If You're Not Interested In Someone, Do You Owe Them An Explanation?

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,242
5,210
113
#1
Hey everyone,

Recently I was thinking about some times I haven't been interested in dating someone for whatever reasons, and the person then wanted a very clear reason as to why.

If I didn't know the person very well (for example, in an online dating situation where you just met the person or when someone wants to try to fix you up with someone), I tend to just kind of shrug it off because I feel that if I'm not comfortable with the thought of going out with someone I don't even know, why should I be expected to give some sort of detailed explanation?

I did have one case in which the person asking was a guy I'd been friends with for many years, and that was a lot tougher, because I felt I owed him some sort of explanation but didn't want to just say, "I just don't have those feelings between us" without trying to explain my stance.

Some of the guys whom I've met have actually been very aggressive about wanting a reason and won't let it go (if it's an online situation and the person is relentlessly asking without even knowing me, I block them), and in my opinion, this can be very uncomfortable. However, it also makes me feel as if I've made the right decision, because someone who demands answers from me and doesn't even know me is not someone I want to date (just my own opinion.)

What do the rest of you what you think? If you don't want to date someone who wants to date you, do you owe them an explanation? Does it depend on how well or how long you've known them? How do you personally handle the situation?

On the other hand, most of us have had more then our fair share of rejection as well. But in all honesty, I can't remember ever asking someone why they didn't want to date me--I just kind of shrugged it off as him not liking me for whatever reasons. Yes, sometimes I'd feel down or really hurt, but I never asked for a reason why. I guess I figured whatever reason they had was good enough and I just had to get over it. (The one exception, of course, was my ex-husband--I would have preferred that he would have told me HIMSELF instead of finding out through others that he didn't love me anymore and had fallen for another girl, but maybe God spared me that because it would have been too much to bear at the time.)

It might be just me but if someone rejects me, I don't bother to ask why. Maybe I'm just afraid of more hurt in addition to the rejection? Because if I don't ask, I can make up my OWN reasons as to why they don't like me, and maybe that seems less painful than allowing someone else to choose their own reasons and tell you all the things they find unattractive about you. At least if I tell myself something like, "Well, I'm not pretty enough," I still have control over my own rejection, in a twisted kind of way.

How do you personally handle rejection? Do you expect someone to give you a clear reason if they aren't interested in you? Does it somehow help you get over the pain of the person rejecting you?

And if no reasons or explanations should be expected either way, what should you tell the other person?
 

Fenner

Senior Member
Jan 26, 2013
7,507
111
0
#2
You don't owe them an explanation, but if they are pushing for one, which would be one reason I wouldn't date them you could say, sorry I feel no.spark or I'm.not attracted to you. Or the moon amd Jupiter aren't in alignment with the Earths atmosphere and I don't date until they are. Or you could say, Ok, we.can vo out but I'll have to introduce you to my family first, then take him to an area filled with creepy dolls and say, John I want you to meet my Daughter's. Bet he'll back off then.
 
B

Breeze7

Guest
#3
You don't owe an explanation. In the case of the person you knew for some time I think its really courtesy or caring( showing you have a heart) that you give some authentic sentiments.
 
Z

zaoman32

Guest
#4
explanations are for the birds
 
Z

zaoman32

Guest
#6
So I'm guessing, Zao, that you're saying that the birds don't have to explain what the bees are doing... :p
what's all this talk about birds and bees...I mean....nevermind, I'm posting that question in streams...

I do think explanations can be overrated though. In a case of not being interested, it really doesn't matter. If you're not attracted to someone you're not attracted to someone, they just need to deal with it and drop it
 

rachelsedge

Senior Member
Oct 15, 2012
3,659
81
48
34
#7
It might be just me but if someone rejects me, I don't bother to ask why. Maybe I'm just afraid of more hurt in addition to the rejection? Because if I don't ask, I can make up my OWN reasons as to why they don't like me, and maybe that seems less painful than allowing someone else to choose their own reasons and tell you all the things they find unattractive about you. At least if I tell myself something like, "Well, I'm not pretty enough," I still have control over my own rejection, in a twisted kind of way.
Yes, this. I understand this.

As far as wanting to know why, I guess I just don't see the point as it's not really going to change anything. If I reject someone because I just don't see it going anywhere, they could ask me for specifics and 1) it would be hard to explain because sometimes it's not specifics, sometimes you just have this gut feeling, you just know; and 2) even if it were specifics, are you going to change everything about yourself so that maybe I will like you? What good does that do?

It makes me wonder if aggressive "wanting-to-know"ers are insecure, thinking it'll be something they can "fix" about themselves to make you like them or be a better person. When in reality, it just may not be a good fit, and someone who is secure in themselves would be able to see that and just move on.

In longer term friendships I could see it getting a little stickier, but I think my point above still stand even in those situations.

Not that I'm vastly experienced in this arena, those are just some thoughts. ;)
 
J

JustAnotherUser

Guest
#8
It likely comes down to two things - insecurity and aggressiveness, which often go hand in hand. People don't like being rejected and told no if they find the opportunity to get something that they want. If it becomes obsessive then I would worry about the type of person that they would be if I were to accept their interest. There has to be a line set as to when to let go and if they continue on pursuing then how they would go about it, though it may not shift my answer or should it be mandatory to do so.

It has sort of happened in one situation and pretty much the only time someone who 'took interest' in me went as far as asking and kept trying to come in contact, on the phone and in real life. Eventually I couldn't keep contact anymore.
 
May 3, 2013
8,719
75
0
#9
There are two situations, the online and the "live" and actually.

Online, ppl developed some hunches they know it without words. It´s easy to be detached as "easy comes easy goes"

Those that once were friends and wanted to step in another level might look somewhat masochistic when asking why. If they were rejected (and surely disliked) that is enough reason to stay away and to avoid asking love or friendship but, those who "violently" insisted on asking are indeed rude and, the ricochet response, will be similar (even worst).

I know one story of one of my friends... When he rejected that woman he was living with (she was a blond model) she hated him with bitter remorse: It was the 1st time a person left her, without her selfish reasons.

It depends on their shoes, of course.
 
C

cmarieh

Guest
#10
I personally feel that it depends on how you know them. If you just talk occasionally then I can understand not giving them an explanation. However, if you have developed a friendship I do feel as though if an explanation is requested then doing the right thing is stating why.
 

jsr1221

Senior Member
Jul 7, 2013
4,265
77
48
#11
I guess I'm the only one so far that thinks this. You don't have to give them one, but I think it'd be common courtesy to give them one. Depending on the situation, it could come off like "hey I'm interested in you. Let's do this " then the next day you just ignore the person and the person is left wondering "What's up?!" which can come off as aggressive. I just think it'd be common courtesy, and if it's something the person could work on wouldn't you want it to be said to you if you were the one left hanging?
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,242
5,210
113
#12
I guess I'm the only one so far that thinks this. You don't have to give them one, but I think it'd be common courtesy to give them one. Depending on the situation, it could come off like "hey I'm interested in you. Let's do this " then the next day you just ignore the person and the person is left wondering "What's up?!" which can come off as aggressive. I just think it'd be common courtesy, and if it's something the person could work on wouldn't you want it to be said to you if you were the one left hanging?
Hi Jsr,

You make some really good points (as does everyone else) and I understand what you're saying about a balance of being respectful and courteous as well as telling the person what's going on.

I'll try to give an example of what I'm thinking of. I've had online situations especially in which a guy will contact me and maybe we'll make small talk instant messages or email. But if I'm not interested and don't think we are a match, I will very clearly state this. Then the person will aggressively follow up with, "Why don't you think we're a match? Why not just come hang out with me and spend some time together?" And I will politely decline.

Then, a few months later... he writes and asks me again... with all the same questions: "Why don't you think we'd be good together?" And it could be a whole host of things. Maybe I just don't feel like there's a connection. Maybe he has situations in his life I'm not comfortable with. Maybe for some reason, I don't get a good vibe from this person a all. Am I obligated to state all these things?

My feeling in that situation is, I clearly said no, and if I said no, it's for a reason. I don't think I should have to explain further. (In the example I'm thinking of, I just couldn't talk to the person about much of anything, along with some other things going on I'd rather not state due to privacy issues.) I understand that this may come across as cold.

But this is really what I'm asking... Where is the line? I understand that people may find this confusing because guys will say, "Well ladies, you tell us to pursue you," but at the same time... I can't find it in my heart to agree to go out with someone whom I feel isn't really listening to what I'm saying, either.

And if it's me who likes another person and they clearly aren't interested, I just let it go. Sometimes people will give me feedback that's helpful as far as bettering myself, but in my own experience, I've found that usually the best advice I receive as far as changing things I can change comes from people who really know who I am, and aren't just reading a profile online or meeting me for the first or nearly first time.
 
Apr 15, 2014
2,050
38
0
#13
There is no explanation needed.
 

tourist

Senior Member
Mar 13, 2014
42,394
16,887
113
69
Tennessee
#14
Explanations can get messy real quick. If there is no chemistry then there is not much point in starting a relationship. There are usually other factors as well. It is best to let your simple 'no' suffice to save hurt and possible embarrassment to the other person.
 
M

mystikmind

Guest
#15
I think it is often the case that guys like to try to improve their dating skills in order to be more successful, so they like to know what they did wrong and avoid doing that the next time.

Personally i think that is a mistake, because you should not be improving yourself to get women, you should be improving yourself for yourself!

How i deal with rejection? Rejection is always unpleasant, but i console myself with the realization she was not the one for me, and i will not change who i am to 'trick' women into dating me, because that is not a good foundation for a long term relationship.
 
Apr 15, 2014
2,050
38
0
#16
I'm of a similar mind as Mystikmind. There are loads of reasons I might not be right for a man, and vice versa. I'm not owed an explanation either.
 
S

Siberian_Khatru

Guest
#17
I don't know about an "explanation," but some footnotes would be the decent thing to do. If you don't want to date me, Kim, because I spit when I talk and fart when I spit, those are things I'd like to know. :p
 

jsr1221

Senior Member
Jul 7, 2013
4,265
77
48
#18
Hi Jsr,

You make some really good points (as does everyone else) and I understand what you're saying about a balance of being respectful and courteous as well as telling the person what's going on.

I'll try to give an example of what I'm thinking of. I've had online situations especially in which a guy will contact me and maybe we'll make small talk instant messages or email. But if I'm not interested and don't think we are a match, I will very clearly state this. Then the person will aggressively follow up with, "Why don't you think we're a match? Why not just come hang out with me and spend some time together?" And I will politely decline.

Then, a few months later... he writes and asks me again... with all the same questions: "Why don't you think we'd be good together?" And it could be a whole host of things. Maybe I just don't feel like there's a connection. Maybe he has situations in his life I'm not comfortable with. Maybe for some reason, I don't get a good vibe from this person a all. Am I obligated to state all these things?

My feeling in that situation is, I clearly said no, and if I said no, it's for a reason. I don't think I should have to explain further. (In the example I'm thinking of, I just couldn't talk to the person about much of anything, along with some other things going on I'd rather not state due to privacy issues.) I understand that this may come across as cold.

But this is really what I'm asking... Where is the line? I understand that people may find this confusing because guys will say, "Well ladies, you tell us to pursue you," but at the same time... I can't find it in my heart to agree to go out with someone whom I feel isn't really listening to what I'm saying, either.

And if it's me who likes another person and they clearly aren't interested, I just let it go. Sometimes people will give me feedback that's helpful as far as bettering myself, but in my own experience, I've found that usually the best advice I receive as far as changing things I can change comes from people who really know who I am, and aren't just reading a profile online or meeting me for the first or nearly first time.
If someone comes back a few months later and doesn't let it go, tthat's a different story. I've been burned really bad and lied to the entire time by two different women, so for me I would like honesty. If you don't think it would work, tell me why you think that. Whether we're in a relationship or not, we are all brothers and sisters in Christ, and if something like honesty to help you in a new relationship down the road with someone else, why not give it to them? As children of Christ, part of our responsibility is to better one another in His name, and I think being honest with the person falls in line with that.
 

jsr1221

Senior Member
Jul 7, 2013
4,265
77
48
#19
I think it is often the case that guys like to try to improve their dating skills in order to be more successful, so they like to know what they did wrong and avoid doing that the next time.

Personally i think that is a mistake, because you should not be improving yourself to get women, you should be improving yourself for yourself!

How i deal with rejection? Rejection is always unpleasant, but i console myself with the realization she was not the one for me, and i will not change who i am to 'trick' women into dating me, because that is not a good foundation for a long term relationship.
While I agree you shouldn't change for anyone, what if you*keep making the same mistakes in relationships? Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. Wouldn't that require a change?
 

seoulsearch

OutWrite Trouble
May 23, 2009
16,242
5,210
113
#20
I don't know about an "explanation," but some footnotes would be the decent thing to do. If you don't want to date me, Kim, because I spit when I talk and fart when I spit, those are things I'd like to know. :p
But those are just some of the things that make you so adorable, Siberian.

The reasons why we couldn't date is an entirely separate issue.

For instance... I don't think I'm well-mannered or nearly sophisticated enough for you. :p