Women as Preachers: Does God's word authorize this???

  • Christian Chat is a moderated online Christian community allowing Christians around the world to fellowship with each other in real time chat via webcam, voice, and text, with the Christian Chat app. You can also start or participate in a Bible-based discussion here in the Christian Chat Forums, where members can also share with each other their own videos, pictures, or favorite Christian music.

    If you are a Christian and need encouragement and fellowship, we're here for you! If you are not a Christian but interested in knowing more about Jesus our Lord, you're also welcome! Want to know what the Bible says, and how you can apply it to your life? Join us!

    To make new Christian friends now around the world, click here to join Christian Chat.

MEN & WOMEN: Agree or disagree with women preaching & leading in churches.


  • Total voters
    37
G

GreenNnice

Guest
Maybe this can put things in a better perspective for everybody.

I do not suffer a women to teach (authority=orgination, thinking loftier than someone else) of man, or to have authority, or to lord over men as if you are God's gift to God.

Maybe this 'infiniite' usage of the two words in questions clears things up, and, here is the original verse to reference.

"I do not suffer a women to teach or to have authority over a man, but to be in silence." 1 Timothy 2:12

Keep in mind that Paul's very NEXT words in 1 Timothy 2, starting v. 13 speak of God forming Adam first and then Eve. Eve was deceived, not Adam. She was the one who started THE BALL ROLLING (thanks a lot, woman :D )
 

oldhermit

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2012
9,144
613
113
70
Alabama
Maybe this can put things in a better perspective for everybody.

I do not suffer a women to teach (authority=orgination, thinking loftier than someone else) of man, or to have authority, or to lord over men as if you are God's gift to God.

Maybe this 'infiniite' usage of the two words in questions clears things up, and, here is the original verse to reference.

"I do not suffer a women to teach or to have authority over a man, but to be in silence." 1 Timothy 2:12

Keep in mind that Paul's very NEXT words in 1 Timothy 2, starting v. 13 speak of God forming Adam first and then Eve. Eve was deceived, not Adam. She was the one who started THE BALL ROLLING (thanks a lot, woman :D )
Paul's citation of the Adimic example serves to lay stress to the reason for the prohibinion that was given TO THE CHURCH. This is not a new principle. Even under the Law women were not allowed beyond the courtyard of the women. Now, in the Church, the devinely established principle still stands.

Do not confuse the prohibition of women speaking, teaching, or preaching in the assymbly with a woman's ability or freedom to teach someone, even a man, outside of the assymbly. This is certainly exemplified in the case Aquilla and Percilla as they were both instrumental in the teaching of Apollos. But, this was not in the assymbly. Can God use women in this capacity? Obviously, and I believe he does. Does he allow them so serve in this copacity in the assymbly? No. In fact, he has forbidden in such chategorical language that can neither be rationalized or explained away.
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
Paul's citation of the Adimic example serves to lay stress to the reason for the prohibinion that was given TO THE CHURCH. This is not a new principle. Even under the Law women were not allowed beyond the courtyard of the women. Now, in the Church, the devinely established principle still stands.

Do not confuse the prohibition of women speaking, teaching, or preaching in the assymbly with a woman's ability or freedom to teach someone, even a man, outside of the assymbly. This is certainly exemplified in the case Aquilla and Percilla as they were both instrumental in the teaching of Apollos. But, this was not in the assymbly. Can God use women in this capacity? Obviously, and I believe he does. Does he allow them so serve in this copacity in the assymbly? No. In fact, he has forbidden in such chategorical language that can neither be rationalized or explained away.

Do not confuse the prohibition of women speaking, teaching, or preaching in the assymbly with a woman's ability or freedom to teach someone
Where does scripture state that women can not teach or preach in the church, or, 'in the assembly?'

Keep in mind, a 'church' is not a building.

I see where they are to be silent IN THE CHURCH and not 'chatter' as is the word's Greek meaning, I think, Nathan (cc user), told us, of 1 Cor. 14/34-35 'silence' orginal Greek meaning as Paul intended, just like 'silence' in 1 Timothy 2:!2 does not mean for women to be silent, but to be 'peaceable,' if the true Greek word is used for our outdated English one, lol .
 

oldhermit

Senior Member
Jul 28, 2012
9,144
613
113
70
Alabama
Where does scripture state that women can not teach or preach in the church, or, 'in the assembly?'

Keep in mind, a 'church' is not a building.

I see where they are to be silent IN THE CHURCH and not 'chatter' as is the word's Greek meaning, I think, Nathan (cc user), told us, of 1 Cor. 14/34-35 'silence' orginal Greek meaning as Paul intended, just like 'silence' in 1 Timothy 2:!2 does not mean for women to be silent, but to be 'peaceable,' if the true Greek word is used for our outdated English one, lol .

Have you not understood a single word I and others have said that you would ask such a question as this. I feel that I am wasting my time here.
 
May 29, 2012
530
1
0
Where does scripture state that women can not teach or preach in the church, or, 'in the assembly?'

Keep in mind, a 'church' is not a building.

I see where they are to be silent IN THE CHURCH and not 'chatter' as is the word's Greek meaning, I think, Nathan (cc user), told us, of 1 Cor. 14/34-35 'silence' orginal Greek meaning as Paul intended, just like 'silence' in 1 Timothy 2:!2 does not mean for women to be silent, but to be 'peaceable,' if the true Greek word is used for our outdated English one, lol .
Again each INDIVIDUAL is a UNION of the man (body) and the woman (spirit). When the bible says that in the churches women are to remain silent, paul is talking about the spirit personified by the wisdom one has obtained. The churches are simply when we are interracting with one another. When women are to remain silent here is an example.

One by whatever wisdom he has believes eating swine is a grave sin against God, another by his wisdom believes swine is not a sin. Now we understand how to act according to the wisdom from above and mother of us all, but what we see is "another" woman or wisdom when these such debates come in to play. How does this woman act in relation to the one in Proverbs 8? Revelation 17 says she REIGNS over KINGS or mankind.
 
T

Tru2JHWH

Guest
The Bible is absolutely clear that Paul did not allow women preachers and pastors. "Shut up and learn" was his position. But there is another related and equally important question: Is this meant to be observed in today's churches, given today's social norms? Or, was Paul's position based on social norms at that time that do not apply today? What's your view of that issue?
Yes I believe that back then in Paul's time their were women who were very disruptive doing church service and this could have caused Paul to say this but also there are other scriptures that back up that women are not to be preachers/bishops in the church Titus 1:5ff tells us what elders and bishops roles and responsibilities are in God's church. Also there are no single account of a woman "preaching" to a group of men and women in the New Testament. I understand that people think this is Paul opinion but if that's the case then we would have to doubt just about everything said in the New Testament since he wrote it and since God is not a God of confusion I don't see us picking and choosing which verses are opinions and which ones are not. Everything Paul said is inspired by God. And just because a lot of "holy" people are doing something doesn't make it right.
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
Yes I believe that back then in Paul's time their were women who were very disruptive doing church service and this could have caused Paul to say this but also there are other scriptures that back up that women are not to be preachers/bishops in the church Titus 1:5ff tells us what elders and bishops roles and responsibilities are in God's church. Also there are no single account of a woman "preaching" to a group of men and women in the New Testament. I understand that people think this is Paul opinion but if that's the case then we would have to doubt just about everything said in the New Testament since he wrote it and since God is not a God of confusion I don't see us picking and choosing which verses are opinions and which ones are not. Everything Paul said is inspired by God. And just because a lot of "holy" people are doing something doesn't make it right.
So WHAT !

Or, should I say, 'WHAT ! ' like Paul did in verse 36 AFTER having been reading what the Corinth church leaders were SAYING NOT PAUL about women keeping silent.

Paul's word was 'What'

This is a questioning word, is it not???

Paul was saying, in essence, 'Who died and MADE you God ?'

Who did, Tru ?

Paul was not saying what you THINK he was saying IF you really analyze Scripture :)

Scripture is clear on this FACT , from Paul , God-ordained minister, and, it's NOT completely clear, but, I for one, believe Paul wrote Hebrews and there too are signs of Paul having NO problem with women in church. Sure, in bible times, women were not preaching much, but ARE WE in bible times now, Tru?

The world has changed, milady . Much !!

God is MOvING in great ways tHrougH craCKs , through creVIces before He surely will come again. He is USING sooo many people now to reach those that otherwise cannot be reached, gay, lesbian, are one people group. God's not dead, He's surely alive, He's living on the inside, roaring like a lion, and, I am NOT judging that people group or any other....

....just saying that God is dot to dotting our landscape with His will and you should PRAY hard about thinking women are NOT allowed to preach TODAY, look around you, there are 100s of women preachers, who are CALLED by God.

Who else called them, ya think??

God is in
CONTROL ! :)
 
T

Tru2JHWH

Guest
So WHAT !

Or, should I say, 'WHAT ! ' like Paul did in verse 36 AFTER having been reading what the Corinth church leaders were SAYING NOT PAUL about women keeping silent.

Paul's word was 'What'

This is a questioning word, is it not???

Paul was saying, in essence, 'Who died and MADE you God ?'

Who did, Tru ?

Paul was not saying what you THINK he was saying IF you really analyze Scripture :)

Scripture is clear on this FACT , from Paul , God-ordained minister, and, it's NOT completely clear, but, I for one, believe Paul wrote Hebrews and there too are signs of Paul having NO problem with women in church. Sure, in bible times, women were not preaching much, but ARE WE in bible times now, Tru?

The world has changed, milady . Much !!

God is MOvING in great ways tHrougH craCKs , through creVIces before He surely will come again. He is USING sooo many people now to reach those that otherwise cannot be reached, gay, lesbian, are one people group. God's not dead, He's surely alive, He's living on the inside, roaring like a lion, and, I am NOT judging that people group or any other....

....just saying that God is dot to dotting our landscape with His will and you should PRAY hard about thinking women are NOT allowed to preach TODAY, look around you, there are 100s of women preachers, who are CALLED by God.

Who else called them, ya think??

God is in
CONTROL ! :)
First of all why are you even on my tread if you have several threads that you can argue you own "opinions" and people who wants to read what that is they have that choice to do so.

Second of all this world is Satan's playgroud. It's full of sin, sorrow, and death. Just because it's being done in this awful world, that will not be our home forever, doesn't make it right.
And yes we do live in Bible times. Everything the New Testament says do I do. And when the New Testament is silent I don't do it. When you love someone you try to do everything in your power to please them and do what they say because you want them to know without a shadow of doubt that you really love them. And the same thing goes with God. The only way we can really show God that we love him is to do what he says in his word (by keeping his commandments) and remaining faithful until death. Religion is not about our feelings and opinions. Never in God's word did he ask anyone how they felt about anything. If we have the holy spirit in us it's gonna teach us all the same things. It's has to. The Holy Spirit comes from God and his Son Jesus Christ.They can't contradict themselves 2 Thessalonians 2:11-12 And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie: 12 That they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness.
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
First of all why are you even on my tread if you have several threads that you can argue you own "opinions" and people who wants to read what that is they have that choice to do so.

Second of all this world is Satan's playgroud. It's full of sin, sorrow, and death. Just because it's being done in this awful world, that will not be our home forever, doesn't make it right.
And yes we do live in Bible times. Everything the New Testament says do I do. And when the New Testament is silent I don't do it. When you love someone you try to do everything in your power to please them and do what they say because you want them to know without a shadow of doubt that you really love them. And the same thing goes with God. The only way we can really show God that we love him is to do what he says in his word (by keeping his commandments) and remaining faithful until death. Religion is not about our feelings and opinions. Never in God's word did he ask anyone how they felt about anything. If we have the holy spirit in us it's gonna teach us all the same things. It's has to. The Holy Spirit comes from God and his Son Jesus Christ.They can't contradict themselves 2 Thessalonians 2:11-12 And for this cause God shall send them strong delusion, that they should believe a lie: 12 That they all might be damned who believed not the truth, but had pleasure in unrighteousness.
Then why are you not learning that The bible NOWHERE says that women can not teach and preach to men?

Where does The bible specifically say that a woman can not teach a man or 'men' about God. How does Paul saying 'women are not to teach (authority ) or usurp , or, swallow up authority over a man' make it so that they can not teach or preach TO A MAN, OR, MEN?

I am on your thread because the Lord leads, but if you don't want me on here, fine, I am off now, I will leave you with this: the lies you speak of in Thessalonians are the oppressive INTERPRETATIONS of Scripture, and, I do not bend, twist scripture. I take it at face value and by virtue of NO verses clearly saying a woman can not preach to a man, it is not true....there are NO contradictions, Tru, but, you are right about one thing, as you preach and teach me, The Holy Spirit is,saying to you right now, 'Tru, be at peafe, go teach others, girl, as I lead, I want to use you in this way.' :)

Notice in 1 Timothy 2:12, the words 'over a man,' tru, these words, IF they were accurately speaking of 'preaching or teaching,' would be 'to a man.' 1 Tim. 2:12 no? Yes? Maybe?

But the words ARE 'over a man,' therefore, it is a 'origination,' context, or, 'orderly domination' as Scripture reads with word, 'usurp.' It is NOT a spiritual ultimatum, Tru. Can't you see this, milady???
Here is the verse:

I suffer not a woman to teach (origination or authority, as in AUTHORSHIP) or have authority ( origination, or,, authorship, or,, another word could be 'control') OVER A MAN , but to be in silence.'

The very next verse AFTER 1 Timothy 2:12 is 'Adam was formed first then Eve.' « This speaks of a 'origination' context, otherwise verse 13 does not properly correlate in context with verse 12 . Just doesn't, and, furthermore, verse 14, states that Eve was deceived, and, this, too, speaks of 'order,' not absolutism of women not to preach TO A MAN.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,290
6,581
113
It is Yahweh's love and mercy that allows any one to preach and teach His Torah (Torah means teaching.)

Yeshua always chose mercy over punitive laws, and He forgave, stating in one place, "I desire mercy and not sacrifice," and in another, "The Son of Man (Adam) came to forgive, not to condemn."

Why are so many who claim to know Yahweh so willing to be unmerciful and unyielding to other souls wrapped in the present world garb of being female?

It is the mercy of Yahweh which allows anyone to spread His Word, it is never by any one person's virtue, aside from Yeshua that is, amen.
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,290
6,581
113
You meant Jesus, right?
Of course. Many times in the Word, Yeshua would refer to Himself as the Son of Man, and in other translations the Son of Adam. Adam may mean man, mankind and more. The word for blood, dam, also comes from the root word, as does the word for earth, adamah. It goes on, the root is also the root of the name Edom. It is certain I am missing more, but it does not come to mind at present.

Just that one name brings so much together for many. Blessed be our Lord and Savior, Yeshua, amen.
 
Aug 11, 2012
631
1
0
The church of Corinth had written Paul a letter stating that the Corinthian church was out of order and that the women were being disruptive. Paul responds and gives them his advice on how to get the church back in order. He was adressing the Church of Corinth specificaly. I say again, every mouth you silence is a victory for the enemy. To say that a woman is less than a man in the Kingdom of God, does not reflect the character of God.
Corinth was unruly and disobeying practically all the New Covenant instructions.
it's no surprise they were corrected on this as well.
 
X

xino

Guest
Jesus said...go and make disciples of all nations.
did he say all men, did he mention sex?

imagine a women going to a place like China where no one knew about Jesus.
and she taught people about Jesus...should she keep her mouth shut? because you are implying women to be quiet.


what the bible talks about in -head- s that, in a church the women should be silent
but the bible does not forbids women from preaching!
 

starfield

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2009
3,393
58
48
"The Son of Man (Adam) came to forgive, not to condemn."
You meant Jesus, right?
Of course. Many times in the Word, Yeshua would refer to Himself as the Son of Man, and in other translations the Son of Adam. Adam may mean man, mankind and more. The word for blood, dam, also comes from the root word, as does the word for earth, adamah. It goes on, the root is also the root of the name Edom. It is certain I am missing more, but it does not come to mind at present.

Just that one name brings so much together for many. Blessed be our Lord and Savior, Yeshua, amen.
I thought the brackets you put around "Adam" was to imply that Adam is the Son of Man. The Son of Adam= Jesus. Not the Son of Man = Adam. Got it. Thanks for clarifying. lol
 

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,290
6,581
113
I thought the brackets you put around "Adam" was to imply that Adam is the Son of Man. The Son of Adam= Jesus. Not the Son of Man = Adam. Got it. Thanks for clarifying. lol
Nope, Adam is still made by Yahweh. I should have placed the word, Adam, in appositive form as I did here, but for some reason I thought the parenthesis would emphasize more. I was wrong!
 
G

GreenNnice

Guest
Hey, hey, hey, Jj.
Starfield was only trying to understand better. No need to say anything with tone to her, she is a young warrior girl of our God, she knows God, she knows Jesus, she knows Holy Spirit, and, in a great light. She knows the way is Jesus, the Truth is His Word, and, she knows 'the Life' is who He is and what immeasurable measure of blessing, Love, grace, mercy, given unto those that embrace Him and the abundant life He 'personally' gives all those who seek Him and His will with all their life :)

We are all wrong, that is why cross went to the.cross, right, wronged by us, I know some on here got you edgy recently, and, making you feel blameworthy but, my Christbro, it is God your maker whom can EVER make you feel guilty and since God NEVER guilts, just corrects us, then why are you judging yourself in a convicted way?

You are led by a gentle Spirit, be led, brother, always by Him :)

Anyway, I wasn't going to comment here unless someone directly pulls one of my quotes, but, like Jesus, I felt their was some peace (through Him) I needed to bring. God bless you all my Christ peeps for following Jesus, our way to Truth and Life :)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

JaumeJ

Senior Member
Jul 2, 2011
21,290
6,581
113
Hey, hey, hey, Jj.
Starfield was only trying to understand better. No need to say anything with tone to her, she is a young warrior girl of our God, she knows God, she knows Jesus, she knows Holy Spirit, and, in a great light. She knows the way is Jesus, the Truth is His Word, and, she knows 'the Life' is who He is and what immeasurable measure of blessing, Love, grace, mercy, given unto those that embrace Him and the abundant life He 'personally' gives all those who seek Him and His will with all their life :)

We are all wrong, that is why cross went to the.cross, right, wronged by us, I know some on here got you edgy recently, and, making you feel blameworthy but, my Christbro, it is God your maker whom can EVER make you feel guilty and since God NEVER guilts, just corrects us, then why are you judging yourself in a convicted way?

You are led by a gentle Spirit, be led, brother, always by Him :)

Anyway, I wasn't going to comment here unless someone directly pulls one of my quotes, but, like Jesus, I felt their was some peace (through Him) I needed to bring. God bless you all my Christ peeps for following Jesus, our way to Truth and Life :)
What in the world are you saying? I just told her I was wrong? I don't get what you are saying or what you are reading into what is posted. She was right in being confused on the issue, and I posted that I should have posted it with better grammar. What are you saying here? Again, I simply do not get it.
 

starfield

Senior Member
Jun 13, 2009
3,393
58
48
Hey, hey, hey, Jj.
Starfield was only trying to understand better. No need to say anything with tone to her, she is a young warrior girl of our God, she knows God, she knows Jesus, she knows Holy Spirit, and, in a great light. She knows the way is Jesus, the Truth is His Word, and, she knows 'the Life' is who He is and what immeasurable measure of blessing, Love, grace, mercy, given unto those that embrace Him and the abundant life He 'personally' gives all those who seek Him and His will with all their life :)

We are all wrong, that is why cross went to the.cross, right, wronged by us, I know some on here got you edgy recently, and, making you feel blameworthy but, my Christbro, it is God your maker whom can EVER make you feel guilty and since God NEVER guilts, just corrects us, then why are you judging yourself in a convicted way?

You are led by a gentle Spirit, be led, brother, always by Him :)

Anyway, I wasn't going to comment here unless someone directly pulls one of my quotes, but, like Jesus, I felt their was some peace (through Him) I needed to bring. God bless you all my Christ peeps for following Jesus, our way to Truth and Life :)
What in the world are you saying? I just told her I was wrong? I don't get what you are saying or what you are reading into what is posted. She was right in being confused on the issue, and I posted that I should have posted it with better grammar. What are you saying here? Again, I simply do not get it.
It's all good guys. lol

God bless.