Total inability - original sin - inherited from adam

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
No I don't have a problem with that concept..we are ambassador for our Heavenly Father, strangers traveling this land that is not our home.

If you have the Bible,verses you referred to in you post, it would be helpful. Personally I am not good at guessing.
Which post, ariel? Do you mean you want to see all of the verses in one post? :)
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
I disagree with this.
I put myself up beside the law, I take a deep breath and say...okay, I think I can maybe do it. I'll try.
I put myself up beside Jesus and what He has said and I say, it's useless! Who can ever keep from getting angry or having a resentful thought??

I see, Your coming at it differently.

I see the law as Gods perfection. Only Christ did it (No way I could do it.) who can obey the 1st command completely in one day without breaking it)

when I meant under Christ, I meant under the mercy seat (his blood)

Sorry if I did not word it properly..
 
A

Ariel82

Guest

Interesting, Never thought about it this way..

Imagine leading the whole way, The before you get to the end of the race, get disqualified. (I like it)

(not that we are working for reward anyway, at least we should not be concerned with those things in my view)


I always took that verse to be paul saying his whole christian life was spent gibving the gospel and starting new churches as an ambassador of Christ, He ran hard, because no matter how many churches he started, no matter how many people he helped lead to the lord. A few wrong actions on his part could take that all away, and his ministry and ability to continue doing what he was cast to do would be destroyed (he would be disqualified)

which goes with what you are saying.. It is good to learn new things, Thanks sis :)

Not quite what I was saying....

I took it as a more personal walk..,for example Paul preaches for walking in the Spirit not the flesh.

To walk in the flesh disqualified you from the race. But there is more than one race and the prize is not your salvation but another soul won for Christ.

We run according to the law to win souls to God by how we run, but other brothers and sisters run too and strive to win that soul as well.

However what if everyone gets disqualified?

The Enemy tries to get people to cheat,lures them with false shortcuts, etc.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Not quite what I was saying....

I took it as a more personal walk..,for example Paul preaches for walking in the Spirit not the flesh.

To walk in the flesh disqualified you from the race. But there is more than one race and the prize is not your salvation but another soul won for Christ.

We run according to the law to win souls to God by how we run, but other brothers and sisters run too and strive to win that soul as well.

However what if everyone gets disqualified?

The Enemy tries to get people to cheat,lures them with false shortcuts, etc.
ok, I see it deeper than this.

I see it as we all have our gifts, And god has plans for all of us, Not everyone wil be an apostle. but each persons job is just as important.

No matter what Job we have, We can disqualify ourselves from being able to be used by God by just one sin. (imagine of paul came in the flesh and got caught in an adulterous affair with another mans wife,

It may have been a moment of time walking in the flesh, But his disqualification would have been for along time, if not permanent (he may never have regained peoples trust)

Thats the Way I always saw it anyway,, As usual, I could be wrong..lol or we both could be right
:D
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
169
0
what is love.
True love, Not mans idea of what love is..

by the way, I would agree with pretty much everything you said in this post.
We spend our life trying to fill that void left when mankind sinned against God, and we try to fill this void with things (sin) it is not until we are returned to the natural order of things (God is restored to our lives) that he is able to fill that void like originally intended, And we can stop relying on ourself. But trust God, and we can turn our focus of self, and on God and others.
This is spiritual growth, Trusting God to take care of our needs, and taking what God gives in excess and giving it to help God fill the needs of others.
"what is love" interesting you started with this phrase. Is it something you are asking?

A traditional presentation is God is where hearts should be but self is evil and selfish. If God is making us into righteous, pure holy people, self is not evil, but outward caring and loving. What is on the throne of ones life is the principles and focuses Jesus has put into us and taught us to follow. Everything is about seeing need, meeting, and serving others. This is love.

The dilemma with obedience, is not the reason to obeying, but is the obedience real. The cleansing power of obedience is asking why you cannot obey, repenting, stopping sin, and walking in righteousness. As a disciple you start with the simple stuff and work upwards. When people have the wisdom to see specks, then it is time to talk about attitudes approaches to life etc. 99% of christians are not even at this level, they find the basics too hard.
 
A

Ariel82

Guest
If you want more, we have tons of threads about free will, Armenian versus Calvin theology....

It's not that I haven't or don't understand the theology behind total depravity or Original sin (which is tied to the idea but not quite the same).

It's just I don't really know what you want to discuss concerning it and I don't think it's key to hash it all out again.

I would rather focus on how does God help us become holy, righteous and perfect people.

But I can let you go and beat up the horse, some folks might join you.

Just don't assume that you two are the,only ones on the site who get a it, just cuz you can shout the,loudest today.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
"what is love" interesting you started with this phrase. Is it something you are asking?

A traditional presentation is God is where hearts should be but self is evil and selfish. If God is making us into righteous, pure holy people, self is not evil, but outward caring and loving. What is on the throne of ones life is the principles and focuses Jesus has put into us and taught us to follow. Everything is about seeing need, meeting, and serving others. This is love.

The dilemma with obedience, is not the reason to obeying, but is the obedience real. The cleansing power of obedience is asking why you cannot obey, repenting, stopping sin, and walking in righteousness. As a disciple you start with the simple stuff and work upwards. When people have the wisdom to see specks, then it is time to talk about attitudes approaches to life etc. 99% of christians are not even at this level, they find the basics too hard.
Yes that was my question. Thanks for trying to answer it..

I asked what Gods view of love is,, Are you holding to the traditional view? I think it is much deeper than that, and that ony maybe scratches the surface, what do you think?

I will hold of responding to your paragraph about obedience, since I asked about love and want to get that issue settled first.

 
A

Ariel82

Guest
ok, I see it deeper than this.

I see it as we all have our gifts, And god has plans for all of us, Not everyone wil be an apostle. but each persons job is just as important.

No matter what Job we have, We can disqualify ourselves from being able to be used by God by just one sin. (imagine of paul came in the flesh and got caught in an adulterous affair with another mans wife,

It may have been a moment of time walking in the flesh, But his disqualification would have been for along time, if not permanent (he may never have regained peoples trust)

Thats the Way I always saw it anyway,, As usual, I could be wrong..lol or we both could be right
:D
God can clean folks and put them back in the race and most races are relay races anyway.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
God can clean folks and put them back in the race and most races are relay races anyway.
Yes he can..

and yes they are. Thats why we need to take the focus of our self and what we do. And on God and what he can do..


and all things, whether in serving others, working inside our gifts, Maturing in Christ, Learning to change our sin habits, If God is not our primary focus We will not win any races..
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
169
0
We have been trying to give you the meaning of those words.
You have two choices..
You put your self up next to the law. And find you are unrighteous.
You put yourself up next to Christ (or should I say under christ) you are righteous.

so what is the context. Being "in Christ" Or "Under the law" there is no other option.
to me, You and HRFTD do not understand this concept. But that is not the issue, I was just showing you how silly and judgmental your comment about how only you two understand your point..
This is just too simplistic. The law just shows us the alien world of the heart of God.
Jesus shows in the cross the open door of love working in a human body.

You see Jesus as a free ticket to heaven and the law just as an exam you failed.

There are some very strong emotional issues here about how emotions lead us to behaviour that is sinful, which is bound up in who we are. If you become someone different, then the behaviour changes. Jesus is into behaviour change, and into changing our emotional frameworks.

And we do understand this concept and the one you are talking about.

You also miss-understood what I was saying.
I am always ignorant about how others are thinking, which is a human failing, but you bring me down to earth.

What I was saying is if you believe you can actually be righteous, pure and holy, not just taking Jesus's imputed status, you need to answer the question of total inability. You from your comments believe this is impossible.

So this is not silly, by a serious goal, which you are not commited to obviously. From our past communications you would also regard any beliefs in this direction as being evil, so already you have a bias. Never a good place to start.
 

Grandpa

Senior Member
Jun 24, 2011
11,555
3,192
113
Galatians 3:24-25
[SUP]24 [/SUP]Wherefore the law was our schoolmaster to bring us unto Christ, that we might be justified by faith.
[SUP]25 [/SUP]But after that faith is come, we are no longer under a schoolmaster.

We are no longer under the law when we come to Christ by faith.

Why?

Because our work at it was a lack of understanding. Or rather, we twist it to think it can be fulfilled by our own carnal will and strength.

The law cannot be fulfilled by a carnal man. Because the law always was spiritual.

The next problem we have is that we can't cause our selves to be spiritual by an act of will and strength. We have to rely on the Lord Jesus Christ, by faith, to become spiritual.

When we rely on the Lord Jesus Christ we repent of our own "understanding" and turn to His Knowledge and Wisdom.

As soon as we turn to our own understanding of what we think the law says and begin working at it we have stopped relying on the Lord Jesus Christ and have abided in our own will and strength.


Inability is not that big of a deal. You can't do it. But Christ can. Have faith that He will guide you in the path of Righteousness.

Ephesians 2:10 For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.

Ezekiel 36:26-27

[SUP]26 [/SUP]A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh.
[SUP]27 [/SUP]And I will put my spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes, and ye shall keep my judgments, and do them.


You can't do any of this. Only God can. It is all a blessing, His Gift. All you can do is attempt to emulate what you think is righteousness. But the bible says lean not unto your own understanding. Because Gods Thoughts are far higher than your thoughts, and His Ways are far higher than your ways.

Hebrews 7:16-19

[SUP]16 [/SUP]Who is made, not after the law of a carnal commandment, but after the power of an endless life.
[SUP]17 [/SUP]For he testifieth, Thou art a priest for ever after the order of Melchisedec.
[SUP]18 [/SUP]For there is verily a disannulling of the commandment going before for the weakness and unprofitableness thereof.
[SUP]19 [/SUP]For the law made nothing perfect, but the bringing in of a better hope did; by the which we draw nigh unto God.


I could go on and on about the Lord Jesus.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
Not quite what I was saying....

I took it as a more personal walk..,for example Paul preaches for walking in the Spirit not the flesh.

To walk in the flesh disqualified you from the race. But there is more than one race and the prize is not your salvation but another soul won for Christ.

We run according to the law to win souls to God by how we run, but other brothers and sisters run too and strive to win that soul as well.

However what if everyone gets disqualified?

The Enemy tries to get people to cheat,lures them with false shortcuts, etc.
I think to say that to walk in the flesh disqualifies you from the race needs some breathing room and I think that breathing room is mercy, forgiveness, and...trusting God that He will always do what is good concerning us.

If to walk in the flesh means immediate disqualification, no one would ever make the cut. All would be disqualified before breakfast time was over. BUT, His mercies begin anew each morning.

It takes SO much patience to raise up a child. How many times does a mother have to tell a toddler to stop throwing toys at the dog? Or to use their inside voice to a child? We wouldn't expect LESS patience from God. We would expect...infinitely MORE patience.

But a mother doesn't just let it all go until some future time. It almost seems this is what some people might think by the things they say.

Hence peter jens objections and struggle with some of the things he hears from people.

Is Gods goal simply that we all receive eternal life? And IF that is His main goal, why did Israel have it so hard with God demanding obedience to the law and we have it so easy, with no law at all?
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
169
0
I agree with two points here

1. Man without God will always sin
2. Man without God will always think the wrong things are good and bad

I also agree that emotional lostness is complete, and unless God breaks in we create for ourselves a self justifying existance.
But once God has broken in, and brought His love and Spirit things change.

The key question for me is what is behaviour and why is it focused one way or the other. Now I know after 30+ years walking with the Lord and learning His ways, and becoming a "mature" christian, which is always relative, I have many faults, I find my understanding of life and what I do and not do are very different than in my youth.

This therefore leads me to understand if ones theology is based on man alone you miss the promise of the Kingdom.
 
Feb 24, 2015
13,204
169
0
Inherited sin nature has two real aspects

1. We are biological creatures limited by our DNA from our parents
2. We are born separate from God

There are two very important aspects of existance
1. Empathy
2. Options

Our brains have to construct what is happening in other people to understand them and have empathy. Without this we could never have a sense of relationships and oneness.

Our brains have to present to us a series of opportunities along with all the emotional paybacks involved. These options have no limit or filter, so can be truly evil or good, because the driving force is survival and optimising the benefits.

Again the fact we are driven and present with all these experiences and alternatives does not mean with a heart of love we cannot choose that which is righteous.

Now many would say Jesus says because the heart pollutes the soul, the heart cannot not be purified.
If you look closely Jesus is saying, purify the heart and then things will be seen correctly. It was the critism of the pharisees that they cleaned the cup but not the heart. To then take that to mean Jesus does not purify our hearts and consciencies is to believe defeat is the way of Christ.
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
This is just too simplistic.
why do you seem to be afraid of everything you think is simple..

I ask of a genuine concern and wonder

Is it realy simple?

Maybe that makes it heard for that very reason. Because our flesh (pride) always gets in the way.


what you see as simple, I see proven every day is one of the hardest things we can ever do.


The law just shows us the alien world of the heart of God.
I think it is deeper than this, The law shows us, If you want to get to me your way, this is what I require (remember, He made moses demand thay, and everyone after, confirm that covenant, by agreeing to confirm and obey every last word completely. One slip up and they failed. The penalty for failing was a curse..

Paul said Christ on the cross removed that curse, Because everyone of us fell short of that standard.


Jesus shows in the cross the open door of love working in a human body.

Yes, Love,, The start of Gods type of love, Not mans kind.


You see Jesus as a free ticket to heaven and the law just as an exam you failed.
I see it different, if you reject the ticket Jesus came to give you, Your left with the law as your only other option.

There are some very strong emotional issues here about how emotions lead us to behaviour that is sinful, which is bound up in who we are. If you become someone different, then the behaviour changes. Jesus is into behaviour change, and into changing our emotional frameworks.

Yes, All based according to scripture on thankfulness and gratitude which is a response to Gods love.


And we do understand this concept and the one you are talking about.

You also miss-understood what I was saying.
I am always ignorant about how others are thinking, which is a human failing, but you bring me down to earth.
Forgive me if I misunderstood you,

I pray I understand better next time, But know I may not always understand all people.. Which is why we should always be open to the fact we could be talking about something totally different that they asked..


What I was saying is if you believe you can actually be righteous, pure and holy, not just taking Jesus's imputed status, you need to answer the question of total inability. You from your comments believe this is impossible.
In your context. No I do not. I can be blameless in a wicked world.. Paul says as much in his letters.

We just have to be careful who we say this too. Some people think they can be this, and this is why they are going to heaven, we must not let them think this is true, because this is them trusting in self. and will lead to a multitude of sin, and a prideful judgmental heart.


which is why I always say, we must figure out context of what others are saying..


I am going to end my respond here, Because I pray we continue this good hearted discussion, so will finish my reply in another post.

I am saddened I have to do this..
 
Last edited by a moderator:
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
So this is not silly, by a serious goal, which you are not commited to obviously. From our past communications you would also regard any beliefs in this direction as being evil, so already you have a bias. Never a good place to start.
see, we got of to a wonderful start today, No judging, No butter fights, Just trying to share the truth as we see it.

Then you had to go and attack me, and again bare false witness against me..


I am committed to spiritual maturity Peter. Anyone here who takes a minute to get to know this will tell you the same.

for you to sit there and say myself and others are not is an outright lie, and I can only assume comes from bitterness, or a prideful heart. I do not know.. But I pray what ever it is, You find out soon, so you can free yourself of this anger.

You just proved what I have been saying all along, You think you know what I believe (which you do not) and you have already made up your mind what I will do.

That my friend, is what you can not discuss the word with anyone for very long. unless they agree 100 % with you.

I pray we forget this last exchange, and put it behind us and continue to have the good hearted discussion we were having before you turned into this once again judgmental person slandering others because you can't find it in yourself to understand the context of their words.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
No the one referencing Ezekiel and Revelation.
Okay! :)
Ezekiel 21 - He tells the prophet to tell the people, I am against you and all of your sanctuaries. I am about to destroy all of you - the righteous along with the wicked. (my paraphrase).
What the heck?? This doesn't fit with Noah, Lot, or any other thing He has ever said!
Is there even one example of God destroying the righteous along with the wicked? We're talking DESTRUCTION - not just like telling His people if they went peacefully to bondage in Babylon they would be safe but if they refused they would die. This is total destruction of the righteous?

It's like He's saying, I don't care if you are righteous or not, you will be destroyed just like the wicked. Was He just having a bad day and He changed His mind later?

And could this tie in somehow to Him saying He was mad at all the priests because they were making no distinction at ALL between what was holy and what was not?

As to the verse in Rev, the 4 groups, my question is, could these 4 groups be placed alongside the 4 soils? And if they were, which groups are the same and how many of the groups produce fruit? It is only the last group.

Could those who do harm be the first soil,
those who are filthy be the second soil,
those who live righteously be the third soil,
and those who are holy be the fourth soil?
 
E

eternally-gratefull

Guest
Okay! :)
Ezekiel 21 - He tells the prophet to tell the people, I am against you and all of your sanctuaries. I am about to destroy all of you - the righteous along with the wicked. (my paraphrase).
What the heck?? This doesn't fit with Noah, Lot, or any other thing He has ever said!
Is there even one example of God destroying the righteous along with the wicked? We're talking DESTRUCTION - not just like telling His people if they went peacefully to bondage in Babylon they would be safe but if they refused they would die. This is total destruction of the righteous?

It's like He's saying, I don't care if you are righteous or not, you will be destroyed just like the wicked. Was He just having a bad day and He changed His mind later?

And could this tie in somehow to Him saying He was mad at all the priests because they were making no distinction at ALL between what was holy and what was not?

As to the verse in Rev, the 4 groups, my question is, could these 4 groups be placed alongside the 4 soils? And if they were, which groups are the same and how many of the groups produce fruit? It is only the last group.

Could those who do harm be the first soil,
those who are filthy be the second soil,
those who live righteously be the third soil,
and those who are holy be the fourth soil?
context is key for ezek.

[SUP]3 [/SUP]and say to the land of Israel, ‘Thus says the Lord: “Behold, I am against you, and I will draw My sword out of its sheath and cut off both righteous and wicked from you. [SUP]4 [/SUP]Because I will cut off both righteous and wicked from you, therefore My sword shall go out of its sheath against all flesh from south to north,

Context is the land, God is going to cut off all people from the land (as he promised in lev 26 he would do if the nation did not obey God)

He finally did it completely in AD 70.

yet as promised, there has always been a remnant,, The righteous are still saved, They just lost their earthly blessing (a home) because of what their bretheren did (sin against God)

Have to research the rev question a little more.
 
Nov 12, 2015
9,112
823
113
context is key for ezek.

[SUP]3 [/SUP]and say to the land of Israel, ‘Thus says the Lord: “Behold, I am against you, and I will draw My sword out of its sheath and cut off both righteous and wicked from you. [SUP]4 [/SUP]Because I will cut off both righteous and wicked from you, therefore My sword shall go out of its sheath against all flesh from south to north,

Context is the land, God is going to cut off all people from the land (as he promised in lev 26 he would do if the nation did not obey God)

He finally did it completely in AD 70.

yet as promised, there has always been a remnant,, The righteous are still saved, They just lost their earthly blessing (a home) because of what their bretheren did (sin against God)

Have to research the rev question a little more.
It does not fit to me to say, I will destroy the righteous along with the wicked, means they would just be cut off from the land. It doesn't fit with the following verses either. A slaughter of all people? A massacre? Why would He not just say, "cut off from the land?"

And the context cannot be land when He says He will bring out His sword against all FLESH, can it...?