Hardshell & Primitive Baptist "Conditional Time Salvation" Warning

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
Antinomianism. Jesus rejects this in Matthew 7:23 showing those who practice lawlessness are lost in their sins and hell bound.
From post # 141...


Uh huh, just as I suspected, you are adhering to free grace theology, where one can live like the devil and yet still go to heaven as an unrepentant scoundrel yet be welcomed into heaven with open arms.
 

ForestGreenCook

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2018
8,441
1,213
113
Yet your doctrine doesn't harmonize, has grave errors, and you change or waver on your beliefs after you're refuted. Example? You've mitigated the importance of repentance being a work of man or work of God when the fact is that upon your belief of the former rests your entire position. It's been proven incorrect, it is not a work of man.

You can't just act like that's no big deal now as you did in post #452 where you stated: "Whether it is a gift of God is not the point." That's where you wavered on your all important teaching.

It is a big deal, and it is the point. It clearly shows you're incorrect from the start.

Once again here is some refutation of your argument with Scriptural context:

For instance 2 Timothy 2:8-10.

Context? Preaching the Gospel, verse 8.

Objective? That the elect will be saved, verse 9.

Extent? That this salvation is eternal life in Christ, verse 10.

Second instance:

You've stated repentance and works are of man, therefore Gospel salvation cannot be eternal. OK, fine, that is your argument and basis for rejecting that eternal salvation is given by means of the Gospel, 1 Corinthians 1:21 &c.

Yet, we've shown you repentance and faith concerning the Gospel are not works of man, but the work of God. You've just blown that off. But you cannot do this when proven incorrect. When proven incorrect you have to accept it, and all it entails. I will be more than glad to receive correction once you prove me incorrect, but you're not doing that.

Conclusion? Your theory that it cannot be eternal salvation because these are works of man falls flat on its face and is disproven. Therefore your theory that Gospel salvation cannot be eternal is incorrect.

Lastly? Repeating the same lines over and again are quite tiresome bro. Seriously that is what you do, not trying to be ugly. You repeat what we already know and things we've already agreed with you on.

We've also been addressing each argument you offer, refuting them line by line, yet you skip over main points of our arguments only to repeat "the natural man cannot receive the things of the spirit of God" and Ephesians 2:5. Come on sir, that is not a debate, it's a cop out.

We already know these texts and agree on this concerning natural man, yet God takes natural man and converts him.

You really ought to concede that you've been refuted at the very foundation of your doctrine as shown above.
conversion comes only after regeneration. The natural man cannot be converted to see the gospel until after he is regenerated. Yes I keep harping about the natural man because you keep saying that he responds to the spiritual gospel before he is regenerated and given the Holy Spirit. I would not have to keep bringing the natural man up if you would just go by what the scripture says and quit giving the natural man the ability to discern spiritual things. The only way that repentance of man is connected to God is that he commands him to repent and he pricks his changed heart after he is regenerated. none of this happens before regeneration. You may think you have, but you have not refuted anything, you have just shown your lack of knowledge of the scriptures.
 

ForestGreenCook

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2018
8,441
1,213
113
Oh please!!! :ROFL:

Um, the Native Americans? Happy hunting ground? Ring a bell? Please see yourself for once and be honest with things you state.

For the record all PB's do this, they can "tell" who the elect are. You've done it yourself. It's a practice of PB's and you know it.

Next!
Are you saying that I grouped the sum of all of the native american as the elect, not so, they are just as we are, some elect and some not and no one can tell them apart for sure. You do that, time, and time again about asserting what I believe, and I don't think you have any idea what I believe, so quit trying to conform me to your liking, in order to ridicule me.
 

ForestGreenCook

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2018
8,441
1,213
113
Well, you say God’s elect can live like hellions and still be welcomed into heaven. I called you on this many pages ago. You are advocating free grace theology my friend.
Yes, God's grace is free, you cannot earn it. If by his foreknowledge he saw that all mankind was filthy and that none would seek after him and that is who he choose his elect from and had Christ to clean them up. I would term that as free grace.
 

Hevosmies

Well-known member
Sep 8, 2018
3,612
2,633
113
After 25 pages we finally know the reason WHY we should choose a primitive baptist Realtor... because they dont believe in the "Great Commission" :cool:
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
Yes, God's grace is free, you cannot earn it. If by his foreknowledge he saw that all mankind was filthy and that none would seek after him and that is who he choose his elect from and had Christ to clean them up. I would term that as free grace.
So, you are advocating God's elect can live like hellions for YEARS, even after being saved? Really? Please answer this. Thank you my friend.
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
Are you saying that I grouped the sum of all of the native american as the elect, not so, they are just as we are, some elect and some not and no one can tell them apart for sure. You do that, time, and time again about asserting what I believe, and I don't think you have any idea what I believe, so quit trying to conform me to your liking, in order to ridicule me.
Wrong my friend. 15 “Beware of the false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly are ravenous wolves. 16 You will know them by their fruits. Grapes are not gathered from thorn bushes nor figs from thistles, are they? 17 So every good tree bears good fruit, but the bad tree bears bad fruit. 18 A good tree cannot produce bad fruit, nor can a bad tree produce good fruit. 19 Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire. 20 So then, you will know them by their fruits.(Matthew 7)

We know the saved from the lost by the lives they live. The Native American Indian worshipped idols and not the One True God. They did not know that God came in the flesh, lived a sinless life, died upon a cross, rose from the dead three days later, ascended to the Father, and is now interceding for the saints, and that He is coming again to gather His elect from the earth.
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
conversion comes only after regeneration. The natural man cannot be converted to see the gospel until after he is regenerated. Yes I keep harping about the natural man because you keep saying that he responds to the spiritual gospel before he is regenerated and given the Holy Spirit. I would not have to keep bringing the natural man up if you would just go by what the scripture says and quit giving the natural man the ability to discern spiritual things. The only way that repentance of man is connected to God is that he commands him to repent and he pricks his changed heart after he is regenerated. none of this happens before regeneration. You may think you have, but you have not refuted anything, you have just shown your lack of knowledge of the scriptures.
That is a flat out lie my friend. He has never stated that. You need to prove this. Pull up that post where he said this or either admit you lied on him. I am seeing a pattern of lying from you my friend. You need to conduct yourself better on here, friend.
 

iamsoandso

Senior Member
Oct 6, 2011
8,048
1,609
113
After 25 pages we finally know the reason WHY we should choose a primitive baptist Realtor... because they dont believe in the "Great Commission" :cool:

That's why I said a page or so back what I did. does the great commission mean go out and save everyone or go out and tell them Jesus saved them? If a preacher tells you Jesus saved you and then ask you if you've been saved yet it could only mean he don't believe what he just told you. No one gets in a taxi and ask the driver if he knows where they can find a taxi.

If a man lays in bed at night and begs the Lord to save him it can only mean he don't believe Jesus did at the cross. If a man begs Jesus to make him understand so he can tell his family and friends it means he don't believe Jesus did at the cross and he thinks he is his own and their savior.

If a man believes Jesus saved him at the cross he can thank him for it and sing praises. If a man don't believe he saved him at the cross he cant thank him or praise him for it but he will because he sees everyone else doing it. An unbelievers mouth says Jesus is his savior but his hands are trying to save himself. A man can be saved by the blood of the cross and deny it. There is a heavy weight on an unbelievers shoulders and much to do but a believers prayers are all answered and he is at rest. Not everyone is at peace in the rest,some are in agony and torment of unbelief go out and tell them the Lord saved them on the cross at Calvary.
 
Oct 25, 2018
2,377
1,198
113
conversion comes only after regeneration. The natural man cannot be converted to see the gospel until after he is regenerated. Yes I keep harping about the natural man because you keep saying that he responds to the spiritual gospel before he is regenerated and given the Holy Spirit. I would not have to keep bringing the natural man up if you would just go by what the scripture says and quit giving the natural man the ability to discern spiritual things. The only way that repentance of man is connected to God is that he commands him to repent and he pricks his changed heart after he is regenerated. none of this happens before regeneration. You may think you have, but you have not refuted anything, you have just shown your lack of knowledge of the scriptures.
Here's an excerpt from an Alistair Begg sermon...

What is the work of the Spirit of God?
It is to accomplish what cannot be accomplished in any other way, by any other root.
The Bible is so clear on this, if you read Ephesians 2.
He Says you were dead in your trespasses and in your sins.
You were made alive in Christ.
How can dead people come to life?
It will take a miracle.
You See, This is the gospel.
The gospel is not a word of encouragement to those who are well meaning people who would like to add a little religion.
It is not a word of encourage to those who want a little Jesus in their life.
No the word of the gospel is a word that comes to the rebel heart.
I am a rebel against God.
I might be indifferent to Him, I might be agnostic to Him.
But I am actually rebelling against Him.
He then comes by the Bible I am commanding you to do an about turn, to repent of your sins and believe in me.
And the individual says there is no way that is going to happen!
Its will take a miracle for that to happen.
Yes it will!
That is the miracle of regeneration.

You see, true regeneration happens when someone is confronted with the word of God, whether they read it or it is explained to them. They are given the very words that gives them wisdom that leads to salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus.(2 Timothy 3:15)
 

preacher4truth

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,719
113
Are you saying that I grouped the sum of all of the native american as the elect, not so,
That's beside the point.

Nice try though.

You claimed they are elect because they believe in the happy hunting ground and used it as evidence for your false gospel and as proof that your misinterpretation of 1 Corinthians 2:14 is true. You then said you never stated you know who are elect later on after you made this absurd claim and after I called you on it.

In conclusion? Um, yes, you do claim this and so do other PB's, well known fact and goes with the territory of your gnostic false gospel.

they are just as we are, some elect and some not and no one can tell them apart for sure.
Uh-huh.

A while back you could tell them apart, that is, until you got called on it. Now you're being deceitful and disingenuous, trying to weasel your way out of it. Own yourself and the asinine claims you make.

You do that, time, and time again about asserting what I believe, and I don't think you have any idea what I believe, so quit trying to conform me to your liking, in order to ridicule me.
I just go by what you say and then you try to wiggle out of it. Any honest person can see that you're a person who makes up what others believe based on NOTHING they've ever said. I base your beliefs on what you ACTUALLY say and you try to wiggle out of it.

Quite dishonest of you, but you're the one painting your picture of yourself on here.
 

preacher4truth

Senior Member
Dec 28, 2016
9,171
2,719
113
conversion comes only after regeneration. The natural man cannot be converted to see the gospel until after he is regenerated. Yes I keep harping about the natural man because you keep saying that he responds to the spiritual gospel before he is regenerated and given the Holy Spirit. I would not have to keep bringing the natural man up if you would just go by what the scripture says and quit giving the natural man the ability to discern spiritual things. The only way that repentance of man is connected to God is that he commands him to repent and he pricks his changed heart after he is regenerated. none of this happens before regeneration. You may think you have, but you have not refuted anything, you have just shown your lack of knowledge of the scriptures.

And another outright lie but you've been doing this for quite a while now.

One can tell when their intended target has been hit, there are casualties and crying. I'm nailing your false gospel and exposing it, exposing you is just a bonus and you're telling on yourself here that you've been found out.

That and you still won't deal with the texts but just spew your doctrine around. I've given you Scripture and context, you don't want to deal with that, instead you resort to vitriol.

You're correct about my lacking in the knowledge of the Scriptures, I have lots more to learn. I've only read it through many times, read daily, and study daily commentaries, books, sermons, theological works.

But with all that, I have a LOT more to learn. But one thing is for certain, sir, your gospel is as false as the book of Mormon, both are heresy, which in my understanding is a dangerous doctrine that damn's men's souls to hell.

What you're telling me in your attempt to ridicule my lack of knowledge is that yours is superior. That's fine, I can read between the lines and it doesn't bother me, because yours is the same tactic that the false ministers in Paul's day used on him. (viz. 1 & 2 Corinthians, Galatians.) It's interesting that you use their same means of attack, and quite telling.

Now, you go on, go around and tell people out there they're elect and on their way to heaven because you can tell. Hmmm assuring people they're on their way to eternal life because you can tell, and when people hear your nonsense, they're going to say to themselves;

"Well, I believe in the afterlife, and FGC and the PB's say that means I am going to heaven, no matter what! And he says I don't need to believe the Gospel, nor in the God of the Bible, nor in repentance, nor have biblical faith in God. And? I can live like hell! Man, that sure is "attractive" to me!!!"

Yeah, yeah, you keep on preaching that nonsense sir. I think any fool can tell whose is the false gospel here.

That's going to work out nicely on the day you give an account, I'm sure.
 
Mar 28, 2016
15,954
1,528
113
FGC and the PB's have it fixed in such a way that the elect don't have to have any faith. Think about it, if this were true then Universalism is true. According to their teaching, who are we to say someone isn't converted, they don't even have to believe in Christ, the Gospel, nothing. Believe in the afterlife and *BAM* you're in! (better yet, who are they to say that others are converted due to their claims that go against Scripture?)

We are justified by faith, that is a truth of the Gospel for certain. There are no other classes of the converted. But FGC doesn't deal with context, all passages are divorced from context.
I am not familiar with those abbreviations. Is one Plymouth Brethren?

I do agree with the faith issue . God reckons the whole human race as having none.(no faith) Many from my experience think they have some faith to start with .But that is not a biblical teaching.
 

ForestGreenCook

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2018
8,441
1,213
113
That's beside the point.

Nice try though.

You claimed they are elect because they believe in the happy hunting ground and used it as evidence for your false gospel and as proof that your misinterpretation of 1 Corinthians 2:14 is true. You then said you never stated you know who are elect later on after you made this absurd claim and after I called you on it.

In conclusion? Um, yes, you do claim this and so do other PB's, well known fact and goes with the territory of your gnostic false gospel.



Uh-huh.

A while back you could tell them apart, that is, until you got called on it. Now you're being deceitful and disingenuous, trying to weasel your way out of it. Own yourself and the asinine claims you make.



I just go by what you say and then you try to wiggle out of it. Any honest person can see that you're a person who makes up what others believe based on NOTHING they've ever said. I base your beliefs on what you ACTUALLY say and you try to wiggle out of it.

Quite dishonest of you, but you're the one painting your picture of yourself on here.
The regenerated American Indian believed in a spiritual God, but had not been taught what to call him. That thought does not even enter the mind of the natural man who has not the Spirit of God dwelling within him. Some of your heckling reminds me of what Jesus had to go through. We can discuss the scriptures in a rational tone, if you can discipline yourself to do so.
 

ForestGreenCook

Well-known member
Jul 8, 2018
8,441
1,213
113
I am not familiar with those abbreviations. Is one Plymouth Brethren?

I do agree with the faith issue . God reckons the whole human race as having none.(no faith) Many from my experience think they have some faith to start with .But that is not a biblical teaching.
Faith is a fruit of the Spirit. When you are born of the Spirit your faith that is given to you in regeneration grows as you come unto a knowledge of the truth.