The Gap vs. New Creationism Propaganda

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
B

BeyondET

Guest
Can't really understand what you are saying here?

I will answer for how I take it.

"Where were you when I laid the foundation of the earth?" Why couldn't of Job answered this question? He could of just said, "seven/six days before you created man."

Job 38 indicates that there was life near when God laid the foundation of the earth. All the angels shouted for joy.
you talking about verses - 7
I haven't seen anything mentioning life other than verse 7 mentioning the morning stars sang together and all the Sons of God shouted for joy. Though many bibles have their own wording.
 

DP

Banned
Sep 27, 2015
3,325
41
0
Who did this? I already said, No one knows how long after adam was created, that he sinned, it could have been many years..
How long AFTER Adam was created? What makes you think Satan didn't sin until after... Adam was created? Where's Biblical proof for that?

I can show you Biblical proof against that idea. It's the parable of Ezekiel 28 about Satan when God originally created him perfect, and then he rebelled against God. Satan coveted God's Throne was what his sin was about, it wasn't about tempting Adam and Eve to sin. When Satan as "that old serpent" shows up in Gen.3 to tempt Eve, that shows he was already in his role as tempter, meaning already fallen, and already an enemy.

Moreover, the Scripture about Christ and His Kingdom being ordained before the foundation of this world also points to that being required to defeat death and Satan, meaning Satan's rebellion had to have been prior to the creation of this world.



So satan fell before the heavens and the earth were created? well you just destroyed your own theory, Because if that is true, Then God could have then created the heavens and the earth in 6 literal 24 hour periods. In thise time, created adam and eve, and then later. Satan deceived eve, and her and her husband fell. causing the deterioration of life as we know it.
Satan fell in Peter's "world that then was":

[/COLOR]2 Peter 3:5-6
5
For this they willingly are ignorant of, that by the word of God the heavens were of old, and the earth standing out of the water and in the water:
6 Whereby the world that then was, being overflowed with water, perished:
KJV


That by the Word of God the heavens were of old is when God first created the heavens and the earth at Gen.1:1. At Gen.1:2-9 is when the earth was "standing out of the water and in the water", as that's about God moving the waters around on the earth, creating the sky, and then making the dry land appear (again). That old world was "overflowed with water" and it "perished." That's what many are willingly ignorant of.


dude , You responded to my post of how death could not have come before adam's sin, That is the topic of our discussion. So keep on topic. or move on, Because I am sick of your false accusations, and lack of humility whenever we talk of these things.
Whoo Hoo, Hullaballoo! Simply admit you are willingly ignorant of these things in God's Word.


The spiritual death of spiritual beings can not be equated to death of phsyical beings.
I see you like to try and make God's Rules for Him. Who told you the power of death having been assigned to Satan because of his sin could not be imparted to rebellion in the flesh via Adam and Eve? Obviously per the end of Gen.3, Adam and Eve having access to the Tree of Life allowed their flesh to be in the state it was prior to Adam's fall. It's removal by God changed that, showing death was already in residence in their imperfect 'flesh'. Paul said God made today's creation subject to vanity, and that applies to man's flesh also, even Adam and Eve's!


Um Nope. Satans spiritual death did, Satan did not die physically, nor did physical death occure because of satans sin..
Well, yes Satan's sin, and being given the power of death, is how the 'concept' of death began. And the fact that death and hell are destroyed reveals this too. It's how it become possible for death to be assigned to Adam and Eve for sinning also.


He is the author of lies, and because of his lies, and the fact Adam and Eve listened to him and not God, He is said to be the father of death..

He did not cause, or create death.. The garden was perfect.. There was no death in pre sin period.. God created the heavens and the earth and all life (including man) and God said it was good.
Then why did John say our Lord Jesus was manifested for the purpose to destroy the devil? And if God's Eden was perfect in the time of Adam and Eve, then how was Satan, having already fallen, there as Tempter? Let Scripture shape your thinking, not men's traditions.

God's creation of this present world is still a wonderous act that only He could do. I'm not knocking that, but I'm not going to knock what Apostle Paul said either in Rom.8, that God made the creation subject to vanity, and in bondage to corruption. Now which do you argue with, because I stand for what is written in God's Word.


What does this have to do with physical death for millions of years of creatures ansd life on earth before adam sinned?

Jesus himself said, because of adams sin, God cursed the ground, Meaning the earth started to die at that moment, In fact, at that moment all creation has started to die.
The ground being cursed to Adam because of his sin was about its produce. Adam would have to labor to get it to produce. That is not about God having made the creation in bondage to corruption. Paul show God created this world in bondage, not that it was create perfect first and then went into bondage, which is what you would be saying.


Paul did not say this, it says creation is in bondgage, awaiting until it is restored.

Creation was not in bondage until sin, and the earth was nnot in bondage until Adam sinned.

"ps, now who is saying God created evil, You just claimed that very thing yourself..
Satan sinned in the world that then was, a world before this present one created at Gen.1:2 forward. This present creation was made in bondage to corruption, placed also in the same hope we have in the redemption. When you redeem something, it means you once had it, lost it, and now are going to redeem it back to yourself. That's not about God creating evil, it's about God placing His creation in bondage with us because of Satan's evil, and our waiting for the time when God will redeem both His creation and us, which is the idea Paul was preaching in Rom.8.


Who gave you the idea that perfection means one can be physically ill and eventually die, and can not sin?

If this was the case, Jesus telling adam and eve they will start to die the moment they ate of that tree is meaningless. They were already going to die anyway.
....

God made us perfect in the way he designed us.. We destroyed that when we sinned..
I never said one can be physically ill and die, and not sin. While we are in the flesh we will always be subject to sin, like Paul taught in Romans.

Adam and Eve were partaking of the Tree of Life in God's Garden, something you forgot.

God did not... make Adam and Eve perfect. If that were so, then they could never have sin. It was a sin of the flesh that Eve was subjected, pleasant to the eyes.


there you go again, God created evil, so he can glorify his son.
One of the things I have never... said nor inferred, was that God created evil. That's apparently what you believe, because you cannot understand how God could create Satan perfect and then allow him to rebel against Him, bringing wickedness. That's something you need to read up on more in God's Word, and not from men's traditions.

No. If mankind never sinned God still would have been glorified, the only difference is his son could remained in heaven and the corss never would occure.
But God knew that would not happen, So instead of changing his mind, and never making man,, He made a plan to save men, then made them, knowing they would fall.
If you're saying it was inevitable that Adam and Eve would sin, and was necessary so Christ could come, then I agree. But it was so because of their 'flesh' being imperfect, not perfect. Only a body that is eternal is not subject to death. Obviously their bodies were not eternal.


 

DP

Banned
Sep 27, 2015
3,325
41
0
Isaiah 45:7

I form the light, and create darkness:

I make peace, and create evil:

I the Lord do all these things.
yeah, but it's for THIS world that God does those things, meaning AFTER Satan had already started it all. God uses Satan as a punishing rod.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Thanks EG.

Can you give an example of one of your questions and how the flood answered it?
One of the biggest one was the fossil theory.

A fossil is created when an animal dies, or is buried alive, then sediment covers the body and hardens before the body decomposes, leaving a void, or fossil in its place.

Fossils do not occure over decades, or millions of years of decay, they occure frequent, or in flood situations.. (although their may be some which may, like an animal getting caught in a tar pit, then that tar pit hardening forever soon after the animal died)

Also, the way in which the fossil record as seen, could readily be explained by a global catastrophic flood.. Not billions of years of life on earth with different ages.


Why are fossils on the top of Mt Everest? well that can be explained, if the mountain was created during a catastrophic flood. the fossil were made in the early stages of the flood, then the mountain was created, and the earth buckled and lifted up.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest


How long AFTER Adam was created? What makes you think Satan didn't sin until after... Adam was created? Where's Biblical proof for that?



ok, I am about fed up with this nonsense.


If you can not read what I say and want to continue this nonsense of slandering me to prove your point, then I refuse to answer any ore of your comments.

I NEVER SAID SATAN SINNED AFTER ADAM.

That is nonsense.
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
One of the biggest one was the fossil theory.

A fossil is created when an animal dies, or is buried alive, then sediment covers the body and hardens before the body decomposes, leaving a void, or fossil in its place.

Fossils do not occure over decades, or millions of years of decay, they occure frequent, or in flood situations.. (although their may be some which may, like an animal getting caught in a tar pit, then that tar pit hardening forever soon after the animal died)

Also, the way in which the fossil record as seen, could readily be explained by a global catastrophic flood.. Not billions of years of life on earth with different ages.


Why are fossils on the top of Mt Everest? well that can be explained, if the mountain was created during a catastrophic flood. the fossil were made in the early stages of the flood, then the mountain was created, and the earth buckled and lifted up.
Thank you. And from my studies, I come up with 2 floods. One of which judged the earth AND the heavens.

IMO, this is the Flood Peter talks about. Not the flood of Noah. No one overlooks that flood. and Noahs flood didn't judge the heavens of old.

2 Pet 3~~4and saying, “Where is the promise of His coming? For ever since the fathers fell asleep, all continues just as it was from the beginning of creation.” 5For when they maintain this, it escapes their notice that by the word of God the heavens existed long ago and the earth was formed out of water and by water, 6through which the world at that time was destroyed, being flooded with water.
 
E

eph610

Guest
One of the biggest one was the fossil theory.

A fossil is created when an animal dies, or is buried alive, then sediment covers the body and hardens before the body decomposes, leaving a void, or fossil in its place.

Fossils do not occure over decades, or millions of years of decay, they occure frequent, or in flood situations.. (although their may be some which may, like an animal getting caught in a tar pit, then that tar pit hardening forever soon after the animal died)

Also, the way in which the fossil record as seen, could readily be explained by a global catastrophic flood.. Not billions of years of life on earth with different ages.


Why are fossils on the top of Mt Everest? well that can be explained, if the mountain was created during a catastrophic flood. the fossil were made in the early stages of the flood, then the mountain was created, and the earth buckled and lifted up.
I saw a show on discovery a few nights ago called draining the oceans, or something like that...and it showed what the earth would like without any of the oceans and it was pretty amazing....
 
E

eph610

Guest
Thank you. And from my studies, I come up with 2 floods. One of which judged the earth AND the heavens.

IMO, this is the Flood Peter talks about. Not the flood of Noah. No one overlooks that flood. and Noahs flood didn't judge the heavens of old.

2 Pet 3~~4and saying, “Where is the promise of His coming? For ever since the fathers fell asleep, all continues just as it was from the beginning of creation.” 5For when they maintain this, it escapes their notice that by the word of God the heavens existed long ago and the earth was formed out of water and by water, 6through which the world at that time was destroyed, being flooded with water.
There was not a Lucifer and then Noah flood...Chalmers took Psalm 104 completely out of context when he started his theory....
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
There was not a Lucifer and then Noah flood...Chalmers took Psalm 104 completely out of context when he started his theory....
Who is Chalmers?
 
E

eph610

Guest
GAP is based on Old Earth practices that align directly with the OLD earth practices among theistic and secular evolutionists.
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
Thomas Chalmers originated the GAP theory and it was picked by many others including CI Scofield...
Ok. Now I have heard of Scofield, and have read some of his stuff. But not much. I have been tempted to read more of Scofield, He gets such a bad rap he must of been pretty close to the truth.

How did Chalmers take Psalm 104 out of context?
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
GAP is based on Old Earth practices that align directly with the OLD earth practices among theistic and secular evolutionists.
What are Old earth practices?

And the GAP idea doesn't have anything to do with evolution. Evolution is from the mouth of satan.
 
E

eph610

Guest
Ok. Now I have heard of Scofield, and have read some of his stuff. But not much. I have been tempted to read more of Scofield, He gets such a bad rap he must of been pretty close to the truth.

How did Chalmers take Psalm 104 out of context?
Scofield was an abuser of alcohol, emotional abuser to his wife and his own kids. He was a cheat and forger and spent time in federal prison for cheating, tax evasion and many other things. He was also a male chauvinist of his times.

It puzzles me that you hold to a theory and have no knowledge of where it came from....Start digging and you will find out how Chalmers and others used Jeremiah 4 and Psalm 104 and many other scriptures to deceive millions....

GAP Theory gives a theological frosting to the cake of natural science, so the carnal mind of a Christian can be appeased.
 
E

eph610

Guest
What are Old earth practices?

And the GAP idea doesn't have anything to do with evolution. Evolution is from the mouth of satan.
You need to stop listening to communicated "Bible" Knowledge and start digging into the lie that is GAP theory.

GAP theory agrees with natural science that the earth, in present form, has to be millions of years old. GAP is also from the mouth of Satan, because it glorifies Satan and makes God look foolish and inept....I am not going to do your homework for you.....

Anything that makes Satan look good and God look silly is of Satan...
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Ok. Now I have heard of Scofield, and have read some of his stuff. But not much. I have been tempted to read more of Scofield, He gets such a bad rap he must of been pretty close to the truth.

How did Chalmers take Psalm 104 out of context?

Scofield is where I first heard of the Gap Theory. It is in his Scofield reference bible. Which I have used since my first bible An old Scofield reference KJV I currently own a Scofield reference 3 NKJV which I use as my main bible..

He has a lot of good things.. And he does get a bad rap. GAP is one of his flaws in my opinion.. For many reasons. Not just the one I just stated..

I do not buy into the 2 flood theory.. I know many teach it, But after thorough examination. I no longer hold to it..

In Gen, when the bible says the fountains of the great deep opened. I think this was a major earth shattering experience. I Have read two views,, 1 being the catastrophic plate tectonic view, and the other being the hydroplate theory view.. Both of which I believe have more backing and biblical support than the GAP view.. I actually believe the truth is most likely parts taken from both views.. Not just one of them..

As usual in Christian politics, they reject each other,, which is sad, I think if they could come together, we would see even more of The truth.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
You need to stop listening to communicated "Bible" Knowledge and start digging into the lie that is GAP theory.

GAP theory agrees with natural science that the earth, in present form, has to be millions of years old. GAP is also from the mouth of Satan, because it glorifies Satan and makes God look foolish and inept....I am not going to do your homework for you.....

Anything that makes Satan look good and God look silly is of Satan...

Hey bro, This is kind of harsh, Lets not be like DP.. We were getting some good conversation with Gr8Grace,, Lets try to discuss and not judge, ok?

I think we have an opportunity for actually study ad discussion here, would hate to see it destroyed because our pride gets in the way..
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
You need to stop listening to communicated "Bible" Knowledge and start digging into the lie that is GAP theory.

GAP theory agrees with natural science that the earth, in present form, has to be millions of years old. GAP is also from the mouth of Satan, because it glorifies Satan and makes God look foolish and inept....I am not going to do your homework for you.....

Anything that makes Satan look good and God look silly is of Satan...
Well thanks for your all your help. I can answer like this too.

You need to fall off of the turnip truck and regurgitating turnip things. And start digging into the lie of YEC.

YEC is a false premise that totally denies Gods word, in order to "fight" evolution. And YEC forgets that God IS science. It is history~~HIS story. YEC hides the true reason we are here and what Gods purpose is for us as a lower creation.

The GAP exposes satan and his fall and all His "silly" arrogance and pride. He devised YEC to hide this truth.

Hows that work? Who won this debate?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Well thanks for your all your help. I can answer like this too.

You need to fall off of the turnip truck and regurgitating turnip things. And start digging into the lie of YEC.

YEC is a false premise that totally denies Gods word, in order to "fight" evolution. And YEC forgets that God IS science. It is history~~HIS story. YEC hides the true reason we are here and what Gods purpose is for us as a lower creation.

The GAP exposes satan and his fall and all His "silly" arrogance and pride. He devised YEC to hide this truth.

Hows that work? Who won this debate?
although he deserved this,, I pray we can start over, and actually discuss it..
 
G

Gr8grace

Guest
In Gen, when the bible says the fountains of the great deep opened. I think this was a major earth shattering experience. I Have read two views,, 1 being the catastrophic plate tectonic view, and the other being the hydroplate theory view.. Both of which I believe have more backing and biblical support than the GAP view..
From my studies EG, I don't see how the GAP idea can eliminate those scenerios? The GAP idea could go right along with both of those conclusions.