IS SMOKING A SIN WORTHY OF DISFELLOWSHIPMENT?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

WHICH OPTION BEST REFLECTS YOUR POSITION ON WHETHER SMOKING IS A SIN?

  • Smoking is a sin, and unrepentant smokers should be disfellowshipped

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Smoking is a sin, but unrepentant smokers should not be disfellowshipped

    Votes: 20 48.8%
  • Smoking is not a sin

    Votes: 21 51.2%

  • Total voters
    41
Feb 5, 2017
1,118
36
0
#81
Some people deal with things by blaming it on 'the thing' and not taking responsibility.

I don't think you ought to call something most people hate and wish they could quit doing to be idolatry.
There's not a lot of mercy in your post.
I guess a church could make the rule that there be no smoking in the parking lot...the whole world has done it so why not the church? In fact, I guess an argument could be made that the church should have been the one to lead the charge to take away permissible places to smoke instead of just following the world on it.
I don't know. I just know I have compassion on people with addictions because they are in misery most of the time. I wish I could help them in some way when I see them. I've met some of them who their eyes light up when you talk about Jesus. They seem more receptive to Him than a lot of people without addictions I've spoken with. And it's painful to watch them struggle and then fall back down and then you have no answer for why God hasn't taken it from them when they put their request before Him.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
#82
Sin is something that misses the mark, and takes you out of alignment with God.

The question is, is it a sin to self-harm? Of course it is.

Is smoking self-harm? Of course it is.

Are drugs mind-altering? Yes. If something is mind-altering does it affect the heart? Yes. That counts for prescription drugs too.

Ps. the word defile means to damage the purity or appearance of; mar or spoil. Do cigarettes do this? Yes. Do most prescription drugs have side-effects? Yes, sadly they do.

I'll tell you the greatest evil of smoking, and just how mind-altering it is, having spent a lot of time analysing vices people use. It will have smokers make-up absolutely any fabrication to justify it being good, making them happy (forget people who don't smoke), and that they smoke because they enjoy it and addiction isn't a factor.

Jesus didn't mention anything about ecstacy or cocaine, and the Bible says "Not that which goeth into the mouth defileth a man", so does that mean it's ok? No, this is fabricating justification.

Smokers have more troubled souls and hearts than most people. Maybe that coincidentally is life, and that moment they thought screw it I will smoke that first cigarette that makes me feel ill and then smoke another one until the addiction tells me I enjoy it. It is those beginning thoughts of insanity into a highly addictive substance, that should tell you whether something is good or not. If you're a smoker, remember the reasons you started, they were not pure...
You've heard some smokers come into this thread and share. Have you heard a single one of them say smoking is GOOD? I haven't heard a single "fabrication to justify it being good" and I haven't heard a single one of them say it makes them happy either or that addiction isn't a factor.

I don't know which smokers you've analyzed but the ones who've come in here all seem to want to quit and don't seem to fit this model you've come up with.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
#84
In regards to the 'vote', did any non-smokers who have never smoked vote for 'smoking is not a sin'? I was just wondering why you think that, or whether it is just smokers who voted this way.
When I hear men talking about something that doesn't happen to be their problem or one of their besetting sins or faults or difficulties speak self righteously and without mercy, I feel worse for them than I do for the men they're being unmerciful towards because I know what happens for them next - a fall and some humbling. (Which is the mercy of God toward them - but still, it makes you wince for what you know will come to them).
 

notmyown

Senior Member
May 26, 2016
4,719
1,144
113
#85
should we see that 1 Cor 6:19 is in the context of sexual sin?
i mean, does that matter?
 
Apr 30, 2016
5,162
75
0
#86
DISFELLOWSHIPMENT????

What is that?

Is it like the Catholic ex-communication?
Are we becoming Catholic?

I never heard of this in any Protestant Church .
 

p_rehbein

Senior Member
Sep 4, 2013
30,256
6,575
113
#87
How does one conclude that smoking is a sin? Is it that "body is a temple" thingy? Isn't the purity of our hearts what that actually means? If smoking is a sin, then......so is drinking any alcohol, and eating any foods that contain various things that are harmful to one's health. Shoot, these days, breathing the AIR is a sin given that standard of what a sin is.

Is smoking good for you? Yes and no.

Like a Preacher I once heard say? You won't go to hell for smoking, but you will smell like you been there.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
822
113
#88
there's that HUGE word again "if",it's not an "if" that smoking is indeed a sin,want an example? Aaron's sons they offered strange fire to God and burnt up by God so this =SIN big time,or another fact noone has mentioned,the ten commandments which includes "thou shalt not kill" well each time you smoke a cigarette or drink alcohol or abuse drugs,guess what you are killing your self which is not only a mere sin but a commandment you break,and yes we are under grace so yeah the commandments won't kill us when we break them but you are still"sinning",or do you believe that God appreciates you destroying the life he gave you or better yet do you believe that Jesus appreciates you killing yourselves after he took away your sins thereby restoring your lives?
hmmmmmmm somehow I believe...NO!'Neither God nor Jesus condone or delight in anyone smoking,drinking alcohol,or abusing drugs!
for what use are the idle and drunkards to God?
If you decide to submit to your "desires" not "addiction" then how are you serving God,seeing as that you have blinded yourselves to that this is wrong,and thus"if the blind leadeth the blind surely they shall fall into the ditch together"all so called addiction is really is simply you "wanting" to keep hurting yourself,and "wanting" to be idle,and did I mention "wanting"????
once again these are all "wants" not "needs" and each one "leads" you to working "iniquity" and wasting the lives that God gave you and Jesus restored,"greed troubles thine household" go ahead say it again that these "things" you indulge in aren't "SINS" I'm listening and so is God!!!!
Do you never submit to your desires?
If someone cuts you off in traffic have you never submitted to your desire to honk the horn and scream and yell they are an idiot?
Jesus says anger toward your brother means you have already committed murder.
Which do you think is worse - a murderer or a smoker?
You do have it right - God IS listening.
 

p_rehbein

Senior Member
Sep 4, 2013
30,256
6,575
113
#89
Nicotine actually has one good thing it does, but Doctors do not talk about it to people, because, for the most part, it does more harm than good. The good thing about smoking is that when one is in a great level of stress or such, smoking will work to calm the person down. Believe it or not, but when one is having coughing fits, smoking will stop them as well. Yeah, smoking is probably what caused the fits to begin with, but, not all the time. Sometimes chronic sinus drainage can cause a person to have a coughing/choking fit.......and smoking will greatly help to calm it down.

No, Doctors do not tell people about this...........but that in no way makes it untrue. If you know a Doctor, ask them to give a serious answer about this.

Anyway......... :)


You've heard some smokers come into this thread and share. Have you heard a single one of them say smoking is GOOD? I haven't heard a single "fabrication to justify it being good" and I haven't heard a single one of them say it makes them happy either or that addiction isn't a factor.

I don't know which smokers you've analyzed but the ones who've come in here all seem to want to quit and don't seem to fit this model you've come up with.
 
Dec 19, 2009
27,513
128
0
71
#90
I believe smoking is a sin, but I don't know why you'd kick smokers out of the church without also kicking out all the other sinners, which probably would be everybody.
 

Huckleberry

Senior Member
Aug 25, 2013
1,698
96
48
#91
I don't think you ought to call something most people hate and wish they could quit doing to be idolatry.
There's not a lot of mercy in your post.
I guess a church could make the rule that there be no smoking in the parking lot...the whole world has done it so why not the church? In fact, I guess an argument could be made that the church should have been the one to lead the charge to take away permissible places to smoke instead of just following the world on it.
I don't know. I just know I have compassion on people with addictions because they are in misery most of the time. I wish I could help them in some way when I see them. I've met some of them who their eyes light up when you talk about Jesus. They seem more receptive to Him than a lot of people without addictions I've spoken with. And it's painful to watch them struggle and then fall back down and then you have no answer for why God hasn't taken it from them when they put their request before Him.
Addiction is idolatry.
Addicted smokers hold their cigarettes in a place of high importance and are, in fact, enslaved by them.
Smoking their cigarettes is ritualistic and they do it, figuratively speaking, religiously.
Cigarettes cost a lot of money, and that money becomes an offering to themselves.
An addict who is "miserable" chose the misery, and they can choose to stop it.

No, I don't have compassion on them, I hold them in contempt.
Especially when I see them buying food with an EBT card and they're obviously smokers.
And especially especially ones whose children are forced to breath their second-hand poison,
and are sent to school in rags that smell like they're stored in an ashtray because their low-life parents
don't have money to buy them new clothes because they wasted it on cigarettes and whatever else.
I have compassion on their children, who are victims of abuse IMO.

And then there's the people that won't leave that garbage at home for two
hours on a Sunday, and feel the need to smoke up in the church parking lot.
I can protect my kids from most evils of the world by not frequenting
crap-holes in real life or on TV, but you'd think church would be the
one place I could take them without having them to see debauchery.
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#92
LOL

I just found out 50% of the people who answered this poll think I don't merit their fellowship.

Might I make an suggestion? The next poll should be worded the same way, except, instead of "smoking" insert the word "haughty."
 
Nov 22, 2015
20,436
1,430
0
#93
Or insert the word "over-eating" and a whole host of other things - this too destroys the temple that the Spirit of God lives in. This body is dead because of the law of sin in it. Rom. 7:22-23

Romans 8:10 (NASB)
[SUP]10 [/SUP] If Christ is in you, though the body is dead because of sin, yet the spirit is alive because of righteousness.
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
56,211
26,267
113
#95
Addiction is idolatry.
I did read the rest of your post, but trimmed to just this, to say I agree. Smoking is a self indulgent self destructive habit that amounts to slowly committing suicide, among quite a few other other not so pleasant things, none of which are life affirming. Everything God has given us is good but man uses it to his destruction. The nicotine in cigarettes stimulate and release chemical messengers like epinephrine and dopamine that allow the smoker to relax, and also sharpens your brain and increases your alertness, but surely there are better ways to achieve the same effect?
 
D

Depleted

Guest
#96
Addiction is idolatry.
Addicted smokers hold their cigarettes in a place of high importance and are, in fact, enslaved by them.
Smoking their cigarettes is ritualistic and they do it, figuratively speaking, religiously.
Cigarettes cost a lot of money, and that money becomes an offering to themselves.
An addict who is "miserable" chose the misery, and they can choose to stop it.

No, I don't have compassion on them, I hold them in contempt.
Especially when I see them buying food with an EBT card and they're obviously smokers.
And especially especially ones whose children are forced to breath their second-hand poison,
and are sent to school in rags that smell like they're stored in an ashtray because their low-life parents
don't have money to buy them new clothes because they wasted it on cigarettes and whatever else.
I have compassion on their children, who are victims of abuse IMO.

And then there's the people that won't leave that garbage at home for two
hours on a Sunday, and feel the need to smoke up in the church parking lot.
I can protect my kids from most evils of the world by not frequenting
crap-holes in real life or on TV, but you'd think church would be the
one place I could take them without having them to see debauchery.
Let me fix that for you.

Addiction is idolatry.
Addicted Pharisees hold their pride in a place of high importance and are, in fact, enslaved by it.
Pride is ritualistic and they do it, literally speaking, religiously.
Pride cost a lot of pain towards others, and that pain becomes an offering to themselves.
An addict who is "miserable" chose the misery, and they can choose to stop it.

No, I don't have compassion on them, I hold them in contempt, because I'm a Pharisee and am much better than anyone else.
Especially when I see them not being like me.
And especially especially ones whose children are forced to breath their second-hand poison,
and are sent to school loathing because their low-life parents
don't have money to buy them the same haughty outfits Pharisees should wear because they wasted it on their own pride and whatever else.
I have compassion on their children, who are victims of abuse IMO, because I was not the one to offer my Phariseeism to them.

And then there's the people that won't leave that Phariseeism at home for two
hours on a Sunday, and feel the need to smoke the church parking lot like I'm doing here.
I can protect my kids from most evils of the world by not frequenting
crap-holes in real life or on TV, but you'd think church would be the
one place I could take them without having them see humility.
There. That's your true love displayed.
 
Apr 23, 2017
1,064
47
0
#97
hard question.......... i think its polluting God's temple but its not specifically prohibited so im also silent on it.............
 
Apr 23, 2017
1,064
47
0
#98
Let me fix that for you.



There. That's your true love displayed.
smoker spotted yo!!!!!!!! :D no way u would say it if u didnt..... its fine sis i wont hate. its just funny
 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,395
113
#99
Addiction is idolatry.
Addicted smokers hold their cigarettes in a place of high importance and are, in fact, enslaved by them.
Smoking their cigarettes is ritualistic and they do it, figuratively speaking, religiously.
Cigarettes cost a lot of money, and that money becomes an offering to themselves.
An addict who is "miserable" chose the misery, and they can choose to stop it.

No, I don't have compassion on them, I hold them in contempt.
Especially when I see them buying food with an EBT card and they're obviously smokers.
And especially especially ones whose children are forced to breath their second-hand poison,
and are sent to school in rags that smell like they're stored in an ashtray because their low-life parents
don't have money to buy them new clothes because they wasted it on cigarettes and whatever else.
I have compassion on their children, who are victims of abuse IMO.

And then there's the people that won't leave that garbage at home for two
hours on a Sunday, and feel the need to smoke up in the church parking lot.
I can protect my kids from most evils of the world by not frequenting
crap-holes in real life or on TV, but you'd think church would be the
one place I could take them without having them to see debauchery.
I don't smoke, but been to AU numerous times...cigs in AU are $25 to $35 pack........imagine that..........