Is This a Red Flag??

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

HopeinHim98

Well-known member
Mar 16, 2023
640
576
93
#1
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
 

CarriePie

Well-known member
Jan 7, 2024
2,194
1,454
113
#2
On his phone? Yes, I'd probably consider that a red flag. However, I'm not quick to consider all pics a red flag. For example, I have a lot of pics that were taken during my longest relationship (which lasted 7 years) and they are in albums on my fb account. Most of them are just scenery of places we visited, food I cooked, etc.

In my last relationship, he also had pics of past situations where an ex-gf was in the pic. We both even showed each other our pics. We assured each other our feelings were only for each other. I trusted him. Even though we aren't together any longer, I still trust they those pics were just kept in a past-memories sort of way just like mine were kept.

Mind you, we didn't ogle our past pics. I didn't have any of mine on my phone (mostly they are in my fb account which I was using at the time of the previous relationship). I don't know where his were stored (but, since they were pretty far back, it just didn't bother me). In any case, it didn't occur to me that our past pics were a red flag and I never felt bothered about it.

In a nutshell, if they are on his phone and he can easily see them, I'd feel uncomfortable with that. If they are stored in some past-memory type of way somewhere, that's different (to me, at least). Also, it depends on the pics. Mine were mostly scenery and my last bf's they were pics that also included friends and family. Neither of us had risque or romantic pics of our exes (that I know of). Keeping risque pics would be a red flag (imo).

Also, if something bothers you, it's important! In a relationship, if something makes you uncomfortable, it should be important to your bf/SO that it bothers you.
 

bluejean_bible

Well-known member
Feb 15, 2025
980
470
63
#3
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
Red flag.

Trophy style. Conquests.
 

cinder

Senior Member
Mar 26, 2014
4,474
2,465
113
#5
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
I think if it bothers you, you should ask him to delete them or move them off his phone. Good test of how over the past relationship he is. If he can't delete any of them, then yeah that's a problem .
 

RodB651

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2021
831
551
93
59
#6
What do y'all think??
I think its a red flag. I would see that as a trophy/conquest as well.

Now if the guy has kids with this lady, I would be more understanding of that because that is the kids mom. If he is constantly comparing you and her or saying she did things this way or that way making it sound like she's somehow doing better than you?.. I'd move on.
 

RodB651

Well-known member
Feb 11, 2021
831
551
93
59
#7
I think its a red flag. I would see that as a trophy/conquest as well.

Now if the guy has kids with this lady, I would be more understanding of that because that is the kids mom. If he is constantly comparing you and her or saying she did things this way or that way making it sound like she's somehow doing better than you?.. I'd move on.
As an aside, I meant to say that if he has kids with this lady, and the kids are in the picture, I'd be ok with that. But if he has pictures of just her, I'd have to say something.
 

HopeinHim98

Well-known member
Mar 16, 2023
640
576
93
#8
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
You know, in retrospect, maybe he didn't say he had all the pics, but that all the girls were on there. It just sounded like he didn't delete any.

It is possible that he had them in a separate file or album, I don't know.

One of my guy friends told me this guy showed him a pic of his last gf. I was immediately insecure and asked him, "Was she really pretty?" Lol.

Before we started talking, it had been 4 years since this guy had been in a relationship. And before that he'd had 9 gfs. He was 30 yrs old. He'd just begun really following the Lord the year before we met so all of his relationships were before this.
 

Sculpt

Well-known member
Apr 18, 2021
1,156
376
83
#12
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
There're two possible issues. One, is him telling you. The other is the issue of someone having old pics of old relationships.

On the first, it depends on the context. Did he tell you this fact out of nowhere? Or was it just part of a natural convo flow... or maybe you asked him if he had old pics of gfs? If he brought it up out of nowhere, you could ask yourself (or him) why he told you. Either way maybe he's just saying he doesn't bother deleting old pics from his phone... like if there's plenty of space, why waste precious time on a meaningless task? Or maybe he's hoping you'll want to see them so he can impress you? I don't think anyone can tell you without context or knowing the person.

Second, him having old pics of gfs in his Gallery... maybe he's sentimental about people he knows/knew and/or times he's had. Or maybe he doesn't care about photos at all, so he wouldn't bother going to the trouble of deleting them. I know people put different values on photos. You'd have to know this person. Most dudes I know put no value in photos.
 
Mar 16, 2023
640
576
93
#13
There're two possible issues. One, is him telling you. The other is the issue of someone having old pics of old relationships.

On the first, it depends on the context. Did he tell you this fact out of nowhere? Or was it just part of a natural convo flow... or maybe you asked him if he had old pics of gfs? If he brought it up out of nowhere, you could ask yourself (or him) why he told you. Either way maybe he's just saying he doesn't bother deleting old pics from his phone... like if there's plenty of space, why waste precious time on a meaningless task? Or maybe he's hoping you'll want to see them so he can impress you? I don't think anyone can tell you without context or knowing the person.

Second, him having old pics of gfs in his Gallery... maybe he's sentimental about people he knows/knew and/or times he's had. Or maybe he doesn't care about photos at all, so he wouldn't bother going to the trouble of deleting them. I know people put different values on photos. You'd have to know this person. Most dudes I know put no value in photos.
So it was at the very beginning of our relationship and we were unofficial... he mentioned me looking thru his pics sometime and warned me of the pics of his exes. He asked if I'd be okay seeing those too. I told him I didn't mind...but maybe I did.
 

Mem

Senior Member
Sep 23, 2014
7,615
2,326
113
#14
So it was at the very beginning of our relationship and we were unofficial... he mentioned me looking thru his pics sometime and warned me of the pics of his exes. He asked if I'd be okay seeing those too. I told him I didn't mind...but maybe I did.
I'll apologize ahead of time if I sound too cold and analytical, I don't mean to exactly, it's just that I'm a sigma female. But, if you did a poll of 10 guys' opinion if they thought their interest might mind looking through their old pics that included exes in some of them, and narrow them down to those that'd answer, 'I think it'd be too risky to even ask... I think you'd end up with at least one emotionally intelligent prospect.
 
Apr 21, 2021
8,886
3,903
113
#15
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag .

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
Yep, a red flag for sure. Rebound relationships aren't a good idea.
 

Kireina

Well-known member
Aug 26, 2020
1,510
1,449
113
#16
Keeping an ex's pictures is a red flag I'd want to discuss this with Him if we were dating. IT seems like he is collecting exes or something 🤔 or holding onto memories of his exes 🤔
 

Lynx

Folksy yet erudite
Aug 13, 2014
28,644
10,228
113
#17
So it was at the very beginning of our relationship and we were unofficial... he mentioned me looking thru his pics sometime and warned me of the pics of his exes. He asked if I'd be okay seeing those too. I told him I didn't mind...but maybe I did.
I know I sure wouldn't bother going back through my whole DCIM folder and cleaning out pictures just because I met a new girl. Ain't nobody got time for that.

How long ago was that? Are y'all in a more serious relationship now? Are the pictures still on his phone?

What kind of pictures are they? Are they pictures with her in them, or are they closeup shots of her wearing a bikini?

Mind you, I have no personal interest in the answers. These are questions you can use to determine the color of that flag you were talking about.
 
May 23, 2009
17,188
6,036
113
#18
Before we started talking, it had been 4 years since this guy had been in a relationship. And before that he'd had 9 gfs. He was 30 yrs old. He'd just begun really following the Lord the year before we met so all of his relationships were before this.
Hi HIH,

Everyone here has already given you stellar advice, so I just wanted to comment on this one detail.

It sounds like he was definitely a newer Christian and maybe he didn't know or even consider that deleting pics of his old girlfriends was a good way to clean the slate. I didn't have many boyfriends and I held on to pictures as a way of reminding myself that I'd found someone in the past, so hopefully this meant I could still find someone in the future. I was putting my faith in the past and not God.

One day, years later, God convicted me and I got rid of any pictures of any guy I had an attachment to, even childhood crushes. It was tough. I remember I had some pics from summer camp I really wanted to keep, but they included a counselor I had a huge crush on and God said, "Those have got to go!", even though it had been 15 years or more.

Now, it might just be a me thing, as I do tend to get attached to people and sometimes God will have me go through and get rid of certain things I'm apparently too emotionally drawn to.

But it took years to do this and again, it might be something more specific God convicts in me, and might not be as strict in others.

Since this guy you were around was a newer Christian, maybe God hadn't convicted him of deleting his pictures yet -- I'm not saying you should have had to accept it, I'm just saying, maybe God would have said he needs more time to be able to let go.

We would all be rich if we got a dollar every time someone quoted, "Do not be unequally yoked." But that's always spoken in the context of a believer with an unbeliever.

One of my frustrations with the church is that they never talk about being unequally yoked with another believer who is at a very different stage in their Christian walk. I've experienced this and personally feel it can be detrimental to relationships, because one person might have the time and experience to know certain things aren't right, but the other person has yet to learn this.

Now of course, believers in different stages MIGHT work out -- but I still think it's important to be mindful of where each person is in their journey.

Years ago, I was friends with a guy who was a new Christians (about 2 years,) but had to say no to dating because of our different stages. He was in a stage of discovering how rewarding it was to give in the name of the Lord. But he was also hooked on the feeling and attention it can bring, to the point where he was giving away so much, he needed help himself.

He was a great guy and had only the best of intentions. I tried to him about it, but he insisted that as followers of Christ, we are to help others -- and I think he was becoming very co-dependent on the reactions he got when he gave.

I could see very quickly that it would soon come down to me paying his bills while he gave what he had away, chasing that feeling of people's appreciation, and I knew this was not going to work.
 
Mar 13, 2014
42,936
17,362
113
70
Tennessee
#19
I'm curious of your opinions on this: in one of my relationships the guy I was getting to know told me he had all the pics of his former girlfriends in his phone gallery still. When I mentioned this to my sister she said "That's a red flag!"

I wasn't sure what to think. I didn't really like the thought of that, but I didn't want to say it was a red flag...

For myself, I tried to delete or get rid of old pics when I had moved on. (or when I was trying to move on)

What do y'all think??
What I think is that he is hanging on to these pics of former girlfriends just in case things don't work out with any current relationship. This does not strike me as someone who is serious about establishing a serious relationship that may lead to marriage. Definite red flag.