Do You Attract the Same Kinds of Potential Dates Online as In Real Life?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,683
5,601
113
#21
id like to know who ever came up with the term "catfish" what a stupid term to call fraud. they need to be smacked upside the head hard,
Wise, I think you are naturally attracted to "stupid" people--because you want to correct them, of course!! :p

I'm kidding, I'm kidding! Please don't hurt me! :D
 
Nov 25, 2014
942
44
0
#22
Here are kinds of men I attract in real life: 1) Alphas who have control issues and who view my kindness as weakness and 2) Men in crisis who love my kindness and empathy...for awhile.

I think I attract these men because I have a commitment to goodness and doing the right thing. So, the Alphas are like, "Can I make the good girl bad?" (No...no...you can't). And the Crisismen are like, "Can I soak up some of this goodness." (Yes, you can. I'm a compassionate person).

After years of falling for these men, I mostly don't anymore (occasionally a really clever one will hook me). Now when I encounter these men, I immediately friend-zone both groups. The Alphas will then be amused by me and not try to adjust or control me while vacillating between flirting with me and treating me like a bro. The Crisismen will at first say, "But I really like you" (No you don't, you just want some empathy), but I hold the line and eventually they realize that they're not really interested in me so much as my ability to empathize.

Online here are the men I attract: 1) Men in crisis 2) Younger men 3) Married men OR 4) Younger married men in crisis.

I attribute all of that to the magical unicorn properties of the online environment and the ability of people to project what they desire onto others in this environment. After being online for over 20 years, I've discovered that if you're kind to people sometimes they will paint an unrealistic image of you in their heads and then proceed to develop feelings for that image.

As for Catfish, here's what I think. I think a goodly number of people who seriously catfish are psychopaths. They have the ability to present themselves as YOUR magical unicorn. They are uncanny at reading and discovering your hidden desires. So, if you meet your magical unicorn online, probably it's really a catfish.
 
Nov 25, 2014
942
44
0
#23
id like to know who ever came up with the term "catfish" what a stupid term to call fraud. they need to be smacked upside the head hard,
The term "catfish" came from the documentary by that name about a young man who was fooled by a woman online. They'd had a long-term relationship and she'd presented herself as someone in her 20s, etc. He tracked her down and discovered that she was a 40-something married woman. Her husband told the filmmaker a story about cod and catfish that led to the title of the film.

Here's a link to read about it:

Catfish meaning and definition: term for online hoaxes has a surprisingly long history.
 

Tinkerbell725

Senior Member
Jul 19, 2014
4,216
1,179
113
Philippines Age 40
#24
Here are kinds of men I attract in real life: 1) Alphas who have control issues and who view my kindness as weakness and 2) Men in crisis who love my kindness and empathy...for awhile.

I think I attract these men because I have a commitment to goodness and doing the right thing. So, the Alphas are like, "Can I make the good girl bad?" (No...no...you can't). And the Crisismen are like, "Can I soak up some of this goodness." (Yes, you can. I'm a compassionate person).

After years of falling for these men, I mostly don't anymore (occasionally a really clever one will hook me). Now when I encounter these men, I immediately friend-zone both groups. The Alphas will then be amused by me and not try to adjust or control me while vacillating between flirting with me and treating me like a bro. The Crisismen will at first say, "But I really like you" (No you don't, you just want some empathy), but I hold the line and eventually they realize that they're not really interested in me so much as my ability to empathize.

Online here are the men I attract: 1) Men in crisis 2) Younger men 3) Married men OR 4) Younger married men in crisis.

I attribute all of that to the magical unicorn properties of the online environment and the ability of people to project what they desire onto others in this environment. After being online for over 20 years, I've discovered that if you're kind to people sometimes they will paint an unrealistic image of you in their heads and then proceed to develop feelings for that image.

As for Catfish, here's what I think. I think a goodly number of people who seriously catfish are psychopaths. They have the ability to present themselves as YOUR magical unicorn. They are uncanny at reading and discovering your hidden desires. So, if you meet your magical unicorn online, probably it's really a catfish.
I can relate and wow 20 years is quite a long time, no wonder you sound really wise about the subject matter. I learned a lot from your post. So how can we find a real man when we keep on attracting dysfunctional men? I guess we ought to go through with them because when it rains we dont have an umbrella that would filter out the few crazies. Lol!
 

Roh_Chris

Senior Member
Jun 15, 2014
4,728
58
48
#25
And so, dear readers, I'm curious: do you attract the same kinds of people online as you do in real life?

It doesn't have to be just potential dates--what about friends, mentors, or people you relate to? If you seem to attract different groups of people through different social medias, why do you think that is?
Barring the Christian aspect, I think I attract the same kinds of people, both in real and in virtual life, and also as dates and as friends. It is true that I have large social circles in my real life, but the handful of friends whom I am close to, share remarkably similar traits to my girlfriend. However, the same cannot be said of my friends at Church or of my colleagues at office, and this could explain why I feel so disconnected there.

I think I attract the same kind of people because I behave the same way whether I am socialising online or offline. In the case of individuals who attract different kinds of people, they could be displaying different facets of their personalities in different environments.
 
Nov 25, 2014
942
44
0
#26
I can relate and wow 20 years is quite a long time, no wonder you sound really wise about the subject matter. I learned a lot from your post. So how can we find a real man when we keep on attracting dysfunctional men? I guess we ought to go through with them because when it rains we dont have an umbrella that would filter out the few crazies. Lol!
In defense of men, I don't think that either of the groups that I typically attract in real life are crazy. They're just not good matches for me.

Some women like men who really take charge and make a lot of decisions, etc. I think some of those Alphas find me to be a challenge and want to try and "tame" me or "make me submit" or "adjust" my uppity attitude, OR because I'm kind they think I'm more moldable and demure and they're unhappy when they find that's not so accurate.

As for the Crisismen, I think it's likely that I'm not really for them. Lots of the Crisismen I've met were attracted to my empathy due to their circumstances. They presumed it meant they were attracted to me, but once the crisis passes, the attraction fades. Lots of these men, btw, were really interesting pretty cool guys.

All of these men were "real men." I think I'm just a fairly challenging match for any man.

So, I don't think I have a lot of wisdom to offer about how to find a good match. If I knew how, I would have by now, right?

I think I know more how to realize that you're not a match and how to end it kindly....and this has been through hard experience.

So, the article I could write would be more like, "How To Avoid Wasting Time Dating People Not Into You," than "How to Get a Husband in Five Easy Steps."


 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,683
5,601
113
#27
Barring the Christian aspect, I think I attract the same kinds of people, both in real and in virtual life, and also as dates and as friends. It is true that I have large social circles in my real life, but the handful of friends whom I am close to, share remarkably similar traits to my girlfriend. However, the same cannot be said of my friends at Church or of my colleagues at office, and this could explain why I feel so disconnected there.

I think I attract the same kind of people because I behave the same way whether I am socialising online or offline. In the case of individuals who attract different kinds of people, they could be displaying different facets of their personalities in different environments.
I've thought about this too... And it's kind of fascinating to me that people can project completely different personalities in different situations... But I guess it's kind of like how you act different at a family function than you would at church or with your friends.

Like I said, I guess if they made a "chart" of my personality, it would be a flatline, because people always say, "You're just the same in person as you are in writing!" I certainly don't see it as something bad.

What can I say, I can turn consistency into an art form! ;)

However, those who've met or talked to me in person can also attest to the fact that when all the restraints of proper social expectations are lifted, I tend to say even more controversial things (using a few words that are much too strong for a Christian forum. It's a personal flaw... and I'm working on that.)
 

Tinkerbell725

Senior Member
Jul 19, 2014
4,216
1,179
113
Philippines Age 40
#28
In defense of men, I don't think that either of the groups that I typically attract in real life are crazy. They're just not good matches for me.

Some women like men who really take charge and make a lot of decisions, etc. I think some of those Alphas find me to be a challenge and want to try and "tame" me or "make me submit" or "adjust" my uppity attitude, OR because I'm kind they think I'm more moldable and demure and they're unhappy when they find that's not so accurate.

As for the Crisismen, I think it's likely that I'm not really for them. Lots of the Crisismen I've met were attracted to my empathy due to their circumstances. They presumed it meant they were attracted to me, but once the crisis passes, the attraction fades. Lots of these men, btw, were really interesting pretty cool guys.

All of these men were "real men." I think I'm just a fairly challenging match for any man.

So, I don't think I have a lot of wisdom to offer about how to find a good match. If I knew how, I would have by now, right?

I think I know more how to realize that you're not a match and how to end it kindly....and this has been through hard experience.

So, the article I could write would be more like, "How To Avoid Wasting Time Dating People Not Into You," than "How to Get a Husband in Five Easy Steps."


Thanks! Very well said.
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,683
5,601
113
#29
As for Catfish, here's what I think. I think a goodly number of people who seriously catfish are psychopaths. They have the ability to present themselves as YOUR magical unicorn. They are uncanny at reading and discovering your hidden desires. So, if you meet your magical unicorn online, probably it's really a catfish.
This is why I think this is so important to talk about in the Christian community especially.

As Christians, we sometimes take "faith" and turn it into "magical thinking", dividing the point between common sense and reality.

There might be red flags all over the field, but in "faith", we'll say, "Oh no, I'm a Child of a King, and God only wants The Best for me, and Look!! He's used the internet to lead me right to that Perfect Person! It's God! It's God's Doing! And Surely, It's God's Will That We Be Together!!"

Never mind that you don't even really know who that person is.

This is why I've been talking about a string of subjects and am tying them altogether--because it follows our whole line of thinking as Christians, and though we should have faith, we can't use faith as an excuse to completely ignore reality.
 

Tinkerbell725

Senior Member
Jul 19, 2014
4,216
1,179
113
Philippines Age 40
#30
Being christians I dont agree that we should isolate ourselves from the real world or that we should close our doors from non christians. They are also under God's sovereign hands and who knows He is using us christians to reach out to them. I believe every person we meet is a holy encounter, it has divine intervention. It is up to us to try and let the light of christ shine through us. After all,everyone of us is a work in progress, we might as well help each other.
 
C

coby

Guest
#31
Hey Everyone,

I was hoping to stagger these threads over a week or so, but due to time constraints I'm just going to go ahead and post this now.

We've already talked about "dating within our league" and unrealistic expectations, so now I'm wondering--if you have been part of a dating service (especially online), do you tend to attract the same kind of people in both everyday life and cyberspace?

I grew up in the same general area for most of my life, but a while back, I lived in a very different area across the country. I remember thinking, "Will people perceive me any differently than the people I've grown up with all my life? Will I be part of a different 'crowd'"?

Here's what I've found--socially, I'm as consistent as a flat line, no matter where I go or who I run into. I'm always seen as "the church girl", "the one who thinks too much and asks too many questions," and, to the party people, "B.O.R.I.N.G." Now granted, I'm not complaining. There are much worse reputations to be had.

But I've also found that even since I was a teenager, I always attract the same kind of men: 1. those who are many decades older, 2. those who are going through a crisis, and 3. the sweet, wonderful, guy-next-door types whom I adore, but we always wind up being just friends (and the guys involved often get married in the meantime.)

One of the fascinations with online dating seems to be the question as to whether or not someone can "move up in the ranks" and be able to date someone "in a higher league"--which in some cases, leads to the fake profiles and catfishing. I've also known some married people who are secretly on dating sites because they want to "see what's out there" and "see what I can attract", because they are hoping to find an "upgrade" from their spouse. Whether people are honest about who they are or not, online dating seems to be seen as a way to "move up" the romantic and social ladder.

I believe that one of the things that's saved me from falling into the clutches of a total catfish is knowing whom I attract. In all the years I've been on dating sites, I've had 3 men contact me who made themselves out to be CEO-types and had ridiculously handsome profile photos (personally, I never trust model-quality photos--I've heard too many bad stories and have never known of anyone who turned out to be real.) Two turned out to be catfish (one was courting several other girls, which is how I found out), another was married, and the third was honestly way beyond my league (if he was who he said he was) and wasn't afraid to let me know it.

I know who I am. And I know that whether in real life or online, I don't attract models or moguls (that's not a put-down in either direction, it's just a fact and part of knowing who you are), so if someone who puts up a front appears to be any of these things, I will take him at his word, but I will also be... extremely cautious.

I'm getting to a point where I won't let my heart budge much until I met the person in real life--and it would have to long enough to be sure they are who they say they are.

And so, dear readers, I'm curious: do you attract the same kinds of people online as you do in real life?

It doesn't have to be just potential dates--what about friends, mentors, or people you relate to? If you seem to attract different groups of people through different social medias, why do you think that is?
Irl I don't attract anybody, since my age most are married or not interested, online I do a good job with handsome men from theStates and England who want to date a single mom in Holland, funny guys those love scammers, I said try something better please, I'm not that stupid and just dumped or also twice divorced guys, but I always put such stuff in my profile.
 
M

Miri

Guest
#32
I don't do on line dating, I just cannot see how it is ever possible to
get to know a real human being warts and all on line.

I want to see people, see their environment, see how they act in real
life and the people they associate with.

Having said that if you want an on line date then just go into
CC chat. Every time I go in there I get pm'd by complete strangers
every single time all men, often several at once. So much so that
I've had to put a notice on my profile that I don't mind chatting with
people but that's all it is.
 

Roh_Chris

Senior Member
Jun 15, 2014
4,728
58
48
#33
I've thought about this too... And it's kind of fascinating to me that people can project completely different personalities in different situations... But I guess it's kind of like how you act different at a family function than you would at church or with your friends.

Like I said, I guess if they made a "chart" of my personality, it would be a flatline, because people always say, "You're just the same in person as you are in writing!" I certainly don't see it as something bad.

I don't think either behaviour is wrong. It's just how some people are - consistent or varying. The consistent people are likely to receive the same kind of feedback from all their social circles, whereas the other group of people would get different feedback depending on which circle they interact with. It's definitely an interesting pattern of behaviour, and I wonder how would such people behave in a relationship - would they reveal all their sides to that special someone or hide a few?
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,704
9,636
113
#34
I've never attracted a date online so I wouldn't know.

But that last line in the OP, that I can answer. People I hit it off with here on the forum are pretty much like the people I talk to in real life. Moderately cool, more than moderately intelligent, good sense of humor (a requirement for putting up with my foolishness) and avidly curious about stuff in general. I can deal with other types of people but that's the kind that seem to both want to talk to me and be able to hold my attention.
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
27,704
9,636
113
#35
Also I seem to attract confidences just as much online as in real life. Not sure how I give off the "I'm a good listener" vibe in a text based medium, but I seem to.
 

Reborn

Senior Member
Nov 16, 2014
4,087
217
63
#36
I'm curious: do you attract the same kinds of people online as you do in real life?
Real people are more odd than the oddballs I meet online.

I'm not sure about attraction, all I know is, I have to go online to meet normal people.
Why? Being online is the new normal.

Talking to real life people is too real.
........and since it's not online, it doesn't feel normal.
 

melita916

Senior Member
Aug 12, 2011
10,467
2,704
113
#37
as for the opposite sex, in real life, as far as i know, i was always considered as "one of the guys." if anyone in the past was attracted to me, i never knew. i was always the friend, never the girlfriend lol.

now online, in chatrooms, i would get messages from guys complimenting me and whatnot, which was a totally different world to me since i never really got that kind of attention in real life. then again, online, i am more "open" to talk with others. in person, i can be awkward and shy. it takes me a while to get comfortable, while online, i'm words on a screen. don't get me wrong. i don't act differently. it's just that in person, it takes me a while to open up.
 
J

jeremyPJ

Guest
#38
life is so confusing for me with this very issue. Most of my life I've been "eaten alive" by people (friends, daters, "frienemies", etc.) that I must admit that as smart as I thought I was, I am a real dummy, truth be told. I've been played by about every type of person imaginable, of both sexes. My last ex and friends win the dubious "gotcha! award". They are the ones who woke me up to "me". I've always been told I'm too nice, and the proof is in.

My therapist says I'm a rare breed, I'm a truly good person. Been going to him for three years to understand people and my background. Who I am. Basically he says that "bad folks" see us as a way to justify themselves as good people because the bad ones are hurting inside so they bring others down to their level. I've been studying this online for a while. I'm not even considering dating right now, because I'm living and learning who I really am, as opposed to the person who has been oppressed by trying to get along with others who weren't so good.

On that note, the ones who I've met who were good people over the years have usually shunned me because they think I'm too good to be true, or their friends who influence them that I'm too short to be dateable. (5'6"). I have learned that among women over the years this is the ultimate sin. This is a very interesting and complicated topic for me, I just got up lol!
I hope i'm making sense...dating in life is what other people are able to influence each other that it is. I'ts that simple, certainly not fair but what among the human condition is? Really not much.
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,683
5,601
113
#39
I love reading the answers here because it's intriguing to me to imagine what everyone must be like in real life.

On a lighter note... I've already warned you all that in real life, I've been known to swear, so I apologize in advance for that.

Additionally, I also have a habit of randomly cuddling people and/or severely threatening to cuddle them, depending on what I think I can get away with at the time and who would or would not have me arrested. :D

And if I happen to randomly cuddle you while swearing, it's truly a sign that I like you.

(For those who think I'm actually a predator, by "cuddling", I mean randomly hugging people.)