Once saved always saved ?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
I

Israel

Guest
Is A liar saved? is one who covets saved? Is one who is proud saved? is a sinner saved? can you be free of sin (sinless)? even if your saved?

The question should not be, are they saved, the questions should be,m can they be healed, can a liar be healed, can a covetor be healed, can a sinner be healed. And the answer will be yes.

I know, I have seen it. It took awhile for the "habit" to be broken. But I have seen healing. I have also seen some who died before healing took place. Do I think they were saved? Yes, because other areas of their life changed, And they showed works. They just struggled breaking their "habit" because the flesh was strong, and died before they overcame.

Am I going to say they were not saved because they struggles with one sin habit? NO! neither should anyone!.

Now if by the law, desire to be gay is aroused and through that sin is born, how is it then desire if there is no law? Did the man stop being gay? No he did not. Why then must he stop his "habit"? Because the law says so? Are we under the law?
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
Now if by the law, desire to be gay is aroused and through that sin is born, how is it then desire if there is no law? Did the man stop being gay? No he did not. Why then must he stop his "habit"? Because the law says so? Are we under the law?
There is a stipulation to not being under law

But if you are led by the Spirit you are not under law Gal 5:18

So, the question becomes. Would the Holy Spirit lead a person to remain in homosexual relationships the whole of their Christian life?

And so I am not seen to be gay bashing

Would the Holy Spirit lead someone to continue having affairs the whole of their Christian life?
 
I

Israel

Guest
There is a stipulation to not being under law

But if you are led by the Spirit you are not under law Gal 5:18

So, the question becomes. Would the Holy Spirit lead a person to remain in homosexual relationships the whole of their Christian life?

And so I am not seen to be gay bashing

Would the Holy Spirit lead someone to continue having affairs the whole of their Christian life?


So in essense, before Jesus death, one could not be gay and after,one still can't be gay and he has to accept Jesus? Where is the rest for his soul?
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
So in essense, before Jesus death, one could not be gay and after,one still can't be gay and he has to accept Jesus? Where is the rest for his soul?
If a gay person becomes saved, it is for them the same as anyone to stand on faith in Christ and the Holy Spirit will sanctify them. I believe that it is entirely possible for the Holy Spirit to transform anyone and to change anything about them that is contrary to how God would have them live
Otherwise we could not say
Nothing is impossible for God
 
I

Israel

Guest
If a gay person becomes saved, it is for them the same as anyone to stand on faith in Christ and the Holy Spirit will sanctify them. I believe that it is entirely possible for the Holy Spirit to transform anyone and to change anything about them that is contrary to how God would have them live
Otherwise we could not say
Nothing is impossible for God

We can both see that it is wrong to be gay. For us then, how is it hope?
 
I

Israel

Guest

The bible says that it is hope that saves us, but hope that is seen is not hope at all. We both SEE that it is wrong. Even nature teaches us this. So not being gay is not hope but simply doing good works out of what we see as profitable out of the law.
 
I

Israel

Guest
does an alcoholic ever stop being an alcoholic?

Exactly. We are to transform the mind and not the flesh.
I'm not trying to stop him from being gay but to give him peace of mind in love. For he is accepted.
 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
does an alcoholic ever stop being an alcoholic?
It is my belief that because few people ACTUALLY LIVE not under law, but still in their hearts believe entry into Heaven to some part depends on their personal goodness that they do not see the power and victory in their lives they could

I have met many in church who say they are saved by the grace of God, but how many REALLY believe in their hearts they are kept by faith in the son of God who loved them and gave Himself for them
How many truly believe in their heart it is what God can do in them to change them by the power of the Spirit as they trust in Christ?

And I believe on this hinges the true victory and is why the power promised is seldom seen

If a person loves God with all their heart body soul and mind and lives in the truth of the Gospel of Grace written in the Bible I believe they will see the power seen in NT times, I am personally convinced of it

There is power in the truth
But when we rely on our own personal strength, or to any degree on our own personal goodness we are in effect ignoring the cross of Christ

I do not set aside the grace of God, for if righteousness could be gained through the law(striving to be good enough for entry into Heaven) Christ died for nothing
Gal 2:21
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Exactly. We are to transform the mind and not the flesh.
I'm not trying to stop him from being gay but to give him peace of mind in love. For he is accepted.
Yet the alcoholic can never drink again, or he will fall back into drinking and have to start over.

the same thing goes for the one struggling with sexual sin (gay or heterosexual)

what we have to do is show them the damage sexual sin causes. So they can see God is not being a judgmental God, but a loving God.
 
I

Israel

Guest
Yet the alcoholic can never drink again, or he will fall back into drinking and have to start over.

the same thing goes for the one struggling with sexual sin (gay or heterosexual)

what we have to do is show them the damage sexual sin causes. So they can see God is not being a judgmental God, but a loving God.

So the alcoholic or gay must stop? If so then it is of the law and faith is dead.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
So the alcoholic or gay must stop? If so then it is of the law and faith is dead.
You misunderstood me. Both cause hurt and pain and damage (even if we can not see it) if we want to stop this pain we have to stop, and resist temptation. for if we fall to temptation after being healed, then we have to start over.


 
Dec 19, 2009
2,723
7
0
So the alcoholic or gay must stop? If so then it is of the law and faith is dead.

NO!

It is because they are not under law that sin shall not be their master and by faith in Christ the Holy Spirit will transform them and take away the desire to do that which is contrary to what God desires. Their law is faith in the son of God who loved them and gave himself for them, but faith will see the supernatural power of God released into their lives

They do not believe their continued salvation depends on how they themselves in their own strength strive to live according to the good laws of God, but by faith, their one and only rigfhteousness for Heaven. And therein lies the victory
 
Last edited:
I

Israel

Guest
You misunderstood me. Both cause hurt and pain and damage (even if we can not see it) if we want to stop this pain we have to stop, and resist temptation. for if we fall to temptation after being healed, then we have to start over.


But how is it temptation where no law is?
 
Feb 14, 2011
1,783
4
0
As for one believing and then departing. I Think 1 John speaks directly at this. (This site was at least for me down all day yesterday, so I will read the rest of the posts to see if this was spoken of before I speak on it further.

As for belief vs faith.

One can believe something, yet not have faith in it.

If my life is in danger, and someone comes and says he can help. I might believe him, but might not trust him, so I might not do everything he says, because I do not realy trust (have faith) he can do what he says he can do.

Paul spoke to Jews who believed in Christ and his death, But showed they did not trust in this, by attempting to bring back the works of the law, or other works in order to what Paul called "perfect their faith" In other words, they had faith that Christ plus their works were more apt to save them than just faith in Christ alone.

James said anyone who believed does well, Even demons believes. Speaking of those who might believe, but have no faith (your faith is dead, or non existent.

I hope this helps..





Anyway, I am gonna head to church, will look at the rest of the posts when I get back.

how do you get strong faith? it is by learning about God and
knowing him,when you get to know him your faith wiil build up.
your trust in God will be so strong.

''wakeup''.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Is not the flesh crucified by those who have the mind of Christ? Can a gay love God with all of his heart and love his neighbor as himself?
The mind of Christ does not happen over night.

Can an alcoholic love God with all his heart and his neighbor as himself?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
how do you get strong faith? it is by learning about God and
knowing him,when you get to know him your faith wiil build up.
your trust in God will be so strong.

''wakeup''.
Ah yes, But if you have no faith, you have nothing to grow.