Hi
@Sunshine2026,
Great thread as always! Please forgive my characteristically long answer.
We've had this topic come up several times over the years, and as people are saying, what God thinks is the most important factor (and the Bible doesn't seem to have any set rules for age gaps.)
However, I do think that some honest and practical topics must be considered very carefully.
Many years ago, I had a chat with a girl on this site who was about 33, and she was telling me about a guy who was begging her to marry him who was around 20 years older. Tragically, his wife had died, and he told her he didn't ever want to be alone again, which was way he was looking for someone younger. He told her she could take out a life insurance policy on him -- he didn't care, just as long as he didn't have to be alone.
I knew of another couple where a man married a girl 17 years younger than him thinking the same thing; unfortunately, she became ill and he became her full-time caregiver before she passed away (bringing to pass the very thing he had feared.)
I think in most cases, an older person looking for someone that much younger is thinking this: "They're going to take care of me when I get old and I'll die first, so not only will I always have a permanent caretaker, but I'll never have to be alone -- it's a total win-win."
I understand this, and it's human to think that way. But I think a couple with an age gap has to have serious conversations about planning for their future. For instance -- if he's 15 year older, what happens to her and their children when he dies? Is it simply a matter of "Tough luck on you, I got to be the one to die first -- you'll just have to figure it out on your own!"?
And I'm not saying this as a means to promote any kind of gold-digging, but rather, some real, practical conversations about the uncertainty of life. We trust in God, but only He knows what will happen.
My parents are only 2 years apart, but my dad had a very stressful job. The thing he worried about most was keeling over with a heart attack and leaving my stay-at-home mom behind to raise a small family alone. Life insurance and providence for her (and us) if he were to die were a common conversation I heard them having. I once wrote a thread if anyone else had fathers/husbands who planned for their providence if/when they died early, and no one really answered.
And while of course I think this is important for any couple of any age, I think it's a crucial talking point for age-gapped couples, no matter how the ages are flipped.
I went through an unwanted divorce in my mid-20's and have been part of the dating scene now for nearly 25 years. Ironically, I now seem to attract guys who are usually about 15 years younger than I am.
Years ago, I was seeing a guy in that age range (roughly 15 years younger than me,) and he asked me to consider marriage.
I never had kids, so if someone that much younger wanted to be with me, he'd have to accept that I wouldn't be able to have kids with him. And it also had me thinking that for the first time in my life, I would need to buy a life insurance policy because my income would have had significance and I wouldn't want to leave him struggling. I know women typically live longer than men but 15 years is quite an age gap.
And although I'm in good health, I felt uncomfortable with the thought of saddling him with "an old lady." I wouldn't ever want to hold someone back from their best life because they had to take care of me. I know we can't control these things, but there are times I've felt I'd rather be alone than be a burden to anyone else.
At any rate, he wound up marrying someone right around his age, and I was happy to hear that. I honestly did not feel God was leading us toward marriage.
Would I consider marrying someone considerably younger, or older?
One of my biggest concerns would be asking God about a "fair" balance between us as a married couple. I know of some situations where a couple might have married when they were 20 and 40 and all seemed well. But when the younger spouse was 50 and the older spouse was 70, the younger became a full-time caretaker to the older and the dreams they had of travel, etc. were over -- even though the younger spouse could have very well gone.
I don't want to feel resentful of someone taking away my life, and I don't want someone to feel resentful of me for turning him into a caretaker.
Now of course, this could happen in ANY marriage -- a car accident could change things in a heartbeat. And of course I know it's impossible to keep any marriage "fair."
But what I mean is, I would ask God if both people were going into the marriage with balanced expectations and willingness to serve, or would one be expecting a lot more benefits than the other? (Or is it mutual use -- is the older to avoid being alone, and is the younger using the older for financial security?)
In other words -- is it real, servant-like love that's actually driving a want for marriage -- or is it mostly a list of benefits that one or each is hoping to get for him or herself?
From what I've personally witnessed, I don't think these issues get talked about nearly enough.
But that's just me.