Funny you say that in a few ways:
1. Yes, you do go with "divorce her" as your starting counsel most of the time.
2. The last time hubby feared I was thinking about cheating was when he was in rehab. He was getting stronger and stronger each day, so there was no doubts, (by then), he was coming home fairly soon, but it was a VA nursing home, so who else lived there but other vets? One woman out of everyone who was living there long-term or short-term. And, I still smoke, so would go out to have a smoke every 90 minutes. (I even went out there during those few days I quit smoking, just because there was no other place to go. lol)
There's only one place anyone could smoke, and I spent months going out for that cig or two, (sometimes I was kicked out so nurses could work on him. lol) So, sure enough, me being me and all, I became friends with a couple of the guys. And, guys being guys and all, one did try and talk up having sex, but, eww, ewww! (And those really were the words I used. lol) As usual, once shot down, we remained friends. He wasn't ever going home. I was never thinking in those terms, and that is the guy hubby thought I might cheat with the last time. Ew ew! Nice guy, but I only have one type, he's one of a kind, and I married him.
Talking to guys isn't always off the charts for what wives can do. You do get we can deal with advances ourselves, right? And somewhere along the way, we made up our own minds of what we should or shouldn't do. If JL was texting a guy, would you think she was cheating on you? Either men should trust their wives, or shouldn't. That's really for a man to decide, and for the man to decide with his wife only. But, likewise, if you do trust your wife, truly trust her. I agree with you when it comes to JL. She is trustworthy. What ever you and she decide together on the issue of conversing with other guys is your and her's decision. But to go off and tell another guy what his wife should or shouldn't do?
Speaking as a faithful wife, it bothers me as much as it bothers me that your first counsel is often to divorce.
And the reason you telling people to divorce bothers me is because I just happen to know you have a good and faithful wife yourself. What is that saying about her and to her, if she reads this?
I really do get divorce is valid advice, but only if we learn enough about what's happening in that marriage to see it as that. Right now all these two people have is suspicion. And they've both been suspicious since they were dating. Even as I write this, I know Raccoon is looking at something he thinks is a ray of sunshine. (Not quite sure why a promise of future counseling is a ray of sunshine since there has been plenty of history on how counseling goes with them, but it's Christmas time, so a time for hoping for miracles.) But, seriously, this marriage has remained the same since before they were married, so it's not time to go with divorce.
And you really should know that two years invested in a marriage means something significant. It doesn't mean "jump ship."