Not By Works

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

Kroogz

Well-known member
Dec 5, 2023
1,740
823
113
No one truly saved can refuse giving their Testimony, giving of themselves to Godly purposes, sharing Jesus to others, feeding the hungry, clothing the needy, helping the widow.
An unbeliever can do all of the above. Many, many unbelievers can fool us.

So the question is.....What are Godly works?
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,554
6,790
113
still should not judge them, leave that to God. they could be prodigal children.. (I was one for 5 years)
There is only One Who is authorized to judge. His judgement is mercy for al who believe.
As for observing other' works, fervent, faithful prayer is works. Acting upon the gift of faith is also.. Love is works in every aspect thereof, and it is a joy to share when give to do so.
So bickering over works is moot for all who are humble in the faith, and not to be judged by any other than our blessed Savior. You said it alread, but I had thought to reply about this when I read your post, God bless you always in Jesus, Yeshua, amen.
 
Oct 19, 2024
4,879
1,055
113
USA-TX
Yea but back then I don't remember Calvin's name being brought up anywhere as much as it is now. Back then it was more about "hyper grace" vs legalism, and back then I was on the opposite side of the argument that I am now. At that point I did believe we could lose our salvation. I didn't believe we could exactly "lose it", as much as I believed we had to have the same freedom to walk away from it as we had to come to it.

Basically I believed like many here teach, that I came to Jesus via my free will and choice, so I just couldn't reconcile that I come to Jesus a free man and am transformed by His mighty power and am made a slave that no longer has the free will choice to walk away from it all if I felt like it and choose to do so.

I just couldn't make sense of this dilemma in my head and went to all these passages that seem to suggest we can lose salvation and read them just like all the others here that teach this. Then God open my eyes to the truth, I didn't come to Him and "choose" Him with my free will, He picked my dead, lifeless, hopeless, helpless, broken self up, and gave me life like I've never known. He did that, I didn't choose it. As a matter of fact, I have to take that back, I did choose Him. I used my free will to respond to the alter call, to repeat the prayer, and was told that I was now saved. I wasn't. So, when the real test in life hit and I was not saved and only thought I was, I found the whole God/Jesus/Christianity thing fell VERY short and just turned from it thinking it was all useless and it led me to where I started this post at, a dead, lifeless, hopeless, helpless, broken man stuck here in life because I can't leave my two sons with nothing but "my dad killed himself".

When I hit my knees in truth it was because I saw clearly the result of "my way" and there was no escape from it. That day, the day God granted me repentance, that day, I didn't even know what was happening, but I saw my way for what it was in truth, and I quit it, I turned from it. I'm not going to go through all the detail I do on here all too often, but I woke up the next day a new man, a completely new creature, born-again of the Spirit and amazed with new eyes and guide.

All that to make the point that it wasn't me who decided to come to Jesus and "get saved". When I did do that, it just made me a false convert, however when I was really saved, saved in truth and in Spirit, I was saved by God not my choice. There is just no denying that for me, I know I didn't have ANY hand in saving myself at all. Then I read His word and read that we are not free, not at all ever. Not that we don't have choice or agency, we do and that is VERY important of course, but no matter what our choices are always enslaved to our natures, which there are two of. The flesh and the Spirit. That born of the flesh puts his mind to things of the flesh, worries about fleshly things and cannot please God, but he who is born of the Spirit sets his mind to the things of the Spirit and only he who has been born of the Spirit is even capable of pleasing God. The man of the flesh CANNOT be pleasing to God, it's just not possible. And before we even think about tooting our own horn, we can only be pleasing to God because Jesus covers us in His perfect righteousness, however this does lead our hearts to desire to live in a pleasing way to God.

I guess there was just no way for me to get my point across in a short, sweet post, but thinking of DC and these old debates reminded me that we are all growing and even truly born-again believers can change our position on some of these issues. We really shouldn't let these things divide us the way they do to the point we are just two gangs going at each other in a nonstop loop/holding pattern never growing closer to each other or to God and doing nothing at all to glorify Him at all.
Re "we are all growing and even truly born-again believers can change our position on some of these issues. We really shouldn't let these things divide us the way they do to the point we are just two gangs going at each other in a nonstop loop/holding pattern never growing closer to each other or to God and doing nothing at all to glorify Him at all.": Amen, and that is my main concern as I participate on CC. It is interesting that my testimony runs in the opposite direction from yours: raised from infancy to be Christian and never rebelling, but also taught OSAS and coming to understand that MFW is the better harmonization of Scripture than TULIP.
 
Oct 19, 2024
4,879
1,055
113
USA-TX
many people got banned all at once. it was during a calvinist debate that Got out of hand, after the mods warning people a few times. and no one heeding, they not only closed the thread. but banned many from both sides who took part.
Wow! That is sad. I wonder what "got out of hand" consisted of--cursing people out or what?
 

lrs68

Active member
Dec 30, 2024
822
226
43
still should not judge them, leave that to God. they could be prodigal children.. (I was one for 5 years)
You are correct but I am talking about those making a claim to be saved, not to being a prodigal.

Once we claim to be saved immediately by all types of people we begin being watched to see if there's a real sincere change in our actions and behavior. It just happens whether someone is trying to or not trying to judge.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,554
6,790
113
Re "we are all growing and even truly born-again believers can change our position on some of these issues. We really shouldn't let these things divide us the way they do to the point we are just two gangs going at each other in a nonstop loop/holding pattern never growing closer to each other or to God and doing nothing at all to glorify Him at all.": Amen, and that is my main concern as I participate on CC. It is interesting that my testimony runs in the opposite direction from yours: raised from infancy to be Christian and never rebelling, but also taught OSAS and coming to understand that MFW is the better harmonization of Scripture than TULIP.
Sounds to me like denominational requirements clashing.
I believe we are all safe when we are following the Way, the Truth and the Life with no exceptions.
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,716
2,135
113
You are correct but I am talking about those making a claim to be saved, not to being a prodigal.

Once we claim to be saved immediately by all types of people we begin being watched to see if there's a real sincere change in our actions and behavior. It just happens whether someone is trying to or not trying to judge.
You can not judge a person or determine what works they have, nor has God demanded you do this.

Not everyone changes overnight. Paul spoke to a whole church of baby Christians, who still struggled with all kinds of sin.

if God saved you. You can be assured. he who began that work will complete it.
 

lrs68

Active member
Dec 30, 2024
822
226
43
I hope you are perfect in all these things.
If not then it's acceptable to believe you are not saved.
Doing the works God leads us to do like feeling we should help someone or suddenly get a specific number thought to how much money we should give doesn't mean anyone is perfect. It means a person is truly converted and serving God and He is able to use them as a way for Him to help others.

When I am led by God to help it's not actually me doing it even though it looks like it is me. It's God doing it but He's able to do it through me or those truly saved. But none of that makes a person perfect. It makes them applicable to do God's Will.
 

lrs68

Active member
Dec 30, 2024
822
226
43
You can not judge a person or determine what works they have, nor has God demanded you do this.

Not everyone changes overnight. Paul spoke to a whole church of baby Christians, who still struggled with all kinds of sin.

if God saved you. You can be assured. he who began that work will complete it.
James, the brother of Jesus said we can see his works and that it reflects his Faith in God. That should be able to apply to anyone of us.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,554
6,790
113
Doing the works God leads us to do like feeling we should help someone or suddenly get a specific number thought to how much money we should give doesn't mean anyone is perfect. It means a person is truly converted and serving God and He is able to use them as a way for Him to help others.

When I am led by God to help it's not actually me doing it even though it looks like it is me. It's God doing it but He's able to do it through me or those truly saved. But none of that makes a person perfect. It makes them applicable to do God's Will.
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,716
2,135
113
James, the brother of Jesus said we can see his works and that it reflects his Faith in God. That should be able to apply to anyone of us.
No he did not

James told people to inspect their own faith

He told them if they claimn to have faith, but has no work, can your faith save you

the answer is no. because they never had faith
 

Magenta

Senior Member
Jul 3, 2015
63,897
32,444
113
read the thread especially at the end.. There were some prety strong attacks of people on both sides.
Remember the guy who joined the thread making a provably false claim, and we told him to go read the thread, and he came back 15 minutes later and said he had read all (approximately) 50,000 posts??? LOL
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,554
6,790
113
lrs68 said:
Doing the works God leads us to do like feeling we should help someone or suddenly get a specific number thought to how much money we should give doesn't mean anyone is perfect. It means a person is truly converted and serving God and He is able to use them as a way for Him to help others.

When I am led by God to help it's not actually me doing it even though it looks like it is me. It's God doing it but He's able to do it through me or those truly saved. But none of that makes a person perfect. It makes them applicable to do God's Will.
Sorry for my finger getting out of hand.

Your description of our Father in Heaven using us is great. It is after we have been uded as instruments we realize a miracle has occurred. He does all of the work, while we simply avail ourselves to Him as tools. When the usage is complete the tool is just as amazed as the recipient.
 

BillG

Senior Member
Feb 15, 2017
9,175
4,553
113
You can not judge a person or determine what works they have, nor has God demanded you do this.

Not everyone changes overnight. Paul spoke to a whole church of baby Christians, who still struggled with all kinds of sin.

if God saved you. You can be assured. he who began that work will complete it.
Matthew 13:24-30

The Parable of the Wheat and the Tares
24 Another parable He put forth to them, saying: “The kingdom of heaven is like a man who sowed good seed in his field; 25 but while men slept, his enemy came and sowed tares among the wheat and went his way. 26 But when the grain had sprouted and produced a crop, then the tares also appeared. 27 So the servants of the owner came and said to him, ‘Sir, did you not sow good seed in your field? How then does it have tares?’ 28 He said to them, ‘An enemy has done this.’ The servants said to him, ‘Do you want us then to go and gather them up?’ 29 But he said, ‘No, lest while you gather up the tares you also uproot the wheat with them. 30 Let both grow together until the harvest, and at the time of harvest I will say to the reapers, “First gather together the tares and bind them in bundles to burn them, but gather the wheat into my barn.” ’ ”
 

BillG

Senior Member
Feb 15, 2017
9,175
4,553
113
We are not saved by works but if we are truly saved we will have Godly works. So anyone claiming to be saved but has no Godly works it is acceptable to believe that person isn't truly saved.

No one truly saved can refuse giving their Testimony, giving of themselves to Godly purposes, sharing Jesus to others, feeding the hungry, clothing the needy, helping the widow.
^
If you are able to reject any or all of those Godly works then it's acceptable to believe you are not saved.
No one can say who is truly saved other than Jesus.
If a believer can only put food on their table based on what they have and do not feed a hungry person can you assume they are not saved?
 
Dec 18, 2021
6,716
2,135
113
Remember the guy who joined the thread making a provably false claim, and we told him to go read the thread, and he came back 15 minutes later and said he had read all (approximately) 50,000 posts??? LOL
yeah there were some make believers there who thought they knew it all. Sad!!