New member

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#21
Yes, and this is what was revealed. Unless I hear the Voice of God in my current troubles, words written thousands of years ago won't help me today. Too many people today believe in Bibliolatry and have elevated the Bible to the fourth level of the Trinity. They won't walk down the hall without a Bible under their arm. My support of this: John 5:39-40. My personal belief, and I may be wrong, is that the Bible is a book of words and words by themselves have no meaning. People give meaning to words so the Bible says what people say it says. Therefore, division, different religions, hate for those that don't worship the way we do, etc. Getting on my knees before God showed me it's all about a relationship with the Creator. The Bible, to me, is a library and not a book. It was written for me but not to me. Forgive me if this is offensive.
John 5:39-40 was spoken, by Jesus, to people who rejected Jesus.

There is a plasticity and fluidity to words, but none are without meaning in my view. That people vary in their views
on what the Bible is really saying should not be a problem for those who do their best to live by Godly principles.


I am sorry you are not helped by what is written. Many find much comfort,
direction, guidance, and value in what was recorded thousands of years ago.
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#22
John 5:39-40 was spoken, by Jesus, to people who rejected Jesus.

There is a plasticity and fluidity to words, but none are without meaning in my view. That people vary in their views
on what the Bible is really saying should not be a problem for those who do their best to live by Godly principles.


I am sorry you are not helped by what is written. Many find much comfort,
direction, guidance, and value in what was recorded thousands of years ago.
Magenta:
Please don't feel sorry for me as I have been greatly helped by what comes from the Sacred Writings. I have found much comfort and understanding. But from my point of view two people can read the same thing and get opposite meanings. Here is an unrelated example that may (not will) get my point across.
After one year into the COVID pandemic, the CDC released a statement to the public: "It is now permissible to have gatherings in your home of up to eight people without any issues." My response? I don't know eight people without any issues.
We both read that one statement and I believe we got opposite meanings. I could be wrong.
 

TheDivineWatermark

Well-known member
Aug 3, 2018
10,887
2,113
113
#23
blueskies:
I can't find any statement by Paul about being saved today. My view is Paul was pursuing salvation everyday but he had not yet attained that goal and wouldn't until the last day. Does this challenge the "Permanence of Salvation" movement? Give me your thoughts here, please.
Hi JPT,

Consider:

Ephesians 2:5 states, "...by grace you are [present tense, plural] HAVING BEEN SAVED [perfect participle - V-RPM/P-NMP - the "R"="perfect tense"]" = ) ["perfect tense - Action completed at a specific point of time in PAST, with results CONTINUING into the PRESENT"]

-- https://biblehub.com/text/ephesians/2-5.htm

____________

As for the Philippians passage you have alluded to...
...Consider:


[quoting from an old post]

Regarding Philippians 3:8-14 [keeping its context of "the Christlike MIND" in the section of Scripture bracketed by 2:2,3,5 on one end, and 3:15,16,19 on the other end (re: 'mind/minded')]:

..."all of us who are mature should take such a view of things. And if on some point you think differently, that too God will make clear to you. Only let us live up to what we have already attained. Philippians 3:15-16

[quoting from Sir Robert Anderson's book "Forgotten Truths"]

"Appendix 4 - Philippians 3:8-14 [for CONTEXT]

"PHILIPPIANS 3:8-141 NOTE CHAPTER 7

"IF the commonly received exegesis of Philippians 3:8-14 be correct, we are faced by the astounding fact that the author of the Epistle to the Romans and of the 15th chapter of 1 Corinthians -- the Apostle who was in a peculiar sense entrusted with the supreme revelation of grace -- announced when nearing the close of his ministry that the resurrection was not, as he had been used to teach, a blessing which Divine grace assured to all believers in Christ, but a prize to be won by the sustained efforts of a life of wholly exceptional saintship.

"Nor is this all. In the same Epistle he has already said, "To me to live is Christ, and to have died is gain"; whereas, ex hypothesi, it now appears that his chief aim in life was to earn a right to the resurrection; and that death, instead of bringing gain, would have cut him off before he had reached the standard of saintship needed to secure that prize! For his words are explicit, "not as though I had already attained."

"Here was one who was "not a whit behind the chiefest Apostles"; who excelled them all in labours and sufferings for his Lord, and in the "visions and revelations" accorded to him; whose prolonged ministry, moreover, was accredited by "mighty signs and wonders by the power of the Spirit of God." And yet, "being now such an one as Paul the aged," [it is wrongly suggested] he was in doubt whether he should have part in that resurrection which he had taught all his pagan Corinthian converts to hope for: for to them it was he wrote the words, "we shall all be changed."

"Such is the exposition of the Apostle's teaching in many a standard commentary. And yet the passage which is thus perverted reaches its climax in the words, "Our citizenship is in heaven, from whence we are looking for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall fashion anew the body of our humiliation that it may be conformed to the body of His glory."

" "Our citizenship is in heaven" here is the clew to the teaching of the whole passage. The truth to which his words refer is more clearly stated in Ephesians 2:6 - God has "quickened us together with Christ, and raised us up with Him, and made us sit with Him in the heavenly places in Christ." More clearly still is it given in Colossians 3:1-3: "If then ye were raised together with Christ, seek the things that are above, where Christ is seated on the right hand of God. Set your mind on the things that are above, not on the things that are on earth. For ye died, and your life is hid with Christ in God."

"Ephesians and Colossians, be it remembered, were written at the same period of his ministry as Philippians; and in the light of these Scriptures we can read this chapter aright. To "win Christ" (ver. 8), or to apprehend, or lay hold of, that for which he had been laid hold of, or apprehended (ver. 12); or in other words, to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven -- this is what he was reaching toward, and what, he says, he had not "already attained."

"The "high calling" of ver. 14 is interpreted by some to mean Christ's calling up His own to meet Him in the air (a blessing assured to all "who are alive and remain unto the Coming of the Lord"); but this is not in keeping with the plain words -- God's high calling in Christ Jesus, i.e. what God has called us (made us) to be in Christ.

"If this passage refers to the literal resurrection, then the words "not as though I had already attained must mean that, while here on earth, and before the Lord's Coming, the Apostle hoped either to undergo the change of ver. 21, or else to win some sort of saintship diploma, or certificate, to ensure his being raised at the Coming. These alternatives are inexorable; and they only need to be stated to ensure their rejection.

"One word more. If the Apostle Paul, after such a life of saintship and service, was in doubt as to his part in the resurrection, no one of us, unless he be the proudest of Pharisees or the blindest of fools, will dream of attaining it. In fact we shall dismiss the subject from our minds."

--Sir Robert Anderson, Forgotten Truths, Appendix 4, pgs 145-147

http://articles.ochristian.com/article12455.shtml

[end quoting article; bold, underline, and brackets mine]

____________


So, Philippians 3:8-14 (esp vv.11-14,15) is referring to (as he says), "to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven"... that is, "in the here and now"


[end quoting old post]



____________


Welcome to CC! Hope to see you around the boards. = )






[hope I don't get in trouble for posting all this in the "intro" section... :geek: :eek: ]
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#24
Magenta:
Please don't feel sorry for me as I have been greatly helped by what comes from the Sacred Writings. I have found much comfort and understanding. But from my point of view two people can read the same thing and get opposite meanings. Here is an unrelated example that may (not will) get my point across.
After one year into the COVID pandemic, the CDC released a statement to the public: "It is now permissible to have gatherings in your home of up to eight people without any issues." My response? I don't know eight people without any issues.
We both read that one statement and I believe we got opposite meanings. I could be wrong.
Is it a grammatical error? But also one of context. For instance, even placing the "without issue" after gatherings, one could say there will always be issues! For instance, perhaps one's abode would not comfortably fit eight people no matter what. Clearer word choices along with sentence structure could still help. For instance: It is now permissible to have gatherings of up to eight people in your home without undue fear of COVID spread. Even so, there are always going to be issues, aren't there? People not accepting the information that is coming out, claiming Covid does not exist, refusing to follow guidelines, ad nauseum. Mark of the beast, anyone? But more than that, it really looks like unnecessary hair splitting and deliberate obfuscation to claim the intent of the message, as is, is unclear.
 

blueskies

Active member
Apr 2, 2022
150
122
43
Pacific Northwest
#25
Permanence of Salvation
There are differing beliefs among Christians about the permanence of salvation. There are different denominations that teach differing views, each being confident that they have the truth. However, the way you frame you question makes me suspect that you already know that no absolute consensus exists. I am not willing to open that particular box here, as this is one of those topics that can become quite contentious. :)

May God Bless you on your walk with the Lord and I wish nothing but the best for you my friend.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#26
Please don't feel sorry for me as I have been greatly helped by what comes from the Sacred Writings.
I did not say I feel sorry for you. You said, Unless I hear the Voice of God in my current troubles, words written thousands of years ago won't help me today. I responded by saying, I am sorry you are not helped by what is written. Perhaps I should have said, IF you you are not helped. Since according to your stipulation, you are being helped by Scripture along with hearing from God directly. Your OP says, Searched for over 40 years for answers to why people believe what they believe and the search continues. I wonder why you are still searching. Have you found no reasons as to why others believe as they do? Or, how many reasons will satisfy? You know what it took for you to be moved to accepting the Truth of God's Word. I realize it is different for different people.
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#27
Hi JPT,

Consider:

Ephesians 2:5 states, "...by grace you are [present tense, plural] HAVING BEEN SAVED [perfect participle - V-RPM/P-NMP - the "R"="perfect tense"]" = ) ["perfect tense - Action completed at a specific point of time in PAST, with results CONTINUING into the PRESENT"]

-- https://biblehub.com/text/ephesians/2-5.htm

____________

As for the Philippians passage you have alluded to...
...Consider:


[quoting from an old post]

Regarding Philippians 3:8-14 [keeping its context of "the Christlike MIND" in the section of Scripture bracketed by 2:2,3,5 on one end, and 3:15,16,19 on the other end (re: 'mind/minded')]:

..."all of us who are mature should take such a view of things. And if on some point you think differently, that too God will make clear to you. Only let us live up to what we have already attained. Philippians 3:15-16

[quoting from Sir Robert Anderson's book "Forgotten Truths"]

"Appendix 4 - Philippians 3:8-14 [for CONTEXT]

"PHILIPPIANS 3:8-141 NOTE CHAPTER 7

"IF the commonly received exegesis of Philippians 3:8-14 be correct, we are faced by the astounding fact that the author of the Epistle to the Romans and of the 15th chapter of 1 Corinthians -- the Apostle who was in a peculiar sense entrusted with the supreme revelation of grace -- announced when nearing the close of his ministry that the resurrection was not, as he had been used to teach, a blessing which Divine grace assured to all believers in Christ, but a prize to be won by the sustained efforts of a life of wholly exceptional saintship.

"Nor is this all. In the same Epistle he has already said, "To me to live is Christ, and to have died is gain"; whereas, ex hypothesi, it now appears that his chief aim in life was to earn a right to the resurrection; and that death, instead of bringing gain, would have cut him off before he had reached the standard of saintship needed to secure that prize! For his words are explicit, "not as though I had already attained."

"Here was one who was "not a whit behind the chiefest Apostles"; who excelled them all in labours and sufferings for his Lord, and in the "visions and revelations" accorded to him; whose prolonged ministry, moreover, was accredited by "mighty signs and wonders by the power of the Spirit of God." And yet, "being now such an one as Paul the aged," [it is wrongly suggested] he was in doubt whether he should have part in that resurrection which he had taught all his pagan Corinthian converts to hope for: for to them it was he wrote the words, "we shall all be changed."

"Such is the exposition of the Apostle's teaching in many a standard commentary. And yet the passage which is thus perverted reaches its climax in the words, "Our citizenship is in heaven, from whence we are looking for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall fashion anew the body of our humiliation that it may be conformed to the body of His glory."

" "Our citizenship is in heaven" here is the clew to the teaching of the whole passage. The truth to which his words refer is more clearly stated in Ephesians 2:6 - God has "quickened us together with Christ, and raised us up with Him, and made us sit with Him in the heavenly places in Christ." More clearly still is it given in Colossians 3:1-3: "If then ye were raised together with Christ, seek the things that are above, where Christ is seated on the right hand of God. Set your mind on the things that are above, not on the things that are on earth. For ye died, and your life is hid with Christ in God."

"Ephesians and Colossians, be it remembered, were written at the same period of his ministry as Philippians; and in the light of these Scriptures we can read this chapter aright. To "win Christ" (ver. 8), or to apprehend, or lay hold of, that for which he had been laid hold of, or apprehended (ver. 12); or in other words, to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven -- this is what he was reaching toward, and what, he says, he had not "already attained."

"The "high calling" of ver. 14 is interpreted by some to mean Christ's calling up His own to meet Him in the air (a blessing assured to all "who are alive and remain unto the Coming of the Lord"); but this is not in keeping with the plain words -- God's high calling in Christ Jesus, i.e. what God has called us (made us) to be in Christ.

"If this passage refers to the literal resurrection, then the words "not as though I had already attained must mean that, while here on earth, and before the Lord's Coming, the Apostle hoped either to undergo the change of ver. 21, or else to win some sort of saintship diploma, or certificate, to ensure his being raised at the Coming. These alternatives are inexorable; and they only need to be stated to ensure their rejection.

"One word more. If the Apostle Paul, after such a life of saintship and service, was in doubt as to his part in the resurrection, no one of us, unless he be the proudest of Pharisees or the blindest of fools, will dream of attaining it. In fact we shall dismiss the subject from our minds."

--Sir Robert Anderson, Forgotten Truths, Appendix 4, pgs 145-147

http://articles.ochristian.com/article12455.shtml

[end quoting article; bold, underline, and brackets mine]

____________


So, Philippians 3:8-14 (esp vv.11-14,15) is referring to (as he says), "to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven"... that is, "in the here and now"


[end quoting old post]



____________


Welcome to CC! Hope to see you around the boards. = )






[hope I don't get in trouble for posting all this in the "intro" section... :geek: :eek: ]

Very eloquently said and very appreciatively received. You're well grounded in your quest for Eternity. Kudos!
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
42,595
17,062
113
69
Tennessee
#28
I am a 67 year old male heading for third. Hope that you find the answers to your questions. Glad to have you onboard with us. Welcome to CC.
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#29
I did not say I feel sorry for you. You said, Unless I hear the Voice of God in my current troubles, words written thousands of years ago won't help me today. I responded by saying, I am sorry you are not helped by what is written. Perhaps I should have said, IF you you are not helped. Since according to your stipulation, you are being helped by Scripture along with hearing from God directly. Your OP says, Searched for over 40 years for answers to why people believe what they believe and the search continues. I wonder why you are still searching. Have you found no reasons as to why others believe as they do? Or, how many reasons will satisfy? You know what it took for you to be moved to accepting the Truth of God's Word. I realize it is different for different people.
Magenta:
I appreciate your directness and I'm impressed with the research you've done and your ability to transmit that knowledge. Thank you.
I'm not searching for answers for myself nor my spiritual condition. I'm interested in challenging others with questions to find out why people believe what they believe.
With that said, why I'm still searching is I have had great difficulty in why others believe in the "Permanence of Salvation" or the "Once saved, always saved" philosophy. After 40 plus years of research I can find no where in any Bible translation in any language, be it Christian, Hebrew, Greek, Aramaic, Hindu, Buddhism, or Muslim where any of the great men and women of their sacred writings emphatically stated, "I got saved today!"
I'm open to suggestions and I'm not above changing my beliefs because, KNOWLEDGE IS A MOVING TARGET. What was true 30 minutes ago may not be true at the moment because of new discoveries. Example: CDC has changed the definition of "vaccine" from immunity to immune response. COVID has defied the old definition of immunity.Not saying anyone is wrong. Stating their knowledge may be limited.
I feel these topics are not for drawing battle lines, rather for healthy discussion about beliefs.
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#30
There are differing beliefs among Christians about the permanence of salvation. There are different denominations that teach differing views, each being confident that they have the truth. However, the way you frame you question makes me suspect that you already know that no absolute consensus exists. I am not willing to open that particular box here, as this is one of those topics that can become quite contentious. :)

May God Bless you on your walk with the Lord and I wish nothing but the best for you my friend.
blueskies:

Your response warmly received. I'm searching as to why people believe what they believe. Most that I've come in contact with are simply following the guidance of someone else and simply re-speaking what has already been spoken.
Be advised, I don't think I fit into this forum because I thrive on conflict and confrontation in search of people defending their beliefs to determine how well grounded they are and to what lengths they will go to to defend those beliefs.
Again, thank you.
 

Evmur

Well-known member
Feb 28, 2021
5,219
2,618
113
London
christianchat.com
#31
We
76 year old male that has rounded third and headed for home. Searched for over 40 years for answers to why people believe what they believe and the search continues. Thousands of questions but will begin with three.
#1. If God forgives sins when we confess, just exactly what is the disadvantage of sinning?
#2. I can't find anywhere in the Bible of any of the great men and women saying, "I got saved today!" Not even the Apostle Paul. Saved from what?
#3. Why do we call Him "Jesus" when the letter "J" was not a part of the alphabet when He was born? Google the Original 1611 KJV, the Hebrew, and Aramaic writings. Bottom line: Does it matter what we call Him as long as we know who He is and what He's done for us and His promises for our eternity?

Reason for my questions: my math is average but I've found that in the Gospels, Jesus was asked about 183 questions of which he gave definitive answers to only 3. He, Himself, asked about 307 questions. I too believe questions enlist people to think about why they believe what they believe.
Your input is appreciated, friend or foe.
Thank you.
JPT
Welcome to CC JPT ... :)
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#32
I don't think I fit into this forum because I thrive on conflict and confrontation in search of people defending
their beliefs to determine how well grounded they are and to what lengths they will go to to defend those beliefs.
The Bible Discussion Forum is just the place for you :):giggle::geek:

Magenta:
I appreciate your directness and I'm impressed with the research you've done and your ability to transmit that knowledge. Thank you.
Thank you! God has been very good to me :) And, you are welcome :D
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#33
The Bible Discussion Forum is just the place for you :):giggle::geek:

Thank you! God has been very good to me :) And, you are welcome :D
To all who have read this thread, thank you for your input. It's time for me to depart as I have stirred the pot with a radioactive spoon and I sense tension over the internet. That was not my intent but it has been an informative couple of days. I bid you adieu!
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#34
To all who have read this thread, thank you for your input. It's time for me to depart as I have stirred the pot with a radioactive spoon and I sense tension over the internet. That was not my intent but it has been an informative couple of days. I bid you adieu!
Adiós, amigo :cry:

 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
60,200
29,500
113
#35
The "Happy Trails To You" song begins very near the end, @ 51:37, but
as I enjoy the whole LP, perhaps others may appreciate it as well :)
 

JPT

New member
Apr 28, 2022
13
3
3
#36
The "Happy Trails To You" song begins very near the end, @ 51:37, but
as I enjoy the whole LP, perhaps others may appreciate it as well :)
Magenta,

Appears there are postings about my "ludicrous and bullying behaviors".
Also, from some of your posts, it appears you are as combative as I am. Reference Gojira for one.
But the icing on the cake came from the denial of my post in the Bible Discussion Forum of 5 questions about the Book of Job.
As a Senior Member, as your title suggests, you must be in the know of the Christian Chat workings.
#1. Do you have any knowledge about these "gossip" postings?
#2. What are your Christian views about free speech when one doesn't agree with you?
#3. Can Christian Chat be compared to Twitter of the past?
 

Jesusfollower

Active member
Oct 21, 2021
352
197
43
jamaica
#38
76 year old male that has rounded third and headed for home. Searched for over 40 years for answers to why people believe what they believe and the search continues. Thousands of questions but will begin with three.
#1. If God forgives sins when we confess, just exactly what is the disadvantage of sinning?
#2. I can't find anywhere in the Bible of any of the great men and women saying, "I got saved today!" Not even the Apostle Paul. Saved from what?
#3. Why do we call Him "Jesus" when the letter "J" was not a part of the alphabet when He was born? Google the Original 1611 KJV, the Hebrew, and Aramaic writings. Bottom line: Does it matter what we call Him as long as we know who He is and what He's done for us and His promises for our eternity?

Reason for my questions: my math is average but I've found that in the Gospels, Jesus was asked about 183 questions of which he gave definitive answers to only 3. He, Himself, asked about 307 questions. I too believe questions enlist people to think about why they believe what they believe.
Your input is appreciated, friend or foe.
Thank you.
JPT
Welcome brother, i will try to answer your questions the best i can,
1-GOD wants us to love him with all our harts, just like any parent would like to be loved by their children. The bible teaches that if you love GOD with all your heart you will try your very best not to sin, GOD gave us the commandments to help our sometimes faulty moral compass. We all fail in this task (except Christ) but must try our best and change our ways, it is what repentance is about, admitting our sin and wanting to stop sinning. To continue sinning is not an option.

2. saved from the second death, after judgement from GOD.

3. Many use YESHUA , many say it is the correct name, is it important, I think so. I am still trying to find out the real name of GOD, maybe it is YAHWEH? the true name was maybe lost ?

see link;

https://wearehebrew.com/name-of-god/

There are a lot of nice people that are a lot more knowledgeable than I, do not hesitate to post a question,

Blessings, and welcome.

JF
 

cv5

Well-known member
Nov 20, 2018
23,008
8,373
113
#39
Hi JPT,

Consider:

Ephesians 2:5 states, "...by grace you are [present tense, plural] HAVING BEEN SAVED [perfect participle - V-RPM/P-NMP - the "R"="perfect tense"]" = ) ["perfect tense - Action completed at a specific point of time in PAST, with results CONTINUING into the PRESENT"]

-- https://biblehub.com/text/ephesians/2-5.htm

____________

As for the Philippians passage you have alluded to...
...Consider:


[quoting from an old post]

Regarding Philippians 3:8-14 [keeping its context of "the Christlike MIND" in the section of Scripture bracketed by 2:2,3,5 on one end, and 3:15,16,19 on the other end (re: 'mind/minded')]:

..."all of us who are mature should take such a view of things. And if on some point you think differently, that too God will make clear to you. Only let us live up to what we have already attained. Philippians 3:15-16

[quoting from Sir Robert Anderson's book "Forgotten Truths"]

"Appendix 4 - Philippians 3:8-14 [for CONTEXT]

"PHILIPPIANS 3:8-141 NOTE CHAPTER 7

"IF the commonly received exegesis of Philippians 3:8-14 be correct, we are faced by the astounding fact that the author of the Epistle to the Romans and of the 15th chapter of 1 Corinthians -- the Apostle who was in a peculiar sense entrusted with the supreme revelation of grace -- announced when nearing the close of his ministry that the resurrection was not, as he had been used to teach, a blessing which Divine grace assured to all believers in Christ, but a prize to be won by the sustained efforts of a life of wholly exceptional saintship.

"Nor is this all. In the same Epistle he has already said, "To me to live is Christ, and to have died is gain"; whereas, ex hypothesi, it now appears that his chief aim in life was to earn a right to the resurrection; and that death, instead of bringing gain, would have cut him off before he had reached the standard of saintship needed to secure that prize! For his words are explicit, "not as though I had already attained."

"Here was one who was "not a whit behind the chiefest Apostles"; who excelled them all in labours and sufferings for his Lord, and in the "visions and revelations" accorded to him; whose prolonged ministry, moreover, was accredited by "mighty signs and wonders by the power of the Spirit of God." And yet, "being now such an one as Paul the aged," [it is wrongly suggested] he was in doubt whether he should have part in that resurrection which he had taught all his pagan Corinthian converts to hope for: for to them it was he wrote the words, "we shall all be changed."

"Such is the exposition of the Apostle's teaching in many a standard commentary. And yet the passage which is thus perverted reaches its climax in the words, "Our citizenship is in heaven, from whence we are looking for the Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall fashion anew the body of our humiliation that it may be conformed to the body of His glory."

" "Our citizenship is in heaven" here is the clew to the teaching of the whole passage. The truth to which his words refer is more clearly stated in Ephesians 2:6 - God has "quickened us together with Christ, and raised us up with Him, and made us sit with Him in the heavenly places in Christ." More clearly still is it given in Colossians 3:1-3: "If then ye were raised together with Christ, seek the things that are above, where Christ is seated on the right hand of God. Set your mind on the things that are above, not on the things that are on earth. For ye died, and your life is hid with Christ in God."

"Ephesians and Colossians, be it remembered, were written at the same period of his ministry as Philippians; and in the light of these Scriptures we can read this chapter aright. To "win Christ" (ver. 8), or to apprehend, or lay hold of, that for which he had been laid hold of, or apprehended (ver. 12); or in other words, to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven -- this is what he was reaching toward, and what, he says, he had not "already attained."

"The "high calling" of ver. 14 is interpreted by some to mean Christ's calling up His own to meet Him in the air (a blessing assured to all "who are alive and remain unto the Coming of the Lord"); but this is not in keeping with the plain words -- God's high calling in Christ Jesus, i.e. what God has called us (made us) to be in Christ.

"If this passage refers to the literal resurrection, then the words "not as though I had already attained must mean that, while here on earth, and before the Lord's Coming, the Apostle hoped either to undergo the change of ver. 21, or else to win some sort of saintship diploma, or certificate, to ensure his being raised at the Coming. These alternatives are inexorable; and they only need to be stated to ensure their rejection.

"One word more. If the Apostle Paul, after such a life of saintship and service, was in doubt as to his part in the resurrection, no one of us, unless he be the proudest of Pharisees or the blindest of fools, will dream of attaining it. In fact we shall dismiss the subject from our minds."

--Sir Robert Anderson, Forgotten Truths, Appendix 4, pgs 145-147

http://articles.ochristian.com/article12455.shtml

[end quoting article; bold, underline, and brackets mine]

____________


So, Philippians 3:8-14 (esp vv.11-14,15) is referring to (as he says), "to realize practically in his life on earth what was true of him doctrinally as to his standing before God in heaven"... that is, "in the here and now"


[end quoting old post]



____________


Welcome to CC! Hope to see you around the boards. = )






[hope I don't get in trouble for posting all this in the "intro" section... :geek: :eek: ]
Evidently Sir Robert Anderson understands the fact of the pre-tribulation rapture. He is after all one of the foremost experts of Scripture so this is to be expected. :giggle: