I wish people (and in this case you) would be careful to not lump all Hebrew Roots folks into beliefs like this. It simply is not the case, and if you did a poll of 100 people who'd call themselves Hebrew Roots folks, very few would hold the view that you're talking about, or anything remotely close to it.
And I'm an example of following Jesus as the Son of God, yay, God Himself. The law plays an important role (in it's proper order) in the life of a New Testament believer. But that statement doesn't negate the work of our Messiah.
you are right...but the very name suggests otherwise
and you are also right in stating how the different groups differ and even argue
IMO, it is best to not even get involved in those groups
I myself was a part of Messianic congregation for about two years and I liked it so much! I really did! I even called Jesus Yahshua because I was told I might offend some members...I was part of the leadership (music/worship) and therefore people looked up to me...I sang in Hebrew and English...some very beautiful songs...and even wrote a small musical presentation of the rebuilding of the wall with Nehemiah and tied that into belief in Christ and how He rebuilds us...that story of Nehemiah is a wonderful story! a wonderful example of living faith in God and the dedication of one man to do what is right! in spite of all the naysayers and scoffers
know what happened? there was a Jewish synagogue across the street from where we met on Saturdays (Sabbath, right?) in the sanctuary of a church that we rented, and some of the congregation in the Messianic group decided to take it across the street and started actually arguing with the Jewish folk there!
someone called the news and we had a reporter with a camera man come to a service...I sat it out...I did not participate...I did not see how arguing with a synagogue was going to do any good
it all went south...there was a split and everyone suffered
so, I do know a little about these things...I have known other Jewish people who have believed in Jesus as their Messiah and I truly love their company
they are indeed a special people and when they accept Jesus, they are so inspiring!
But again, these are JEWISH by birth...true Jews...not make believe ones
I grew up around many Jewish people...went to a High School where about 50% of the population was Jewish and I have worked for Jewish companies...Montreal has a very large Jewish population
so, I'm not exactly ignorant of all things Jewish, but the point is, Jesus is God's sin offering