The False Doctrine of OSAS

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Shall we continue with this debate?

  • yes

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • no

    Votes: 3 100.0%

  • Total voters
    3
  • Poll closed .
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
No Abiding........we do........just read the commandments and the epistles.
Then do all of what it says........simple enough.
That is how you know you have God's grace.
Yeah I agree, except in part.

I agree in the part of we read them we will know how much of Gods grace we have, because we will realise we can not keep all of Gods commands 100 % of the time, thus we still need Gods grace.

I disagree with the part that we have to do them, Because if we COULD do all God commands us to we would not longer have the need for Grace, because we have made it.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Good thing Jesus did not show His love to the Father by His obedience to His will, we would all be in trouble then......this would be fooilish speaking
Good thing for Us Jesus showed his love to us by doing this very thing, then taking the punishment we deserve on his own flesh, and dieing in our place so we could be made complete in him, by trusting in his finished work on the cross.
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
I know a lot has been said, but I wanted to respond to this.
I know you're sincere! I never doubted it. :)

I also believe in obedience. You may choose to believe that or not, but it is true.
I want to obey the Lord. I just know it can't be done in my own power. -- Me either my friend. That is why I rely on the guidance of my Lord to show me His ways (path). Naturally, since I am in the flesh, i will fall sometimes, and He is merciful. So I get up from my fall, and He is there again showing me the way. Ponder: is not that fall my own freewill in play? I choose to fall. But I also choose to repent. So, yes He leads but I can fall. I can either repent or remain under His correction. His Spirit is not like the evil spirits which possesses one, but He leads and one still has a choose to follow. That willingness to follow is obedience.

You know, not by might, nor by power, but by My Spirit? --Yes. And I say to my Lord, led on. I cannot do it and I know. And I trust you to led me to the way I am suppose to be in you. It is by my willingness to be led that I am led. If He led by force, is He no better than a dictator (I am speaking as a man)?
That's what I'm saying (and apparently really poorly! lol). I do not know if you are or you are not reading everything I am saying, but take this into note (my words as always are absolute): I am justified from the adverse sentencing of condemnation, I am being sanctified (made holy) by the One who is sanctifying, I will receive my reward, I will receive my wreath(s), I will be in God's rest when i am before Him as a saint. But, If my Lord, your Lord, says I must contend for my faith then I take that as Hs Wisdom telling me not to depend on myself, but look at my Forerunner who has finished the race and left me an example to follow. His example: not my will but your will. And how am I to do that: hearken to His Voice. Who is His Voice: Jesus said I will send my Spirit and He will LED you into all Truth. So, no. I do not work for my salvation, I have it already. If I am not being led by Him, then by whom am I being led by and to where, seeing that only He knows the way to God's rest as He did in the wilderness. My hope is in Him and I trust Him to finsih what He has started in me. But, I do not ignore Him when He shows me where to go on that racetrack. I know He is my Forerunner. But, what if I do not lsiten, and the Light is not my light I am looking upon, shall not the darkness cause me to fall. Now, of that fall, as in any race, I have a choose to get back up and continue or to call it quites. But all that way, He is there encouraging me on, even as a couch would. But, still the choice is mine, as it is with any runner on that course.

I do not have the power to obey the Lord. Only He can give me that. -- He gives the Spirit, He gives hope, He gives promises, He gives encouragements, and in times of need He gives help, and none of this is of my own, but all of these things are from Him. If I continue to remain in the race, I possess all of this and will possess even more when i have finished. The only work which is of me is my willingness to follow my Forerunner, in as much as Jesus willingly followed God in all He showed Him to be His will.

I am responsible for any failure (but forgiven!), - Amen. Even a million times. God knows the intent of the heart.

and He is responsible for any success. -- Amen. So perhaps all I am speaking of is the possibility of falling and not willing to get back up to finish the race. Obedience to Him is not works. No, ma'me. It is concuring that He knows the way and I trust Him to lead me safely there.


Does that help at all to overcome the impasse? I responded with what I know to be the Truth. So if people can accept that we can fall but we are given a Helper (hence, one who helps to overcome), and that we are to listen to God in His guidance to His rest as those in the wildereness had to, seeing that those who did not fell, then yes. I proclaim the full adminstration of God's salvational plan. God the Father is who God the Word is leading His children to under God the Spirit's leading. So, is the impasse over?

-ellie


-chris
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
The only way people offend me is the mockery of the Scriptures they denullify so that the OSAS can stand. The mockery is not to me but to God.

This should answer all emails concerning this.
lol. So its ok for you to make a mockery of scripture to support your legalism. OSAS stands on Scripture. It stands on God, because it is all about God, his promises and his work.

You want to make it based on you, your work, and your ability. This is not from the word of God.
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
lol. So its ok for you to make a mockery of scripture to support your legalism. OSAS stands on Scripture. It stands on God, because it is all about God, his promises and his work.

You want to make it based on you, your work, and your ability. This is not from the word of God.
Show me my mockery and do not spare. Are yuo willing to show people where my mockeries are?
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
lol. So its ok for you to make a mockery of scripture to support your legalism. OSAS stands on Scripture. It stands on God, because it is all about God, his promises and his work.

You want to make it based on you, your work, and your ability. This is not from the word of God.
How can you possibly believe hearkening to God's lead is work and is based on us? The only thing which is based on us is our willingness to listen to where He wills to lead. And that is obedience? No. It is common sense to follow the one who has the answers.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Show me my mockery and do not spare. Are yuo willing to show people where my mockeries are?
I have been showing you for the past few weeks. As has everyone else. It is up to you to see how you are misinterpreting scripture to support your own belief of a works based Gospel.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
How can you possibly believe hearkening to God's lead is work and is based on us?

Because we have free will. God told Abraham he would have a son, and this son would be a son of Promise. Abraham laughed, Then committed a adultery with his maid because he did not fully trust God. Did God fail to keep his promise because Abraham lacked faith and committed a grave sin?


The only thing which is based on us is our willingness to listen to where He wills to lead. And that is obedience? No. It is common sense to follow the one who has the answers.
Thats not the problem. The problem is your basing your eternal life on this. And not on the work of Christ. Are you perfect? If your not perfect. You have failed to meet the mark of being good enough to deserve eternal life
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
I have been showing you for the past few weeks. As has everyone else. It is up to you to see how you are misinterpreting scripture to support your own belief of a works based Gospel.


Likewise, I have been showing you all your error.

So then, I guess there is but one conclusion to all of this.

One is right and one is wrong.

If both is right, then Scripture is wrong.

You say faith alone is what saves and you have your proves.

I say faith without works is dead and I have my proves.

So, I guess, we need to reconcile those two differences or we both risk the change of posioning the babes and risk the change of being erased from the Book of Life.

And at this point, it is apparent that no one is willing to harmonize Scripture.

But I will:

Faith alone saves, but faith without works is dead (non-existing) .

They who are disobedient (refuse beleive and thus, obedience), do not have everlasting life abiding in them.

So we see that they who are faithful are the ones who have life in them. And faithful expressed out is: remaining true to what was taught to us through the new Covenant.

In Christ, we have all we need for salvation. And without Him, we have nothing. And He said,

Joh 15:10 If ye keep my commandments, ye shall abide in my love; even as I have kept my Father's commandments, and abide in his love

So, do we listen to our Lord and do as He has commanded us to do or do we say it is to much and abandon Him.
 
A

Abiding

Guest
convince me of what? that the Lord i serve will not help me? -- Who said that the Lord will not HELP you?
that if i abide in Him and His words abide in me that i wont have fruit? -- So we all better start producing fruit or be like the unproductive servant who take what he had taken away from him and thrown in out darkness (give over to the tormentors).dont think you understand the tormenters, but anyway...we cant produce fruit...we only bear it. Does a branch produce or carry fruit? Even to say bear, it means to carry fruit.....so we carry our fruit with us and must show the Harvester our fruits. Are have we yet fogotten how the unfruitful tree is cut down and burnt?I honestly dont think you understand the burning part. A branch is nothing but dead wood...it cant produce anything..the fruit comes from the vine all it does is abide on the vine. No we dont do this to show the Husbandman the fruit is for others we become fruitful to the church and world...the husbandman prunes us to get max yield. A branch is a dead wood....how does it produce if it is not alive as the trunk? Does not the branch because it is attached to the trunk bring forth fruit, or does the trunk without the branches bring forth fruit? No, we prune each other as it is said of Paul and Apollos. One seeds, one waters, yet another prunes. But the Harvester is God. If Paul spoke of himself as the one who seeds and another who waters, then is it not us who produced the wheat for God's farm barn through the leading of the Spirit? Who is said to be rewarded for their toils in Christ? Did not Paul said we would be rewarded accordingly?

Or that if im faithful..i still should worry? -- if you produice fruit than no. But if not then yeslike i said you dont understand you CANT rpoduce fruit...just wood hay and stubble. But yet, you say, I think you do, that we produce fruit of righteousness with the Spirit. Either way, bear or produce, we will have been rewarded on our fruits. So, how then is rewarded? The Spirit who leads to good works or the one who hearkened to Him and produced those fruits. Would it not be illogical to say that God will reward Himself for the work He did through you*? Your mixing different parables please dont...you not quite understanding them. The answer is no...God needs nothing the fruit is for service, others eat it....in it we Glorify the Lord...like i said we CANT produce fruit...just wood hay and stubble. The fruit of righteousness is another thought altogether yet it works the same....abiding on the vine...i dont think about doing this, fruits of the Spirit are not fruits of my labor but fruits of Him.....Now if you want to talk about labor as in duties like study, prayer, ect...then we should change topics for that. We have been through this already. They are both speaking of the same end result: the unproductive servant. I understand it completely, I accept all of Scripture whether i like what is said or not. My truth is nothing, His Truth is everything. The subject, whether I talk about this or talk about that, does remain the same: we are to follow Him, His Spirit, and if we do not then how can one be productive. If one is following the Spirit, then nothing I say is towards them, but if one speaks as though they can enter thier rest and yet discredit God's own Spirit, then they have another thing coming. How can i stay on subject when we have about 5-10 different subjects being spoken about just in this one post.

Is He Lord? Didnt He make promises? --- Did not God make promises to the Hebrews and some did not hearken to His Voice and thus did not receive His promises. Simple faith, if you become disobedient, rest in the assurance that God will remain faithful.Of coarse they were disobedient...they didnt believe. you know that.If they had they would have been obedient.. Do we not know that almost all who came out of Egypt were disobedient and they learned obedeince by the things they suffered, in much the same way our Lord learned His: by hearkening to Him?Of coarse and so do we learn by suffering Rom5 1peter1 along with discipline from the Father. I see no argument here then, if we both see that one must be willing to be obedient (willing to accept discipline) from His Spirit. What you see me saying as obedient you say as discipline. So, if I say that we must hearken to Him, what then if we do not? It is told us what we are considered if we do not accept His discipline.


Did He ask me to trust Him? Do you? YES! then no worries. If you do not trust Him in His leading you? Then what? As a broken record, yes I trust Him to lead me home and I trust that what He has said is True. Why not simply accept one can fall.Well i know people will fall, never said they couldnt..done it myself. But Guess whose arms i fell in when i did? And praise God you decided to repent and return to His open arms. But that still does not answer for those who decide a rebellious life is still better and remain under the Spirit's coniviction. Have we not heard that the Lord is longsuffering. It does not stay that He is eternally patient, but LONGsuffering?Do you think all the Lord does is convict? are you kidding? He has followed them through their life till they become reprobates. But you know what...if a person doesnt respond to grace and mercy....few will change out of fear...the fearful go into the lake of fire, they bury their gift thinking the Lord is mean and austere. And that wont save them...He wants our willingness. By no means, he convict those who walk in opposition to His leading. To those who are not, they walk in peace. Are you kidding, thinking that one can who choices to leave his walk and live in the flesh can still go to Heaven even through they live in rebeliion? Even though God said they will die in their sins? Every thing you said after 'but you know what...' is what I am saying. What words can I use so that that can be understood? I simply do not get it.

Cast all my cares on Him? Amen.

There are hundreds of verses people could have brought to your thread. -- and yet there are still thousands more which they ignore.I just think you have the wrong attitude (my attitute comes from you all. But then aagin, people do not like it when it is thrown back into thier own face. If I cannot teach patiently, then i will become as one of them so that by such, they will learn from one who speaks like them) and perspective...the ones youve contended with do not ignore any scripture they have been wonderful faithfull upright believers that didnt like your position and how you are dealing with scripture. Most of them have walked many many years with the Lord and have deep understanding of all the scripture you provided and seen your point and understand your sentament. Really? You mean all those scriptures which I presented was not contented with? So if they live a righteous and upright life and I tell others about the pitfalls on the racetrack, they do not like that I point to Jesus' Spirit as the way to walk that same path? But yet, if they remain faithful, they shall be led into salvation. I wasnt contending with the verses...just what you were blowing into them,if you wanted to teach folks HOW to stand and how to stay strong, renew their minds, show them the Lovelyness and beauty of the Lord...in His(as David always said) Lovingkindness and tendermercies...id be all withyou If you realy cared they hung around show them how beautiful the Lord is and give them something to be interested in. What has been blown into them? The one which says if you love me then keep my commandments? This is spoken in the active. Who keeps the commandments, Jesus? You? Surely it can be seen that 'you' is being spoken to here. So, if we do not keep His commandments, are we reaelly loving Him? What about the one which says to contend for the faith? Are we to iognore this as nothing but empty air? Come now, let us reason together? Contend, strive to enter, walk not as, keep, guard, test spirits, love, follow me, etc,.... are all in the active. how is it possible to renew their minds when every single verse given to them is disannuled in favor of that OSAS doctrine? as long as they deny Truth presented to them, it is impossible to have their minds renewed by the Spriit? Is not the Spirit the Spirit of Truth? If He is thought of as an it a thing of a loons mind, how can they be renewed? It is the spirit who shows people the lovingness and beauty of the Lord...but how can He if He is denied His place in their salvation? I will not deny the full administation of God's salvation plan to them, that would be misleading them. How can i show them God's love when they reject Him in His Spirit's adminstration. Until they learn to accept God in all His Forms, there can be no love spoken, seeing that deny God His place.

Only thing i see in what you teach is that ill fall away. -- yes there is that possbility, otherwise the God would not have said so.like i said i have, but thats not the end of the story. But what of the ones who believe no matter what one does, he cannot loose salvation? So it is wrong to tell them the words of God that if one who is righteous and leaves his righteousness to live an disobedient life will not have his righteousness remembered, but in the iniquity of his iniquity and the sinfulness of his sin, HE SHALL DIE? Are we to ingnore God over one verse of what Paul said, where is the agreement of Scripture of that?No we dont just agree with Paul as if they contradict...but there is a slight difference in --You set there and repeatly tell people you are not of the OSAS doctrine but here you include yourself to be of them. So you can no longer, out of being fair, deny that you are of the OSAS teaching Abide

administrations....also i never notice when you quote that ezekiel passage you reading the next few verses...where it talks about if the person repents. -- Yes, so if a person repents all is well. But if not? You said you repented and all is well with you. But if you did not repent?

Mighty important part of that script. Both new and old testament Gods Spirit worked on mans heart empowering him to repent. Just like He does to you and me. IF i didnt repent id say you were right id die...but can i not repent? thats another thread. -- No, it is not another thread, it has every thing to do with OSAS. If you desire not to repent, then has not God no choose but to leave you as you are. Neithe does this say that He will give up on you, but it is certain that in His wisdom there will come a time when He says enough. The Book of revelation tells us that there will come a time when He will say enough of trying to reach out to the lost, enough of the hypocrite. enough of the children of rebellion.

Im a new creation my nature is new, now when i fall
i hate it sin now is something i hate. He did this to me when He gave me a new spirit and a new heart.
--- This still does not answer about one's freewill. If you can answer these questions with an open heart then maybe I will shut up about freewill.


Adam and Eve were in God's rest. They fellowshipped with Him and saw Him face to face. They disobeyed. The consequence of that freewill was that they were thrown out of that rest and was placed under work. Now, if one who is in fellowship with God choose to leave that by their action. why didn't God make them come back into that union? But instead, have they not abandoned their rightousness (the means by which they stood before God: by their obediene to His commands)? And what happened to them because of choosing disobedeince?

And what of Lucifer and the fallen angels, they were before God, yet He did not force them to come back but as they chose of their freewill, they faced the consequences of their actions.

So it is with us, who are faithful and in uniion with God spiritual for the moment, if we choose to abandon our righteousness: Jesus Christ, we are in the same codemnation: an everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord. So, who is right God who says the one who practice righteousness is righteous as He is rightous or a doctrine of man which says one actions, once they believe, have no bearing on their salvation. This sort of believe only concludes with the notion that we are free to do as we well please, inasmuch as the Universal Salvation opponents declare. Every religion has it rules and Christ set those rules out for us. If we do not comply with Him, dont be fooled, He is no Lord of yours, seeing that you cannot even obey Him in the flesh.



Or because
I trust Him more than me...even tho the word says a man who trusts in himself is a fool.
I shouldnt have hope. -- Hope is only given to those who trust. So, if one falls and remains there, does he still trust?Not according to my experience, i guess when He pulled me into His arms i could have jacked Him in the face...but it just didnt come into my mind.. It is when you repented and turned back towards Him as your light that He pulled you into His arm. God did not to offend us, we offened into in whatever rebellion we chose to leave Him in. So, who repent and who was still there to accept you in His arms?all our stories are different...i once went back into the world and just hated it and didnt belong...so when i decided to go back He was there before i repented...oh yes i repented but not because i was scared He was so all over me first i think my repentance was out of gratitude....another time i just drifted inside...not in sin...just alseep at the wheel...like ephesus in revelation...same thing He was on me while i was seconds before calling on Him....Hes always faithful...but not intrusive. I cant imagine how anyone can reject Him, to be truthful.....but in my younger years things were not that clear. Again, I am glad you repent, but it canot be said that all will repent. Yes again, God is there waiting for that person to repent, but in no way will He force His Lordship on that person as it was spoken about above.

Im not against anyone warning people with truth. Im not a grace only teacher. -- Hmmm
Youd like to think so. -- who then approves of yuour posts if not the ones you say you are not a part of? One is know by the flock they flock with.Oh im sure everyone here that opposed you have rebuked many folks as often as it was necessary..but maybe with words seasoned with grace and always with the intent to restore...unless it was time to bid them farewell till they repented. And surely they all believe in total obedience to bad you never thought to ask. Reread...what you say is not the point I am making. I do not have to ask, I read what you say. So perhaps???????????????????? Well i sure dont remember what you have read or whether you even understood it...would have to examine that one by one. Do you mean you read into what i say? As to asking people what they believe, I trust what they write to be what they believe. Now if they do not believe what they write, then that would be a different story of a wayward wave.

But then you may think since i have my trust in the Lord
its because im wallowing in sin. -- that would be between you and God.But I will say that God's Spirit is not to be denied His leading. I trust my Lord and I have salvation. You say you have trust in Him, and accordingly, you have salvation. But never forget, that the reward is at the end of the race, not in the middle where there is pitfalls.Im not forgetting the race isnt over. But the race isnt with
God on the sidelines waiting for me to fall so He can laugh and condemn me...He died for me..He wants to purify me. Do you know why job didnt pack it in? maybe not.
OH but.......................He runs before us to show us the pitfalls and to give us directions to go around them......That is why He is called our faith's Forerunner.
Hmm ive not given that much thought ive fallen in alot of pits but He was there too. -- Abiding , yes He is there and will allllllllllllwayyyys be there WHEN we come back to Him in true repentance. God know the intent of the heart and He will not be mocked forever. There will come a time when one is not producing nothing but briers and thorns and it is in His providence that He decides that there is no more hope for one who seek forgiveness only for the instant.

But thats not even logical although its been all over
these threads.



This is getting quit long, can we break it down some, i will leave it up to you if you want to and how you want to. But I reread the every paragraph every time and it is getting to be to much for me to respond in a clear head.
Thanks i just read it ill reread tomorrow after work and glean what i think is important
to our convo and make a new smaller post..blessings :)
 
H

hopesprings

Guest
Isn't the whole idea that faith will produce works in your life? And if you have no works, then you really have no faith? Faith without works is dead. We don't work for our salvation, we work out our salvation (which would mean we already have it in a sense). Isn't that why Jesus said that we will know them by the fruits they produce? Maybe you guys already covered this but I always thought works were evidence of your faith....
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
Because we have free will. God told Abraham he would have a son, and this son would be a son of Promise. Abraham laughed, Then committed a adultery with his maid because he did not fully trust God. Did God fail to keep his promise because Abraham lacked faith and committed a grave sin? -- So did Adam and Eve, the fallen angels, so did the Hebrews, so did Judas, etc.... but yet they recieved the reverse of what Abraham did. Why? Because he remained faithful to God, even though he fell, his fall was not as complete.



Thats not the problem. The problem is your basing your eternal life on this. -- I base my everlasting (not eternal) life on this: I trust my Lord in all He promsied. I trust Him when He spoke through His Wisdom of what we need to do. I believed Him when He said that He will send His Spirit to led us into all Truths. I believe Him when He said I always with you. I put my confidence in Him as the One who will lead me home. He is my High Priest, and my everlasting sacrfice, because He from eternity came to assure me of this in the personage of Jesus Christ, my God.

And not on the work of Christ. Are you perfect? Knowing that there are numberous words whcih can be defined as perfect and I am sure you are not speaking about perfect as having been glorified, I will pick one of them which means equity. So, am I as righteous in my love towards all as God is: no. But I sure do try my best to be as my Father in Heaven. Should we say, I am perfect (completed) and in need of nothing to be able to stand justified before God: Yes. We have that through Jesus Christ. He is the only thing needed to make me complete as which is requirement before God's glory. But are you speaking of the perfect as to having no sin: well, have we not all said that we are not perfect in that sense? Thus, the reason we have an Advocate with our God.

If your not perfect. You have failed to meet the mark of being good enough to deserve eternal life -- Then again, I am complete (perfect) through faith and able to be presented to my Father blameless and without spot by my High Priest, Jesus Christ, the Son of the Most High.

Can an American stop being an American? Yes. Can a child of the rebellion stop being a child of the rebellion? Yes. Why then can we not stop being a child of God? Have we lost any freedom afforded to those who are not a child of God?
 
A

Abiding

Guest
Isn't the whole idea that faith will produce works in your life? And if you have no works, then you really have no faith? Faith without works is dead. We don't work for our salvation, we work out our salvation (which would mean we already have it in a sense). Isn't that why Jesus said that we will know them by the fruits they produce? Maybe you guys already covered this but I always thought works were evidence of your faith....
your absolutely correct that why those without works havnt true faith
and not true believers
 
C

cfultz3

Guest
cfultz3:who then approves of yuour posts if not the ones you say you are not a part of? One is know by the flock they flock with.

Well you do this if you want. I dont run in gangs. And there are people here i love
and if i disagree with them sobeit...that doesnt mean i write them off.

EG and i i think totally disagree with eschatology and in rest of scripture im hoping to learn
from him as i am with many others.

Likewise if someone likes my post...that doesnt mean they agree with anything else i say
or should they..unless of coarse they feel its true to the word.

By the way you may have made that mistake...someone who you agreed with in this op
you thumbs up and even went to battle with me when i clipped him for totally wrong stuff
id watch that kind of stuff...i call those gangs. What he said was a lie and it totally
dishonored and misrepresented God.

This is not the point I was making:

Please listen to every word (this is giving understand not contradiction or belittlement):

Birds of the same feather flocks together.

If by what you write a vast majority of those who gives you a 'like' based on what you have said, then what you have said is what they approve of. And it seems to me that those of the OSAS doctrine agrees greatly with you.

Although you say you are not OSAS, but by what you say, they are who agree with you the most.

The only reason I am bringing this up is because you say you are not OSAS and if you are not, then why are so many of your posts approved of by members of the OSAS?


I tried my best not to say anything negative to you are to others. So please, just take it at face value only.
 
P

psychomom

Guest
Chris--thank you so much for your reply. ♥
After having been flippant once before here (I am so sorry! :( ) I want to choose the words carefully before I answer.
Or, better yet, may the Lord choose them. :)

Back soon.
Thanks again-
ellie
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Likewise, I have been showing you all your error.

So then, I guess there is but one conclusion to all of this.

One is right and one is wrong.

If both is right, then Scripture is wrong.
I agree 100 %

You say faith alone is what saves and you have your proves.

I say faith without works is dead and I have my proves.
Again, I agree 100 % Faith without works IS DEAD. What we disagree on is what this means.

So, I guess, we need to reconcile those two differences or we both risk the change of posioning the babes and risk the change of being erased from the Book of Life.

That is the point. One of us is headed to heaven. One is evidently not. or can't prove he is because his salvation will be based on his future ability to do whatever he claims he has to do to keep saved.


And at this point, it is apparent that no one is willing to harmonize Scripture.
Ah, but scripture is in harmony. As I have been showing. It is your belief which causes God to contradict himself. Notice how twice now I have shown how abraham was saved, even though he commited Grave sin and God still kept his promise. Instead of responding to this. You went to adam and Eve, How am I supposed to listen to you or anyone like you when you refuse to stick to the positional facts? What does adam and eve have to do with Abraham and Gods promise given to him, inspite of his many sins?

But I will:
Faith alone saves, but faith without works is dead (non-existing)


Your right, If I claim I have faith but have ZERO WORKS. My faith is dead. Yet none of you will show how much work proves a faith is real. All this passage does is show that if we have zero zip nada works, we have zero zip nada faith. As James said, Can one be saved if he has no faith? The answer is a big resounding NO. .


They who are disobedient (refuse beleive and thus, obedience), do not have everlasting life abiding in them.
And have you ever heard me say they did? You telling me what I believe now, and at the same time saying this proves I am wrong, See the irony here?

So we see that they who are faithful are the ones who have life in them. And faithful expressed out is: remaining true to what was taught to us through the new Covenant.
In Christ, we have all we need for salvation. And without Him, we have nothing. And He said,

Joh 15:10If ye keep my commandments, ye shall abide in my love; even as I have kept my Father's commandments, and abide in his love

So, do we listen to our Lord and do as He has commanded us to do or do we say it is to much and abandon Him.
Do we listen to you and say this proves you can lose salvation? (especially when everything you just said is everything I have been saying except for the MUST part)

Or listen to paul and james who state that those who have faith out of the abundance and appreciation for what God did to them WILL WORK. Thus they can not lose salvation. because their actions will prove their faith.

Just like I showed earlier. Abraham did believe God, so he did leave, He did go to where God said, he did quite a few works. But he also disbelieved God, and laughed at him, commited adultry, Lied about his sister wife and many other things which were in disobedience. Yet God still kept his promise. Why? Because when God makes a promise he keeps it!
And as Paul said in Romans 4, Abraham was saved, not because he did those works, but because he had faith in what God said, And God took this faith and accredited Abraham as righteous, in spite of all his sin.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Isn't the whole idea that faith will produce works in your life? And if you have no works, then you really have no faith? Faith without works is dead. We don't work for our salvation, we work out our salvation (which would mean we already have it in a sense). Isn't that why Jesus said that we will know them by the fruits they produce? Maybe you guys already covered this but I always thought works were evidence of your faith....
Your 100 % right. Works don't save. Because those who do have faith will work. Thats why we are saved 100% by faith. and not by works. lest any man should boast.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Because we have free will. God told Abraham he would have a son, and this son would be a son of Promise. Abraham laughed, Then committed a adultery with his maid because he did not fully trust God. Did God fail to keep his promise because Abraham lacked faith and committed a grave sin? -- So did Adam and Eve, the fallen angels, so did the Hebrews, so did Judas, etc.... but yet they recieved the reverse of what Abraham did. Why? Because he remained faithful to God, even though he fell, his fall was not as complete.
So adam and eve commited adultry, Lied about each other, etc etc? Adam ate a fruit. And he died because he was alive before his fall, because he earned it.
Judas never had it, Scripture makes this clear.

Abraham remained faithfull, because he did have faith. Judas never had faith, thus why he continued to sin the whole time he was with them, and why he easily fell to the snare of satan.

Nice how you twisted things here. Abraham did nt completely fall? Did God tell abraham if you do this I will give you a son> a nation, anything? No. God fulfilled his promise in spite of abraham's sin and disbelief in many things. Just like he will us.




Thats not the problem. The problem is your basing your eternal life on this. -- I base my everlasting (not eternal) life on this: I trust my Lord in all He promsied. I trust Him when He spoke through His Wisdom of what we need to do. I believed Him when He said that He will send His Spirit to led us into all Truths. I believe Him when He said I always with you. I put my confidence in Him as the One who will lead me home. He is my High Priest, and my everlasting sacrfice, because He from eternity came to assure me of this in the personage of Jesus Christ, my God.
1. Everlasting means eternal. Nice way to try to twist it around.
2. Then why don't you believe him. Everything else you said is true, so why do you not trust him to do what he promised to do?


And not on the work of Christ. Are you perfect? Knowing that there are numberous words whcih can be defined as perfect and I am sure you are not speaking about perfect as having been glorified, I will pick one of them which means equity. So, am I as righteous in my love towards all as God is: no. But I sure do try my best to be as my Father in Heaven. Should we say, I am perfect (completed) and in need of nothing to be able to stand justified before God: Yes. We have that through Jesus Christ. He is the only thing needed to make me complete as which is requirement before God's glory. But are you speaking of the perfect as to having no sin: well, have we not all said that we are not perfect in that sense? Thus, the reason we have an Advocate with our God.
yet perfection is the ONLY WAY in which you can earn salvation on your own, and not need the grace of God. So why do you think you could ever be more righteous than anyone, and thus more deserving of eternal life? I don;t get it. and I don;t think you do either!

If your not perfect. You have failed to meet the mark of being good enough to deserve eternal life -- Then again, I am complete (perfect) through faith and able to be presented to my Father blameless and without spot by my High Priest, Jesus Christ, the Son of the Most High.

Can an American stop being an American? Yes. Can a child of the rebellion stop being a child of the rebellion? Yes. Why then can we not stop being a child of God? Have we lost any freedom afforded to those who are not a child of God? [/quote]

Why can;t you stop being a child of God? Because God adopted you into his family based on his work and his promise. If God all of a sudden nullified that adoption. he goes against his own promise.

I can;t stop being a child of my father. Through Blood I will always be his son, even if the courts state I am no longer his son for whatever reason, i would still be his son, because Blood is what unites us forever.

The same is with God. The blood of Christ is what united us, and it will untile us forever. Because it is the blood which caused adoption. Ads scripture says, as long as Christ, lives, i will live, He promised me I would never die, Never hunger or thirst, He would raise me, And I would have eternal life. So why don;t you believe him when he said those things?