even predict His 2nd advent?

Matt....24:36 KJV....But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only.

This is a pure spin to accommodate ......................your slant.....and is not cricket.

If you can't address facts in a debate, I for one, will leave it with your chosen program.

Be blessed.
I thought Jesus was ALL man and ALL God? Are you saying Jesus is half man and half God?
 

Oncefallen

Idiot in Chief
Staff member
Jan 15, 2011
6,031
3,269
113
I thought Jesus was ALL man and ALL God? Are you saying Jesus is half man and half God?

Interesting how what you have quoted (as my post) is actually information that was quoted BY my post. The content that I posted is actually nonexistent in the quote. I certainly hope that this was a foul up in the quoted post reply system (it happens) and not an intentional ploy to make it appear as if I was pushing some form of heresy.

This is how that conversation actually took place


Why are you spinning?
Christ is not the creator of the universe and He does not know the day and hour of His return...so how could He even predict His 2nd advent?

Matt....24:36 KJV....But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels of heaven, but my Father only.

This is a pure spin to accommodate ......................your slant.....and is not cricket.

If you can't address facts in a debate, I for one, will leave it with your chosen program.

Be blessed.

Pure heresy against John 1

1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2 He was with God in the beginning. 3 Through him all things were made; without him nothing was made that has been made. 4 In him was life, and that life was the light of all mankind. 5 The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome[a] it.
 
Jun 10, 2019
4,304
1,659
113
I don't know that God does not exist. I am not making (and have never made) that strong positive claim. So far, I do not accept the Christian God claim because I am convinced there are flaws in the Bible and flaws in Christian thinking. The burden of proof is on the Christian to demonstrate that their God claim is true or likely true.
I don’t think any bible is perfect in every way, and yea there’s some wild thinking in this world.

if that burden of proof is on the Christian in what way does the proof need to be directed too?
 
Jun 10, 2019
4,304
1,659
113
Is it proof through science?
 

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
36,682
13,139
113
You tell me? How does heaven and hell work? More importantly how do you know? Have you recently flatlined? Maybe afterlife works in exactly the same way as beforelife?

I'm sorry, since you were talking about these measures as though you are qualified to judge and correct almighty sovereign God over them, I assumed you had some kind of knowledge about them.

But reality is that you are cursing God over things you don't actually understand or have a basis to judge?

I should have expected that tbh. The humanist atheistic evolutionary monism position requires that what you call 'reason' is only a predator/prey/reproduction feedback-loop-induced randomness of electrical pulse patterns in a temporary arrangement of basically mud under the psychosis that it is self aware and cognizant. It is shaped by survival pressure, which includes of course believing it is important and that it knows what its talking about, and being also shaped by pressure to find and attract suitable mates, it is inexorably vain. However it being nothing more than a random set of EM waves under the influence of random physical events, what it considers 'logical' has no epistemological basis to be considered as actually true.

With that in mind, of course you're talking nonsense, only making noise, and of course you don't think that's the case. Why would you? Natural selection demands that you consider your own thoughts authoritative, no matter how ridiculous they are from an objective standpoint - that's the snake eating itself. Humanism destroys its own logic by the basis on which it exalts itself, but can't admit that to itself, because admitting it's own fundamental derangement would be counterproductive to what it considers its own origin and motive force of 'existence' - what it calls existence, tho it is really only non existence waiting to be revealed as such, a temporary delusion of dust and EM waves consumed by self replicating self devourment.

Your paradigm, not mine.
I don't believe that rot at all, but the fundamentals of your belief system all humans are this way. We are nothing but a brief, meaningless static. That's your view of reality, if you were honest and thought it through.
 
Jun 10, 2019
4,304
1,659
113
I don’t think any bible is perfect in every way, and yea there’s some wild thinking in this world.

if that burden of proof is on the Christian in what way does the proof need to be directed too?
Yet perfectly imperfect like a four leaf clover in field of three...
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
Go on then. But you would be trying to show that a lack of belief in something (God) is wrong. Will you be defining what the something (God) is and demonstrating that the something (God) warrants belief? This kind of goes back to my point that Christianity seems unable to demonstrate its own claims but instead tries to find something wrong with the unbeliever - a double negative - which is simply shifting the burden of proof. But don't let me hinder you. If you think you've got something then let us hear it.
Fyi.......I have no interest in finding something wrong with you, it is not personal for me we are entering the world of ideas and rationalism.

Let us put aside the moral reasonong of wrong or right and see if there is a purely rational basis for the existence of a transcendent moral being?
 

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
36,682
13,139
113
Let us put aside the moral reasonong of wrong or right and see if there is a purely rational basis for the existence of a transcendent moral being?
The quantum physics principle of the observer effect.

The actuality of the universe physically requires an intelligent universal observer
 
Mar 23, 2016
6,857
1,646
113
I don't know that God does not exist. I am not making (and have never made) that strong positive claim. So far, I do not accept the Christian God claim because I am convinced there are flaws in the Bible and flaws in Christian thinking. The burden of proof is on the Christian to demonstrate that their God claim is true or likely true.
Right … there certainly isn't any flaw in your understanding. :rolleyes:


You need a check-up from the neck up because you have been shown that there were flaws in your understanding of certain records. Yet you will not admit the veracity of Scripture concerning those two records. What is up with that?

Why is it so hard for you to consider that the error is on your part (due to misunderstanding the record)? What other error[ s ] do you carry in your heart which keep you from full comprehension of the Creator?

Why is it so hard for you to state "Scripture is accurate" in those instances where you were shown that it was, in fact, your understanding of the record which was in error? That is an area where you need to search your heart.

In searching your heart, try to get to the root of why you find it so difficult to admit error in your understanding of Scripture. Perhaps you will find a need on your part to tweak your understanding concerning Scripture. Start afresh with a heart accepting of the Creator. Those records where you find yourself drawing away from Him … put those aside for the time being. Allow the Author to reveal to you what you need to know at any given time and then move on from there.
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
24,730
13,400
113
Exactly. No justice at all. Justice is proportionate. I have good reasons for not having faith in the Christian God. If God was real and was all-knowing, he would clearly understand how important good evidence is to accept the fanciful claims in the Bible. And you talk as if there are no consequences for adopting this worldview, as if it's a gift you just accept. The real cost, is you would have to engage in cognitive dissonance to not accept Islam or Mormonism as well and you would have to deny your humanity and empathy to accept that genocide and slavery are ok. Your God allegedly set up the whole system so he has to take full responsibility for it.
It appears that you completely missed the point of my post. You argue that justice is proportional, but you overlook the reality of a boundless sin.

You have reasons for not believing that you find satisfactory. I assure you that they are not "good" for they will not excuse you from the justice that God holds for you. God understands evidence far better than you do; that's why He makes it clear that unbelievers are without excuse.

Cognitive dissonance is for those who refuse to think through the implications of their inadequate belief systems. I have found Christianity to be consistent and more than satisfactory intellectually, ethically, logically, historically, and morally. Islam and Mormonism are pathetic jokes in comparison.

You're stuck on genocide and slavery. Genocide, as you call it, was justice for a depth of sinfulness that only exists in novels (and abortion clinics) today. Slavery was limited by God, not endorsed wholesale.

You are still standing in judgment of God. That's not a place of wisdom.
 

no1

Member
Aug 19, 2019
43
13
8
I almost fell into a hypnotic spell reading that one!
From what you've described I did have a similar experience leading up to my conversion process and after. But after a while I realised I could not differentiate those inner voices/feelings from myself. After several months, whenever I prayed I realised I was speaking to myself. There was no good evidence that there was an "other". And I became aware of problems with the Bible as an alleged authority.
Really?
The voice I heard would teach me things I didn't know was in the bible, until I checked it out. Feelings don't do that.
There are words in the bible, interpreted as though there was a Greek or Hebrew word there, when there was not.
For example;
The bible talks about the old man, new man, spirit man, and hidden man.
These are real being in you that speak, among other things.

1Pe 3:4 But let it be the hidden man of the heart, in that which is not corruptible, even the ornament of a meek and quiet spirit, which is in the sight of God of great price.

It sounds like that hidden man of the hearts is that meek and quiet spirit, which is what I thought originally.
Until I was told there is no word "of" in the original language.
There is more than one word in the Greek for the word "of".
So that changed the meaning, entirely.
And the voice went on to tell me why he told me that and the real meaning of it.
Feelings don't yell or scream at you either.
And neither do feelings tell you what others are thinking or feeling in their heart.
Yes, many times it sounds like you are doing the talking, but that is where Jesus said, "My sheep KNOW my voice... "
It comes with time and experience I suppose.
But aside from that, my guess is, you NEVER saw God do a miracle, have you.
Like a real one that can't be explained away.
Have you ever been told, God says what He means, and means what He says?
Take Mark 11:24 for example.

Mar 11:24 Therefore I say unto you, What things soever ye desire, when ye pray, believe that ye receive them, and ye shall have them.

One reason why most people don't see God do any miracles is because they don't really believe what God said.
The above verse says, what ever YOU desire, shall be given to you, right?
Yes, but that is not the whole truth of this promise.
No, it doesn't have anything to do with what God's will is, like most are told.
God's will, according to this is to give you whatsoever YOU desire, IF, you follow through with the other conditions listed.
If you don't, I can guarantee you, absolutely NOTHING will happen, like it does for most ignorant Christians.
Most start out believing, because their faith hasn't been tested yet. And then they fall away or stop believing simply because nothing happened, like I said.
Many people die from wasting diseases, TRYING to believe. Saying they are believing, yet nothing happens.
There's a problem with that situation. Either what is written in the bible is a lie, which would mean, God lied, if you believe He wrote it through speaking to men of old, or the problem is with us.
And since most people can't handle the truth, along with, most don't know the truth, like most preacher, pastors, and teachers, they tell them, "it wasn't God's will for you or your loved one to be healed", and so they prepare the person to go "home" to be with the lord.
What a load of crap.
I could tell you a few reasons why both you and others failed to receive, and a lack of faith is not the only reason.
Most Christian are told their sins are automatically forgiven and therefore redeemed from the curses of both the law of sin and the law of death.
NOT!!!
So much ignorance in the church concerning the promises of God and how faith works.
Sickness CANNOT come on the righteous, only those who sin, because sin cause God to put a curse on the person, even Christians or believers, and therefore that gives the devil legal right to afflict the person with a sickness or disease.
You can't get rid of the sickness or disease, many times, until you get rid of the sin that causes the curse to come on you in the first place. If you did get rid of it without taking care of the sin, the condition WILL come back, guaranteed, only it will be worse than before, when it does.
You are no different than anyone else that TRIED to believe, "that faith stuff", and failed.
I have had a number of growths and condition leave or disappear, on myself and others, after praying or commanding the thing to leave, in Jesus' name. And that is because this faith stuff works. If it didn't, then nothing would happen.
At this point in my life, I both know and have experience, too much to be swayed from believing otherwise.
Had you got with someone who taught you the true truth from the start, you might not have been so easily turned from the truth of God's word.
If it works for both my family and I, as well as many others, it will do the same for you.
But just like it doesn't work for you, or at least, in your favor, neither does it work for all the so-called believers, or unbelieving/doubting Christian.
Hoping, wishing, and/or wondering won't cut it. It never has, and it never will.
But when you meet all the conditions of whatever promise you are standing on, God NEVER, EVER, EVER fails to do what He said He will do.
 

stonesoffire

Poetic Member
Nov 24, 2013
10,665
1,829
113
Co 5:14 The love of the Messiah controls us, for we are convinced of this: that one person died for all people; therefore, all people have died.

2Co 5:15 He died for all people, so that those who live should no longer live for themselves but for the one who died and rose for them.

2Co 5:16 So then, from now on we do not think of anyone from a human point of view. Even if we did think of the Messiah from a human point of view, we don't think of him that way anymore.

2Co 5:17 Therefore, if anyone is in the Messiah, he is a new creation. Old things have disappeared, and—look!—all things have become new!

2Co 5:18 All of this comes from God, who has reconciled us to himself through the Messiah and has given us the ministry of reconciliation,

2Co 5:19 for through the Messiah, God was reconciling the world to himself by not counting their sins against them. He has committed his message of reconciliation to us.

2Co 5:20 Therefore, we are the Messiah's representatives, as though God were pleading through us. We plead on the Messiah's behalf: "Be reconciled to God!"

2Co 5:21 God made the one who did not know sin to be sin for us, so that God's righteousness would be produced in us.

God holds nothing against anyone because of the obedience of His Son. But one thing and only one thing would keep a person from partaking of His goodness and that is unbelief. Failure to believe this word and receive His intercession on your behalf.

So what charge can anyone direct at the Lord in light of this truth?