This makes me think of an interesting conversation I had with a couple of single ladies from this site.
We were talking about the phenomenon of how, as we've seen in our churches, some of the single Christian women who have been faithful to their beliefs all their lives, would make terrific wives and mothers, are still virgins -- but aren't exactly up to what the world sees as a "10" in the looks department -- and so they get passed by. Maybe they're a little heavier or plainer -- but the argument is always made that God made men visual, therefore, men must have a a beautiful wife. To which I say, "If men are visual, does that mean He made women blind?"
So into the church walks the beautiful newcomer, the former fallen stripper/prostitute/drug addict who has just found Jesus and is turning her life around, even though she's still halfway lost in the world of drugs, alcohol, and needing attention from a variety of men, not just one.
But she looks like she belongs on the Top 10 List of the Maxim's World's Most Beautiful Women -- and every guy in the congregation is smitten.
Now, of course, I've seen this happen on the opposite of the fence as well -- good Christian women fighting each other at every turn for what's seen as the most handsome and most eligible bachelor in the church.
And I'm certainly not criticizing people from harsh backgrounds -- I've been friends with many such people, and used to go write and visit people who have been through more than I'm sure most of us could ever imagine.
But what I'm trying to say here is that, YES, discernment CAN be helpful.
And it seems to be dished out in varying degrees to all kinds of different people, whether men or women. Most people I know, including myself, have very good discernment in certain areas -- and virtually none in other parts of life.
But sometimes the most important thing is deciding exactly WHAT'S doing the discerning for you (your spirit, or your hormones,) and if whatever parts of you are pushing that discernment are also trying to justify your reasoning/convince you that it's actually from God.
Sure, it MIGHT be from God.
But I think we've all seen -- and sometimes experienced -- a WHOLE LOT of cases where it wasn't.
This is a lot more complex and also a lot simpler than it might seem. There is way too much to unpack here. That is why God gave us the Holy Spirit. But I'll list some things and it might give you an idea that there is a
whole lot more (mountains of a whole lore more) to romantic relationships and marriage than "We like each other, so let's do it." The complexity might also begin to make sense of all the marriages that end in divorce
besides the couples who don't divorce but who might as well be divorced (eg. one or both are cheating on the other, polyamory, dead bedroom, separation, etc.).
1.)
Women are more visual than men. People say, "Men are visual." True. I think a better way to say it is "Men are very visual
and focus on that aspect when it comes to women." Men are 'visual' when it regards sexuality; I don't think men are 'visual' regarding anything else. On the other hand, women are very visual about everything and make judgments about people and things faster and more often than men. Eve 'ate the fruit' because she was more visual than Adam. (You can read the story again. Adam had seen the fruit many times, but Eve ate it when the serpent got her to look closer at it and so
"the woman saw that the fruit of the tree was good for food and pleasing to the eye" --Genesis 3:6). When a man is attracted to a woman, he looks at her only with only his eyeballs (and maybe something else). But when a woman is attracted to a man, she looks at him with her entire self-- her whole body and attention (soul) turn to him and she wants to 'become a part of his world'. If that isn't 'hard looking' I don't know what is. This is related to the statement that 'women love hard'. I've seen women check me out. Women check men out harder than men check women out. The confusion here is largely related to the fact that men are more forward and so more obvious with the lusting and men also find
a lot more everyday women attractive whereas women find few everyday men attractive; so it looks like men are more visual than women but that's just not true.
2.)
Men usually relate to women from a place of weakness (and inferiority). Those men in your church who overlook the average girls and lust after the 'models' are operating from a place of weakness. When Adam ate the fruit
because Eve ate it, he was operating from a place of weakness, of need, of
worship. Those men are worshiping or setting themselves beneath the women because deep inside the men feel inferior. It's not easy to explain. People talk about 'the Ahab spirit' (or mindset). There is also 'the Samson spirit' (mindset). Both are similar but distinct. Ahab is more about a man being
morally weak (he's lazy when it comes to caring about anyone besides himself and his close circle) while Samson is about a man being
sexually weak toward women (he's willing to put his well-being and even life on the line just because a woman is attractive). The men in your church who are lusting after the new girl have the Samson thing (and by intuition, I'm sure they also have Ahab).
3.)
Church ain't a good place to look for a godly man (or woman). But it also depends on your definition of a godly man. Many church women 'like' weak men and they call them godly. The men and women in your church (and many churches) are chasing this and that because there's no sanctification going on. Jesus isn't there. If the people in your church aren't being sanctified, you can't reasonably expect the men to be godly the way the Bible defines the term. Church kills testosterone and murders masculinity. If you want a man like that (no backbone, eager to follow, etc.), then keep looking in church. I went to a particular church where I was new. I had four to six different colognes and one of them smelled lovely. (It's called EGM Musk or Egyptian Musk. You can buy and sample the smell.) I was new in church and one of the only single men there, so I was getting a lot of attention from the women. I intuitively knew that this cologne would get me even more attention, so I refused to wear it. I didn't want to cause any stumbling. So, why is it that at a church, christians are just like the world in that they chase whatever looks good (or smells good) just like the world?
Because there is no sanctification in those churches. That isn't a place for anyone to look for a mate unless you want someone who is basically just like the world and many times way worse.
And yes, God gave men more discernment. This isn't a competition; it's what God did. Men are rarely in touch with their discernment, so it doesn't
look like God gave men more discernment but He did. If a man was to get in touch with his discernment, he would find it easier to discern women than men. Why? Men are naturally less emotional and 'emanate' less of their vibes outward. Women are more emotional and so their vibes tend to constantly come off them. In short, women communicate non-verbally a lot more than men do. I've heard of some girls who asked their boyfriends what they were thinking about and were surprised when he said nothing. A man can 'stop communicating', stop thinking, etc. It's not as easy for a woman to 'rest' or 'be at peace'. This makes them more communicative, and anyone with decent discernment will pick it up. Most men just aren't in touch with their God-given discernment,
but the more a man grows in the natural masculinity God designed in him, the more in touch he will come with His discernment. Jesus had to be on earth with none of His God abilities; His ability to discern as a mix of the Holy Spirit giving Him discernment
as well as His masculinity which He never denied or lost. The Bibe often says that He discerned or picked up what people were thinking
in their hearts. Not their minds but hearts (the place where people's original character,
prejudices, and
attitudes lie).
You wrote, "Sometimes the most important thing is deciding exactly WHAT'S doing the discerning for you (your spirit, or your hormones,) and if whatever parts of you are pushing that discernment are also trying to justify your reasoning/convince you that it's actually from God." I'm going to write a post shedding some light on this issue.