Replacement theology? Yes or No.

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
No.
It is what it says.
If you need it changed then you need a new starting place.
God went the extra mile to list them as who they are and numbered them in more than one way.

But beyond that , he put up a guard rail against changing them into a made up doctrine enhancer.

They are FIRSTFRUITS of a group.
Jewish firstfruits.

Who is the firstfruits of the church.
Look it up.
The answer is Jesus.

That alone prevents men from muddying up the 144k.

They are who they are declared to be.

Mens doctrines get hammered.
Big time.
Are you telling the 144k not to accept Jesus today?
 
God had them selected by tribe into twelve distinct groups - 12,000 per tribe.

Yet? Jews who believe today during the Church age?
They no longer have a tribe.

For they are the "new man" (2 Corinthians 5:17) as the result of becoming a new creation in Christ!

So when God divides them up according to their tribe?
That means the Church age on earth had ended.
RAPTURE!
And, back to the age of the Jews during the Tribulation!
144,000!


........
Then you have a problem

You have a different firstfruits than the church

Jesus is the firstfruits of the church


You have something other than that as your firstfruits?
144,000, as your firstfruits?
See what happens when "intellect" attempts to unpack Revelation?
 
Fairly sure the millennium is a different topic. This doesn't relate to the confirmation of the covenant or the Holy Spirit. It comes afterward.

You're still missing the main point. The Holy Spirit is only within us until full redemption takes place at the time of our resurrection.
 
No.
It is what it says.
If you need it changed then you need a new starting place.
God went the extra mile to list them as who they are and numbered them in more than one way.

But beyond that , he put up a guard rail against changing them into a made up doctrine enhancer.

They are FIRSTFRUITS of a group.
Jewish firstfruits.

Who is the firstfruits of the church.
Look it up.
The answer is Jesus.

That alone prevents men from muddying up the 144k.

They are who they are declared to be.

Mens doctrines get hammered.
Big time.

Of course it is what it says. When it is written "The Twelves Tribes" and you do not have a list of the Twelve Tribes, you are to seek the Lord for wisdom. It's not a one to one correlation. Something else is going on. Religious gymnastics are required to shoehorn Dan's omission and Manasseh's inclusion. Let the text speak for itself.

We also have these accounts:

"Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect. For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel..."

"For he is not a Jew who is one outwardly..."
"For as many of you as were baptized into Christ have put on Christ. 28There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave nor free, there is neither male nor female; for you are all one in Christ Jesus. 29And if you are Christ’s, then you are Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise."


One would have to ignore many scriptures to conclude these are ethnic Jews.
 
Then you have a problem

You have a different firstfruits than the church

Jesus is the firstfruits of the church


You have something other than that as your firstfruits?
144,000, as your firstfruits?
See what happens when "intellect" attempts to unpack Revelation?
What ever you are trying to turn that into I am not sure.
You jumped on a first fruits theme, which may not be applicable.

As for what I did say?
It is truth.

Jesus is the firstfruits of the church.
OK....

The 144,000 are not the Church.
That means Jesus cannot lead them?

Jesus led Moses. Was Moses the Church?
Was Ezekiel? Isaiah?

Like I said... The Tribulation is the continuation of the Jewish age.
 
"The Jews are waiting for MESSIAH."

But Jesus already come. Some reject Jesus till today, till their last breath.

they know they have tomorrow?

Jesus say just worry for today.

So, you don't think Jesus wanted people to be watching for His Second Coming? If that's the case, I disagree with you.
 
Yeah and the Lord has ways of dealing with people such as yourself who seek to lead others in to false doctrine.

Those following the ways of the Nicolaitans are not accepted by the Lord so FYI on that in all your efforts to deceive others in to bowing down to follow you rather than following the Lord Jesus



I'm happy to not be one that rejects the whole counsel of the Lord such as yourself.
Your reprobate ways are going to kill you, so you should repent quick!

What false doctrine do you think he is leading others to?

Scooter, I think you're so quick to argue that you don't even take the time to understand what people are saying, even when they believe the same thing you do. That has happened between the two of us before too. Slow down and take your time to understand what's being communicated. If you can't, well, you might just have a communication problem in general.
 
What false doctrine do you think he is leading others to?

Like a lot of people, he demands that everyone bow down and follow him.

As in turn away from the Lord and from God's Word and instead just believe whatever he says.

If one is will to do this, then he'll think they are OK and saved and stuff.
 
Revelation 7 "Then I heard the number of those who were sealed: 144,000 from all the tribes of Israel."

And then the number from each tribe is enumerated:

"From the tribe of Judah 12,000 were sealed,
from the tribe of Reuben 12,000,
from the tribe of Gad... etc."


Notice, this was to be a list from "all the tribes of Israel" yet , if that was expected it falls short of the record: Dan is missing and Mannasseh, one of Joseph's sons, is added.
So, just from the text (and excluding any religious gymnastics) we should know that this is NOT a list of the physical tribes of Israel.

Dan is missing because those from the tribe of Dan were idolaters and were never saved. The 144,000 represent the saved people from all the 12 tribes that are listed and one of them merged into the other.
 
Like a lot of people, he demands that everyone bow down and follow him.

As in turn away from the Lord and from God's Word and instead just believe whatever he says.

If one is will to do this, then he'll think they are OK and saved and stuff.

That didn't answer my question about what you considered to be false doctrine.
 
Those relying on what AI says and posting what AI says cannot be taken seriously.

It's almost like those doing this don't even know or have the Holy Spirit to lead them

Scooter, you can't be taken seriously because you can't communicate well. Maybe if you used A.I. to communicate those views for you, you wouldn't spend so much time arguing with people over ideas in which you actually share.
 
"The Jews are waiting for MESSIAH."

But Jesus already come. Some reject Jesus till today, till their last breath.

they know they have tomorrow?

Jesus say just worry for today.

The Jews are waiting?

I am not waiting.
My sister is not waiting.
My brother is not waiting.

So we were not Jews because we are not waiting?

Besides...
Are all gentiles Christian?

Jews and gentiles do not accept Christ.
 
Dan is missing because those from the tribe of Dan were idolaters and were never saved. The 144,000 represent the saved people from all the 12 tribes that are listed and one of them merged into the other.
Or maybe Dan was to far North at the time of the wars and conflicts within Rome at that time. Dan always named places after their tribe as they travelled - so we get the river Danube and we get the country Denmark etc