I attended public schools but attended weekly Saturday morning catechism classes which the nuns taught. I am familiar with the paddle too and had after school detention a few times too in junior high.Yeah, Physical was truly a thing when we were growing up. I did'nt attend Catholic school but my teacher's were very strict. I got the ruler to my hand in second grade by miss Taylor.
In middle school we got the paddle. That was no joke! I think the school system outlawed this when I was in grade eight. As far as mass, It's hard for me to explain. I truly feel God's presents when I'm in church. I have since I was a young child.And as far as conflicts with doctrine. That is what the men's meetings are for..Lol....
I wasn't a bad kid but rather just a typical kid from the period I grew up in, 60's - early 70's. During the detention they pass out a list of that afternoon's detainees. One time there was a quote on top of the page, I forget who was quoted but it is as follows- "The problem with the kids today is that they don't get patted on the back enough, low enough, and hard enough". There was an element of truth to that.