Hey Art05,
You brought up some interesting stuff. Why did you go off about how you're not good looking? If there are seriously no Christian girls your age there, then that's your problem. What you're doing is like going fishing in a lake with no fish and then calling yourself a terrible fisherman. If the lake has no fish, then it doesn't matter how good a fisherman you are! You get what I'm trying to say?
In any case, being good looking is not really a requirement for us men. I know you may think it is because it's important to you, but it's not as important to women. I know, strange right? But that's just how God made us. Dressing well, and looking well-groomed, is much more important than looking good. And it can be done on a tight budget.
From what you described, you don't sound boring to me. I used to talk about the Bible all the time and girls loved it. It shows them you're a strong man of God, but more importantly, it shows that you're passionate about something. Keep talking about the Bible; a really special Bible-loving girl will find that REALLY attractive! As far as video games and anime go, most girls don't like that kind of stuff, but that's really a non-issue. Most girls don't like watching football, weight lifting, or working on cars either, but I'm sure you know that guys that do like those things don't get turned down by many girls because of their hobbies. Guys and girls, for the most part, enjoy doing different things. Trying to find a girl who enjoys video games is missing the point; you're looking for a life partner and co-parent, not a video game partner. Make bro-friends for that.
And don't ignore that last sentence. Make bro-friends! It's really, REALLY important for a man to have friends who are other men. There are a plethora of reasons for this, but suffice it to say, if you really don't have any friends, make friends FIRST, then look for a lady.