I believe only one of them produced fruit, so only one had faith.
The other three are examples of other different responses to the gospel.
A. Rejects, no conversion lost
B. Recieves, (believes) but since it was not rooted in christ, (had no root) they walked away
C. Others tried to mix the world with christ,, but again, since had no root, what they truely had faith in chocked their “belief” in christ out and they walked away (the antichrist of 1 john who dpearted but were never saved)
That is why I said I know we disagree.....and no offence but your analogy leave no room for spiritually immature believers and or worldly believers which is why I disagree....
They with JOY received the word....the word RECEIVED means to take to oneself....
Receive with meekness the engrafted word
To them that RECIEVE HIM....
It is a completed action
dechomai: to receive
Original Word: δέχομαι
Part of Speech: Verb
Transliteration: dechomai
Phonetic Spelling: (dekh'-om-ahee)
Definition: to receive
Usage: I take, receive, accept, welcome.
HELPS Word-studies
1209 déxomai – properly, to receive in a welcoming (receptive) way. 1209 (déxomai) is used of people welcoming God (His offers), like receiving and sharing in His salvation (1 Thes 2:13) and thoughts (Eph 6:17).