Didn’t God make all things Good?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
U

UnderGrace

Guest
#61
Hahaha. That’s funny. What would you know about those things to be able to judge me... maybe you that judge does the same things. Romans 2:1. How else would you know about Gnosticism if you have studied those things yourself..
I am not judging you, but what you espouse is not biblical.

You are a free agent you can believe as you will.
Christianity is about a relationship with Christ Jesus not about secret knowledge.
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
#62
Darkness has many names... and many false prophets and teachers. Certainly his name regardless is insignificant to any purpose.
Well I would agree here.
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#63
I probably know more than you sadly.

I studied it for a reason not because I believed any of it.

You no nothing of me.. Nor do you know who speaks within me.. Nor do you know the wind I have gathered and that has been given to me.... I also studied for a reason... is my reason less significant than yours? I sought answers and understanding in a sorrowful spirit. No one MADE ME. It was my free will...
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
#64
Absolutely. And Jesus our Lord and Savior came for the ungodly... not the righteous. For they already walk with God... need you be a judge of Lucifer too? Only God can judge evil from Good. We are no one to say the least... but I believe God that all things are good. Therefore in this case....Lucifer is for the good... not for evil... he is no one by whom sent him... Even Jesus said... why do you call me Good.. No one is good but God. For God can judge all men with respect to persons...
I really wish you would get to the point, was Satan/Lucifer created by God or no?
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,577
3,614
113
#65
Sounds like Adam to me... given free will... he knew what was at stake when he ate the fruit. And then he used Gods own gifted word to blame God and the woman... and the woman knew the law as she stated before she took the fruit as well .. so how was she deceived. And I thought the creation desired the host? And the host desired the creation? All things are for good in the end. After all. No disobedience or denial.. we wouldn’t have Jesus... so it was all for Gods purpose to dwell in the place that he made.. is what I have concluded.
Well i think Adam observed Eve after she ate of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and when she didn't drop dead right away Adam disbelieved God and ate also.. satan did his deceiving work on Eve and was successful in his efforts to sabotage Gods creation.. I believe satan did this in an effort to undermine the standing of God in the eyes of his fellow Angelic host..

He probably expected God to destroy His now corrupted creation and then satan could have pointed to God as a failure because His creation failed.. And if God did not destroy His now imperfect creation satan could accuse God of being corrupt, allowing an imperfect creation to exist.. God being Perfect should not allow any imperfection to exist.. So satan thought he had God in a no win situation, between a rock and a hard place as the saying goes.. But God foreknew all of satans moves and knew hot to Redeem His creation.. And the satanic challenge was defeated from the moment it started.. You cannot defeat an opponent who knows every move you are going to make before you even make your first move..

so how was she deceived. And I thought the creation desired the host? And the host desired the creation?
Not sure what you are talking about when you say Host.. The Host of heaven is the angelic beings in heaven in all their varied types.. As for Eve she was deceived by satan into thinking God had lied to her and that God was withholding a great blessing ( the knowledge of good and evil ) unjustly from her.. Who you believe and what you believe are very critical when it comes to God and eternal life..

I believe Gods purpose is to have true free willed beings to dwell with in eternity that will willingly accept Him as the one and only God of all existence.. Not because He is some kind of all mighty dictator who simply cannot be opposed, But that He is the only One who can be the One and only God of all existence and maintain all existence in a perfect state Eternally..

satans error was thinking he could be a God equal with God and with him in this delusion is 1/3rd of the angels and a number of delusional human beings also..
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,577
3,614
113
#66
Absolutely. And Jesus our Lord and Savior came for the ungodly... not the righteous. For they already walk with God... need you be a judge of Lucifer too? Only God can judge evil from Good. We are no one to say the least... but I believe God that all things are good. Therefore in this case....Lucifer is for the good... not for evil... he is no one by whom sent him... Even Jesus said... why do you call me Good.. No one is good but God. For God can judge all men with respect to persons...
I am not going to sit in judgement of lucifer/ satan God is going to be doing that.. I trust in the Holy Bible and It tells me what is going to happen in the future.. It tells me satan is going to be spending eternity in the Lake of Fire and thus will not be sharing eternity with God in His perfect eternal existence.. So irrespective of how i view satan i know God is perfect and just and i know where satan is going to be spending eternity.. So therefore i know satan has loved evil..

Jesus was and is Good.. The young man who called Jesus ""good Teacher"" did not know who Jesus truly was and just looked upon Jesus as a fellow human being.. Calling other faulty human beings Good is not truth.. Many people quote that portion of scripture thinking Jesus was denying He was Good.. But Jesus never denied He was Good, He only asked the guy Why do you call me Good only God is good... Now if the young man had responded ""well Jesus i called you Good because i believe you are God manifested in the flesh"" then that whole conversation would have went in an entirely different direction then what it did..
 
U

UnderGrace

Guest
#67
You no nothing of me.. Nor do you know who speaks within me.. Nor do you know the wind I have gathered and that has been given to me.... I also studied for a reason... is my reason less significant than yours? I sought answers and understanding in a sorrowful spirit. No one MADE ME. It was my free will...
You are awfully defensive, I was talking about myself not you.
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#69
I am not judging you, but what you espouse is not biblical.

You are a free agent you can believe as you will.
Christianity is about a relationship with Christ Jesus not about secret knowledge.

Oh but wait... Gods name is a secret. The fathers name has been a secret from the foundation of time... who’s name did Jesus come in.. His own.. or his father’s? Do you know secrets? To whom it will be revealed. If there wasn’t something to be revealed. Then why would Jesus speak about it?
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#70
Well i think Adam observed Eve after she ate of the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil and when she didn't drop dead right away Adam disbelieved God and ate also.. satan did his deceiving work on Eve and was successful in his efforts to sabotage Gods creation.. I believe satan did this in an effort to undermine the standing of God in the eyes of his fellow Angelic host..

He probably expected God to destroy His now corrupted creation and then satan could have pointed to God as a failure because His creation failed.. And if God did not destroy His now imperfect creation satan could accuse God of being corrupt, allowing an imperfect creation to exist.. God being Perfect should not allow any imperfection to exist.. So satan thought he had God in a no win situation, between a rock and a hard place as the saying goes.. But God foreknew all of satans moves and knew hot to Redeem His creation.. And the satanic challenge was defeated from the moment it started.. You cannot defeat an opponent who knows every move you are going to make before you even make your first move..



Not sure what you are talking about when you say Host.. The Host of heaven is the angelic beings in heaven in all their varied types.. As for Eve she was deceived by satan into thinking God had lied to her and that God was withholding a great blessing ( the knowledge of good and evil ) unjustly from her.. Who you believe and what you believe are very critical when it comes to God and eternal life..

I believe Gods purpose is to have true free willed beings to dwell with in eternity that will willingly accept Him as the one and only God of all existence.. Not because He is some kind of all mighty dictator who simply cannot be opposed, But that He is the only One who can be the One and only God of all existence and maintain all existence in a perfect state Eternally..

satans error was thinking he could be a God equal with God and with him in this delusion is 1/3rd of the angels and a number of delusional human beings also..
You know a lot about Satan? How so???
 
Jul 27, 2019
12
6
3
#72
Why do people think the serpent is bad? Didn’t God say all things were Good? I never read that God spoke Satan into creation... so where does evil come from? Is our ignorance the darkness?
Hi, I do not really know the answear to you question.

We have two state religions in Finland, Lutheranism and Orthodoxy. I belong to the Lutheran church in Finland, but my interest is in the Orthodox faith. You could say that I am Lutherian Eastern Orthodox.

This is what I found from the Orthodox perspective on evil.

Evil does not exist as a reality in the moral constitution of man; rather, it is the result of man's free will and of his ability to select between the two antithetical personality states, those of good and evil."

Source: All that a Greek Orthodox Should Know by Fr. Nicon D. Patrinacos
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#73
I am not going to sit in judgement of lucifer/ satan God is going to be doing that.. I trust in the Holy Bible and It tells me what is going to happen in the future.. It tells me satan is going to be spending eternity in the Lake of Fire and thus will not be sharing eternity with God in His perfect eternal existence.. So irrespective of how i view satan i know God is perfect and just and i know where satan is going to be spending eternity.. So therefore i know satan has loved evil..

Jesus was and is Good.. The young man who called Jesus ""good Teacher"" did not know who Jesus truly was and just looked upon Jesus as a fellow human being.. Calling other faulty human beings Good is not truth.. Many people quote that portion of scripture thinking Jesus was denying He was Good.. But Jesus never denied He was Good, He only asked the guy Why do you call me Good only God is good... Now if the young man had responded ""well Jesus i called you Good because i believe you are God manifested in the flesh"" then that whole conversation would have went in an entirely different direction then what it did..

He saw him as good...Because his works were good. But it is The fathers works which he came to do.. they were not Jesus works. But the will of his father’s. .. that’s why Jesus denied being Good... The father is Good.
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,577
3,614
113
#74
You know a lot about Satan? How so???
Well note i said "I believe" and "probably" From the entirety of scriptures thats what i believe.. And the probably was about the possible motivations of satan in sabotaging Gods creation.. I know from scriptures that lucifer wants to be the equal of God and that was the enticement he used to sway Eve.. and thats the enticement some human beings of today are also deceived into thinking.. Just take a look at the mormons just for one instance of a group of people who think they will be elevated into being Gods..
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#75
Hi, I do not really know the answear to you question.

We have two state religions in Finland, Lutheranism and Orthodoxy. I belong to the Lutheran church in Finland, but my interest is in the Orthodox faith. You could say that I am Lutherian Eastern Orthodox.

This is what I found from the Orthodox perspective on evil.

Evil does not exist as a reality in the moral constitution of man; rather, it is the result of man's free will and of his ability to select between the two antithetical personality states, those of good and evil."

Source: All that a Greek Orthodox Should Know by Fr. Nicon D. Patrinacos
I agree. God uses men’s ignorance for his Gods therefore it’s not evil. It’s just God. One diety.. Evil gets no glory or praise. Darkness was good for a season. Like nighttime is good for rest..
 

Dino246

Senior Member
Jun 30, 2015
25,325
13,713
113
#76
He saw him as good...Because his works were good. But it is The fathers works which he came to do.. they were not Jesus works. But the will of his father’s. .. that’s why Jesus denied being Good... The father is Good.
Jesus didn't deny being good. Read the text more carefully.
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#77
Well note i said "I believe" and "probably" From the entirety of scriptures thats what i believe.. And the probably was about the possible motivations of satan in sabotaging Gods creation.. I know from scriptures that lucifer wants to be the equal of God and that was the enticement he used to sway Eve.. and thats the enticement some human beings of today are also deceived into thinking.. Just take a look at the mormons just for one instance of a group of people who think they will be elevated into being Gods..
To exalt your knowledge against another is like the devil to me... for the serpent in the garden was never asked for a confession?? Only the woman and the man. So who did God believe to be at fault? (I’m only asking since you say you know so much about the scriptures?) And of the serpents eats dust... and men are made from dust.. does the serpent eat our flesh? Like it is supposed to do. Afflict ya and purify is... Jesus said eat of his flesh. So who ate dust?? What is your interpretation my dear Bible scholar?
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#78
Jesus didn't deny being good. Read the text more carefully.
I know he didn’t. Are you trying to take words out of something I did not say? I believe The father that lived within his flesh was good.. a righteous voice wrapped in a coat of skin. The flesh is filthy. The Holy spirit is divine..
 

Adstar

Senior Member
Jul 24, 2016
7,577
3,614
113
#79
He saw him as good...Because his works were good. But it is The fathers works which he came to do.. they were not Jesus works. But the will of his father’s. .. that’s why Jesus denied being Good... The father is Good.
Well i believe the Bible when it says:

1 Timothy 3: KJV
16 "And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory."

Also

Isaiah 9: KJV
6 "For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace."

Jesus never denied being good..
 
T

TheWind

Guest
#80
Well i believe the Bible when it says:

1 Timothy 3: KJV
16 "And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God was manifest in the flesh, justified in the Spirit, seen of angels, preached unto the Gentiles, believed on in the world, received up into glory."

Also

Isaiah 9: KJV
6 "For unto us a child is born, unto us a son is given: and the government shall be upon his shoulder: and his name shall be called Wonderful, Counsellor, The mighty God, The everlasting Father, The Prince of Peace."

Jesus never denied being good..
I didn’t say he did... because he was to become one with the father. As he sought his glory. He prayed “ Father glorify your name”. And he answered I have glorified it. And will glorify again. Therefore the father is good.. not the flesh of man.. God is a spirit.