A 5th Avenue Bar is a far superior Butterfinger - and it actually tastes like peanut butter. It's an American candy bar. There is a whole WORLD of sweets and chocolate out there...
Truly my favorite candies growing up were Cream Filberts (hazelnuts in a sugar coating that is amazing), Angel Food (a molasses puffed toffee - sorta like Violet Crumble for those of you with access to UK candy), and horehound hard candy - which you can find sometimes at retro/historic places. I have a soft spot for the old-fashioned stuff.