Exactly when and what triggered the ceasing of the gifts of the Spirit?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
WOW!!!!! Zone you are splitting hairs and trying incessantly to get otherts to follow your way of beleif and thought bad on you girl. God is mine and I am God's and I quarantee you that your denomination along with all denominations are not 100% right in waht they beleive and how they go about thier belief. There true believers in each one but not all believe 100% and all have destructable heresis in each one.
The true place of worship is in Heaven Hebrews 8 and there is no denominational name mebtioned anywhere in the Bible just those that believe God are his and God never set up a second place of woirship only one and that is in heaven. Man as you are pointing has even in your place of worship for God is not there God does not reside in buildings at all
WHAT ARE ALL THE LETTERS TO THE CHURCHES FOR?
NOTHING?

you're making excuses to not join the Body.
nothing less.

wrap it anyway you like.

your denomination is LONE RANGER.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
WOW!!!!! Zone you are splitting hairs and trying incessantly to get otherts to follow your way of beleif and thought bad on you girl. God is mine and I am God's and I quarantee you that your denomination along with all denominations are not 100% right in waht they beleive and how they go about thier belief. There true believers in each one but not all believe 100% and all have destructable heresis in each one.
The true place of worship is in Heaven Hebrews 8 and there is no denominational name mebtioned anywhere in the Bible just those that believe God are his and God never set up a second place of woirship only one and that is in heaven. Man as you are pointing has even in your place of worship for God is not there God does not reside in buildings at all
and what does this have to do with my reply about MIRACLES?
PLEASE RESPOND TO IT.
 
Feb 21, 2012
3,794
199
63
well, you can sit with your thoughts, or align with what the bible says, peaceful.
That is what I believe the bible says. . .I don't believe we see scripture "face to face"! The Greek word here for perfect, zone, is not the same Greek word used in 2 Timothy 3:17. teleios is used in 1 Corinthians 13 meaning what has reached its end, term, or limit; hence, complete, perfect, full, wanting nothing, with special reference to the end for which it was intended. We will not be complete, perfect, full, wanting nothing until Jesus Christ returns. So, I have no problem believing I am in align with scripture.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
That is what I believe the bible says. . .I don't believe we see scripture "face to face"! The Greek word here for perfect, zone, is not the same Greek word used in 2 Timothy 3:17. teleios is used in 1 Corinthians 13 meaning what has reached its end, term, or limit; hence, complete, perfect, full, wanting nothing, with special reference to the end for which it was intended. We will not be complete, perfect, full, wanting nothing until Jesus Christ returns. So, I have no problem believing I am in align with scripture.
seeing face to face isn't a face to face meeting between someone and someone (you and Jesus).

it's seeing something CLEARLY that was previously seen PARTIALLY - as in a glass (brushed metal mirror) darkly; or blurry; ill defined.

Paul isn't speaking of a WE.

he is speaking of a THING.

you can't possibly align with scripture - you hold to Bullingerism.

you could always quit that though.

thx
 
P

Powemm

Guest
there's the loaded part.
of course it's one-on-one.
salvation.
He knows every hair on every head, He knows us by name.

BUT: does that mean YOU are Moses or Ezekiel or Paul?

[[[No I'm pretty much just me]]]

are you claiming God appears to you in a burning bush or in Person some other way?

[[[claiming He has appeared to menin a bush? Um no.. No not in person.. In spirit ]]]

doctrines are confusing? [[[yes
God is always the same every doctrine is different ..]]]



that was the point of all this....make doctrine too hard to cope with.
rely on experience.
once that happens, you're a sitting duck.

[[[ that's not what God says to me ]]]


there's ONE doctrine...THE faith delivered ONCE for all....it's in the Bible ALONE. [[[ well kinda ]]]. Bit god has a way he speaks to me outside of that .. I just use the bible to confirm it ..
As well as other people ]]]
...
if you are even remotely wondering about what you're involved in, this is a really good time to get real with the Lord and just ASK Him to show you what is the Truth.
[[[ I'm involved with God through Jesus Christ directly zone, no I'm not wondering , Gods very capable revealing what He wants]]]


He might be merciful. i don't know.
[[[ He's very merciful zone why would he not be?]]]

most never come out of this.
[[[ out of what ? God has healed menof many things, I'm not who ibises to he at all, and continues to do so daily , new truths of his kindness, love and grace]]]
.....
A BRIEF HISTORY OF PENTECOSTALISM

(The Three Waves)*. [[[I trust God zone, not mans words]]]

From the second century to the nineteenth century, there is no historical evidence that godly, orthodox believers spoke in tongues. We do have instances of tongues speaking in these centuries, but in every case the people speaking in tongues belonged to heretical groups. (See #15 in the report "The Charismatic Movement: 35 Doctrinal Issues.") From Montanus (2nd Century) to Edward Irving (19th century), instances of "tongues" within the church were never considered to be part of genuine Christianity. Also, we should note that these "heretics" who spoke in tongues were speaking some kind of emotional, nonsense gibberish and not real languages as was the case in Acts chapter 2.

A Brief History of Pentecostalism < click
[[[Gods doing a fine job Work in me zone as well as in you, oh I commented to your questions above]]]
Thank you for sharing your views ... Gods way is a lot less confusing ...
And way more simple
 
P

Powemm

Guest
I want you to know we are simply sharing views .. I in no way am asking you to digest what I'm sharing ..I'm just looking at all sides of tue box and I find your view to be worth looking at .. I'm not here to karate chop it out really ... Just looking :)
 
M

Mojopin

Guest
The gifts are still there! are you that blind? Our fellowship have the gifts every Sunday has it is written in the bible. You know, GOD IS REAL! and Jesus is still with us today? open your eyes people! and also seeking answers on a chat site? open your bible and seek the LORD and you will find whatever you're looking for.
 
P

Powemm

Guest
I've been to the Lutheran church .. Met some very
nice people
As well as the catholic ..
Baptist
Pendacostal
Among others ... Some parts working in them but the body coming together as a "whole" .. Very very rare ..

do you find the whole body "everyone " working well at your church ? it excites me to think that it might ..
I guess what I mean is the church able to work with other denominational churches as a working group?
Or is it pretty much working within it's own denomination?
I'm
Just curious
 
Feb 21, 2012
3,794
199
63
seeing face to face isn't a face to face meeting between someone and someone (you and Jesus).

it's seeing something CLEARLY that was previously seen PARTIALLY - as in a glass (brushed metal mirror) darkly; or blurry; ill defined.

Paul isn't speaking of a WE.

he is speaking of a THING.

you can't possibly align with scripture - you hold to Bullingerism.

you could always quit that though.

thx
Ok, thanks, zone.

Paul is not speaking of a WE but a THING? And when he says "face to face". . .He means we fully see our own reflection? which will make me know fully even as I am fully known?

OK. . . . .?

Has nothing to do with Bullingerism. . . has to do with properly reading the scripture.

 
M

Mojopin

Guest
If you work along different churches, you will get flooded with different beliefs.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
The gifts are still there! are you that blind? Our fellowship have the gifts every Sunday has it is written in the bible. You know, GOD IS REAL! and Jesus is still with us today? open your eyes people! and also seeking answers on a chat site? open your bible and seek the LORD and you will find whatever you're looking for.
what gifts?
why are the gifts only there every sunday?
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
do you find the whole body "everyone " working well at your church ?
uh...ya. totally.
we all love each other and have peace and communion.

what do you mean working?

it excites me to think that it might ..
it's peace and joy.

I guess what I mean is the church able to work with other denominational churches as a working group?
working for what?
a working group for what?
please be specific.

Or is it pretty much working within it's own denomination?
define working.
i have no idea what you're referring to.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
Ok, thanks, zone.

Paul is not speaking of a WE but a THING? And when he says "face to face". . .He means we fully see our own reflection? which will make me know fully even as I am fully known?

OK. . . . .?

Has nothing to do with Bullingerism. . . has to do with properly reading the scripture.

read this, follow up would be my suggestion.

i've found though that people don't actually follow up for a couple of reasons, mainly they are afraid to be found in error....that would mean starting over.

i'll put some paragraph breaks in it.

i won't be covering this part again with ya.

.....

"The Greek word translated “perfect” is teleios. The term does not refer to “perfect” in the sense typically understood by the average modern English reader, i.e., to be sinless.

Following this faulty notion, some have concluded that the “perfect” refers to Jesus—since He has been the only perfect person. Other interpretations apply “perfect” to heaven (the only perfect place that will be free of sin and imperfection), or Christian maturity and perfect love (the perfect condition or quality).

But, in context, Paul was not contrasting qualities or places. He was contrasting quantities, i.e., those things that were incomplete and partial (miraculous gifts) with that which would be total and complete (the fully revealed Word of God).

The inaccuracy of these interpretations is seen further in the Greek definition of teleios. The word refers to totality, that which is whole, brought to its end, finished, and lacking nothing necessary to completeness (Delling, 1972, 8:73; Arndt and Gingrich, 1957, p. 816; Thayer, 1901, p. 618).

When referring to persons, teleios refers to being full-grown, adult, and mature (Arndt and Gingrich, 1957, p. 817; Thayer, 1977, p. 618).

Used in its neuter form, Paul was referring to a thing—not a person—something that, when completed or finished, would replace the incomplete or partial, i.e., the miraculous gifts—which clearly had only temporary significance.

Commenting on the abolition of the miraculous gifts of prophecy and supernatural knowledge (mentioned in vss. 8 and 9), W.R. Nicoll observed that “these charisms are partial in scope, and therefore temporary: the fragmentary gives place to the complete” (1900, 2:900, emp. added).

Kenneth Wuest agreed: “In I Corinthians 13:10, the word means ‘complete,’ and is contrasted to that which is incomplete”
(1943a, pp. 117-118).

Whereas James used the term teleios to refer to the all-sufficiency of God’s Word in its ability to achieve everything it was intended to do (James 1:25), the exegete is forced to conclude that Paul’s use of “perfect” referred to the completed revelation or totally revealed New Testament Scriptures.

The revelation of God’s will was completed in its entirety when the final book of the New Testament, Revelation, was written by John prior to A.D. 100."

Apologetics Press - Modern-Day Miracles, Tongue-Speaking, and Holy Spirit Baptism: A Refutation--EXTENDED VERSION < click
 
P

Powemm

Guest
uh...ya. totally.
we all love each other and have peace and communion.
[[[ see that's awesome! I've been to so many churches where there's a lot if separation in it ..]]]

what do you mean working?
I'll give you an example .. Like this weekend my oldest son ( 23) and His wife and their church joined several other denominational churches (people in their age group, married couples) and they all came together to do a clothes drive, put needed items together for the homeless ... I may have used a poor word "working " .. I mean like a larger body movement ..

it's peace and joy.

Through the whole church as well as helping one another as a whole body outside if it?

working for what?
a working group for what?

Coming together in a larger body with other churches working inside each others churches and together ... sharing views and doing projects to help the betterment of communities an stuff .. "not working for your salvation type thing " outside of that box..


please be specific.



define working.
i have no idea what you're referring to.
Not working for salvation .. What I'm referring to is beyond the salvation part
That's parts non negotiable ..
Thanks for Sharing zone , I'm just trying to get a feel for what's going on everywhere ..,
What's happening type thing ..
Really not trying to argue or anything :)
Thanks for your patience with me ..
 
P

Powemm

Guest
I put some answers in your quote too zone ...
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
Not working for salvation .. What I'm referring to is beyond the salvation part
That's parts non negotiable ..
Thanks for Sharing zone , I'm just trying to get a feel for what's going on everywhere ..,
What's happening type thing ..
Really not trying to argue or anything :)
Thanks for your patience with me ..
well, we don't make a point of gathering with other denominations to share ideas.

we know what the other denominations believe.

we do missions and outreach with all kinds of people, and other denominations - provided it doesn't require us to do anything which goes against our convictions - for example....activism for ordination of gays in ministry. no...we don't come together over things like that.

as for community service, individuals do that as they are led.
avenues for service are posted at the church.

our church exists for the SHEEP first.
for care and feeding of Christ's sheep.


i know that sounds opposed to what you may have been taught.
 
Jan 8, 2013
114
7
0
Coconut ... this was Zone's first response to this thread. And it is a view that I agree with entirely. Might this matter be better resolved if you yourself presented one example (I'm asking for only one) "gifted" miracle worker in existence today in lieu of your endless stream of hypothetical scenario's ? Show us one is all we ask. The same goes for one "gifted" with speaking in tongues. Again ... only one example is what I ask for. How hard can that be to produce ? An apostle today ? Name one. A prophet today ? Name one. A tongue-speaker today ? Show me one that is biblical and authentic. Were we not instructed to test these things ? I nor Zone have never disputed that our Father may or may not choose to do something supernatural on behalf of one of His beloved .... for His namesake, purpose and glory. But this is not what is being discussed here. The topic is certain and specific "gifts" that were granted chosen men by God for the very purpose of validation and the laying of the foundation of Christ's church. I'll wait for only one example of any of the above mentioned that you can produce. Thank you and God bless.
You know as well as I do that when someone gives an instance of any of these kinds of happenings as you have requested, it goes through an intense scrutiny that goes way beyond the testimony of two or three witnesses. For any of you to even consider believing that these things can and have happened, you would have to have to witnessed it with your own eyes, just like Thomas, 'Unless I see it I won't believe it' and that had to do with Christ being raised from the dead. There are many examples which are isolated but have happened none the less, but you won't believe it nor would any of you submit to it's veracity. If you ask me that is just as much unbelief and are others things that we do not perceive as truth with our own understanding. You would label them as cronies and phonies and not from God. That's the size of it.
 

zone

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2010
27,214
164
63
You know as well as I do that when someone gives an instance of any of these kinds of happenings as you have requested, it goes through an intense scrutiny that goes way beyond the testimony of two or three witnesses. For any of you to even consider believing that these things can and have happened, you would have to have to witnessed it with your own eyes, just like Thomas, 'Unless I see it I won't believe it' and that had to do with Christ being raised from the dead. There are many examples which are isolated but have happened none the less, but you won't believe it nor would any of you submit to it's veracity. If you ask me that is just as much unbelief and are others things that we do not perceive as truth with our own understanding. You would label them as cronies and phonies and not from God. That's the size of it.
why are they isolated?
Paul had a whole church operating.

if they continued, and we have a billion christians...wel....where are the NUMBERS?

anything...ONE REAL MIRACLE please!

i'll believe it, because i'll know it when i see it.

someone raised from the dead would be good.

or, people suddenly proclaiming the Gospel in languages (all at once) they never learned.

just post it!!

you can't....that's why.
so you toss it our way saying WE lack faith.
i'm afraid the opposite is true.

thx anyways.

i'll post prophets and tongues and signs and wonders...if there are any you think are genuine please let me know.

back later on that
 
J

jimmyjames

Guest
I agree with you 100%. In John 10:37-38, Jesus is letting us know that gifts have a meaning and purpose. In the case of Jesus the gift of miracles from his Father was to prove to the people he was the awaited Messiah. I know the gifts are present and the Holy Spirit is forevert present. We are living in a time period for however long God chooses to display his gifts by the keeping of his commandments by his disciples. We are his supernatural hands to feed, clothe, and give medicine unto the sick. There will be a time for the supernatural presence of Jesus again and will be accomplished through his two witnesses for sure. The future church and the world will witness exactly what the world saw when Jesus walked this earth as a man. The church needs the gift of patience.
 
J

jimmyjames

Guest
I'll second that comment.