Are you Christian or Jewish...

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
37,721
13,521
113
Oh they sure will learn a lot more by listening to all and sundry.....
but will it be the Truth ?
why did He make disciples, and then tell them to make more disciples?
kinda the same reason He gave the tribe of Levi, right?
what did Levi do - apart from being employed in ritual ordinances? what was the purpose God gave them?
 
D

Depleted

Guest
No, no issue. I understand and am advised on rational action by my brain. I am advised also from my heart, it provides the instinctual understanding and also my heart is how I feel connection with God.
I have worked hard at my logic. It is particularly important to me because I am a woman, thus instinct goes with react-by-emotions.

That said, so you understand I really do appreciate rational advise.

BUT, look carefully at what you've said, and compare it to how people responded to it. (You don't even have to answer every response. I'm honestly asking you to think out the logic of what was said on both sides -- yours and everyone else.) And honestly ask yourself if your logic is working.

Time and time again, folks have told why it isn't.

And then once you start questioning exactly how logical you are, then take it one step further. Since your logic isn't working, (not trying to be mean here. If my logic isn't working, I want people to tell me why not), is your heart doing any better?

Now, the natural man -- the emotional man (or woman) -- is going to go with, "of course." BUT then you have to go back to remember, your brain isn't working right either. You thought it was logical, but it was proved illogical.

That leaves you at a place everyone here has already been. (We really have. And, if we have not, then we're still where you are.) Since you cannot trust your own brain or heart, where do you go? What do you do?

Sure, you can see a shrink, but I don't think you're that kind of loss. You're problem is you were born in a world full of people who all think they're thinking and feeling right. But they aren't. The nut jobs in England running large vehicles into pedestrians? The whackos shooting Senators or ramming their cars into protesters in the States? The maniacs hating women and children enough to enact Sharia Laws? The simple dude who thinks purse snatching is the obvious thing to do. They all think they are just as rational and heart driven as you do.

We're all whacked! We can't think right or feel right. That requires the Lord to heal us of our very corrupted minds and hearts.

So when you go back and search out exactly how illogical you are, please! Do the obvious. Ask! Ask us what you want to know about the Lord -- the real Lord, Not the Red-Letter-Jesus you don't really follow at all.

He's right there. All you have to do is get to the point of realizing how much you need him. ALL of him!
 

preacher4truth

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,718
113
I need no man to teach me, and can take a verse out of context to prove it!

Plus I'm humble, and proud of it! :D

 
Dec 12, 2013
46,515
20,401
113
Do we need a man to teach us or would that reveal the works of the antichrists, the man of sin?
Paul did tell Timothy to teach faithful men who in turn should teach faithful men etc..........and God places teaching pastors in churches for the purpose of teaching and edifying the body.......
 

OneFaith

Senior Member
Sep 5, 2016
2,270
369
83
Greetings beautiful people! I have a delema that pains my heart...
I am a Christian because I follow the words of Christ. The Old Testament has no place in my life.
The first testament describes a vengeful God, (a God that would kill children) a God that is definitely not the God described by Christ.
So it makes me sad when my friends or even my Pastor quotes from the Old Testament, as I feel they are straying from Christ's teaching. I understand through impeccable Logic, that a Christian should only read the words of Christ. Because when an individual, be them Christian or not, reads or speaks the old testament at that moment they are being Jewish. The Old Testament is the Jewish Bible when you speak it your being Jewish, full stop, logical and rational fact. I am definitely not anti-Semitic as I follow Christ's words and I love my neighbour.
Can anyone provide me with a logical and rational argument that refutes my argument. Furthermore, let's pick any contentious issue: let's say gays or gay marriage. Did Christ say anything against gays? If not, and you quote Leviticus, then in quoting and believing Leviticus, you are being a Jew not being Christian.
I have used this example because it is so volitile, not because I approve personal of homosexuality. But as a True Christian I should have no issue with homosexuality. Please only rational replies, I actually want to be proved wrong, but fact is fact.
God has not changed. It seems like He was more active, or more mean in the Old Testament, but this is because things were done physically in the Old Testament that are now done spiritually in the New Testament. When King David physically killed his tens of thousands, it represented how Christians today spiritually kill tens of thousands.

Both were killing evil. When we get baptized, or baptize others, the person dies to their self, buries their old sinful self in the watery grave of baptism, and are raised a new creature in Christ. But no one is shocked at that, saying "How could you kill the person they used to be! So what if they had faults, I liked their personality, and now they have Christ's personality. How boring!"

You have to understand that God knows things before they happen, and it is He Who decides which soul is put into which body, and which timeframe they will be born in. Therefore He can put all the people that He knows will be evil, into the babies, women, children, and men who would die during wars in which He commanded that all be killed. There were some lands that the Israelites took over that God commanded them to spare the women and children. This shows that He is in control, and has reasons for His decisions.

If you think that God does not speak against homosexuality in the New Testament, you need to read Romans chapter one. Again, God does not change, He's just as against it as He was in the Old Testament. Him physically destroying Sodom and Gamorah represented how He will spiritually destroy homosexuals and murderers (hell/second death). God is just as much against evil as He has always been, and always will be.
 
Last edited:
Feb 28, 2016
11,311
2,972
113
I have worked hard at my logic. It is particularly important to me because I am a woman, thus instinct goes with react-by-emotions.

That said, so you understand I really do appreciate rational advise.

BUT, look carefully at what you've said, and compare it to how people responded to it. (You don't even have to answer every response. I'm honestly asking you to think out the logic of what was said on both sides -- yours and everyone else.) And honestly ask yourself if your logic is working.

Time and time again, folks have told why it isn't.

And then once you start questioning exactly how logical you are, then take it one step further. Since your logic isn't working, (not trying to be mean here. If my logic isn't working, I want people to tell me why not), is your heart doing any better?

Now, the natural man -- the emotional man (or woman) -- is going to go with, "of course." BUT then you have to go back to remember, your brain isn't working right either. You thought it was logical, but it was proved illogical.

That leaves you at a place everyone here has already been. (We really have. And, if we have not, then we're still where you are.) Since you cannot trust your own brain or heart, where do you go? What do you do?

Sure, you can see a shrink, but I don't think you're that kind of loss. You're problem is you were born in a world full of people who all think they're thinking and feeling right. But they aren't. The nut jobs in England running large vehicles into pedestrians? The whackos shooting Senators or ramming their cars into protesters in the States? The maniacs hating women and children enough to enact Sharia Laws? The simple dude who thinks purse snatching is the obvious thing to do. They all think they are just as rational and heart driven as you do.

We're all whacked! We can't think right or feel right. That requires the Lord to heal us of our very corrupted minds and hearts.

So when you go back and search out exactly how illogical you are, please! Do the obvious. Ask! Ask us what you want to know about the Lord -- the real Lord, Not the Red-Letter-Jesus you don't really follow at all.

He's right there. All you have to do is get to the point of realizing how much you need him. ALL of him!
=====================================================

WOW, what an astounding and insightful Post! Tanks, dep...
 

Desertsrose

Senior Member
Oct 24, 2016
2,824
207
63
Do we not read 'in the Word of God everything we need to know ? Do we need to listen to someone who calls himself a preacher ?
Hi Beta,


God has gifted the church with teachers. Don't you think we still need them?
 

CherieR

Senior Member
May 6, 2017
2,269
1,425
113
I would advise you to ask God to reveal himself to you and then read the bible, the Old Testament and the New Testament. Perhaps starting with Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John and looking up the verses Jesus referred to from the Old Testament and go from there.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
Hmmm...

So if i do no more than teach my child how to read, then given him/her a Bible ((KJV of course, "
Authorized version")), and then i turn them loose in the world without further guidance, advice, explanation or conversation they should be fine?


:confused:
If they have the Spirit of Christ as to the person who has begun the good work of salvation in them He will finish it. To have that faith(Christ's) by which we can seek the approval of God and having that work in respect to any man defines a antichrist or what the scriptures calls a daysman .
God is not a man as us.

We do not seek His approval through men

So if you were to teach a child what to believe and send them out into the world with another gospel, another Christ could we say they are seeking the approval of God?

The faith (Christ's) to believe God does not come seeking the approval of a person's parents or any man. To seek after a faith that comes from trusting men is blasphemy.

The warning in 1 John 2 reveals the the man of sin the antichrist. That chapter gives us all we need to know to spot the antichrists.
 

beta

Senior Member
Aug 8, 2016
2,782
333
83
why did He make disciples, and then tell them to make more disciples?
kinda the same reason He gave the tribe of Levi, right?
what did Levi do - apart from being employed in ritual ordinances? what was the purpose God gave them?
The point being that the Disciples JESUS made are NOT being followed today ! THEY were all Sabbath-keepers !
 

beta

Senior Member
Aug 8, 2016
2,782
333
83
Hi Beta,


God has gifted the church with teachers. Don't you think we still need them?
Can I ask you which of the many different churches GOD has gifted with a teacher ?
 
May 1, 2013
220
31
28
You've heard it said, "follow your heart", but I strongly advise against doing so, for it is written:

Proverbs 28:26 - He that trusteth in his own heart is a fool: but whoso walketh wisely, he shall be delivered.

Jeremiah 17:9 - The heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure. Who can understand it?

Matthew 15:19 - For out of the heart come evil thoughts, murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false witness, slander.

Proverbs 3:5 - Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not on your own understanding.
Wow MultilingualMessenger! So True, short and directly to the point!
 

beta

Senior Member
Aug 8, 2016
2,782
333
83
Greetings beautiful people! I have a delema that pains my heart...
I am a Christian because I follow the words of Christ. The Old Testament has no place in my life.
The first testament describes a vengeful God, (a God that would kill children) a God that is definitely not the God described by Christ.
So it makes me sad when my friends or even my Pastor quotes from the Old Testament, as I feel they are straying from Christ's teaching. I understand through impeccable Logic, that a Christian should only read the words of Christ. Because when an individual, be them Christian or not, reads or speaks the old testament at that moment they are being Jewish. The Old Testament is the Jewish Bible when you speak it your being Jewish, full stop, logical and rational fact. I am definitely not anti-Semitic as I follow Christ's words and I love my neighbour.
Can anyone provide me with a logical and rational argument that refutes my argument. Furthermore, let's pick any contentious issue: let's say gays or gay marriage. Did Christ say anything against gays? If not, and you quote Leviticus, then in quoting and believing Leviticus, you are being a Jew not being Christian.
I have used this example because it is so volitile, not because I approve personal of homosexuality. But as a True Christian I should have no issue with homosexuality. Please only rational replies, I actually want to be proved wrong, but fact is fact.
Let me ask you something----
was Jesus Christ jewish or christian ?
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
Hi Beta,


God has gifted the church with teachers. Don't you think we still need them?
Has he gifted them with infallibility?

Need no. The warning is in regard to those who say we do need an man to teach us. Not can they teach or should they teach.

Do we need to heed the warning and rather than following the commandment to seek after the approval of God when rightly dividing His word .

Do we give over that approval to men?

How do we reconcile that God has given us teachers but warns us of those who say we need men to teach us as we seek their approval .
 
Last edited:

posthuman

Senior Member
Jul 31, 2013
37,721
13,521
113
The point being that the Disciples JESUS made are NOT being followed today ! THEY were all Sabbath-keepers !

how does that point flow from "
we don't need any human teachers" ?

i never had the idea from reading the Bible that as a Gentile believer in the new covenant of Christ that i should be keeping the Jewish Sabbath regulations.

it was only humans that have ever taught me that.
 

miknik5

Senior Member
Jun 2, 2016
7,833
591
113
Greetings beautiful people! I have a delema that pains my heart...
I am a Christian because I follow the words of Christ. The Old Testament has no place in my life.
The first testament describes a vengeful God, (a God that would kill children) a God that is definitely not the God described by Christ.
So it makes me sad when my friends or even my Pastor quotes from the Old Testament, as I feel they are straying from Christ's teaching. I understand through impeccable Logic, that a Christian should only read the words of Christ. Because when an individual, be them Christian or not, reads or speaks the old testament at that moment they are being Jewish. The Old Testament is the Jewish Bible when you speak it your being Jewish, full stop, logical and rational fact. I am definitely not anti-Semitic as I follow Christ's words and I love my neighbour.
Can anyone provide me with a logical and rational argument that refutes my argument. Furthermore, let's pick any contentious issue: let's say gays or gay marriage. Did Christ say anything against gays? If not, and you quote Leviticus, then in quoting and believing Leviticus, you are being a Jew not being Christian.
I have used this example because it is so volitile, not because I approve personal of homosexuality. But as a True Christian I should have no issue with homosexuality. Please only rational replies, I actually want to be proved wrong, but fact is fact.
Christ has a two fold ministry.
The OT depicts both of those ministries...but the NT depicts one ministry until all has been accomplished...and then that other ministry will begin.

Just as Luke 4 shows CHRIST announcing HIS public ministry and stopping midpoint in Isaiah 61:2...and declaring Today, scripture has been fulfilled in your hearing.


If you continued on in Isaiah 61:2, you would see that the second part of HIS ministry is the DAY of Vengeance of OUR GOD...


That day has not yet come.


It is still the year of GOD's Favor...
 

Desertsrose

Senior Member
Oct 24, 2016
2,824
207
63
Can I ask you which of the many different churches GOD has gifted with a teacher ?

Hi Beta,

Your question has nothing to do with my question. It's also one I can't answer because there are false churches, just as there are false teachers. And I'm not God so I don't know what is going on in the churches in my own town, let alone my state, the nation or the world.

What I asked is if the gift of teacher is still in use today?