Mary the mother of my Lord (Heresy?)

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.
Dec 5, 2012
885
5
0
I do not remember the whole history of how it came to be, but where the vatican is now, it was a place that hated christians and it had something to do with Peter being put on the cross there to push the christians away, then it became the burial grounds for many christians. Many christians kept going there and later it became the vatican. I remember the story to be quite rich and motivating to me, but it is also very long.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
In my view, Mary is just a woman that was chosen to bear Jesus into the world. She isn't more holy or special than any other earthly woman. She was sinful and corrupt like we are all. She wasn't a "saint", she was simply a woman chosen to bear the task of being Jesus's earthly mother, even though he was God, he had to have a way to be called 'earthly' by being born by an ordinary woman who chose to have faith. Sure, he could've just called himself from heaven to earth and been an adult, however that wouldn't be 'human' in the way we see it, as being developed in the womb and then being birthed and growing up.

She's not a mediator, she's not an angel, she's not God. She's not who we pray to. We pray to Jesus who is our lord who died on the cross to allow us to be with him in eternity. If he was just born into the world, it wouldn't have been enough. If he was born into the world and was just beaten and put the crown of thorns on his head, it wouldn't have been enough. If he was jailed, it wouldn't have been enough. He had to die for our sins.

Mary was just a vessel for him to be born, as the 'godhuman' into the world. Both fully human and fully God.
just picking out the Mary 'isn't more special' part.

I think it would be the greatest privilege,blessedness,honor to carry in my womb (if I were a woman that is) the Creator of the heavens and earth, the Savior of all mankind even He who made the maiden that carried Him. I think that would make her 'special' as she is more blessed among all women which interestingly is a word you have not included.
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
Its ok bro i would love to hear it if you can show me rock22
Or find any text on it or youtube vid etc.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
Born anything other than being born again will not get you to heaven.

Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. (Joh 3:3)

I will answer you in dew time bro.
I think the time is 'dew'.
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
Born anything other than being born again will not get you to heaven.

Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. (Joh 3:3)



I think the time is 'dew'.
Lol now now patience is a virtue
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
Born anything other than being born again will not get you to heaven.

Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. (Joh 3:3)



I think the time is 'dew'.
To be saved is to be børn again to be be børn again is gods salvation all Praise must go to god.
For now you are a christian you have converted to the true gospel .
You have excepted jesus into your life your salvation is jesus. all praise goes to god.
From this day on you shall know the truth.
Salvation though can be lost because now that you know the truth if you sin you are deliberetly sining.
Unless i know sincerly you did not mean it.

Be careful not to.become to righteous on my lost sheep now that you know the truth, because as much as i wanted you back i want them back to .
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
Born anything other than being born again will not get you to heaven.

Jesus answered and said unto him, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born again, he cannot see the kingdom of God. (Joh 3:3)



I think the time is 'dew'.
To be saved is to be børn again to be be børn again is gods salvation all Praise must go to god.
For now you are a christian you have converted to the true gospel .
You have excepted jesus into your life your salvation is jesus. all praise goes to god.
From this day on you shall know the truth.
Salvation though can be lost because now that you know the truth if you sin you are deliberetly sining.
Unless i know sincerly you did not mean it.

Be careful not to.become to righteous on my lost sheep now that you know the truth, because as much as i wanted you back i want them back to .
If in doubt always ask why
 
K

kenisyes

Guest
Saints to pray for another Saint on Heavens?

Indeed we get many blessing from God even we didn't directly ask.But on all things we must give a thanks to God.All things coming from Him.Good as reward and bad as punishment(because of love on us).
Sorry, what they are attacking is that we should ask saints to pray for use who are still on earth. It did not come out right.
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
I do not remember the whole history of how it came to be, but where the vatican is now, it was a place that hated christians and it had something to do with Peter being put on the cross there to push the christians away, then it became the burial grounds for many christians. Many christians kept going there and later it became the vatican. I remember the story to be quite rich and motivating to me, but it is also very long.
Im composing for you a verry comprehensive study on first christian churches in rome and bishops of rome and whether there is links between the pope of rome and the first bishop of rome st peter

So will post soon for you
 
Nov 22, 2012
626
2
0
Sorry, what they are attacking is that we should ask saints to pray for use who are still on earth. It did not come out right.

Sure,on earth also.Nothing wrong in it.But what about them who are in Jesus alredy,are they near Him,or what?If they are in Him,then they pray directly in front of Him.His prayers are very effective.
 
K

kenisyes

Guest
Sure,on earth also.Nothing wrong in it.But what about them who are in Jesus alredy,are they near Him,or what?If they are in Him,then they pray directly in front of Him.His prayers are very effective.
Understand, I am not defending either side. Some of them believe these people are dead, and resting until the resurrection on the last day. Even if not, they say, why not just go to Jesus directly? I started as a boy being taught to pray to saints, so I have had plenty of chance to try it both ways. I have to say, going to Jesus directly is way faster, more efficient, and He even answers me regularly with understanding. The saints never did that for me.
 
Nov 22, 2012
626
2
0
Understand, I am not defending either side. Some of them believe these people are dead, and resting until the resurrection on the last day. Even if not, they say, why not just go to Jesus directly? I started as a boy being taught to pray to saints, so I have had plenty of chance to try it both ways. I have to say, going to Jesus directly is way faster, more efficient, and He even answers me regularly with understanding. The saints never did that for me.

Look,no one ever forced me to pray to any Saint.That will tell u Monks,if u have big problem of any kind.If u have no childrens,if u are sick a lot itc.
On example,vine of Saint Simeon teh Myrrh bearer,at Mountain Athos with prayers and fast,helped on hundereds of the faithful to get childrens.This is truth and many today find it when all resources are empty.That is at Hilandar Monastery,vine old 800years and from grave of Saint Simeon coming out myrrh.
 
K

kenisyes

Guest
Look,no one ever forced me to pray to any Saint.That will tell u Monks,if u have big problem of any kind.If u have no childrens,if u are sick a lot itc.
On example,vine of Saint Simeon teh Myrrh bearer,at Mountain Athos with prayers and fast,helped on hundereds of the faithful to get childrens.This is truth and many today find it when all resources are empty.That is at Hilandar Monastery,vine old 800years and from grave of Saint Simeon coming out myrrh.
The problem with this kind of information is data like this: click>>Effects of Prayer on Immune System If it works without a saint, there is no way to prove that what happened back then was due to the saint.
 
Q

quickfire

Guest
i think its important to know that the chair of saint peter is not the chair which st peter actualy sat on.



The Chair of Saint Peter is a relic conserved in St. Peter's Basilica, enclosed in a gilt bronze casing that was designed by Gian Lorenzo Bernini and executed 1647-53.
The chair of a bishop is a cathedra. The cathedra in Saint Peter's Basilica was once used by the popes. It was therefore often thought to have been used by Saint Peter himself, but was in fact a gift from Charles the Bald to the Pope in 875


this is a list of popes and bishops dating back to the apostle peter. but should not be taken as direct predesessors to peter our christian leader. peter the apostles title as bishop of rome was given after his death.

here is a list of popes bishops etc dating back to peter.
List of popes - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

what you should also understand that many of them popes where of eastern christian orthodox a long long time ago and they are not now ???

the new testament was ordered to be put together by this guy constantine ??? just after the
Emperor Constantine the Great: Pagan
conversion to christian.

after his conversion he was the first roman pagan to be baptized.
he then ordered that all the the church leaders get together and write the new testament ????
 
Last edited:
Q

quickfire

Guest
i think its important to know that the chair of saint peter is not the chair which st peter actualy sat on.



The Chair of Saint Peter is a relic conserved in St. Peter's Basilica, enclosed in a gilt bronze casing that was designed by Gian Lorenzo Bernini and executed 1647-53.
The chair of a bishop is a cathedra. The cathedra in Saint Peter's Basilica was once used by the popes. It was therefore often thought to have been used by Saint Peter himself, but was in fact a gift from Charles the Bald to the Pope in 875


this is a list of popes and bishops dating back to the apostle peter. but should not be taken as direct predesessors to peter our christian leader. peter the apostles title as bishop of rome was given after his death.

here is a list of popes bishops etc dating back to peter.
List of popes - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

what you should also understand that many of them popes where of eastern christian orthodox a long long time ago and they are not now ???

the new testament was ordered to be put together by this guy constantine ??? just after the
Emperor Constantine the Great: Pagan
conversion to christian.

after his conversion he was the first roman pagan to be baptized.
he then ordered that all the the church leaders get together and write the new testament ????
SORRY THE FIRST ROMAN PAGON EMPEROR TO BE BAPTIZED
 
Nov 22, 2012
626
2
0
The problem with this kind of information is data like this: click>>Effects of Prayer on Immune System If it works without a saint, there is no way to prove that what happened back then was due to the saint.

Look Kenisyes,i dont know why someone do not believe in this,by Faith everything will be given.If faithful come and do exactlly what Monks says there are no reason that it fail.There are many faithful who cannot have childrens,and after they try everything they come to Hilandar Monastery.When no medicine can help,God is their last hope.I will try to give some testimonies.
 
Nov 22, 2012
626
2
0
i think its important to know that the chair of saint peter is not the chair which st peter actualy sat on.



The Chair of Saint Peter is a relic conserved in St. Peter's Basilica, enclosed in a gilt bronze casing that was designed by Gian Lorenzo Bernini and executed 1647-53.
The chair of a bishop is a cathedra. The cathedra in Saint Peter's Basilica was once used by the popes. It was therefore often thought to have been used by Saint Peter himself, but was in fact a gift from Charles the Bald to the Pope in 875


this is a list of popes and bishops dating back to the apostle peter. but should not be taken as direct predesessors to peter our christian leader. peter the apostles title as bishop of rome was given after his death.

here is a list of popes bishops etc dating back to peter.
List of popes - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

what you should also understand that many of them popes where of eastern christian orthodox a long long time ago and they are not now ???

the new testament was ordered to be put together by this guy constantine ??? just after the
Emperor Constantine the Great: Pagan
conversion to christian.

after his conversion he was the first roman pagan to be baptized.
he then ordered that all the the church leaders get together and write the new testament ????

http://christianchat.com/bible-discussion-forum/56094-1700-years-milan-edict.html << visit
 
Nov 22, 2012
626
2
0
As u said quickfire,most of Popes of Church of Rome were Greeks,not Latin.There are many Orthodox Saints among Popes of Rome.
 

crossnote

Senior Member
Nov 24, 2012
30,742
3,670
113
To be saved is to be børn again to be be børn again is gods salvation all Praise must go to god.
For now you are a christian you have converted to the true gospel .
You have excepted jesus into your life your salvation is jesus. all praise goes to god.
From this day on you shall know the truth.
Salvation though can be lost because now that you know the truth if you sin you are deliberetly sining.
Unless i know sincerly you did not mean it.

Be careful not to.become to righteous on my lost sheep now that you know the truth, because as much as i wanted you back i want them back to .
If in doubt always ask why
so if you become His child and then go astray into sin you get the boot?
that's ok, I'm getting off topic...as usual ;(
 
Last edited: